Is there anything to "Replacement Theory"?

Whu would be doing that? Any immigrant arrives by their own free will. No one is driving around Mexico with a truck looking for progressives.

I believe that its assumed that Latin immigrants will vote Blue, as its the Democrats who have been pushing for lax border enforcement and amnesty.
 
Seems "true" Replacement Theorists believe there is an attempt at white genocide, by means of non-white immigration, inter-racial marriages, low birth rate amongst white couples, etc. Obviously its silly.

But what if Replacement Theory is about politics rather than race?

What if there is a not so secret attempt to turn Red states purple and even Blue, by means of illegal immigration and eventual amnesty which provides citizenship and voting rights to tens of millions of illegals?

There is some basis for such a theory. There is some basis for thinking that one of the agendas of liberal attitudes towards illegal immigration on the southern border is to bring in lots of folks from communities that traditionally vote Blue and use them to help swing elections.

https://www.usatoday.com/story/news...hispanic-votes-to-turn-texas-purple/81224392/

Majority of Hispanics vote Democrat. Everyone knows this. Not too crazy to see how amnesty and voting rights for 13 million illegals could definitely help turn some Red states purple, especially of the folks who gave them their amnesty and voting rights are Democrats.

Is this paranoid thinking? Democrats would never dare think of such a hush-hush strategy to win national elections? I dont think it is. I myself am a Democrat and could definitely see this as being a long-term goal of refusing to do hard core enforcement at the border. Obviously building a border barrier would make such a goal harder, which I believe is partially why there was such anger at the idea of Trump's wall. Although the Democrats did almost give Trump his wall, in exchange for DACA, which Trump refused.

No Fox Fraud News just picked it Up from Jerome Corsi, and the Crazy Minute man Milita Movement and it spread like wild fire among Alt Right Militia Movement Conspiracy theorists.
 
Considering our most recent shooter (and killers before) targeted black people, a population that stopped mass immigrating to the US when the slave trade was outlawed centuries ago, focusing strictly on immigration across the southern border is overlooking the racist white-anxiety that is the root of the ideology.

Great Replacement theory isn't strictly about immigration, it's about white anxiety more broadly.

Hercules, it would be nice if you addressed this. Great Replacement racists are just as anxious about the black population, which are as deep-rooted in this country and American as anyone else (bar Native Americans).

Focusing entirely on immigration is eliding a pretty important element of this racist, white-nationalist CT.
 
Last edited:
No Fox Fraud News just picked it Up from Jerome Corsi, and the Crazy Minute man Milita Movement and it spread like wild fire among Alt Right Militia Movement Conspiracy theorists.

Its not a major secret that Democrats are hoping that amnesty and immigration will eventually turn some Red states purple, or blue. Have to be kinda blind and deaf to have not noticed this over the last few decades.
 
Also let's be honest Democrats going "LOL we've got this election in the bag because we have all of [minority demographic X] in the bag!" and then losing isn't exactly a rare occurrence.

As with all of these type of conspiracy theories the conspiracy doesn't actually seem to be working with any type of gran efficiency
 
Seems "true" Replacement Theorists believe there is an attempt at white genocide, by means of non-white immigration, inter-racial marriages, low birth rate amongst white couples, etc. Obviously its silly.

But what if Replacement Theory is about politics rather than race?

What if there is a not so secret attempt to turn Red states purple and even Blue, by means of illegal immigration and eventual amnesty which provides citizenship and voting rights to tens of millions of illegals?

There is some basis for such a theory. There is some basis for thinking that one of the agendas of liberal attitudes towards illegal immigration on the southern border is to bring in lots of folks from communities that traditionally vote Blue and use them to help swing elections.

https://www.usatoday.com/story/news...hispanic-votes-to-turn-texas-purple/81224392/

Majority of Hispanics vote Democrat. Everyone knows this. Not too crazy to see how amnesty and voting rights for 13 million illegals could definitely help turn some Red states purple, especially of the folks who gave them their amnesty and voting rights are Democrats.

Is this paranoid thinking? Democrats would never dare think of such a hush-hush strategy to win national elections? I dont think it is. I myself am a Democrat and could definitely see this as being a long-term goal of refusing to do hard core enforcement at the border. Obviously building a border barrier would make such a goal harder, which I believe is partially why there was such anger at the idea of Trump's wall. Although the Democrats did almost give Trump his wall, in exchange for DACA, which Trump refused.
It's one of these weird things. If you are in favour of this demographic shift then you can celebrate it in the NYT. If you against it, then you are a white supremacist conspiracy theorist.
 
It's one of these weird things. If you are in favour of this demographic shift then you can celebrate it in the NYT. If you against it, then you are a white supremacist conspiracy theorist.

I know some people want the USA to keep its white majority, but they usually have basically racist or nationalist reasons for this. Its not like our immigration laws favor any specific race. They certainly do NOT favor non-whites, as very often European nations are on the diversity lottery.

Illegal immigration does favor non-whites, but that's just by accident. Its not America's fault that many Latin nations are full of poverty and social decay. Will white supremacists jump for joy if illegals start flooding from Uruguay and Argentina, with their large white populations? I guess.
 
Last edited:
Yes. Being racist is less socially acceptable then being not racist.

Next I can teach you not to touch the hot stove and if that goes well we can move on to shapes and colors.
 
Its not a major secret that Democrats are hoping that amnesty and immigration will eventually turn some Red states purple, or blue. Have to be kinda blind and deaf to have not noticed this over the last few decades.
It's kind of similar to the situation around Bloody Kansas. Once you start using immigration to swing elections your going in a bad direction.
 
Its not a major secret that Democrats are hoping that amnesty and immigration will eventually turn some Red states purple, or blue. Have to be kinda blind and deaf to have not noticed this over the last few decades.

Or simply want to see your evidence.
 
It's kind of similar to the situation around Bloody Kansas. Once you start using immigration to swing elections your going in a bad direction.

Right. Which is why I'm sure you support only Native Americans voting and holding political office.
 
I know some people want the USA to keep its white majority, but they usually have basically racist or nationalist reasons for this. Its not like our immigration laws favor any specific race. They certainly do NOT favor non-whites, as very often European nations are on the diversity lottery.

Illegal immigration does favor non-whites, but that's just by accident. Its not America's fault that many Latin nations are full of poverty and social decay. Will white supremacists jump for joy if illegals start flooding from Uruguay and Argentina, with their large white populations? I guess.

I thought most illegals came via south American countries?
 
Its not America's fault that many Latin nations are full of poverty and social decay.

Bit of a derail, but you might want to look into the history of many of these desperately poor Central and South American countries a bit more closely. You might find that American influence often has a lot to do with why mass exodus is occurring there.
 
Bit of a derail, but you might want to look into the history of many of these desperately poor Central and South American countries a bit more closely. You might find that American influence often has a lot to do with why mass exodus is occurring there.

Yes I have heard this. Are there any threads about this?
 
Yes I have heard this. Are there any threads about this?

I'm not sure why there would be. America's use of soft and hard power over our Southern neighbors is not really that hotly contested anymore. It's not even "conspiracy theory", but more accepted fact including by key players like the CIA and State Department. The historical record is out there for anyone to read. Fire up Wikipedia if you want to know more.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom