Is there anything a person can do to justify torture?

Yes, "at least" - in fact, given the culpability of a person who chooses to harm someone else, getting exactly the same harm is inadequate as a preventive and deterrent, much less retribution. Punishment should exceed the harm a person voluntarily causes to an unwilling victim.

I think youre being naieve if you think a criminal is thinking about the harm his actions do when he commits a crime, the more shocking a crime is the more likely it is that the person who commits it is not going to react like normal people to the idea of retribution for his actions

arsonists do not care about damage to property,
child murderers for do not even contemplate getting caught when they murder chidren
serial killers do not worry about being executed for their crimes

so having a justice system based on revenge will achieve nothing as a preventative measure, so the only benefit would be to families of the victims, and that is not very moral, something which a justice system needs to be.
 
Last edited:
I remember a post TragicMonkey made about justifying such actions, his view which I now share is something like "OK so there are circumstances that I would torture someone, but that does not mean I think it is a good act and I should be subject to punishment in a civilized society"

In other words don't try to find an argument that makes it "right" or "good" accept that it is "wrong" or "evil" and go with that.
 
To the contrary, vengeance serves positive purposes. That seems so obvious I wonder if you are lying aboput not getting it, just to extend an argument.

Vengeance for a wrong encourages the wrong-does not to do it again and deters others from similar conduct.

No it doesn't. Not only does it not deter, but the punishment itself also tends to foster resentment which can lead to more crime. How is that useful to society ?
 
I remember a post TragicMonkey made about justifying such actions, his view which I now share is something like "OK so there are circumstances that I would torture someone, but that does not mean I think it is a good act and I should be subject to punishment in a civilized society"

In other words don't try to find an argument that makes it "right" or "good" accept that it is "wrong" or "evil" and go with that.

Aside from the fact that I don't think that torture ever serves a functionally reliable purpose, this is my perspective as well, and very similar to the perspective I apply to the taking of human life whether we are talking self-defense/defense of others, military action, or state sponsored executions.
 
*snippity snip*

GB

Ok then, my bad for not giving you the benefit of the doubt. I think I understand your position now, and it seems much more reasonable now that I do. Indeed, where I live it's not even allowed to defend yourself against a criminal who breaks into your home; you can't do anything to him unless he draws a weapon or explicitly tells you that he intends to hurt you. Heck, the criminal can even sue you if he trips over some stuff you had lying around on the floor and he breaks something :confused:


Wait what? You're joking right? I'm a pacifist? Where did you get that idea?

I've no such thing. I consider the concept of justice outdated and unnecessary.
That's a pretty amazing statement. Not just my concept of justice but any concept of justice is "outdated and unnecessary"?

It only sounds amazing because people are so accustomed to shouting "For Truth, Justice and Freedom!" and other such platitudes without ever stopping to pause and think what on earth it is supposed to mean.

Mirrorglass is entirely right. Justice is barbaric.
 
Last edited:
Ok then, my bad for not giving you the benefit of the doubt. I think I understand your position now, and it seems much more reasonable now that I do. Indeed, where I live it's not even allowed to defend yourself against a criminal who breaks into your home; you can't do anything to him unless he draws a weapon or explicitly tells you that he intends to hurt you. Heck, the criminal can even sue you if he trips over some stuff you had lying around on the floor and he breaks something :confused:

Where would that be ? So far I've heard about it but I've never seen the actual legal articles that show it to be true. (I'm genuinely interested)
 
Sorry Sophronius, perhaps "Pacifist" was a poor choice of wording. It just seemed that in relation to your (our?) views on justice such views could be considered Qualified Pacifism.

"Qualified Pacifism, what's that?" one might ask. For me it means I'm basically a Pacifist until I'm attacked, and then I'll fight back. I hold no truck with things like "Pre-emptive Strikes," and I favour diplomatic solutions over violent ones. If I can talk my way out of a fight, so much the better.

The only reason the Pacifism of Ghandi worked against the British, is that they shared the same Moral Universe, and the British could be shamed by being forced to acknowledge their bad behaviour.

I would wager good money that Ghandi's Pacifist resistance wouldn't have worked against Nazi's, who would have happily mowed down peaceful protesters. And I dare say Ghandi's pacifism wouldn't have worked against Right Wing US administrations either--particularly those that believe in de-criminalizing torture and preemptive strikes.

The funny thing is, even Ghandi was actually a "Qualified Pacifist."

It is better to be violent, if there is violence in our hearts, than to put on the cloak of nonviolence to cover impotence.--Ghandi

In other words, had Ghandi been faced with opposing Nazis or a Right Wing US administration NOT fighting back would have been a sign of impotence.

I would also like to add my support to Mirrorglass's views regarding Retributive Justice vs Utilitarian Justice.

GB
 
No, I would conduct a referendum on what the people want the punishment for each crime to be. Then so be it. I would also allow for local variation, if 60% of people want a death penalty for murder, and 40% want 20 years imprisonment for murder, the country can be divided into to areas where these two laws are in place, so people can choose to live under the style of legislation that makes them feel more secure, which is one of the main goals of legislation.

This is very different from your previous market-based punishment scheme, and is, in fact, pretty much what we in the US have now.

What's to prevent the victim from lying about how psychologically damaging something is?
Nothing, wherefore it is not very useful to listen to the criminal so much.

You must be confused, as this is non sequiter with the question I asked.

What if I said that your ideas of vengeance are so barbaric that they cause me real fear that someone like you should ever come into power? Do I have a claim to vengeance against you?
If you personally believe so, you would see most of the world at war with yourself, for various similar reasons.

:confused:

Do you really not understand that this is the status quo? One person's act of vengeance is just another link in the chain of violent acts that need avenging by some aggrieved party. Vengeance doesn't work because people are dishonest and prone to acting emotionally.

Say I run over my neighbor's dog because I'm distracted by his wife doing a little topless gardening. Then my neighbor decides to avenge his dog by killing my two cats. My neighbor feels that my act was negligent and that my two cats are worth his dog. I, of course, feel my act was an honest mistake and that my two cats over-compensate for his dog, and so now I need to take my vengeance by setting fire to his tool shed. Now my neighbor is aggrieved, and decides to burn my house down, and so on. This is the reality of vengeance. This sort of scenario has borne itself out time and again throughout history.

It would be good if everyone would be honest and admit that vengeance serves only to satisfy an emotional need.
 
I remember a post TragicMonkey made about justifying such actions, his view which I now share is something like "OK so there are circumstances that I would torture someone, but that does not mean I think it is a good act and I should be subject to punishment in a civilized society"

In other words don't try to find an argument that makes it "right" or "good" accept that it is "wrong" or "evil" and go with that.

I concur with you and TragicMonkey. I am human, and occasionally my emotions get the best of me. If someone were to hurt my daughter, I'm sure I would want to inflict GBH on the assailant. But I have no illusions that it would be right or just.
 
Ah, yes. Mob rule is always the best option when determining laws.
I haven't heard democracy called "mob rule" in a while. Maybe you imply that a "mob" decides here and now what to do with a person other than themselves. That is not the case, punishments would be decided for future offenses, not past offenses, and the localized variation ensures that nobody is forced to play with rules of crime and punishment that he does not want to play with.

since when is punishment "justice" ?
Since 10,000 BC?

how do you punish fraud, for instance, if the person has already spent the money ?
By writing a debt in the name of the person, with monthly payments automatically from his salary bank account. If this arrangement fails, then forced labour.

How do you punish rape ?
Prison guards turning a blind eye know a lot of what happens to molesters in some prisons.

How do you punish multiple murders ?
With a death sentence and confiscation of all his property.

Just killing a murderer is not useful for the society, since the society already lost a life in the hands of the murderer. It is more useful, more reasonable, to use the person sentenced to death for purposes that potentially can save lives of others. Many possibilities do exist, such as experimenting with new surgery techniques, new medicines, etc.

If experiments done with 1000 murderers help us to develop a medicine one year faster than would happen by normal routine, the saved time could save many more than 1000 lives.

I find it curious that you answered my question about "true justice" by switching the wording to "perfect justice". But I suppose it doesn't really change anything.
Actually it was you who changed my expression "perfect justice" into "true justice", yet claiming it to be "mine", so I had to choose whether to address the idea of "true justice" or to address "the justice of mine". I chose the latter, abandoning the former.

Maybe just wordplay, but "true" is commonly used in religion to mean "the only right choice", at least Jehovah's Witnesses use the word a lot in that sense, so I din't want to go discussing "true justice". I feel that "perfect" is a more neutral expression, of course it implies that the maximal possible value is reached according to a known indicator, but it does not imply that people would or should try to reach the maximal possible value.

What I'm asking is why you consider it to be so far superior to the others as to be labeled "perfect". Did you read about true/perfect justice somewhere, or are these labels your own addition?
The label is mine, but I don't assume it to be unique, trying it with Google must certainly produce many results of various nature.

"Perfect" refers to (the pursuit of) crime and punishment being exactly equal, contrary to policies where this is not the main goal to pursue.
 
Last edited:
This is very different from your previous market-based punishment scheme, and is, in fact, pretty much what we in the US have now.
USA doesn't decide by referendum what are crimes and what are their punishments, neither is there much real localized variation, other than something very cosmetic.

One person's act of vengeance is just another link in the chain of violent acts that need avenging by some aggrieved party.
(...)
It would be good if everyone would be honest and admit that vengeance serves only to satisfy an emotional need.
It would be good if everyone accepted the same religion, etc. Well there is no realistic chance in sight, so why start with this argument at all?

You were talking about a cycle of private vengeance, punishments given by the state are a deterrent against that, because they (in most cases) make the victims feel that vengeance has been taken care of, unless the punishment given by the state is too mild to give this feeling to the victims, which might leave the door open for another cycle of private vengeance.
 
Actually it was you who changed my expression "perfect justice" into "true justice", yet claiming it to be "mine", so I had to choose whether to address the idea of "true justice" or to address "the justice of mine". I chose the latter, abandoning the former.

Oh, quite right. My bad.
Maybe just wordplay, but "true" is commonly used in religion to mean "the only right choice", at least Jehovah's Witnesses use the word a lot in that sense, so I din't want to go discussing "true justice". I feel that "perfect" is a more neutral expression, of course it implies that the maximal possible value is reached according to a known indicator, but it does not imply that people would or should try to reach the maximal possible value.

But why must that indicator be the amount of retribution, something very difficult to measure and even more difficult to compare with the crime? What is inferior about restorative justice, where the indicator is how well the harm caused by the claim is neutralized? Or utilitarian justice, where the indicator is the overall benefits for all? I've repeatedly tried to get you to explain why you consider retribution to be so much more important than actually doing something good. Is there a reason why you will not touch the subject?

The label is mine, but I don't assume it to be unique, trying it with Google must certainly produce many results of various nature.

Did you try it? I'm going to have to assume not, since it certainly doesn't produce results that are anywhere close to your ideas. Indeed, I have never heard of anyone else promoting your view on justice. If there are any, I'd say it's up to you to show at least one.

"Perfect" refers to (the pursuit of) crime and punishment being exactly equal, contrary to policies where this is not the main goal to pursue.

Apparently it does, when you use it, but that is not a common usage of the words. As I've pointed out, I've never heard of the term being used that way, so I'd say the meaning is hardly as obvious as you suggest.
 
USA doesn't decide by referendum what are crimes and what are their punishments, neither is there much real localized variation, other than something very cosmetic.

Really? You are aware that only some states have the Death Penalty, and there are quite a few differences between prisons in different states?
 
Where would that be ? So far I've heard about it but I've never seen the actual legal articles that show it to be true. (I'm genuinely interested)

Crud. I took a look through the online dutch lawbook, but so far without much success. Best I could find was this:

http://www.vvd.nl/standpunt/277/veiligheid

It's from one of our main political parties (dutch) so should be trustworthy. It states there that according to current law you are only allowed to use violence if the other one attacks you first (so seems I was partly wrong: if he tells you he is going to kill you, you still may not do anything) AND you are only allowed to use as much violence as is strictly necessary. For example, if someone tries to stab you with a knife, and you twist his arm around, then that's okay. If you then break his arm, then off to jail with you.

I can sort of see the logic in it, but it still seems kind of crazy to protect criminals that much :boggled:

Sorry Sophronius, perhaps "Pacifist" was a poor choice of wording. It just seemed that in relation to your (our?) views on justice such views could be considered Qualified Pacifism.

"Qualified Pacifism, what's that?" one might ask. For me it means I'm basically a Pacifist until I'm attacked, and then I'll fight back. I hold no truck with things like "Pre-emptive Strikes," and I favour diplomatic solutions over violent ones. If I can talk my way out of a fight, so much the better.

That's just being reasonable. Pacifism is supposed to be this strong belief against violence in general. If you broaden it to not wanting to use violence unless it's necessary, it kind of loses its meaning. I imagine about 90% of my country's population would qualify as pacifistic under your definition.

Anyway, I still don't hold your view of only using violence if attacked. What if a country simply offers you no other reasonable choice? If some foreign power tries to starve a country to death by preventing all import + some combination of other sneaky tactics, then I think using aggression is entirely reasonable, to name but one example.

So I am still not a pacifist. ;)
 
Anyway, I still don't hold your view of only using violence if attacked. What if a country simply offers you no other reasonable choice? If some foreign power tries to starve a country to death by preventing all import + some combination of other sneaky tactics, then I think using aggression is entirely reasonable, to name but one example.

I agree. ;)

GB
 
Just killing a murderer is not useful for the society, since the society already lost a life in the hands of the murderer. It is more useful, more reasonable, to use the person sentenced to death for purposes that potentially can save lives of others. Many possibilities do exist, such as experimenting with new surgery techniques, new medicines, etc.

If experiments done with 1000 murderers help us to develop a medicine one year faster than would happen by normal routine, the saved time could save many more than 1000 lives.

Nice to know we have a Nazi posting on this thread.

GB
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom