Is there anything a person can do to justify torture?

A uselessly broad definition.
There is a very useful common denominator: nobody is ethically guilty for what happens.

what I said you CAN prevent is the death penalty.
The state can stop killing murderers, but will we then lose fewer lives or more lives?

A hint: also the US Army can stop killing anyone at all anywhere, right today. Would we then lose fewer lives or more lives in the world?
 
Years wasted in prison are irreversible too. You only have one life.

Perhaps you should follow the conversation better. I said that you can at least COMPENSATE for incarceration. Not so with death or torture.

nobody is ethically guilty for what happens.

What is that supposed to mean ?

The state can stop killing murderers, but will we then lose fewer lives or more lives?

A very interesting question. I, however, am not necessarily willing to sacrifice X people to save Y people, no matter who they are.

A hint: also the US Army can stop killing anyone at all anywhere, right today. Would we then lose fewer lives or more lives in the world?

The US army, specifically ? :D
 
It's a fair enough argument, but the premise is invalid. I've never suggested that the same laws should not apply to me as well as others - so for the few situations where I would condone torture, I would support a law that also made it legal to torture me in such a situation.

Even if you were innocent ?

Well, we'll have to disagree there. I said you were dishonest, which was true; you did blatantly misrepresent my position.

So one can be unintentionally dishonest ? That's a new one, for me.

I wouldn't say you can compensate for two years of jailtime any more meaningfully than for permanent physical harm. In neither case, what is lost isn't coming back. Admittedly it isn't possible to give any recompense to a dead person, but then again, they don't really want any, anyway.

Not AFTER you kill them, no. :rolleyes:

But anyway, the reversibility issue is not central to the problem. The idea is that in this hypothetical, having the death penalty gives the society an overall greater benefit.

Is this a bad time to point out that western constitutions are mostly based on individual liberties ?

Basically, that means is that while you do have a marginally higher chance of being executed, you have a clearly lower chance of being murdered. If you turn the situation around, giving up the death penalty would increase your chances of being killed through no fault of your own, while having the penalty increases your chances of dying only if you commit serious crimes. All in all, it's very simple math that one situation is better than the other, which is the whole point.

That's only true, however, if someone can statistically prove the deterence factor of capital punishment.
 
Even if you were innocent ?

Was someone suggesting a law that made it legal to torture innocent people?

So one can be unintentionally dishonest ? That's a new one, for me.

I'll admit I haven't seen many besides you do it, either.

Not AFTER you kill them, no. :rolleyes:

Why did you ignore the point about physical injury and jailtime being equally difficult to compensate for?

Is this a bad time to point out that western constitutions are mostly based on individual liberties ?

Any time is a good time for an argument from popularity.

I never did claim I represent the views of most people. I'm an utilitarian, interested in achieving an ideal ratio between harm and benefit. A lot of people believe individual liberties should always be respected, even if everyone suffers from it. I don't agree.

This is usually the point where the Hitler-references start. I hope I'll be pleasantly surprised, though.


That's only true, however, if someone can statistically prove the deterence factor of capital punishment.

Technically, it would be true if the factor existed, whether it was proven or not. But it's a moot point, since this is a hypothetical that is known not to represent reality.
 
you can at least COMPENSATE for incarceration. Not so with death or torture.
Just a detail, if you can "compensate" years lost sitting innocent in prison, (with all the psychological stress and harm to social relationships included), then also torture can be "compensated". Just pay a big enough sum of money and that settles he case.

I, however, am not necessarily willing to sacrifice X people to save Y people, no matter who they are.
You qualify as a pacifist (which is not a viable military defense strategy in the current world) if you state that you would not harm another human even in self defence when attacked. Turn the other cheek.

The US army, specifically ? :D
I could have said Finnish army, but we would need to go nearly a century back in time to see them killing anyone anywhere.
 
Just a detail, if you can "compensate" years lost sitting innocent in prison, (with all the psychological stress and harm to social relationships included), then also torture can be "compensated". Just pay a big enough sum of money and that settles he case.

This is a specious distinction. In one case (imprisonment), assuming that the conviction was honestly a mistake (and not a deliberate frame-up), financial compensation is a reasonable expectation but the agents of the state are considered to be acting in good faith.

Torture on the other hand is a deliberate act of sadism (and a violation of civil liberties), the suffering of which monetary compensation alone can never undo. Indeed, the perpetrators of Torture should themselves face criiminal charges.


A very interesting question. I, however, am not necessarily willing to sacrifice X people to save Y people, no matter who they are.
You qualify as a pacifist (which is not a viable military defense strategy in the current world) if you state that you would not harm another human even in self defence when attacked. Turn the other cheek.

Now you are deliberately misrepresenting Belz's position. His remark is clearly in the context of our criminal justice system. Yet you conflate this with Pacifism to create a Straw Man to suggest that Belz is such a pacifist that he wouldn't defend himself or others if he or others were in danger.

Now I don't know if Belz is such an idealist that he would sacrifice himself rather than harm someone who was attacking him, and neither do you.

In any case, your response suggests that you believe Criminal behaviour can be justified under some circumstances.

And in the context of your previous statements that imply that YOU would willingly allow yourself to be Tortured and Executed even if you were innocent "for the greater good", suggesting that BELZ is the "Pacifist" that would "turn the other cheek" strikes me as rank intellectual hypocrisy.

One could clearly make the argument that you yourself are a "turn the other cheek" Pacifist by taking your previous comments out of the context of your (rather barbaric) support of State Sanctioned Torture and Execution.

GB
 
Last edited:
Was someone suggesting a law that made it legal to torture innocent people?

Obviously, since you're never 100% sure that the person is innocent. Therefore there's a definite risk that you, being innocent, would be tortured.

I'll admit I haven't seen many besides you do it, either.

Please answer my question.

Why did you ignore the point about physical injury and jailtime being equally difficult to compensate for?

I didn't. I agreed. But "difficult" and "impossible" are usually different.

Any time is a good time for an argument from popularity.

Mirrorglass, usually I appreciate your posts, but I feel you're knee-jerking this thread. How is this an argument from popularity ?

I never did claim I represent the views of most people. I'm an utilitarian, interested in achieving an ideal ratio between harm and benefit. A lot of people believe individual liberties should always be respected, even if everyone suffers from it. I don't agree.

Well, neither do I, actually. But one has to admit that legal systems based on individual freedoms seem to work better than those based on the polar opposite.

Technically, it would be true if the factor existed, whether it was proven or not. But it's a moot point, since this is a hypothetical that is known not to represent reality.

Well, there goes your argument, then.
 
Just a detail, if you can "compensate" years lost sitting innocent in prison, (with all the psychological stress and harm to social relationships included), then also torture can be "compensated". Just pay a big enough sum of money and that settles he case.

And this will remove the physical damage how ?

You qualify as a pacifist (which is not a viable military defense strategy in the current world) if you state that you would not harm another human even in self defence when attacked. Turn the other cheek.

Good thing I never said that nor will never say that either. In fact, in self defense I usually advocate full, deadly force. But then, that's not what we were talking about. Now that I've used my right of self-defense against your impotent strawman, care to adress what I really said ?
 
Obviously, since you're never 100% sure that the person is innocent. Therefore there's a definite risk that you, being innocent, would be tortured.

There is a difference between it being legal to punish innocents and accepting the fact that some mistakes are unavoidable. Which was your original question.

This is really getting to be problematic, by the way; we can't hold a conversation if you forget what we were talking about after a few posts.

Please answer my question.

I would have thought it was obvious what my view was - that yes, it is possible to be unintentionally dishonest, and you proved it a few posts back..

But it occurs to me we might be using the word with different meanings. So allright, you weren't dishonest; you just read my post carelessly and assumed I meant the complete opposite of what I said.

I didn't. I agreed. But "difficult" and "impossible" are usually different.

That doesn't make sense. If two things are equally difficult, then they are equally possible or impossible, as well.

Mirrorglass, usually I appreciate your posts,

Thanks.

but I feel you're knee-jerking this thread. How is this an argument from popularity ?


"Is this a bad time to point out that western constitutions are mostly based on individual liberties ?"

How is that anything but an argument from popularity? It was your intention to suggest that constitutions based on individual liberties are preferable to others, right?

Well, neither do I, actually. But one has to admit that legal systems based on individual freedoms seem to work better than those based on the polar opposite.

Certainly, but on the other hand, legal systems that impose some limits on individual freedoms in order to make things better for everybody work even better.



Well, there goes your argument, then.

Really?

Perhaps I really have been unclear in my presentation.

My original point, in post #201, was that if the death penalty and torture did give a clear benefit to society, I would be for them, despite the risk of occasionally punishing innocents, even me. To put it in simpler terms, if by having the death penalty, I could significantly lower the rate of violent crimes, it would be worth it even if sometimes innocents were convicted; people would be more safe, anyway.

And in the same post I mentioned that this is not the way it works in reality.

Apparently you did confuse what I meant to say in the post, something I've given you flak about already. But seriously. Are you really saying my argument about a hypothetical situation is invalid, because the situation is hypothetical?
 
There is a difference between it being legal to punish innocents and accepting the fact that some mistakes are unavoidable. Which was your original question.

This is really getting to be problematic, by the way; we can't hold a conversation if you forget what we were talking about after a few posts.

How did I forget anything, now ?

I would have thought it was obvious what my view was - that yes, it is possible to be unintentionally dishonest, and you proved it a few posts back..

That makes no sense whatsoever. Dishonesty implies deliberation. Otherwise we call it a "mistake". You seem to be desperately trying to maintain the use of your original wording.

That doesn't make sense. If two things are equally difficult, then they are equally possible or impossible, as well.

Compensating for permanent physical harm is impossible. Incarceration is not permanent.

How is that anything but an argument from popularity?

It's just a fact that the US constitution, for example, is based on individual liberties rather than social benefits. How is that an appeal to popularity ???

It was your intention to suggest that constitutions based on individual liberties are preferable to others, right?

Nope.

Certainly, but on the other hand, legal systems that impose some limits on individual freedoms in order to make things better for everybody work even better.

Agreed.

My original point, in post #201, was that if the death penalty and torture did give a clear benefit to society, I would be for them, despite the risk of occasionally punishing innocents, even me.

That's clear, indeed. Personally I do not accept that risk, and will avoid any and all countries that ask me to take it.

To put it in simpler terms, if by having the death penalty, I could significantly lower the rate of violent crimes, it would be worth it even if sometimes innocents were convicted; people would be more safe, anyway.

Would the medieval system of justice (executions without proper trials) be acceptable to you if they were so socially useful ?

And in the same post I mentioned that this is not the way it works in reality.

Oh.

Apparently you did confuse what I meant to say in the post, something I've given you flak about already. But seriously. Are you really saying my argument about a hypothetical situation is invalid, because the situation is hypothetical?

No. For some reason I thought this thread was about reality. It didn't occur to me that you were arguing for something that doesn't, never has and will never exist. Silly me. But you're right. I did misunderstand.
 
Sigh. I think that's about enough. Somehow, I don't think you'll be getting my point, no matter how many times I rephrase it.
 
And this will remove the physical damage how ?
Waterboarding leaves no scars. I bet the Guantanamo guards, and every self-respecting intelligence agency, are very careful not to leave any permanent physical damage.

in self defense I usually advocate full, deadly force.
Thank you, this logical dead end I wanted to hear.

Hint: Ever heard that innocent persons _do_ sometimes get killed when a gun-bearing person gets scared of something he misinterpreted in the dark, and defends his own life? You can prevent that from happening, by never defending yourself in the manner you just described...
 
Waterboarding leaves no scars. I bet the Guantanamo guards, and every self-respecting intelligence agency, are very careful not to leave any permanent physical damage.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2010/jan/18/guantanamo-investigation-harpers-interrogation

http://www.harpers.org/archive/2010/01/hbc-90006368

I'd bet you are wrong.

Thank you, this logical dead end I wanted to hear.

Hint: Ever heard that innocent persons _do_ sometimes get killed when a gun-bearing person gets scared of something he misinterpreted in the dark, and defends his own life? You can prevent that from happening, by never defending yourself in the manner you just described...

If JREF had an Intellectual Hypocrisy and Straw Man award you would be the winner:

You qualify as a pacifist (which is not a viable military defense strategy in the current world) if you state that you would not harm another human even in self defence when attacked. Turn the other cheek.

Talk about Logical Dead Ends. :rolleyes:

GB
 
Sigh. I think that's about enough. Somehow, I don't think you'll be getting my point, no matter how many times I rephrase it.

And you seem to have missed this bit:

That's clear, indeed.

What's amazing is that, on the one hand, you ask me to accept that an example of yours in this thread dedicated to a very real and heated subject was only fictional, but you seem to refuse to discuss my own hypotheticals about that very example. Odd.
 
And you seem to have missed this bit:



What's amazing is that, on the one hand, you ask me to accept that an example of yours in this thread dedicated to a very real and heated subject was only fictional, but you seem to refuse to discuss my own hypotheticals about that very example. Odd.

This is, once again, broken logic. What does you accepting the fact that I brought up a hypothetical situation have to do with my willingness to discuss something else? Is there some rule that states if I don't talk about everything you want to, you get to claim I said something I didn't?

The reason I'm not interested in continuing this discussion is that you consistently pick apart lines of my posts and attack them individually, freely changing subjects without any care to the original topic. Since you've repeatedly gone as far as to cut away parts of my original post which gave context to the parts you did respond to, I can't really believe this is unintentional. So I have no reason to assume anything I say will be treated any differently.
 
This is, once again, broken logic. What does you accepting the fact that I brought up a hypothetical situation have to do with my willingness to discuss something else? Is there some rule that states if I don't talk about everything you want to, you get to claim I said something I didn't?

Well, this time I think you're the one who didn't understand. That's alright, though. I won't stop talking to you because of that.

The reason I'm not interested in continuing this discussion is that you consistently pick apart lines of my posts and attack them individually, freely changing subjects without any care to the original topic.

I wasn't aware I changed the topic at any time. We're still talking about torture. You made a hypothetical, which I misinterpreted. Now that you've made that clear, I'm reiterating a question pertaining to your hypothetical, which you refure to answer. I find that odd because I can't understand why you would bring up a hypothetical you're unwilling to discuss.

I can't really believe this is unintentional.

You believe what you will. Of course, that is the venue of woo-woos, not skeptics. I know you can do better.
 
Well, this time I think you're the one who didn't understand. That's alright, though. I won't stop talking to you because of that.



I wasn't aware I changed the topic at any time. We're still talking about torture. You made a hypothetical, which I misinterpreted. Now that you've made that clear, I'm reiterating a question pertaining to your hypothetical, which you refure to answer. I find that odd because I can't understand why you would bring up a hypothetical you're unwilling to discuss.



You believe what you will. Of course, that is the venue of woo-woos, not skeptics. I know you can do better.

Of course. Well, fine. I assume the question you mean is the one about medieval judical systems?

Well, the principle is very simple. With any judicial system, a certain amount of people will fall victim to violent crimes. Let's call this amount V. Now, in any judicial system, a certain amount of innocent people fall victims to faulty judgment, since no judicial system is perfect. Let's call this amount J.

To simplify the model, let's only concentrate or people who are killed. Assault and torture could be added in, but it wouldn't really change much. So V is the number of people murdered and J the amount of people wrongly executed.

Now the question is, how does changing the policy on capital punishment affect these values?

The value of J will be determined by the effectiveness and harshness of the judicial system. In other words, the more people are sentenced to death, the more innocents are, as well, and the better the cases are investigated, the less innocents go to jail.

What determines V is more difficult to determine. Luckily, in this model the value is assumed.

Now, the main point here is that the value we care about is neither V nor J, but V+J. This number represents the number of innocent people getting killed, and it's the number we wish to get as low as possible.

My original point was that if by having the death penalty we could lower the amount of violent crimes greatly while only slightly increasing the number of wrongly executed people, this would be a good thing.

Or, to use the symbols,

1) V1 > V2
2) J1 < J2
3) V1-V2 > J2-J1

=> V2 + J2 < V1 + J1

Where J1 and V1 refer to the original values and J2 and V2 to the values after implementing death penalty. Since the value of V+J is lower in the second case, it is preferable to the first one.

The point of this is that it does not matter how cruel the model sounds, or how it appears to violate individual liberties. What does matter is minimizing the risk to citizens. If by slightly increasing the risk of being executed one can greatly decrease the risk of being murdered, it is a good deal. After all, it doesn't really matter how you'll be killed; you want to do all you can to avoid it anyway.

So yes; a medieval justice system would be preferable to another system if the total number of undeserved deaths in the system was smaller.


Now, to remind you once more, I am quite aware that this model does not represent reality with much accuracy, and that was never it's purpose. I brought the idea up in response to Gandalf's post where he asked whether I (well, it was not addressed to me, but still) would want to live in a society where it is possible to be wrongly convicted or tortured by the judical system.

And my response was yes, if a small chance of that led to a significantly lowered risk of being assaulted or murdered. It's really just about minimizing all risks.
 
Last edited:
I wouldn't hold the death of a person by the hands of a criminal and the death of a person by wrongful execution to be equally undesirable. Part of the responsibility of the State is to make people feel safe; the knowledge that you could be unfairly incarcerated and executed would do severe harm to public welfare. This kind of refutes what you say here:

My original point was that if by having the death penalty we could lower the amount of violent crimes greatly while only slightly increasing the number of wrongly executed people, this would be a good thing.

Change "would" to "could" and I'll agree with that statement. As it is, it's far too simplistic. The number of innocent people dying is obviously not the only thing that matters. I'll assume that you didn't mean it to be taken that way however.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom