Well, this time I think you're the one who didn't understand. That's alright, though. I won't stop talking to you because of that.
I wasn't aware I changed the topic at any time. We're still talking about torture. You made a hypothetical, which I misinterpreted. Now that you've made that clear, I'm reiterating a question pertaining to your hypothetical, which you refure to answer. I find that odd because I can't understand why you would bring up a hypothetical you're unwilling to discuss.
You believe what you will. Of course, that is the venue of woo-woos, not skeptics. I know you can do better.
Of course. Well, fine. I assume the question you mean is the one about medieval judical systems?
Well, the principle is very simple. With any judicial system, a certain amount of people will fall victim to violent crimes. Let's call this amount V. Now, in any judicial system, a certain amount of innocent people fall victims to faulty judgment, since no judicial system is perfect. Let's call this amount J.
To simplify the model, let's only concentrate or people who are killed. Assault and torture could be added in, but it wouldn't really change much. So V is the number of people murdered and J the amount of people wrongly executed.
Now the question is, how does changing the policy on capital punishment affect these values?
The value of J will be determined by the effectiveness and harshness of the judicial system. In other words, the more people are sentenced to death, the more innocents are, as well, and the better the cases are investigated, the less innocents go to jail.
What determines V is more difficult to determine. Luckily, in this model the value is assumed.
Now, the main point here is that the value we
care about is neither V nor J, but
V+J. This number represents the number of innocent people getting killed, and it's the number we wish to get as low as possible.
My original point was that if by having the death penalty we could lower the amount of violent crimes greatly while only slightly increasing the number of wrongly executed people, this would be a good thing.
Or, to use the symbols,
1) V
1 > V
2
2) J
1 < J
2
3) V
1-V
2 > J
2-J
1
=> V
2 + J
2 < V
1 + J
1
Where J
1 and V
1 refer to the original values and J
2 and V
2 to the values after implementing death penalty. Since the value of V+J is lower in the second case, it is preferable to the first one.
The point of this is that it does not matter how cruel the model
sounds, or how it
appears to violate individual liberties. What
does matter is minimizing the risk to citizens. If by slightly increasing the risk of being executed one can greatly decrease the risk of being murdered, it is a good deal. After all, it doesn't really matter
how you'll be killed; you want to do all you can to avoid it anyway.
So yes; a medieval justice system would be preferable to another system if the total number of undeserved deaths in the system was smaller.
Now, to remind you once more, I am quite aware that this model does not represent reality with much accuracy, and that was never it's purpose. I brought the idea up in response to Gandalf's post where he asked whether I (well, it was not addressed to me, but still) would want to live in a society where it is possible to be wrongly convicted or tortured by the judical system.
And my response was yes, if a small chance of that led to a significantly lowered risk of being assaulted or murdered. It's really just about minimizing
all risks.