Is there anything to "Replacement Theory"?

Hercules56

Banned
Joined
Aug 4, 2013
Messages
17,176
Seems "true" Replacement Theorists believe there is an attempt at white genocide, by means of non-white immigration, inter-racial marriages, low birth rate amongst white couples, etc. Obviously its silly.

But what if Replacement Theory is about politics rather than race?

What if there is a not so secret attempt to turn Red states purple and even Blue, by means of illegal immigration and eventual amnesty which provides citizenship and voting rights to tens of millions of illegals?

There is some basis for such a theory. There is some basis for thinking that one of the agendas of liberal attitudes towards illegal immigration on the southern border is to bring in lots of folks from communities that traditionally vote Blue and use them to help swing elections.

https://www.usatoday.com/story/news...hispanic-votes-to-turn-texas-purple/81224392/

Majority of Hispanics vote Democrat. Everyone knows this. Not too crazy to see how amnesty and voting rights for 13 million illegals could definitely help turn some Red states purple, especially of the folks who gave them their amnesty and voting rights are Democrats.

Is this paranoid thinking? Democrats would never dare think of such a hush-hush strategy to win national elections? I dont think it is. I myself am a Democrat and could definitely see this as being a long-term goal of refusing to do hard core enforcement at the border. Obviously building a border barrier would make such a goal harder, which I believe is partially why there was such anger at the idea of Trump's wall. Although the Democrats did almost give Trump his wall, in exchange for DACA, which Trump refused.
 
No there's no good version of a violent racist death fantasy.

So there's no good reason to go looking for one.
 
Yes, racism.

Eta: Have you never heard of Florida?

Florida seems to be an exceptional case as most Cubans were fleeing Communism.

Most Hispanic immigrants these days are not.

Democrats assume amnesty will eventually pass, and they will reap the political benefits. I can just imagine the campaign ads:

"we gave u citizenship, now dont forget us at the polls".
 
Seems "true" Replacement Theorists believe there is an attempt at white genocide, by means of non-white immigration, inter-racial marriages, low birth rate amongst white couples, etc. Obviously its silly.

But what if Replacement Theory is about politics rather than race?

What if there is a not so secret attempt to turn Red states purple and even Blue, by means of illegal immigration and eventual amnesty which provides citizenship and voting rights to tens of millions of illegals?

There is some basis for such a theory. There is some basis for thinking that one of the agendas of liberal attitudes towards illegal immigration on the southern border is to bring in lots of folks from communities that traditionally vote Blue and use them to help swing elections.

https://www.usatoday.com/story/news...hispanic-votes-to-turn-texas-purple/81224392/

Majority of Hispanics vote Democrat. Everyone knows this. Not too crazy to see how amnesty and voting rights for 13 million illegals could definitely help turn some Red states purple, especially of the folks who gave them their amnesty and voting rights are Democrats.

Is this paranoid thinking? Democrats would never dare think of such a hush-hush strategy to win national elections? I dont think it is. I myself am a Democrat and could definitely see this as being a long-term goal of refusing to do hard core enforcement at the border. Obviously building a border barrier would make such a goal harder, which I believe is partially why there was such anger at the idea of Trump's wall. Although the Democrats did almost give Trump his wall, in exchange for DACA, which Trump refused.

The base assumption is that the right will never divorce itself from explicitly racist and nationalistic positions which means immigrants will overwhelmingly support their opposition.

It's probably worth asking why immigration is bad for Republicans. Many immigrants are coming from more socially conservative countries that might align with many conservative values if it weren't for the overt racism that is a central plank of the American right political platform.

For this CT to have any merit, you also have to assume that Democrats are somehow open-border extremists, when in observed reality their policies do not differ significantly from those of Republicans (with the exception of stupid vanity projects like the wall). Obama was labeled the "deporter in chief" by activists, and liberals have already forgotten about "kids in cages" now that it's their guy running the camps.

You also can't divorce "Replacement Theory" ideas from the anti-semitism and anti-black racism that has been at its core for generations now. This newest iteration isn't meaningfully different from the crap that inspired white nationalist dreck for decades now, such as in "The Turner Diaries". These freaks are as much concerned about non-white populations that have been in the US for as long as proper white people have as they are about immigrants.
 
Last edited:
Florida seems to be an exceptional case as most Cubans were fleeing Communism.

Most Hispanic immigrants these days are not.

Democrats assume amnesty will eventually pass, and they will reap the political benefits. I can just imagine the campaign ads:

"we gave u citizenship, now dont forget us at the polls".

Florida is one of the most populous states in the union, hardly an outlier.

Then head to south Texas. Many, many rural Hispanics are staunchly pro-life and very conservative.
 
*snip*

Is this paranoid thinking? Democrats would never dare think of such a hush-hush strategy to win national elections? I dont think it is. I myself am a Democrat and could definitely see this as being a long-term goal of refusing to do hard core enforcement at the border. Obviously building a border barrier would make such a goal harder, which I believe is partially why there was such anger at the idea of Trump's wall. Although the Democrats did almost give Trump his wall, in exchange for DACA, which Trump refused.

I can't see what is paranoid about it. Any political party or movement will want to support their supporters. That is sort of the whole idea. And some political movements are, to various degrees, sympathetic to immigration. And, obviously, most immigrants will tend to support such groups.

Replacement theory is the idea that you want somehow do away with certain parts of a population and insert others in their place. That's a different thing from thinking that there should be room for, ideally all, groups.

Hans
 
The base assumption is that the right will never divorce itself from explicitly racist and nationalistic positions which means immigrants will overwhelmingly support their opposition.

It's probably worth asking why immigration is bad for Republicans. Many immigrants are coming from more socially conservative countries that might align with many conservative values if it weren't for the overt racism that is a central plank of the American right political platform.

For this CT to have any merit, you also have to assume that Democrats are somehow open-border extremists, when in observed reality their policies do not differ significantly from those of Republicans (with the exception of stupid vanity projects like the wall). Obama was labeled the "deporter in chief", and liberals have already forgotten about "kids in cages" now that it's their guy running the camps.

You also can't divorce "Replacement Theory" ideas from the anti-semitism and anti-black racism that has been at its core for generations now. This newest iteration isn't meaningfully different from the crap that inspired white nationalist dreck for decades now, such as in "The Turner Diaries".

Many Democrats do pretty much believe in open-borders.

They believe all illegals detained in the USA should be released with a pending court date, with no control over where they go after they are released. If they don't come to their court hearing, oh well. They will just live & work in the USA until the next big amnesty bill is passed by Congress.

Many on the far-Left also believe that Mexicans have the historic right to come to the southwest USA, as it used to be part of Mexico. They also see Latin American migration to the USA and citizenship as a form of reperations for past American involvement in Latin American affairs. The DSA literally calls for no borders.
 
Florida seems to be an exceptional case as most Cubans were fleeing Communism.

Most Hispanic immigrants these days are not.

Democrats assume amnesty will eventually pass, and they will reap the political benefits. I can just imagine the campaign ads:

"we gave u citizenship, now dont forget us at the polls".

So this is your conspiracy theory.
 
So this is your conspiracy theory.

Yes kinda.

Now whether or not more Latin immigrants will actually fulfill the Democrats agenda remains to be seen. I read that its not working exactly as planned in Texas, but it has worked well in California.
 
Considering our most recent shooter (and killers before) targeted black people, a population that stopped mass immigrating to the US when the slave trade was outlawed centuries ago, focusing strictly on immigration across the southern border is overlooking the racist white-anxiety that is the root of the ideology.

Great Replacement theory isn't strictly about immigration, it's about white anxiety more broadly.
 
Only the Right could turn "The other side doesn't treat an entire demographic like crap" into a conspiracy theory.

Yes the Left doesn't call everyone who isn't a waspy old money what man a rapist, killer, or subhuman. It's SOOOOOO unfair that that loses the Right some votes.
 
Only the Right could turn "The other side doesn't treat an entire demographic like crap" into a conspiracy theory.

Yes the Left doesn't call everyone who isn't a waspy old money what man a rapist, killer, or subhuman. It's SOOOOOO unfair that that loses the Right some votes.

Its true, the GOP could attempt to embrace Latin immigrants with Conservative social values. Im sure many of them are not a big fan of gay/transgender and abortion politics, as it is very against their Catholic beliefs.
 
This idea is ridiculous, but even if were true, so what? The US immigration policy doesn't have a political quota, and it's against the law to prevent immigration due to beliefs.
 
This idea is ridiculous, but even if were true, so what? The US immigration policy doesn't have a political quota, and it's against the law to prevent immigration due to beliefs.

Using immigration to change the political dynamics of a country is pretty dispicable.
 
Personally I don't care if the USA and Canada lose their white majority. We are immigrant nations, taken by brutal conquest of non-white natives. Maybe its karma.

European states, however, I believe have every right to have immigration laws that work to maintain their ethnic or even racial majorities, if they so choose.

Japan does it, South Korea does it, Taiwan does it, so why not Denmark and Ireland?
 
Using immigration to change the political dynamics of a country is pretty dispicable.

Who would be doing that? Any immigrant arrives by their own free will. No one is driving around Mexico with a truck looking for progressives.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom