Is there anything a person can do to justify torture?

You are making a bald assertion without offering any evidence. The idea that every crime is a rational decision based on risks and gains is, in my opinion, rather silly. Do you believe that a man who murders another man in a drunken rage truly thought the satisfaction he got from the murder was worth the chance of being caught?
Yep, that economic model of crime is crazy, if you say so, but I believe it's pretty fundamental, going back at least to Jeremy Bentham and the modern version is part of the economic work that got Dr. Gary becker a Nobel Prize

Do I believe it? From pretty much a lifetime of being involved with crime in about every way possible - Absolutely. A drunken rage is simply one of the causes of having made a poor calculation - no different than a drunk who thinks he can drive home safely, even though he would normally be against driving drunk, because he is in no shape to weigh the odds.

You are on the right track on one thing; what is important is how often criminals get caught. If you know you'll almost certainly be caught and punished for your crime, there is a strong deterrent. But there's no reason to believe the harshness of the punishment affects the deterrent effect.
Examine yourself. If the punishment for robbing banks was 30 days in jail and benefit and chance of success were what they are now, I'd probably rob one every day. There are probably plenty of illegal things you'd do - drive without a seatbelt if the punishment was a $5 fine? Answer the question for yourself and you'll convince yourself better than I can.

What do you mean? Are you claiming that the crime rates in states which use the death penalty are impossible to know, and that suggesting they are, in fact, not lower than those in other states, is "smoke and mirrors"?
What I said, and you quoted, was that neither side could prove it. You claim "it's a known fact" but even though I agree that you are probably right, there is no evidence to support your bare conclusion that "it's a known fact."

Are you really suggesting that if there were no prisons, every human would be committing crimes? That is a rather bleak worldview, and fortunately one not supported by evidence.

No - before there were prisons, there was vengeance. Without legal punishment, we would still have the deterrent effect of private justice. There is NO evidence to dispute that world view, it's as simple as the history of civilization.
 
So you are saying a person under the influence of alcohol won't do anything they wouldn't do sober?
I didn't say that. But I say that alcohol does not cause a person to commit any crime, the reason for any crime is somewhere else than in the fact that alcohol was consumed by the person (okay we can exclude drunk driving from this).

The vast majority of crimes are committed spontaneously
A bold claim. Majority, hmmm. And vast majority, uhh. Begs for a source. And details what type of crimes this applies to.

by people who don't really think of the consequences.
That is a problem, and the state must do something about these people. Consequences to themselves are a secondary thing, the main point is how criminals do to others what they do to others.

no bearing on the idea that making a harsh prison sentence an even harsher death sentence, or torture sentence, if you will, would increase the deterrent effect.
We are interested in creating an efficient deterrent, but that is not the only thing we are thinking about. Responding equal with equal is the lesson to give, every person should know that the state will respond equally to them what they do to their victims.
 
Last edited:
I can't argue that the death penalty is little deterrent. It has nothing to do with whether "torture" "vegeance" or plain old punishment is a deterrent (execution is a long way from torture).

Yes, it does. People commit crimes whether there's a punishment or not. And one of the multiple problems with the death penalty, of course, is that it is irrevesrible.

"It's a known fact"? I agree and I still can't prove it. neither can the advocates who regularly oppose the death penalty, other than by some smoke and mirrors that doesn't hold up to examination.

Perhaps you should look for threads about the death penalty where this has been discussed to... er... death.

You also neglected to respond as to whether you are deterred from doing things to people for fear of vengeance or punishment. Since you are human, alive and not in prison, we can probably guess the answer.

I don't need to guess my own answer, Brenn. I don't commit crime because I feel empathy towards others. The minute that empathy dissapears (if it were ever to), then, and only then, would fear of reprisal enter into the equation.

The fact that I just purchased 350$ worth of music albums rather than just download them like I could shows this.
 
That is called insurance fraud, a crime that is punished not only by taking back the stolen money, but also with further legal consequences to the person.

And a lot of headaches for no reason. So when you give an alledged victim a compensation, then they spend it, then you discover they lied, you're going right back to the monetary punishment you mentioned in the first place. Very inefficient.

With this in mind my previous comment included the phrase "that evidently has taken place", requiring some evidence that a crime has taken place at all.

No. "Evidently" is what you do when you skip the courts and go right to the conclusion. In order for this to be evident, you need the jury to rule on the case, in which case you'd have to wait. You can't have your cake and eat it, too, JJM.

You can argue that no theory whatsoever works in practice. In reality they do, with varying outcomes.

Not all of them. And not this one. Or perhaps you have some evidence to show that it does ?

The criminal is the issue, because the criminal is the author of crimes, unlike the mainstream population. The criminal is _the problem_ that must be taken care of to avoid further damage, and to give the mainstream population peace of mind that dangerous persons have been removed from the society.

Even at the cost of worsening the situation ? This is justice to you ?

For example robbers or drug traffickers "might as well go all the way and kill any police officer who tries to arrest you"

Gosh, you really understand nothing of what you read. Since the punishment for murder is WORSE than the punishment for drug trafficking (I assume), then YES they to have something to lose by doing that.
 
Examine yourself. If the punishment for robbing banks was 30 days in jail and benefit and chance of success were what they are now, I'd probably rob one every day.

This is precisely what I hate, no offense, about religious fundamentalists: the idea that without some sort of sword of divine vengeance hanging over their heads, the atheists are immoral monsters.

You're doing the same thing here: assuming that the only thing preventing everyone from being an evil bastard is the law.

No. The law is there to prevent the most evil of us from doing what most of us wouldn't do anyway. That's why the law is there, in fact: because we view those acts as evil.

And then you go right ahead and include YOURSELF in the group of people who would do evil if there was no punishment involved. No wonder you think everyone would do this: you're one of them !

Not to burst your bubble, but not everyone is like you: you are the minority.
 
So when you give an alledged victim a compensation (blah blah) Very inefficient.
Immediate compensation to every victim. Some cases of fraud here and there, as happens in the insurance business.

Versus what we have now: the victim _waiting_ that the police _maybe_ catch the criminal, who is _maybe_ convicted in court, and then he _maybe_ has money to pay a compensation to the victim. Not very efficient either.

"Evidently" is what you do when you skip the courts and go right to the conclusion. In order for this to be evident, you need the jury to rule on the case
If (any kind of) an insurance company feels that a compensation claim is fraudulent, they will request an inquiry into the case, and if fraud can be proven, it will result in criminal charges against the fraudulent person. So it goes, now and in future.

Even at the cost of worsening the situation ? This is justice to you ?
We seem to have a different view of what "worsening the situation" means, punishing the criminal or leaving him unpunished.

> [omitted from quote]Such extreme scenarios happen also when
> the criminal _does_ have more to lose.[/omitted from quote]
> For example robbers or drug traffickers "might as well go all
> the way and kill any police officer who tries to arrest you"

Gosh, you really understand nothing of what you read. Since the punishment for murder is WORSE than the punishment for drug trafficking (I assume), then YES they to have something to lose by doing that.
Ehh read again the _whole quote_, you are claiming exactly what I already said, and then failing to address my point that they shoot at the police _even though_ they have a lot to lose by doing so. It is a gamble, "all or nothing", no punishment at all if shooting at the cops helps them escape from the scene, _even though_ shooting at the police also worsens their situation a lot if they get caught.
 
Not to burst your bubble, but not everyone is like you: you are the minority.

And you are not only incorrect - you know it. Can I prove it? No, but I don't have to. Everyone just has to examine themselves honestly to prove it to themselves. I gain nothing by making an unprovable argument about your motivations, but people reading it don't believe it any more than you do, so I win anyhow.
 
And you are not only incorrect - you know it.

It's very telling when someone tries to claim that they know what another person knows or doesn't know. And what it tells is that the claimant thinks he knows the other person more than that person himself.

But since you don't know me at all, I find it odd that you think you can make this claim. Also: why would I claim something I know to be untrue ?

Can I prove it? No, but I don't have to.

Spoken like a woo-woo.

I gain nothing by making an unprovable argument about your motivations, but people reading it don't believe it any more than you do, so I win anyhow.

So you're right because people will believe as you do ? Since when does the popularity of an opinion make it true ?

Getting back on topic: have you ever seen stats from countries with the death penalty vs those without ? Magically, there is less violent crime in the latter. Odd, that. You'd think it'd be the other way around.

Now, getting back off-topic, since you seem much more certain than I that you are correct, how about we see some numbers that show that people are only kept in check by laws that prevent them from becoming murdering monsters ?
 
Immediate compensation to every victim. Some cases of fraud here and there, as happens in the insurance business.

So you are of the opinion that the accused is guilty until proven innocent ?

We seem to have a different view of what "worsening the situation" means, punishing the criminal or leaving him unpunished.

You could at least ACT like you're following the discussion. We're talking about the effect of cruel and unusual punishment on the person it's being dealt to. Like bullying in school: it doesn't really make you into a better, more sociable person, does it ?

Ehh read again the _whole quote_, you are claiming exactly what I already said, and then failing to address my point that they shoot at the police _even though_ they have a lot to lose by doing so. It is a gamble, "all or nothing", no punishment at all if shooting at the cops helps them escape from the scene, _even though_ shooting at the police also worsens their situation a lot if they get caught.

But the existence of a worse scenario for them doesn't LEAD them to seek out that scenario, which was my entire point. If there ISN'T a worse scenario, however, things are different.
 
So you are of the opinion that the accused is guilty until proven innocent ?
No, neither was "the accused (= criminal)" even mentioned in this context. The discussion was about insurance compensation to the victim, regardless of who the criminal is, or if he will ever be found at all.

Insurance can be immediate, according to some standard policies, even if the insurance company has doubts about the circumstances and wants to order an inquiry into the case.

We're talking about the effect of cruel and unusual punishment on the person it's being dealt to. Like bullying in school: it doesn't really make you into a better, more sociable person, does it ?
Two very different things:
- punishing evil with equal evil, sending a message that everything you do to others the state will respond to you
- teasing an innocent person just for fun (or even worse, with a pretense such as "he is black / fat / ugly"), sending a message that nothing he has done or will do can change his scumbag social status

But the existence of a worse scenario for them doesn't LEAD them to seek out that scenario, which was my entire point. If there ISN'T a worse scenario, however, things are different.
If it is true that murderers consider their killings so carefully, then they will consider more carefully killing anyone at all, if its punishment will be too much for them to accept. My argument wins your argument, what comes to deterrent effect.

If it is not true that murderers consider their killings so carefully, then your argument loses as much as my argument, what comes to deterrent effect.

"All or nothing" is a popular urge for criminals, they want to escape justice no matter what.
 
Last edited:
No, neither was "the accused (= criminal)" even mentioned in this context. The discussion was about insurance compensation to the victim, regardless of who the criminal is, or if he will ever be found at all.

But you ARE assuming that a crime HAS taken place before any evidence is presented. Isn't that what I described ? Guilty until proven innocent, only in this case it's victim until proven mistaken/liar/etc. Insurance companies usually don't give out money without asking serious questions, first.

- punishing evil with equal evil, sending a message that everything you do to others the state will respond to you

The vast majority of crimes are commited without a thought given to those punishments; and historically the existence of far greater punishments for petty crimes didn't stop those crimes from being commited. Crimes are usually commited without analysing the consequences, either for the victim, if any, or for the perpetrator. That alone should put your utopic view of justice to rest.

- teasing an innocent person just for fun (or even worse, with a pretense such as "he is black / fat / ugly"), sending a message that nothing he has done or will do can change his scumbag social status

Wrong. It teaches that person that bullying makes one the top dog. I was bullied for four years during high school, and I almost learned that lesson, myself. Good thing I snapped back to reality before that happened.

If it is true that murderers consider their killings so carefully, then they will consider more carefully killing anyone at all

Who said they considered it carefully ?

My argument wins your argument, what comes to deterrent effect.

Only in your mind because you're only seeing your argument.

If it is not true that murderers consider their killings so carefully, then your argument loses as much as my argument, what comes to deterrent effect.

And thanks for proving my point. "Head I win, tails you lose !"
 
Insurance companies usually don't give out money without asking serious questions, first.
The procedure is not that complicated. Years ago some thug broke the glass of my car and stole my car stereo. A police officer visited the site, and then I drove the car to car repair, they replaced the glass and installed a new stereo. I never even saw the bills, as the garage sent them directly to the insurance company. If the police ever caught the criminals (I never heard of it), it certainly happened long after I got my compensation. I was a victim of crime, but thanks to the smooth insurance policy my trouble was minimized to a few days of emotional sorrow and the car under repair. Victims of various crimes seldom get compensation as quickly and smoothly as this, which worsens their emotional and practical suffering.

As for the other issues under debate, you are not returning any new arguments so the dust is about to descend.
 
Last edited:
What makes you think that torture is a reliable means of acquiring information?

It is marginally better than getting no information if that happens. If you get the real info, it is much more than marginally better.

To further this - if the bad guy is not going to tell, I have no problem assisting him in understanding what he faces if the victim is not found safe. I, equally, have no problem lying to the bad guy to make him think telling will earn him a simple quick death - but only after verification. I have no sympathy or care for the bad guy or anyone who knowingly assists him/her in any way. Thus, what I said about any lawyer not working frantically to get the bad guy to tell without any attempt to gain leniency or avoid chosen penalties for his deeds I really mean. And I would happily revisit any case where that was done in the past.
 
It is marginally better than getting no information if that happens. If you get the real info, it is much more than marginally better.

You're still not showing that there's a relationship between torturing an individual and acquiring information from them. So now you're shifting your argument towards, "If we don't get any info out of this, at least we get to torture the bastard!" That's pretty disturbing. As far as heinous crimes go, torturing someone for the thrill of it ranks pretty high.
 
Just a friendly non-antagonistic rejoinder re:deterrence - or, more precisely, the apparent assumption that all those pre-death for certain crimes are directly concerned about the value of deterence. I'm not.

That doesn't mean that I am not "wishing" that executions were a deterrent to murder as I am happy to use anything that is one. However, my concern is that a cbc has no value and should be eliminated from any possibility of future poor behavior (rape, murder, kidnapping, commission of intentional bodily damage, or psychological damage, etc. to innocents/non-criminals) and that such elimination should be carried out in a manner such as to leave his/her mind with no doubt that A)at least one person was concerned for the victim(s), B)that the cbc made a very large mistake for which a very high price must be paid, C)that such price would be slow, efficient and memorable - so even in the non-existant afterlife the cbc would have trouble forgetting the message. And, as I have said, same for the lawyer if the lawyer knew the cbc was guilty and did his/her "duty" anyway.
 
You're still not showing that there's a relationship between torturing an individual and acquiring information from them.
Assuming that the person _has_ information, and he is not a brainwashed fundie believer in his ideology, we should have good chances to bribe or threaten the person to betray someone or something that he loves less than his own life. Many would sell even their grandma, so there certainly are persons that give in under pressure more easily than some others. A problem is when these persons _don´t have_ the information that we believe them to have, whom the person will frame or what disinformation the person will make up to save his own buttocks, not because he wants to mislead us but because we force him to mislead us.
 
I once saw an interrogation technique that didn't involve any torture. The "main man" walked into the room and asked which guy most likely knew the most. The man on the left was indicated. The big guy then drew a gun and shot the man on the right. The man on the left immediately began talking.
 
I once saw an interrogation technique that didn't involve any torture. The "main man" walked into the room and asked which guy most likely knew the most. The man on the left was indicated. The big guy then drew a gun and shot the man on the right. The man on the left immediately began talking.

I saw that movie too. :rolleyes:

Wonder how that would work in Real Life. And I wonder if that "interrogation technique" would hold up in court.

In any case, murder with the intent of suggesting that the other detainee is next is still a form of torture.

GB
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom