Is there anything to "Replacement Theory"?

Florida seems to be an exceptional case as most Cubans were fleeing Communism.

Most Hispanic immigrants these days are not.

Democrats assume amnesty will eventually pass, and they will reap the political benefits. I can just imagine the campaign ads:

"we gave u citizenship, now dont forget us at the polls".

Bollocks. Amnesty which Reagan signed into law BTW, didn't grant anyone citizenship. And you know who opposed the bill? Employers who wanted to keep exploiting undocumented immigrants.
 
We need workers, doers. And we shouldn't give hoot about their skin color, their language, their country of origin, or their religion as long as they accept the "American way" (whatever that is?)
Do they accept it?
 
you are proving my point of not knowing what you are talking about.

I clearly said "undocumented immigrants", not migrants with a legal right to be in the US.

I would take right-wingers more seriously on the subject if they would even make the attempt make a distinction between migrant workers, documented migrants, undocumented migrants and refugees.


I guess "citizen" and "non-citizen" isn't a good enough distinction, right? Obviously this is a big change, if only 15 areas in the US allow such voting. Let's not be coy...I think we all know where this is headed, if liberals get to choose.

Democrats celebrate a more diverse voting base, obviously. They would love to wake up tomorrow with less whites voting, overall. They aren't shedding tears as that base shrinks, no doubt.
 
Last edited:
What do you mean by nation?

Japan seems to be the most immediate demographic time bomb. Will it somehow be lessened by the inevitable mixing of local and foreign culture or will the emerging culture be just as valuable?
Globalism blends all cultures together into a cross between a grey goo and "Its a Small World After All". Cultural identities need to exist within the context of other people practicing the same culture and producing their culture. Sure, the odd outsider is fine, but for the culture to really live... it needs to be the overwhelming majority. How Irish are Irish Americans really? It fades over time, and what endures is like the St Patrick's day version of Irishness. Very few cultures are suited to long term survival uprooted from their association with some region that is theirs, particularly now with the homogenising effects of media.

Why should the Japanese let this happen to their culture?
 
Last edited:
Okay, you're right. I do care. That was a little stupid. I guess I presume that humanity will naturally improve human rights as the lives of people improve, but that might be naive on my part.

You know, my post was a bit over snarky, I kind of regret that but your response is quite gracious. Thank you.
 
No, now they are running away from either dictatorial death squads or cartels that make old Murder Inc. look like 'we only kiss babies'. :rolleyes:

Why should that matter? America proudly refused to take in refugee jews in 1943 when it knew the holocaust was happening why should we fail to live up to the standard set by the greatest generation?

https://time.com/5889460/american-history-war-on-immigrants/

The jews were Europe's problem it was up to Europe to find a solution.
 
A nation is a group of people with similar background, history, culture, going back at least a few centuries.

Says who? By that definition, only a handful of nations exist. Hell, I'm not even sure the U.S.A. would qualify under those specifications.

Hercules' definition of a nation runs counter to the U.S of freakin' A in colonial times.

Dutch, Jews and Muslims in NY. English Puritans in New England. Well to do plantation owners who transplanted slavery to the old south from the Caribbean. Tide water Virginians from the English upper classes. Quakers in PA. Scots/Irish in early Appalachia. French. Spanish. Slaves and freed blacks. Assimilated Native Americans.

Apologies to anyone left out.


--------------
Dope Clock II: It's been 327 days since Bobby Menard announced plans to create "Artists Valley". So far all he has done is lie through his teeth.
 
Last edited:
I think a view properly american on race is best found in Ben Franklin and his concerns over they degredation of the white race by those swarthy germans.

"Which leads me to add one Remark: That the Number of purely white People in the World is proportionably very small. All Africa is black or tawny. Asia chiefly tawny. America (exclusive of the new Comers) wholly so. And in Europe, the Spaniards, Italians, French, Russians and Swedes, are generally of what we call a swarthy Complexion; as are the Germans also, the Saxons only excepted, who with the English, make the principal Body of White People on the Face of the Earth. I could wish their Numbers were increased." Ben Franklin

https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2008/02/swarthy-germans/48324/
 
Hercules' definition of a nation runs counter to the U.S of freakin' A in colonial times.

Dutch, Jews and Muslims in NY. English Puritans in New England. Well to do plantation owners who transplanted slavery to the old south from the Caribbean. Tide water Virginians from the English upper classes. Quakers in PA. Scots/Irish in early Appalachia. French. Spanish. Slaves and freed blacks. Assimilated Native Americans.

Apologies to anyone left out.


--------------
Dope Clock II: It's been 327 days since Bobby Menard announced plans to create "Artists Valley". So far all he has done is lie through his teeth.
I would say it is debatable whether it was truly a nation. Maybe at first in the sense of being united around a shared idea.... but the Civil War is kind of evidence that it had ceased to be. It seems to go through periods where some new idea of itself holds it together for a bit before that falls away. If you don't have a uniting sense of purpose and identity, you are in a world of trouble as a country. What is the uniting idea of America and being an American at present that the overwhelming majority of Americans can get behind? Justifying national myths allow you to hold a country together without having to rely on force. The typical end result of failing to do this is violence and balkanization.
 
Last edited:
I am reading American Nations by Colin Woodard

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Nations

A History of the Eleven Rival Regional Cultures of North America is an American non-fiction book written by Colin Woodard and published in 2011. Woodard proposes a framework for examining American history and current events based on a view of the country as a federation of eleven nations, each defined by a shared culture established by each nation's founding population.

Noting that the original thirteen colonies were established at different times and by different groups with different goals and values, Woodard shows how these colonies both cooperated and competed from their founding. The principles held dear by each colony often conflicted with those of other colonies, and those conflicting agendas shaped the founding and growth of the United States. As the country expanded, the populace that moved into the new territory brought with it the culture of the society from which they came, resulting in nations – a group that shares a common culture and origin – divorced from legal state and international boundaries. American Nations argues that the contrasts between regional cultures, as opposed to state borders, provide a more useful and accurate explanation of events and movements.

--------------
Dope Clock II: It's been 327 days since Bobby Menard announced plans to create "Artists Valley". So far all he has done is lie through his teeth.
 
I would say it is debatable whether it was truly a nation. Maybe at first in the sense of being united around a shared idea.... but the Civil War is kind of evidence that it had ceased to be. It seems to go through periods where some new idea of itself holds it together for a bit before that falls away. If you don't have a uniting sense of purpose and identity, you are in a world of trouble as a country. What is the uniting idea of America and being an American at present that the overwhelming majority of Americans can get behind? Justifying national myths allow you to hold a country together without having to rely on force. The typical end result of failing to do this is violence and balkanization.

The United States is a country based on a social philosophy, not race. The philosophy is laid out in the Declaration of Independence, and in the Preamble of the Constitution.

That's it.

The Constitution is the mechanism for governing the country, while limiting the powers of the government at the federal and state levels. The Constitution - by design - can be amended to as the nation, and its people evolve. And it has been amended many times, and will continue to be.

As to the OP: It's BS. Rantings of white trash who are too lazy to measure up, and or blame others for their own failings.

Nobody complains about the Canadians moving here, or the folks from the UK. We're taking in thousands of Ukrainians at the moment to thundering silence from the right. But folks from Central and South America? ZMG! Invasion!

I live in a largely Hispanic community in Central California where John Steinbeck lived, and wrote about. The issues in his books, The Pearl, Grapes of Wrath, Of Mice and Men still exist here, and in our Central Valley, only the faces are darker, and Okies are now the latest Latin American migrants. California's ethnic breakdown is this:

39% of state residents are Latino, 35% are white, 15% are Asian American or Pacific Islander, 5% are Black, 4% are multiracial, and fewer than 1% are Native American or Alaska Natives, according to the 2020 Census.

Yet with the rise in the Latino population there has been no corollary rise in liberalism. In fact, a voter initiative to reinstate affirmative action in state college admittance was voted down, as have been other left-wing initiatives such as rent control. This next primary election will see this trend to the right continue, led by various local Latino communities. Why? Seems Latinos are capable of thinking for themselves, and tend to vote on issues based on merit, rather than blind party loyalty.

If I ran the GOP, I'd have teams along the border waiting to greet those crossing the border with food, and shelter. And the whole time these teams would be passively indoctrinating our newest residents into the GOP. But I'm sneaky that way.

Meanwhile, every day when I pull onto main road, heading to the highway, I see four or five large, orange agricultural robots/drones tending the Artichoke and Spinach fields, as technology has begun "Replacing" humans in the fields...

https://californiaagtoday.com/farmwise-bringing-automation-to-field/

In short, the threat might not be a human one.
 
I would say it is debatable whether it was truly a nation. Maybe at first in the sense of being united around a shared idea.... but the Civil War is kind of evidence that it had ceased to be. It seems to go through periods where some new idea of itself holds it together for a bit before that falls away. If you don't have a uniting sense of purpose and identity, you are in a world of trouble as a country. What is the uniting idea of America and being an American at present that the overwhelming majority of Americans can get behind? Justifying national myths allow you to hold a country together without having to rely on force. The typical end result of failing to do this is violence and balkanization.

I never claimed the USA is or ever was a nation-state.

We are a post-colonial nation, developed mostly by invaders who massacred the natives following an absurd and racist ideology of racial supremacy and manifest destiny.

Unlike Ireland, Germany, France, Spain, Italy, Lithuania, etc.
 
Why should that matter? America proudly refused to take in refugee jews in 1943 when it knew the holocaust was happening why should we fail to live up to the standard set by the greatest generation?

https://time.com/5889460/american-history-war-on-immigrants/

The jews were Europe's problem it was up to Europe to find a solution.

