Is there anything a person can do to justify torture?

Your argument is patently ridiculous. I'm not arguing merely to score a rhetorical point which is what you seem to be engaged in.

It all boils down to whether or not YOU want to live in a society where YOU could be Tortured or Executed even if YOU are completely innocent of all charges and wrongly suspected or convicted.

If YOU are happy enough to sacrifice YOURSELF because you think it's worth it for the good of society to keep Torture and the Death Penalty in place, then just say so and stop playing rhetorical games.

I don't have any patience for rhetorical BS.

GB

I know I bowed out of this discussion already, but I wanted to reply to this one.

Firstly, as shown upthread, I am strongly against torture and the death penalty because of their inherent cruelty.

But, if your question is "are you willing to subject yourself to possibly being wrongly convicted, tortured and killed, if taking that chance provides a greater benefit to the society overall", then the answer is yes, yes, a hundred times yes. The example is an extreme one, but nevertheless, this is precisely how an utilitarian philosophy works. Doctors accept a heightened risk of contracting an infectious disease, because their work benefits many others. Policemen accept the risk of injury or death to protect many more people. And eventually, all members of society accept the risk of being wrongly convicted, because the alternative would be much worse.

So the reason I oppose unnecessarily harsh punishments is not that they are harsh; it's that they are unnecessary. As I've stated, they provide no real benefit to the society, and one can really only argue for them by claiming "justice" demands it. Well, what some call justice, I call sadism, and whatever the name, I do not permit murder in the name of the ideal.
 
Even if the person being tortured is you ?

I would prefer it not to be me but, yes, I choose to accept that risk for the benefits I receive from it. In fact, I am accepting it and benefitting from it right now, as are you.


Come to think of it, I'll bet many of us, unknown to us, are benefitting from people being tortured at this very moment - we may even be alive because of it. I guarantee every one of us is benefitting from people being punished through the justice system.

I'll even go a step farther and say that, simplified all the way down to the most fundamental level, civilization exists for the purpose of facilitating violence against people. Grass-eating sheeple have the luxury of being such only because they live in a system in which others do their violence for them.
 
Last edited:
It all boils down to whether or not YOU want to live in a society where YOU could be Tortured or Executed even if YOU are completely innocent of all charges and wrongly suspected or convicted.

This.

But you're wasting your time on someone who uses arguments like this:

So you suggest closing all hospitals, because innocent people get wrong diagnoses and lethal MRSA infections there?
 
But, if your question is "are you willing to subject yourself to possibly being wrongly convicted, tortured and killed, if taking that chance provides a greater benefit to the society overall", then the answer is yes, yes, a hundred times yes.

Let's see you continue to say this when you're the one being tortured.

The example is an extreme one, but nevertheless, this is precisely how an utilitarian philosophy works. Doctors accept a heightened risk of contracting an infectious disease, because their work benefits many others. Policemen accept the risk of injury or death to protect many more people. And eventually, all members of society accept the risk of being wrongly convicted, because the alternative would be much worse.

All of your examples are of people paid to do this kind of job. What's the benefit of execution and torture ?
 
I would prefer it not to be me but, yes, I choose to accept that risk for the benefits I receive from it. In fact, I am accepting it and benefitting from it right now, as are you.

Sorry, I live in a country without torture or capital punishment. It's not something I accept as a risk, and I won't agree to subjecting my fellow citizens to this kind of cruelty just so I can feel safer.

I guarantee every one of us is benefitting from people being punished through the justice system.

Nice attempt at equivocation. Not all punishments are cruel.

I'll even go a step farther and say that, simplified all the way down to the most fundamental level, civilization exists for the purpose of facilitating violence against people.

That's odd. I thought civilization existed to provide greater benefits for its members. Silly me.

You still haven't answered my question: if you were the one being tortured, would you still agree with your current position ?
 
Let's see you continue to say this when you're the one being tortured.

You are a cruel and unusual man.


All of your examples are of people paid to do this kind of job. What's the benefit of execution and torture ?

Why would you ask such a question, after carefully snipping off not one, but two paragraphs, in different parts of my post, where I explain I do not condone execution and torture because they offer no benefit? That is so blatantly, obviously dishonest I can't fathom what you were hoping to accomplish.
 
It all boils down to whether or not YOU want to live in a society where YOU could be Tortured or Executed even if YOU are completely innocent of all charges and wrongly suspected or convicted.
I _would like_ to live in a society where you have no risk of dying or suffering from any accidental thing of any kind. But that is not possible. So I am constantly at risk of losing my life innocently, (nowhere so much as when driving my car on the road). A death penalty law and its potential misuse is statistically a much lesser threat to me than all the threats that I already live under. This is why I find it unnecessary and weird to give the lesser threats more attention than they statistically deserve compared to other known threats.

If YOU are happy enough to sacrifice YOURSELF because you think it's worth it for the good of society to keep Torture and the Death Penalty in place, then just say so and stop playing rhetorical games.GB
Yes I would like to live in a society where murder is punished with a death penalty, _when_ the proof is so strong that the defence (or anyone else) is unable to suggest a scientifically viable alternative theory about the incident where the defendant is not guilty and which _might potentially be true_ according to the evidence that exists (and is not based on any woo-woo or voodoo or alien abduction).
 
Last edited:
You are a cruel and unusual man.

And that was a weird comment. It's easy to say it's an acceptable risk, but I don't think you'd sing the same tune if you were in that situation. That's the whole foundation of the "golden rule", in fact.

That is so blatantly, obviously dishonest I can't fathom what you were hoping to accomplish.

It's amazing how much "skeptics" on this forum jump to unwarranted conclusions, especially about things they can't possibly know, namely the intentions of their correspondants.

Although I seemed to have missed that last paragraph, the fact remains that there's a clear difference between someone who chooses a risky profession, and citizens who decide to subject others to torture when they themselves feel immune to those practices.
 
I _would like_ to live in a society where you have no risk of dying or suffering from any accidental thing of any kind.

That was NOT the question, JJM. Being executed or tortured for a crime you didn't commit isn't an accident. It's a miscarriage of justice resulting from human error or malice. Surely you can see the difference ? In the latter case, you CAN prevent it from ever happening to anyone, simply by NOT having torture or capital punishment in your society.

Yes I would like to live in a society where murder is punished with a death penalty, _when_ the proof is so strong that the defence (or anyone else) is unable to suggest a scientifically viable alternative theory about the incident where the defendant is not guilty and which _might potentially be true_ according to the evidence that exists (and is not based on any woo-woo or voodoo or alien abduction).

That's quite a grocery list of "ifs". Speaking of viable theories...
 
Firstly, as shown upthread, I am strongly against torture and the death penalty because of their inherent cruelty.

Noted.

But, if your question is "are you willing to subject yourself to possibly being wrongly convicted, tortured and killed, if taking that chance provides a greater benefit to the society overall" then the answer is yes, yes, a hundred times yes.

I suspect that this is appealing to a martyr or hero complex somewhere.

Let's try and control for that by asking: would you still support this system if it were your child, your parent, or your spouse who was wrongly convicted and then tortured and/or put to death?

Now it's no longer, "I'm willing to die for my beliefs" but "I'm willing to let a loved one die for my beliefs".
 
Noted.



I suspect that this is appealing to a martyr or hero complex somewhere.

Let's try and control for that by asking: would you still support this system if it were your child, your parent, or your spouse who was wrongly convicted and then tortured and/or put to death?

Now it's no longer, "I'm willing to die for my beliefs" but "I'm willing to let a loved one die for my beliefs".

I don't oppose prison sentences because there is a chance I, or a loved one of mine, could be wrongly convicted. Why would a harsher sentence make any difference? If I deemed the system gave greater harm than good, then yes, I would advocate it, despite there being a small chance of a bad outcome. It's really just math and choosing the lesser evil.

But of course if I, or a loved one of mine were wrongly convicted, I would fight the decision. I would fight the system that convicts a person without sufficient evidence, that allows injustice to happen. But I wouldn't fight the punishment.

Just because I'm against shooting people doesn't mean I have to be against guns, just because I'm against jailing innocents doesn't mean I have to be against jails, and just because I don't want innocents to die doesn't mean I have to be against the death penalty. My reasons for opposing it are based on utilitarian calculation, not fear of an extremely unlikely situation.
 
isn't an accident. It's (...) resulting from human error
I won't argue matters of taste, but in my vocabulary and ethical thought, what happens by error or bad luck or otherwise without intention, goes to the "accident" category.

or malice. Surely you can see the difference ? In the latter case, you CAN prevent it from ever happening to anyone, simply
Malice happens, and we CANNOT prevent it from ever happening to anyone. We design laws and punishments with the intention to minimize the amount of malice both outside and inside of the justice system. And to kick some ass when a malignant person deserves it.
 
I _would like_ to live in a society where you have no risk of dying or suffering from any accidental thing of any kind. But that is not possible. So I am constantly at risk of losing my life innocently, (nowhere so much as when driving my car on the road). A death penalty law and its potential misuse is statistically a much lesser threat to me than all the threats that I already live under. This is why I find it unnecessary and weird to give the lesser threats more attention than they statistically deserve compared to other known threats.


Yes I would like to live in a society where murder is punished with a death penalty, _when_ the proof is so strong that the defence (or anyone else) is unable to suggest a scientifically viable alternative theory about the incident where the defendant is not guilty and which _might potentially be true_ according to the evidence that exists (and is not based on any woo-woo or voodoo or alien abduction).

To put this in a nutshell, you are more than happy to martyr yourself for the cause of State Torture and State Execution.

Fair enough.

I however, am not willing to martyr myself or any other innocent. I do not agree that State Sanctioned Torture and Execution are beneficial to society.

GB
 
Last edited:
I won't argue matters of taste, but in my vocabulary and ethical thought, what happens by error or bad luck or otherwise without intention, goes to the "accident" category.

A uselessly broad definition. Why am I not surprised ?

Malice happens, and we CANNOT prevent it from ever happening to anyone. We design laws and punishments with the intention to minimize the amount of malice both outside and inside of the justice system. And to kick some ass when a malignant person deserves it.

In case you read my post too fast to catch its meaning: what I said you CAN prevent is the death penalty.

Oh, wait. I guess you DID read it because you snipped it from its own paragraph !
 
And that was a weird comment. It's easy to say it's an acceptable risk, but I don't think you'd sing the same tune if you were in that situation. That's the whole foundation of the "golden rule", in fact.

The argument you are making is basically just "If I tortured you, you might change your mind." It's true, and it's also trivial. The fact that torture can make people accept your opinions does not mean those opinions are correct, even opinions concerning torture.



It's amazing how much "skeptics" on this forum jump to unwarranted conclusions, especially about things they can't possibly know, namely the intentions of their correspondants.

Again, a strange response. I said I could not fathom your motivations, and you interpret that as making unwarranted conclusions about your intentions? It's almost as if you were reading some bizarro version of my posts.

Although I seemed to have missed that last paragraph, the fact remains that there's a clear difference between someone who chooses a risky profession, and citizens who decide to subject others to torture when they themselves feel immune to those practices.

You also missed the example about other punishments, such as incarceration. Irreversibility is an argument, but frankly, a jailed man does not get back the time he lost, either.

But, like I've said, I don't actually condone the death penalty; I simply oppose it because of different reasons. As such, vilifying me isn't a valid counterargument.
 
The argument you are making is basically just "If I tortured you, you might change your mind." It's true, and it's also trivial. The fact that torture can make people accept your opinions does not mean those opinions are correct, even opinions concerning torture.

I don't think you understood what I meant. I didn't mean that I could torture you to change your mind. The argument is this: if you're not willing to be tortured yourself, no matter what crime you did, why would you, as a member of society, subject others to torture ? I think it's a valid argument from empathy, in addition to the utilitarian ones.

Again, a strange response. I said I could not fathom your motivations, and you interpret that as making unwarranted conclusions about your intentions? It's almost as if you were reading some bizarro version of my posts.

Did you not say this:

That is so blatantly, obviously dishonest [...]

? To me that's fathoming my motivations.

You also missed the example about other punishments, such as incarceration. Irreversibility is an argument, but frankly, a jailed man does not get back the time he lost, either.

True, but there is a way to compensate for ihs wrongful conviction at least to a degree. Not so with permanent physical harm or death.

But, like I've said, I don't actually condone the death penalty; I simply oppose it because of different reasons. As such, vilifying me isn't a valid counterargument.

I've already agreed that I missed part of your post. Vilifying is never an actual argument.
 
I don't think you understood what I meant. I didn't mean that I could torture you to change your mind. The argument is this: if you're not willing to be tortured yourself, no matter what crime you did, why would you, as a member of society, subject others to torture ? I think it's a valid argument from empathy, in addition to the utilitarian ones.

It's a fair enough argument, but the premise is invalid. I've never suggested that the same laws should not apply to me as well as others - so for the few situations where I would condone torture, I would support a law that also made it legal to torture me in such a situation.

Of course, it is possible that in such a situation I wouldn't exactly be willing to be tortured. And perfectly analogously, if I stole a car, I might not be willing to go to prison. But I can nevertheless support a system where a crime will lead to a punishment - I just can't do it and commit crimes.


Did you not say this:



? To me that's fathoming my motivations.

Well, we'll have to disagree there. I said you were dishonest, which was true; you did blatantly misrepresent my position. I made no assumptions about why you did so; it would seem it was out of carelessness.

This, by the way, was fathoming your motivations. ;)

True, but there is a way to compensate for ihs wrongful conviction at least to a degree. Not so with permanent physical harm or death.

I wouldn't say you can compensate for two years of jailtime any more meaningfully than for permanent physical harm. In neither case, what is lost isn't coming back. Admittedly it isn't possible to give any recompense to a dead person, but then again, they don't really want any, anyway.

But anyway, the reversibility issue is not central to the problem. The idea is that in this hypothetical, having the death penalty gives the society an overall greater benefit. Basically, that means is that while you do have a marginally higher chance of being executed, you have a clearly lower chance of being murdered. If you turn the situation around, giving up the death penalty would increase your chances of being killed through no fault of your own, while having the penalty increases your chances of dying only if you commit serious crimes. All in all, it's very simple math that one situation is better than the other, which is the whole point.

I've already agreed that I missed part of your post. Vilifying is never an actual argument.

I can be fun, though. :D
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom