Is there anything to "Replacement Theory"?

Well, there was the same theory about the evil Catholics going to outbreed all the good protestants in the Netherlands and turn the country into a papal dependency by abusing democracy, which is why they should not be given the vote or be allowed to re-establish the bishoprics.
This was in the early to mid 1800's

By now we are a country where more than 50% of the populations considers themselves non-religious.

So, I'm not too worried.

That's a little different. If Ireland suddenly sees a wave of conversions to Buddhism, its a matter of free choice.
 
800,000 a year is low? Says who?

My amateur economic projections based on dropping birth rates.

What other country allows so many yearly immigrants plus 100,000 refugees?

You're right of course, the US is pretty welcoming compared to the rest of the world. Might be why it's such a global power.

Why are you advocating for people who are not only not yet citizens, but don't even live here yet...or American citizens?

Are the needs of possible future residents and citizens of the USA equal to those of current Americans???

Because I don't see a net negative to people who are currently citizens if more people immigrate. I don't care about any specific "culture", so the only real concern is economical.
 
My amateur economic projections based on dropping birth rates.



You're right of course, the US is pretty welcoming compared to the rest of the world. Might be why it's such a global power.



Because I don't see a net negative to people who are currently citizens if more people immigrate. I don't care about "culture", so the only real concern is economical.

So you don't believe in nations, and anyone who does you see as backwards? Ok.
 
I believe that its assumed that Latin immigrants will vote Blue, as its the Democrats who have been pushing for lax border enforcement and amnesty.

Non-citizens can't vote. Just how are these immigrants supposed to vote for Democrats?
 
Non-citizens can't vote. Just how are these immigrants supposed to vote for Democrats?

Democrats are VERY adamant that any amnesty law includes path to citizenship to pretty much all but most recent illegal migrants.

An extra 10 million Democrats could have a big effect on control of the Senate and the White House.
 
There are also some folks who want to get rid of citizenship requirements for voting.
 
So you don't believe in nations, and anyone who does you see as backwards? Ok.

What do you mean by nation?

Japan seems to be the most immediate demographic time bomb. Will it somehow be lessened by the inevitable mixing of local and foreign culture or will the emerging culture be just as valuable?
 
Democrats are VERY adamant that any amnesty law includes path to citizenship to pretty much all but most recent illegal migrants.

An extra 10 million Democrats could have a big effect on control of the Senate and the White House.

Oh noes it make actually *checks notes* make the Senate more aligned with actual America instead of a minority that has cheated and gerrymandered their way into power.

Not that! Anything but that!
 
My amateur economic projections based on dropping birth rates.



You're right of course, the US is pretty welcoming compared to the rest of the world. Might be why it's such a global power.



Because I don't see a net negative to people who are currently citizens if more people immigrate. I don't care about any specific "culture", so the only real concern is economical.

I do not believe you, unless of course you'd be fine with a "culture" that required women to be accompanied by a male of their household when ever they leave the house. A culture were violent retaliation is required at any insult. A Culture that allowed for dog fights, rape, child marriage, etc.

Relatively extreme examples but I suspect strongly that you do actually care about the culture of the place you live in.
 
I'm sure some also want to get rid of residency requirements too.

:D

And there's people who want to forego election results all together, and just rule by force by storming the Capitol and preventing the government from executing the will of the people. And unlike your hypothetical boogeymen, the people I'm talking about have actually tried to put their plan in action, and still believe what they did was justified. Scariest of all, those people are real, they walk the streets, we meet them every day -- unlike the nebulous "some" to which racists like to refer when trying to find justification for their racism.
 
Last edited:
<Opinion tags on>

We have an aging population, jobs going unfilled and many of the filled jobs being poorly done.

We need workers, doers. And we shouldn't give hoot about their skin color, their language, their country of origin, or their religion as long as they accept the "American way" (whatever that is?).

Who gives a dang whether the great grandkids are darker then Paw Paw or go to a different house of worship?

It beats the hell out of living in a gated community being served by loafs too stupid to read your medic alert bracelet.

<Opinion tags off>

--------------
Dope Clock II: It's been 327 days since Bobby Menard announced plans to create "Artists Valley". So far all he has done is lie through his teeth.
 
A nation is a group of people with similar background, history, culture, going back at least a few centuries.

Says who? By that definition, only a handful of nations exist. Hell, I'm not even sure the U.S.A. would qualify under those specifications.
 
I do not believe you, unless of course you'd be fine with a "culture" that required women to be accompanied by a male of their household when ever they leave the house. A culture were violent retaliation is required at any insult. A Culture that allowed for dog fights, rape, child marriage, etc.

Relatively extreme examples but I suspect strongly that you do actually care about the culture of the place you live in.

Okay, you're right. I do care. That was a little stupid. I guess I presume that humanity will naturally improve human rights as the lives of people improve, but that might be naive on my part.
 
Says who? By that definition, only a handful of nations exist. Hell, I'm not even sure the U.S.A. would qualify under those specifications.
I read a book by a guy called Walker Conner called Ethnonationalism: The Quest for Understanding. He's supposed to be the founder of nationalism studies. It's a while now, but my recollection is that he thinks for a nation to exist, you need some kind of shared national story, probably an origin story, that frames the people of the nation within the context of the nation. It's subjective, so it doesn't really matter what the actual ethnic origins of the people are, so long as they buy into their common identification as a nation and a people.

The US is a bit unique in that it genuinely is a nation of immigrants. What unites the US into a nation is the shared identification into this origin story of coming to the land of hope and opportunity and working their way up. You don't have to go back that far to find immigrants deliberately not passing on their native language to make sure their children were "American". What would destroy the US as a nation would be if large numbers of people stopped identifying with that origin story. What you then have is a whole bunch of different peoples from widely different cultures contending with each other.

He points out that most peoples never get a nation.

One of the big things in the book is the distinction between state, country and nation.
 
Okay, you're right. I do care. That was a little stupid. I guess I presume that humanity will naturally improve human rights as the lives of people improve, but that might be naive on my part.
This is the same assumption that said it was fine to help grow the Chinese economy because it would lead to them becoming liberal. This is Fukuyama's end of history. There are countless examples of civilisations reaching (from the liberal standpoint) a high point, only to lose vigour and be overwhelmed by more vital barbarians.

Liberalism is culturally specific to a particular tradition that came out of northern Europe. There is nothing universally self evident about its "self evident" truths.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom