Mirrorglass
Illuminator
- Joined
- Mar 9, 2010
- Messages
- 3,464
Your argument is patently ridiculous. I'm not arguing merely to score a rhetorical point which is what you seem to be engaged in.
It all boils down to whether or not YOU want to live in a society where YOU could be Tortured or Executed even if YOU are completely innocent of all charges and wrongly suspected or convicted.
If YOU are happy enough to sacrifice YOURSELF because you think it's worth it for the good of society to keep Torture and the Death Penalty in place, then just say so and stop playing rhetorical games.
I don't have any patience for rhetorical BS.
GB
I know I bowed out of this discussion already, but I wanted to reply to this one.
Firstly, as shown upthread, I am strongly against torture and the death penalty because of their inherent cruelty.
But, if your question is "are you willing to subject yourself to possibly being wrongly convicted, tortured and killed, if taking that chance provides a greater benefit to the society overall", then the answer is yes, yes, a hundred times yes. The example is an extreme one, but nevertheless, this is precisely how an utilitarian philosophy works. Doctors accept a heightened risk of contracting an infectious disease, because their work benefits many others. Policemen accept the risk of injury or death to protect many more people. And eventually, all members of society accept the risk of being wrongly convicted, because the alternative would be much worse.
So the reason I oppose unnecessarily harsh punishments is not that they are harsh; it's that they are unnecessary. As I've stated, they provide no real benefit to the society, and one can really only argue for them by claiming "justice" demands it. Well, what some call justice, I call sadism, and whatever the name, I do not permit murder in the name of the ideal.