I make an exception for refugees fleeing persecution/war. I think all nations should do their best to have a generous refugee policy. Its the moral thing to do. Not saying they should guarantee citizenship or permanent settlement.
 
I never claimed the USA is or ever was a nation-state.

If you are going to use "Nation State" as a code word for "Ethnically Pure Vunderstate" you could have led with that.

Race should not factor into the identity of any political division.

Let's see how you doublespeak your way out of not answer that.
 
I never claimed the USA is or ever was a nation-state.

We are a post-colonial nation, developed mostly by invaders who massacred the natives following an absurd and racist ideology of racial supremacy and manifest destiny.

Unlike Ireland, Germany, France, Spain, Italy, Lithuania, etc.
Most of those countries were conquered and reconquered. Is there a point at which the US stops counting as stolen land in the way that Europe apparently has? I know it's a tired old thing to point out, but Native American tribes fought brutal wars and stole the land from weaker tribes. Was their ethnic destruction and theft just, and that of the white man not? Why?

What doomed the Native Americans was the advance of American industry and agriculture westward. Nothing could have preserved their way of life.
 
The United States is a country based on a social philosophy, not race. The philosophy is laid out in the Declaration of Independence, and in the Preamble of the Constitution.

That's it.
No. You don't get to axiomatically define a country by fiat. 1776 is only the basis of the country so long as the overwhelming majority of the population believe it.

Nobody complains about the Canadians moving here, or the folks from the UK. We're taking in thousands of Ukrainians at the moment to thundering silence from the right. But folks from Central and South America? ZMG! Invasion!
No indeed, but then there is far less of a culture clash when a family of Canadians moves in next door than a family of Somalis. A few Ukranians aren't going to make any difference. Cultures aren't fungible.

What makes a difference is a million this year, a million next year, a million the year after that. It's laughable to suggest that one should also complain about a one off migration of some trivial number. This isn't some anti-immigrant moral principle that applies equally whether it is one immigrant or a million, it's a practical concern.

I live in a largely Hispanic community in Central California where John Steinbeck lived, and wrote about. The issues in his books, The Pearl, Grapes of Wrath, Of Mice and Men still exist here, and in our Central Valley, only the faces are darker, and Okies are now the latest Latin American migrants. California's ethnic breakdown is this:

39% of state residents are Latino, 35% are white, 15% are Asian American or Pacific Islander, 5% are Black, 4% are multiracial, and fewer than 1% are Native American or Alaska Natives, according to the 2020 Census.

Yet with the rise in the Latino population there has been no corollary rise in liberalism. In fact, a voter initiative to reinstate affirmative action in state college admittance was voted down, as have been other left-wing initiatives such as rent control. This next primary election will see this trend to the right continue, led by various local Latino communities. Why? Seems Latinos are capable of thinking for themselves, and tend to vote on issues based on merit, rather than blind party loyalty.
Indeed, I wouldn't particularly expect a rise in liberalism through these communities. Ultimately I think immigration is a good way to end the liberal project, even if in the short term it gives Democrats an electoral advantage. Whether one thinks that is a good thing is up for debate.

If I ran the GOP, I'd have teams along the border waiting to greet those crossing the border with food, and shelter. And the whole time these teams would be passively indoctrinating our newest residents into the GOP. But I'm sneaky that way.
Sure, but I don't think a country can really run on bribing immigrants to vote a particular way with welfare treats and handouts. The GOP are dumb.

Meanwhile, every day when I pull onto main road, heading to the highway, I see four or five large, orange agricultural robots/drones tending the Artichoke and Spinach fields, as technology has begun "Replacing" humans in the fields...

https://californiaagtoday.com/farmwise-bringing-automation-to-field/

In short, the threat might not be a human one.
Sure, that is something else. At the same time jobs continue to be shipped overseas, skilled labour is being imported along with a permanent client class. The elite are global and can easily escape the social consequences of all this.
 
Many Democrats do pretty much believe in open-borders.
According to right-wing talking heads.

They believe all illegals detained in the USA should be released with a pending court date, with no control over where they go after they are released. If they don't come to their court hearing, oh well. They will just live & work in the USA until the next big amnesty bill is passed by Congress.
More falsehoods.

11 Years of Government Data Reveal That Immigrants Do Show Up for Court

Many on the far-Left also believe that Mexicans have the historic right to come to the southwest USA, as it used to be part of Mexico. They also see Latin American migration to the USA and citizenship as a form of reperations for past American involvement in Latin American affairs. The DSA literally calls for no borders.
More bollocks. I notice you never cite the sources of these beliefs of yours.
 
Democrats are VERY adamant that any amnesty law includes path to citizenship to pretty much all but most recent illegal migrants.

An extra 10 million Democrats could have a big effect on control of the Senate and the White House.

And this path to citizenship takes how long?

The idea is that immigrants don't end up languishing as second class citizens forever. Of course the business owners who benefit from using undocumented labor (aka underpaid) would prefer they stay second class citizens.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom