Is there anything to "Replacement Theory"?

As ALWAYS, questions of immigration are being conflated with questions of citizenship.

Anyone here wants to claim that Dems let undocumented immigrants vote?
 
I think maybe there is a difference between winning an election based on the people who actually live in the country, and winning an election by importing new voters. Isn't it the current citizens of our country that we want our government to represent?

First, no one is "importing" people.

Second, every succesful country needs immigration to continue growing, and those immigrants automatically become citizens of the country. Unless you want to prevent all immigrants from voting, there will always be non-citizens that are about to have a say in things.
 
First, no one is "importing" people.

Second, every succesful country needs immigration to continue growing, and those immigrants automatically become citizens of the country. Unless you want to prevent all immigrants from voting, there will always be non-citizens that are about to have a say in things.

Immigration is a good and useful thing. But it needs to be orderly and controlled. Do you believe our current legal quota of 800,000 per year is too small? Change the law.

Immigration should not be used to change election outcomes. If your political views only have a chance via bribery of new immigrants, your views suck.
 
To take the questions seriously, their is a tendency of lefties and dems so celebrate the coming minority majority in the US and how that means there will be a permanent democratic majority, demographics are destiny and what not. It was overblown by both left and right.

But really it is mostly just racism.

Immigration is a good and useful thing. But it needs to be orderly and controlled. Do you believe our current legal quota of 800,000 per year is too small? Change the law.

Immigration should not be used to change election outcomes. If your political views only have a chance via bribery of new immigrants, your views suck.
Its the perception that it is uncontrolled that really causes the backlash. There's other issues with how the elites of both dems and reps have treated immigration that have fed into the trumpist rebellion in the GOP. All the talk about how is just good with now down side and anyone worried about it is just racist from the Dems with the Reps just giving lip service about reform. Well, it is an unalloyed good for the elites, the immigrants they deal with are just like them, elites. The poor are dealing with immigrants just like the poor only with completely different cultures and often languages, it makes folks uncomfortable. Its not just racist, its a perfectly normal predictable human reaction to having your towns and neigbhorhoods change. Years ago I heard a line to the effect of, "if responsible people don't deal with immigration then irresponsible people will", that's exactly what's happened.
 
Last edited:
Crazy people do crazy things. Not sure how murdering a store full of black people accomplishes anything.

Me neither. In fact, such things make me think about gun control. Or how we need to improve public education so people will be better equipped to resist such diseased ideas. Or what we can do to stop those who seek to gain political power by pandering to this stupidity. Or in my darker moments, it makes me despair for society.

What it does not make me think about is whether or not the shooter maybe, just maybe, might have been onto something. And even if that did somehow cross my mind, I'd probably give it a decent interval before posting my thoughts in front of a public still reeling in shock and horror -- at least I would if I hoped the discussion would be treated with anything other than anger and revulsion.
 
Last edited:
I used to hear it said that the second generation of immigrant groups tended to vote more conservative than their 1st generation parents.

I know I am not being very scientific here. . .but, it's not unusual to hear 2nd generation Americans to say something like, "My parents came over here with nothing but the clothes on their backs. They never took welfare and they worked their arses off! Why do I have pay taxes for (insert liberal social program) when all these people really need to do is work?"

If that's the case I often wondered why conservative Republicans didn't years ago seriously start trying to win over these kids, who are now adults.

If I recall correctly this is exactly the approach George and Jeb Bush took.

--------------
Dope Clock II: It's been 327 days since Bobby Menard announced plans to create "Artists Valley". So far all he has done is lie through his teeth.
 
As I said, the only way "Replacement Theory" works in the USA is if somehow by some magic power, whites have a natural God-given right to be a majority in the USA and Canada.
How do you figure that?

We simply do not.

Do ethnic Irish have a right to maintain their majority in Ireland? An argument could be made.
I think the EU will take care of any desire they may have for this.

Same with Denmark, Sweden, Finland, France, etc.
Look, the majority of the world isn't liberal. The majority of the world is religious. The majority of the world is poor. There is a lot of violence in other parts of the world. If we just open up our borders and say "welcome brothers and sisters, we are all the same." The borders will be closed again, but not by us.

But NOT colonialist nations in the Western hemisphere. Whites have no such right or privilege.
What is this focus on whites? This is a cultural thing. If you import enough people from other cultures into your country such that you are in a minority, then it ceases to be you are changing the culture of the country. Maybe you want Roe vs Wade to survive.... well tough **** if the people you let in come from a conservative religious tradition. One has to make a choice about what kind of country ones children and grandchildren will live in... immigration can have a big impact on that.

I don't think it is a coincidence that the people who are in favour of immigration are also the people who assume it benefits their cause.
 
Immigration is a good and useful thing. But it needs to be orderly and controlled. Do you believe our current legal quota of 800,000 per year is too small? Change the law.

Immigration should not be used to change election outcomes. If your political views only have a chance via bribery of new immigrants, your views suck.

We can't change the law. Republicans are scared of losing the election due to immigrant voters, so they are keeping immigration numbers low, even though a larger quota would make life much better for everyone. They are using immigration to change the election outcome.
 
And even if that did somehow cross my mind, I'd probably give it a decent interval before posting my thoughts in front of a public still reeling in shock and horror -- at least I would if I hoped the discussion would be treated with anything other than anger and revulsion.


"Shock and horror"? LOL. Really?

I'm kind of past that sort of thing in these cases. I mean, if it were my friends or relatives, yeah, don't talk to me about it right now. But, on a debate forum? No problem.
 
We can't change the law. Republicans are scared of losing the election due to immigrant voters, so they are keeping immigration numbers low, even though a larger quota would make life much better for everyone. They are using immigration to change the election outcome.

How many immigrants are in the US? What is a low number?

Our current system is essentially strict limits on educated and skilled immigrants with essentially unlimited immigration for uneducated and unskilled immigrants. I don't see the any effort by Dems to change that either.
 
I used to hear it said that the second generation of immigrant groups tended to vote more conservative than their 1st generation parents.

I know I am not being very scientific here. . .but, it's not unusual to hear 2nd generation Americans to say something like, "My parents came over here with nothing but the clothes on their backs. They never took welfare and they worked their arses off! Why do I have pay taxes for (insert liberal social program) when all these people really need to do is work?"

If that's the case I often wondered why conservative Republicans didn't years ago seriously start trying to win over these kids, who are now adults.

If I recall correctly this is exactly the approach George and Jeb Bush took.
There's a few articles that compare and contrast CA with TX on this. The CA republicans went hard on immigration and haven't recovered since, the TX GOP did the opposite.
 
I am struck that this conspiracy theory, like many others, really seem to lack a certain sense of scale or imagination. The world these conspiracy theories exist in always seem very small. There's no trends or forces at work, complicated systems spitting out results. No, it's the small clique of Jews pulling all the strings. Rather than contend with the chaos the world, real life is simplified into a series of conspiratorial cliques that control everything.

Real life rarely runs on such straight rails. You'd have to be a simpleton to think such huge forces are controlled by such simplistic schemes.

The idea that the Democratic party is controlling immigration, rather than simply reacting to forces vastly beyond their control, strikes me as a wild exaggeration of their power.
 
Last edited:
Immigration is a good and useful thing. But it needs to be orderly and controlled. Do you believe our current legal quota of 800,000 per year is too small? Change the law.

Immigration should not be used to change election outcomes. If your political views only have a chance via bribery of new immigrants, your views suck.
They US managed for decades without it. At the moment it is being used to mask the below replacement birth rate. If nothing is done to fix that, aspects of the problem will kind of take care of themselves as big parts of the existing culture die off.
 
"Shock and horror"? LOL. Really?

I'm kind of past that sort of thing in these cases. I mean, if it were my friends or relatives, yeah, don't talk to me about it right now. But, on a debate forum? No problem.

Your tolerance for public mass shootings, especially those designed to instigate further interracial violence, appears to be several orders of magnitude beyond my own. Hopefully I won't live long enough to get to the point where my reaction to someone else's shock and horror at a racially motivated mass murder is "LOL."
 
I am struck that this conspiracy theory, like many others, really seem to lack a certain sense of scale or imagination. The world these conspiracy theories exist in always seem very small. There's no trends or forces at work, complicated systems spitting out results. No, it's the small clique of Jews pulling all the strings. Rather than contend with the chaos the world, real life is simplified into a series of conspiratorial cliques that control everything.

Real life rarely runs on such straight rails. You'd have to be a simpleton to think such huge forces are controlled by such simplistic schemes.

The idea that the Democratic party is controlling immigration, rather than simply reacting to forces vastly beyond their control, strikes me as a wild exaggeration of their power.

Its like a lot of CTs, the most mild versions are at least plausible. In this case, Dems are more favorable towards large scale immigration because they think most immigrants that become citizens will vote for Dems. That's perfectly plausible and believable. The notion that this some master plan by a cabal of elites(the Jews!) is absurd. Really, what's the point, just hatred of white people? Last I checked, lots of white people vote for dems. I suppose, if the secrete cabal was run by the Black Israelites it would make sense but then, I don't think they like Latin folks that much either.
 
I used to hear it said that the second generation of immigrant groups tended to vote more conservative than their 1st generation parents.

I know I am not being very scientific here. . .but, it's not unusual to hear 2nd generation Americans to say something like, "My parents came over here with nothing but the clothes on their backs. They never took welfare and they worked their arses off! Why do I have pay taxes for (insert liberal social program) when all these people really need to do is work?"

If that's the case I often wondered why conservative Republicans didn't years ago seriously start trying to win over these kids, who are now adults.

If I recall correctly this is exactly the approach George and Jeb Bush took.

There's a few articles that compare and contrast CA with TX on this. The CA republicans went hard on immigration and haven't recovered since, the TX GOP did the opposite.

It's interesting how the fringes of political parties can say and do things that scare the blazes out of their party's moderates and seal the doom on any efforts to capture the middle.

The far left democrats who shouted "Defund the police" in 2020 came close to handing both houses of congress over to the Republicans.

--------------
Dope Clock II: It's been 327 days since Bobby Menard announced plans to create "Artists Valley". So far all he has done is lie through his teeth.
 
So other than the outright racism the only thing we're going to get is bland references to it being "bad" if immigration affects the political landscape.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom