Is there anything to "Replacement Theory"?

As usual the sensationalist news media fails to point out none of the immigrants coming into this country can vote and they won't be able to vote for years and years even if they eventually are.
 
Florida is one of the most populous states in the union, hardly an outlier.

Then head to south Texas. Many, many rural Hispanics are staunchly pro-life and very conservative.

I was about to chime in with this. Yes, South Texas is definitely Blue, but it's a different kind of Blue. You would be very surprised at the "man on the street" support for overturning Roe v. Wade and for stricter immigration controls. And in the past few elections there has been a shift towards being a bit more purple.

South Texas is very Catholic, very machismo-oriented which reflects the broader Hispanic culture. The Democratic Party has the reputation of being "for the little guy," (which is exactly how my Father-in-law and others of his generation have stated it) and I think it's that reputation that results in the historic support for the Dem Party, not any actual policy positions. But that historic support is eroding, make no mistake.

At the end of the day, I don't think there is anything to "Replacement theory," other than a thinly-veiled excuse for racism. The real issues are, of course, much more complex. "The races" are not monolithic blocks of voters or, more importantly, blocks of citizens who all want the same things.
 
As usual the sensationalist news media fails to point out none of the immigrants coming into this country can vote and they won't be able to vote for years and years even if they eventually are.

Yeah, apparently whoever's doing this is playing the long game -- the really long game. And thus far it appears to be failing. Some conspiracy. Makes one wonder why they don't just stick with stealing elections, since it worked so well last time (something I suspect many adherents of "replacement theory" also believe).
 
Um, source?
I was thinking of the impact of the 1924 and 1965 immigration acts. I agree that immigration still went on, but you see the rate of foreign born labour force participation dropping through that period.
 
Yes, this is currently allowed at the local level, in some areas.

https://www.cnn.com/2021/12/10/opin...ncitizen-voting-smart-policy-reyes/index.html

Right now it is just a Dem dream, at the national level.

you are proving my point of not knowing what you are talking about.

I clearly said "undocumented immigrants", not migrants with a legal right to be in the US.

I would take right-wingers more seriously on the subject if they would even make the attempt make a distinction between migrant workers, documented migrants, undocumented migrants and refugees.
 
Yeah but until "Not knowing what you are talking about" actually gets you excluded from decision making it's an advantage.
 
My wife and I have a very liberal friend who fears "being replaced".

Her take is very different.

She believes non-whites have been treated badly for years. She believes that "human nature being what it is" when anglo-whites become a minority they will get pushed aside.

My wife's counter argument is that, having been the victims of racism, non-whites would certainly not visit such hatred on others.

Makes ya' think.

--------------
Dope Clock II: It's been 327 days since Bobby Menard announced plans to create "Artists Valley". So far all he has done is lie through his teeth.
 
The fact that white people are terrified of what is going to happen when there is more of "them" then of us is kind of all the explanation you need though isn't it?
 
My wife and I have a very liberal friend who fears "being replaced".

Her take is very different.

She believes non-whites have been treated badly for years. She believes that "human nature being what it is" when anglo-whites become a minority they will get pushed aside.

My wife's counter argument is that, having been the victims of racism, non-whites would certainly not visit such hatred on others.

Makes ya' think.

--------------
Dope Clock II: It's been 327 days since Bobby Menard announced plans to create "Artists Valley". So far all he has done is lie through his teeth.

South Africa.

Such a wonderful utopia. :)
 
Jesus Christ. People could not be pre-staging their "Now that racism (real, exaggerated, or imaged) is happening against white people I've decided now that it's the greatest justice evar!" routines more if the tried.
 
We can't change the law. Republicans are scared of losing the election due to immigrant voters, so they are keeping immigration numbers low, even though a larger quota would make life much better for everyone. They are using immigration to change the election outcome.

800,000 a year is low? Says who?

I think its pretty ******* generous.

What other country allows so many yearly immigrants plus 100,000 refugees?

Why are you advocating for people who are not only not yet citizens, but don't even live here yet...or American citizens?

Are the needs of possible future residents and citizens of the USA equal to those of current Americans???
 
800,000 a year is low? Says who?

I think its pretty ******* generous.

What other country allows so many yearly immigrants plus 100,000 refugees?

Why are you advocating for people who are not only not yet citizens, but don't even live here yet?

Is national identity something that matters a lot to you?

I have more in common with the illegal immigrants living in my community than silver spoon ghouls like Carlson trying to gin up race hatred.

That's kinda the problem for the "White Replacement" morons, is that not even that many white people are that concerned about their pure white communities or even their pure white children as they would hope. Well adjusted white people will continue to live near, socialize with, and even procreate with, non-white people, much to the horror of white supremacists.
 
Last edited:
No, whites have no moral argument for keeping the USA majority white. History says they have none.

No, it is WRONG to not enforce immigration law so as to possibly in the future swing elections your way, in a quid pro quo.
 
It's akin the fear plantation owners in the old Deep South had about slave uprisings.

Ya' gotta' wonder if people who have **** on others are all too aware of how easy it is to rationalize and justify doing so. in the above case I think our friend just saw cruelty done so often.

While on the other hand fair, honest and loving people may have trouble believe that others could be cruel.

--------------
Dope Clock II: It's been 327 days since Bobby Menard announced plans to create "Artists Valley". So far all he has done is lie through his teeth.
 
Well, there was the same theory about the evil Catholics going to outbreed all the good protestants in the Netherlands and turn the country into a papal dependency by abusing democracy, which is why they should not be given the vote or be allowed to re-establish the bishoprics.
This was in the early to mid 1800's

By now we are a country where more than 50% of the populations considers themselves non-religious.

So, I'm not too worried.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom