Is vegetarianism arbitrary?

I can't help but wonder what your shoes and belts (etc) are made of.......
Well, I don't think it's worth killing animals for food, but I do think it's worth killing them for clothing. In the same way as that I think it's good to do animal tests for curing diseases but not for cosmetics.
It's where you draw the line, I think it's enough not to eat meat, some people don't wear leather or don't eat any animal products. That for me goes to far. I still want to live normally and it is fine to do so as a vegetarian, but it would make my life harder to go any further.


You also said meat is healthy. I'm sorry to say, it isn't, there is a lot of *** going round saying meat is healthy but the real truth is, it isn't. The only thing in meat that is healthy is protein, which you find in eggs, cheese etc.. The rest in meat is pretty much useless. Meat is also bad for your intestines and can cause problems later on in life.
Oh, and don't vegetarians have a longer life expectansy than carnivores?
 
Last edited:
There's also no evidence that it's deleterious to heath either, and there certainly is evidence linking high levels of meat consumption to increased morbidity.

So what's your point?

Ethically, logically and environmentally, veg[etaria]nism strikes me as the most rational dietary choice. There are other threads where I explain, at length, why I believe that to be the case, and back it up with citations.


This is where the arguments break down. Of course the set of ALL people who eat meat are generally more unhealthy than the set of people who self-identify as vegitarians. All of the studies I've read make no distinction between meat eaters who avoid unhealthy foods vs. those that eat meat but also keep a twinky (sp?) in their cheek at all times.

When it's all meat eaters vs. vegetarians conscious of their diet, of course the stats are going to skew in favor of vegetarians.
 
The irony is, if a vegetarian used a slur to refer to people that ate meat, he'd be considered one of the arrogant pushy vegetarians mentioned above.

I guess it's only okay to hurl insults when you're on the "right team"?

You can hurl insults all you want. I think they're funny. I'm not making any ad homenim style arguments, simply augmenting my points by adding some color.

But I must admit that I am SHOCKED that a vegitarian can't take a little chop-busting. Usually you're such well humored people with no strain of self-righteousness.
 
Then ignore them.



Hum...how categorical. The sake of brevity would have been fine, even with a couple of study links
Of course I can't use my own data because as we all know one case study does not evidence make (anecdotal).... Science, be damned.



As a cud chewer who has watched the process from close up, I can say with certainty that before you actually eat the meat, the animal has to be disposessed of its most precious asset, its life. Well.. as long as it spends its short life happy and well fed.....



There we go again with free range vacation style farms....It suffered because it's dead and can no longer enjoy your loving attention and its carefree hoping-around of a life.


Oh my god....such blasphemy...You are uttering the unthinkable.
Let's see... what would you choose ?? Freedom and the possibility of falling prey to some evil mountain lion or live in a prison where your benevolent guard will provide food and shelter ( and may be some lovin:D) ?.... Oh right, you don't have to.
You eat the animals because you wish to do so, not to ensure their well-being. That's simple and fair enough. I chose not to eat either them or their secretions, and that is simple and fair enough.

PS If your turtle-neck clad anemic visitor decides to show up again, please advise him in buying a more manly, butch looking sweat shirt... may be he'll have beer with you.. milk ? Nahhh.


Right, so I'm supposed to ignore people arguing on a public forum meant for...arguing. Glib, contentless, useless, unfunny. That's better than a hat trick.

I ignored the nutrition science to focus on another aspect of the argument. That doesn't mean I haven't read the science, it simply means I want to talk about something else. I don't know where you've spent your time learning, but this is hardly a scandalous practice. As in, I could spend my time discussing what a sanctimonious prick you are, but instead I will continue to deal with the scant content you've provided.

Your argument, as near as I can tell, is that ANY taking of life is inherently unjustified. Death, however, is unavoidable. Yet we can control both the quality of life and the means of death. I would love to see you work out a serious argument that expresses exactly WHY it is wrong to maintain a healthy flock and then slaughter the animal in a humane way.

It seems to me we have three choices with respect to dealing with livestock:
1) ignore completely and allow them to go wild. There they will suffer immensely throughout their lives compared to a tended flock. Their death will involve extended moments of terror as they are ripped to pieces and likely partially consumed while still alive by predators.
2) Humans invest time and effort tending to the flock but never slaughter the animal for meat. We feed them, provide them medication, fight off predators, and heal injured beasts. Yet we just let them die in the means selected by nature. This means that despite our best efforts they will die in pain from disease, injury, or some other situation.
3) We raise the animals, tend to their well-being, and when they've reached a point that their meat can be enjoyed by their caretakers, we humanely slaughter them.

Both 2 and 3 are obviously preferable to 1 from the animal's perspective.

Your job is to not only explain why 2 is better than 3, but you need to show that somehow the difference between the two is enough to establish immorality in 3. In fact, if suffering is your only metric, there seems to be less in 3 than 2 if for no other reason than the discomfort of old age is avoided. I'll ignore the clearly impractical nature of 2 to simply focus on the conceptual difference.

I am also ignoring your bad faith conflation of free-range treatment of animals with feed-lots. I clearly said in my original post that such tactics are reprehensible. But you know that, you're simply trying to fill in the gap left by your complete lack of salient argumentation with aimless slander.
 
Last edited:
Care to elaborate? How is endangerment a relevant moral difference? Is it wrong to kill an elephant? Is it wrong to kill a human?

Like everything else, it's only a moral difference if we construct a morality to say so - the reason I answered it that way is because you asked for an ethical difference and that's one possible one. Whether any are relevant, I don't know.

I don't think any killing is "wrong" without imposition of a constructed morality. Unless you want to argue that leopards are immoral.

Not at all. Regardless of if any value is placed on the DNA of the grass, the elephant (1), both, or neither, the fact remains that there is a difference betwen removing an organism from a gene pool and merely temporarily prevent it from participating in it. I see no values in this statement; if you see any, please point them out for me.

Same thing - there's a difference in result, but saying whether one is more desirable than the other is the value judgement.

In a more human reference frame it is the difference between stopping your teenage son from having sex by gluing a condom to the relevant parts, and killing him. For many teenage boys, one might be as desirable as the other. That doesn't make the actions identical, though.

No, but without human constructed morals, they are morally equivalent.

(1) I walked next to one today on my way from the bookshop!!!!!

An elephant or a teenage boy with a condom glued to him?
 
But a really inefficient way to provide food for humans.:)

But of course this has nothing to do with the MORALITY of meat eating in a conceptual sense. I can agree with you that the current infrastructure that raises and ships meat products is archaic and cruel. But this isn't a criticism of meat eating.

I could likewise say that people who eat corn are immoral because corn syrup has been one of the primary contributors to obesity and related illnesses. But again, this is just a complaint against the way we've decided to use a product, not the product itself.
 
But of course this has nothing to do with the MORALITY of meat eating in a conceptual sense. I can agree with you that the current infrastructure that raises and ships meat products is archaic and cruel. But this isn't a criticism of meat eating.

The funny thing is, that exact reasoning - inefficiency of animals in growing food vs plants - is a de facto argument that there are far too many people on the planet. With half the population, the problem wouldn't exist.
 
The funny thing is, that exact reasoning - inefficiency of animals in growing food vs plants - is a de facto argument that there are far too many people on the planet. With half the population, the problem wouldn't exist.

I would also point out that with food, efficiency isn't really an issue once you separate fuel consumption from the equation. The minute we begin using trains or develop a better alternative fuel, inefficiency is moot. There is more than enough food on the planet, overpopulated as it is. It's just our bizarre understanding of economics and global trade (as well as dangerous, retarded local regimes) that create starvation.
 
I might be the coolest vegetarian here. My neighbors like that I'm a bit eccentric; a non-hunter. More opportunity for them to hunt. One of the coolest things about being vegetarian is how it works to the advantage of meat-eaters. Its a seldom used argument.
 
Well, I don't think it's worth killing animals for food, but I do think it's worth killing them for clothing.
:boggled: So you think we should just pitch the meat out after skinning them? Or you're saying it's OK to kill them, yiou'd just rather take advantage of the skins and not the meat? They're just as dead either way FYI, so I then would assume you're a vegetarian for health reasons, not moral ones.

You also said meat is healthy. I'm sorry to say, it isn't, there is a lot of *** going round saying meat is healthy but the real truth is, it isn't.
I'm sorry to say you're wrong. The protein in meat is of a higher quality than in eggs etc. And meat is only bad in other ways if you eat too much of it (like most other things). Also lumping "meat" as all the same isn't too accurate either, eg beef vs chicken.
 
I don't think any killing is "wrong" without imposition of a constructed morality. Unless you want to argue that leopards are immoral.

I started a thread on animal rights some months back, and anticipated the above as one possible objection. It's a fitting comment for this thread because it's atypically introduced to topics on eating meat and rarely anywhere else; in other words, the meta-ethics card is played arbitrarily.


Like everything else, it's only a moral difference if we construct a morality to say so - the reason I answered it that way is because you asked for an ethical difference and that's one possible one. Whether any are relevant, I don't know.

I thought your initial answer -- elephants are endangered -- was evasive at best, and this confirms it. There are many differences between elephants and humans -- and there are many differences between any two individual humans -- but an ethical or moral difference narrows things down significantly. So, it appears that according to your own "constructed morality," whatever that means, what you find significant is that elephants have been classified as "endangered." Well, why is that important? Endangerment is typically of instrumental value -- humans will miss the chance to witness certain "beautiful creatures," or their extinction threatens ecosystems, or whatever. You decided not to elaborate.

Not all "constructed" moralities are equally rational. A person could charge that elephants have thicker skin, tusks, or weigh more than humans. Those are differences, but I don't see how they're meaningful. On your view it's merely a matter of constructing a morality to say anything at all. Well, One simple test when evaluating any moral belief system is whether or not it's internally consistent. According to the above a relevant moral difference between a human and a plant is that the latter is endangered. :rolleyes:

So when you say, "I don't believe that there is any ethical difference between killing an elephant or cutting my lawn," what you're really doing is making a provocative claim in bad faith. What's the difference between killing a human and cutting my lawn?

And let's return to the second part of this comment:
I don't think any killing is "wrong" without imposition of a constructed morality. Unless you want to argue that leopards are immoral.

What does the "imposition of a constructed morality" mean? This is another evasive non-answer. Can you provide a stronger concrete example because leopards are not aware of their actions; they are not moral agents.
 
So, it appears that according to your own "constructed morality," whatever that means, what you find significant is that elephants have been classified as "endangered." ...

Nice of you to miss the entire point.

I'll trot you through it slowly:

Me said:
Like everything else, it's only a moral difference if we construct a morality to say so - the reason I answered it that way is because you asked for an ethical difference and that's one possible one. Whether any are relevant, I don't know.

I'm not making any claims at all.

I am, however, waiting for Lonewulf to tell me where the non-constructed morality is.
 
Where's the meat?

Nice of you to miss the entire point.

I suppose it's easy to miss what isn't there.

I'm not making any claims at all.

You certainly are and you're completely failing to back them. You said you cannot see moral difference between cutting grass and killing elephants. When asked for a moral difference between elephants and humans you offered up "endangerment," and then immediately tried to walk it back with a non-committal "whether any [ethical differences] are relevant, I don't know." Well, buttercup, if a significant difference between humans and elephants is that elephants are endangered, then that's also a difference between elephants and grass. Of course, you put no stock into your vague throwaway "endangerment" because you're making meaningless comments intended to provoke rather than offer insight, and when challenged directly on a claim you attempt to misdirect:

I am, however, waiting for Lonewulf to tell me where the non-constructed morality is.

It sounds more like trolling, but how does that excuse evading my questions?
 
How much consideration do the vegetarians/vegans give to the animals that die for the production of their vegetables/fruits and grains?

Just wondering if that is factored into the dietary concerns and if so, would you kindly tell me what you (veg*n) do to minimize the animals deaths that make up your diet.

Thanks.

I have to eat to live. Fewer animals die should I eat a plant based diet rather than an omnivorous one. A non-perfect vegan diet is better than one that does not even try.

This is obvious if you think about if for more than a microsecond.
 
Um it does? How so? What makes these people think cavemen lived long, healthy lives? Do they also go out in packs to hunt elephant with sharpened sticks? Lacking mastodon that is.

Their basic idea is that proto-humans and early humans and humans mostly hunted animals and gathered plant items and other foods for millions of years, but that we radically changed our diets with the advent of agriculture, 10,000 years ago. We have eaten in the post-agriculture manner for a much smaller amount of time, so that should indicate that we're best adapted to eat the pre-agriculture hunter-gatherer diet.
In a broad way that seems to make sense. I guess I don't see any obvious flaws with that basic concept, possibly people here do.

So anyway they prefer a meat- and animal fat-heavy diet, with vegetables and fruits (admitting that those have changed character with selective breeding), nuts, seeds, honey, and such. They eschew dairy (but not all of them do) as I said, and they typically shun wheat products that they seem to think suddenly entered our diet 10,000 years ago. Some of them think raw is better, but most of them aren't really raw-foodists.
They do take some stances I find silly. Many think that beans are poison.

I don't really agree with this. For example, my ancestry is from northwest Europe, and I have that mutant adaptation to keep on producing lactase as an adult. I could chug down a pint of milk right now, and digest it, no problem, although if I avoided all dairy for years my production would probably adapt downwards (but not go away). Surely this is a mutation I profit from? Just because this is a relatively recent adaptation in human history...why does that matter? Are longer-standing adaptations really better? And surely we continue adapting at all times no matter what, anyway?
 
Last edited:
I have to eat to live. Fewer animals die should I eat a plant based diet rather than an omnivorous one. A non-perfect vegan diet is better than one that does not even try.

This is obvious if you think about if for more than a microsecond.

Obvious even though you won't be able to articulate a coherent explanation of why veganism is morally superior. Ignore the easy case of feed-lots, nobody likes those. Explain how a vegan lifestyle is preferable to eating cared for animals that are humanely slaughtered.
 
You certainly are and you're completely failing to back them. You said you cannot see moral difference between cutting grass and killing elephants. When asked for a moral difference between elephants and humans you offered up "endangerment," ...

Quite right.

You need to realise that because I can see that a moral argument exists doesn't mean I subscribe to it. It's a reasonably safe bet that I don't go around killing things wantonly, so I probably take a few moral positions myself.

The only point which matters here is that morality is a human construct, and therefore indefinable, other than by some kind of arbitrary consensus, which is pretty much how the world survives right now.Beyond those societal constructs, I don't believe morals exist.

If you have an alternative argument, go ahead. If you've just misunderstood me, then it should be cleaered up now. My comments were more aimed at Lonewulf than you and he won't back up his argument.
 
Their basic idea is that proto-humans and early humans and humans mostly hunted animals and gathered plant items and other foods for millions of years, but that we radically changed our diets with the advent of agriculture, 10,000 years ago. We have eaten in the post-agriculture manner for a much smaller amount of time, so that should indicate that we're best adapted to eat the pre-agriculture hunter-gatherer diet.
In a broad way that seems to make sense. I guess I don't see any obvious flaws with that basic concept, possibly people here do.

So anyway they prefer a meat- and animal fat-heavy diet, with vegetables and fruits (admitting that those have changed character with selective breeding), nuts, seeds, honey, and such. They eschew dairy (but not all of them do) as I said, and they typically shun wheat products that they seem to think suddenly entered our diet 10,000 years ago. Some of them think raw is better, but most of them aren't really raw-foodists.
They do take some stances I find silly. Many think that beans are poison.

I don't really agree with this. For example, my ancestry is from northwest Europe, and I have that mutant adaptation to keep on producing lactase as an adult. I could chug down a pint of milk right now, and digest it, no problem, although if I avoided all dairy for years my production would probably adapt downwards (but not go away). Surely this is a mutation I profit from? Just because this is a relatively recent adaptation in human history...why does that matter? Are longer-standing adaptations really better? And surely we continue adapting at all times no matter what, anyway?

Let me add that the position is also based on modern methods of determining the quality of a diet by studying bones. We know, for example, that IMMEDIATELY upon moving to a sedentary lifestyle the life expectancy and quality of life (gauged by health) dropped dramatically. Hunter gatherers in many parts of the world enjoyed a healthy lifespan that wasn't reached by civilation until well the Christian era.
 
Quite right.

You need to realise that because I can see that a moral argument exists doesn't mean I subscribe to it. It's a reasonably safe bet that I don't go around killing things wantonly, so I probably take a few moral positions myself.

The only point which matters here is that morality is a human construct, and therefore indefinable, other than by some kind of arbitrary consensus, which is pretty much how the world survives right now.Beyond those societal constructs, I don't believe morals exist.

If you have an alternative argument, go ahead. If you've just misunderstood me, then it should be cleaered up now. My comments were more aimed at Lonewulf than you and he won't back up his argument.

The only thing I would disagree with here is the idea that the construct is "arbitrary." Maybe I'm not understanding the sense in which you're using the word, but developing a code of behavior based on empiricism may be a human construct, but it hardly seems arbitrary. It's root is in how the environment in which humans evolve direct our behavior.

It's easy to imagine, for example, that humans evolved with thick hides and giant claws meaning we didn't need to rely on groups to survive. The morality stemming from such a situation would be much more individualistic. Again, constructed but not arbitrary.
 
Same thing - there's a difference in result, but saying whether one is more desirable than the other is the value judgement.

However, no implication is made that one is more desirable than the other (by me, at least). Thus, I approach this without any values placed on either of the actions. I just point out that they are different and therefore incomparable actions.

No, but without human constructed morals, they are morally equivalent.

If by this you mean to say that 0 = 0, then I agree. However, these actions could then be said to be euivalent to any action which directly or indirectly causes the breakage of chemical bonds, either immediately or after a delay.

An elephant or a teenage boy with a condom glued to him?

Only the former, as far as I know.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom