Yep, that economic model of crime is crazy, if you say so, but I believe it's pretty fundamental, going back at least to Jeremy Bentham and the modern version is part of the economic work that got Dr. Gary becker a Nobel PrizeYou are making a bald assertion without offering any evidence. The idea that every crime is a rational decision based on risks and gains is, in my opinion, rather silly. Do you believe that a man who murders another man in a drunken rage truly thought the satisfaction he got from the murder was worth the chance of being caught?
Do I believe it? From pretty much a lifetime of being involved with crime in about every way possible - Absolutely. A drunken rage is simply one of the causes of having made a poor calculation - no different than a drunk who thinks he can drive home safely, even though he would normally be against driving drunk, because he is in no shape to weigh the odds.
Examine yourself. If the punishment for robbing banks was 30 days in jail and benefit and chance of success were what they are now, I'd probably rob one every day. There are probably plenty of illegal things you'd do - drive without a seatbelt if the punishment was a $5 fine? Answer the question for yourself and you'll convince yourself better than I can.You are on the right track on one thing; what is important is how often criminals get caught. If you know you'll almost certainly be caught and punished for your crime, there is a strong deterrent. But there's no reason to believe the harshness of the punishment affects the deterrent effect.
What I said, and you quoted, was that neither side could prove it. You claim "it's a known fact" but even though I agree that you are probably right, there is no evidence to support your bare conclusion that "it's a known fact."What do you mean? Are you claiming that the crime rates in states which use the death penalty are impossible to know, and that suggesting they are, in fact, not lower than those in other states, is "smoke and mirrors"?
Are you really suggesting that if there were no prisons, every human would be committing crimes? That is a rather bleak worldview, and fortunately one not supported by evidence.
No - before there were prisons, there was vengeance. Without legal punishment, we would still have the deterrent effect of private justice. There is NO evidence to dispute that world view, it's as simple as the history of civilization.