Is there anything to "Replacement Theory"?

I'm not sure why there would be. America's use of soft and hard power over our Southern neighbors is not really that hotly contested anymore. It's not even "conspiracy theory", but more accepted fact including by key players like the CIA and State Department. The historical record is out there for anyone to read. Fire up Wikipedia if you want to know more.

Yes I see some articles about troubles in the "Northern Triangle" nations. Not exactly sure how the USA caused this.
 
Interesting note, the Buffalo mass shooter's manifesto contains images (the famous IQ gap image) taken directly out of Murray's "Bell Curve" book, the much debunked holy text of the scientific racism crowd.

There's no way to view this great replacement crap as anything but the conspiratorial delusions of white supremacists.
 
...I read that its not working exactly as planned in Texas, but it has worked well in California.

Then you read crap, because "as planned" assumes a priori that this is in fact the Democrat's plan all along, rather than simply some idle speculation based on faulty assumptions. It would be a pretty stupid plan anyway, since as you yourself admit it apparently isn't working in two of the three most populous states -- pretty poor track record if true.

In any case, the timing of your speculation could not possibly be worse, coming as it does immediately in the aftermath of a horrific mass shooting in which the killer justified his actions based on this idea. Did you really think this was an appropriate time to discuss whether or not there may be something to "replacement theory"? Maybe allow sufficient time to wash the blood off the sidewalks next time.
 
I believe that its assumed that Latin immigrants will vote Blue, as its the Democrats who have been pushing for lax border enforcement and amnesty.

People voting for whomever gives them what they want is a pretty common occurrence.
 
Seems "true" Replacement Theorists believe there is an attempt at white genocide, by means of non-white immigration, inter-racial marriages, low birth rate amongst white couples, etc. Obviously its silly.


I don't think there is a widespread organized attempt at white genocide. However, a reduction of the white-majority is a happy side effect that many endorse and celebrate. Which in itself kind of means that the CT has merit, from a certain perspective.

From a political standpoint, of course Democrats want to see this. It is funny to watch white Dems, who are more than happy to wallow around in white-guilt and self-loathing bliss, try to earn that minority vote.
 
Last edited:
People voting for whomever gives them what they want is a pretty common occurrence.

Yes but having loose immigration rules so as to eventually give them voting rights assuming they will pay you back in the polls, is not how things are supposed to work.

If the only way you can hope to win elections is by bribing foreigners, you dont deserve to win.
 
I know some people want the USA to keep its white majority, but they usually have basically racist or nationalist reasons for this. Its not like our immigration laws favor any specific race. They certainly do NOT favor non-whites, as very often European nations are on the diversity lottery.
The Greencard diversity lottery accounts for 50,000 greencards. You've got more than 1million legal immigrants per year and something like 10million illegals in the US. The Greencard lottery stuff isn't relevant.

Illegal immigration does favor non-whites, but that's just by accident.
This sounds like exactly the same argument that the left uses when they claim that laws that have differential impacts on marginalised groups are racist. In any case, you assert that it is an accident. I don't see how you could possibly know that.

Its not America's fault that many Latin nations are full of poverty and social decay.
Well, one could argue about that given some of the history, but it doesn't really matter since fault isn't really the issue.

Will white supremacists jump for joy if illegals start flooding from Uruguay and Argentina, with their large white populations? I guess.
I think it will come down to whether they are doing so in such numbers that they can swing elections, or depress wages etc..., and who is being impacted by these things. Very few people are so fixated on race that they aren't interested in culture and politics. Generally in these discussions race is just a proxy for those things.
 
Can all the usual suspects who we already know are going to be on the side of this nonsense just go ahead and jump in the thread now instead of trickling in one at a time and making us restart the discussion over and over?
 
Yes but having loose immigration rules so as to eventually give them voting rights assuming they will pay you back in the polls, is not how things are supposed to work.

If the only way you can hope to win elections is by bribing foreigners, you dont deserve to win.

I think a grocery store full of dead black people killed in the name of the Great Replacement theory is an elephant in the room a bit hard to ignore, but you're doing your damndest not to mention it.

White supremacists are not solely worried about "foreigners". There's no non-racist way to explain why black Americans are a threat.
 
Last edited:
I think a grocery store full of dead black people killed in the name of the Great Replacement theory is an elephant in the room a bit hard to ignore, but you're doing your damndest not to mention it.

White supremacists are not solely worried about "foreigners". There's no non-racist way to explain why black Americans are a threat.

I mean it's only logical. If you can't keep them out you just have to kill them once they are here.

It's really the Democrat's fault. If they didn't insist on non-white people being treated like humans and living in this country then there wouldn't have been anyone for him to shoot. QED checkmate libtard.
 
I mean it's only logical. If you can't keep them out you just have to kill them once they are here.

It's really the Democrat's fault. If they didn't insist on non-white people being treated like humans and living in this country then there wouldn't have been anyone for him to shoot. QED checkmate libtard.

It's worth pointing out that Great Replacement theory is more than simple nationalism (keeping foreigners out) and in fact hostility towards all non-white demographics, even those that are unambiguously, deeply American.

None of these people are going to lose any sleep about white Europeans immigrating here after all. You really have to be operating in bad faith to not concede that this issue is strictly seen through a racial (rather than national) lens. These freaks aren't shooting up the German-American clubs after all, despite them being bastions of foreign culture.

These people leave behind manifestos before they go on their killing sprees. It's not exactly a mystery what they believe.
 
Last edited:
Yes but having loose immigration rules so as to eventually give them voting rights assuming they will pay you back in the polls, is not how things are supposed to work.

If the only way you can hope to win elections is by bribing foreigners, you dont deserve to win.

But Republicans passing extremely strict immigration laws in order to win elections by keeping out those same immigrants would be okay?
 
Yes but having loose immigration rules so as to eventually give them voting rights assuming they will pay you back in the polls, is not how things are supposed to work.

If the only way you can hope to win elections is by bribing foreigners, you dont deserve to win.
The other thing about this is that the political parties are looking 10, 20, 30 years down the track. If you have a group that is growing both in terms of having an above replacement birth rate, and new arrivals... you invest you energy into that. You can abandon your original supporters. If you were being really cynical, you'd let people in but keep large numbers of them illegal to keep them dependent on you not enforcing the laws and hoping that if they waited long enough there would be an amnesty.
 
As I said, the only way "Replacement Theory" works in the USA is if somehow by some magic power, whites have a natural God-given right to be a majority in the USA and Canada.

We simply do not.

Do ethnic Irish have a right to maintain their majority in Ireland? An argument could be made.

Same with Denmark, Sweden, Finland, France, etc.

But NOT colonialist nations in the Western hemisphere. Whites have no such right or privilege.
 
Last edited:
Florida seems to be an exceptional case as most Cubans were fleeing Communism.

Most Hispanic immigrants these days are not.

No, now they are running away from either dictatorial death squads or cartels that make old Murder Inc. look like 'we only kiss babies'. :rolleyes:
 
But Republicans passing extremely strict immigration laws in order to win elections by keeping out those same immigrants would be okay?
I think maybe there is a difference between winning an election based on the people who actually live in the country, and winning an election by importing new voters. Isn't it the current citizens of our country that we want our government to represent?
 
But Republicans passing extremely strict immigration laws in order to win elections by keeping out those same immigrants would be okay?

Passing laws to convince American citizens to vote for them, is perfectly normal.

Passing laws so as to bring in more immigrants who may become citizens and will hopefully vote for you to pay you back for the favor you did for them, is not cool. Politicians are supposed to be looking out for current citizens.

Full stop, The End.
 
Last edited:
I think a grocery store full of dead black people killed in the name of the Great Replacement theory is an elephant in the room a bit hard to ignore, but you're doing your damndest not to mention it.


Why ignore it? But it really doesn't affect whether this CT has merit, either way.
 
I think a grocery store full of dead black people killed in the name of the Great Replacement theory is an elephant in the room a bit hard to ignore, but you're doing your damndest not to mention it.

White supremacists are not solely worried about "foreigners". There's no non-racist way to explain why black Americans are a threat.

Crazy people do crazy things. Not sure how murdering a store full of black people accomplishes anything.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom