Is there anything a person can do to justify torture?

Wait.... let me see if I get this whole "perfect justice" thing right.

Any crime should be punished by an exact equal amount of suffering to the criminal, right? So if I break someone's leg, and then my leg is broken as punishment, those things 'cancel each other out'.

Shouldn't this also work the other way around then? Surely, if I develop a medicine that saves hundreds of lives, I would then be entitled to killing hundreds of people with no punishment. According to this idea of "justice", it's only fair. :p
 
USA doesn't decide by referendum what are crimes and what are their punishments, neither is there much real localized variation, other than something very cosmetic.
There is plenty of localized variation in what is considered criminal activity and the appropriate sentences for it, and the variation is typically a result of public opinion becoming realized through elected officials. While not the result of referenda, per se, the effect is similar.

It would be good if everyone accepted the same religion, etc. Well there is no realistic chance in sight, so why start with this argument at all?

This is a very poor analogy. I am claiming that there *is* a truth regarding vengeance, and that it is only a means of satisfying base emotions. This is not a religious claim, or a claim of faith. Hence the inclusion of the word "honest". I think people who defend vengeance as legitimate merely don't want to give up the possibility of emotional satisfaction. No one has supplied a practical reason for vengeance.

You were talking about a cycle of private vengeance, punishments given by the state are a deterrent against that, because they (in most cases) make the victims feel that vengeance has been taken care of, unless the punishment given by the state is too mild to give this feeling to the victims, which might leave the door open for another cycle of private vengeance.

So you're saying that states should take vengeance so that individuals won't? This makes as much sense as saying that states should rape drunk college girls so that frat boys won't do it.
 
Wait.... let me see if I get this whole "perfect justice" thing right.

Any crime should be punished by an exact equal amount of suffering to the criminal, right? So if I break someone's leg, and then my leg is broken as punishment, those things 'cancel each other out'.

Shouldn't this also work the other way around then? Surely, if I develop a medicine that saves hundreds of lives, I would then be entitled to killing hundreds of people with no punishment. According to this idea of "justice", it's only fair. :p

And those poor souls who spend years in prison after being wrongly convicted should be allowed to commit crimes whose sentences would equal the time they've already served. Right? After all, they've been wronged by the state, so they deserve vengeance!
 
No it doesn't. Not only does it not deter, but the punishment itself also tends to foster resentment which can lead to more crime. How is that useful to society ?

I live in a world full of evidence to the contrary, yet your response is just a conclusion with no stated basis.

I'll use myself as an example. I have been in lots of fights in my life, many of which were my fault, and I ride a motorcycle. But if a guy wearing a Hells Angels patch, or even a support patch, decides to pick a fight with me or does something I don't like, I'm going to avoid that fight. I'm also not going to touch his motorcycle, insult his family or take his beer without being invited. Why? because I know that if I do so I can expect a punishment far in excess of what I do to earn it. I know that because the Hells Angels have made it known that they will punish anyone who wrongs them, in their opinion. That is clearly a deterrent to me and I know from experience that it is a deterrent to many others. I am deterred because I know I would face "vengeance."

Do you really claim that I and many, many others are not deterred from conduct against people we know will seek vengeance? I'm willing to bet that you are deterred by people like that, as well (although it would be impossible for me to prove here).
 
Last edited:
And those poor souls who spend years in prison after being wrongly convicted should be allowed to commit crimes whose sentences would equal the time they've already served. Right? After all, they've been wronged by the state, so they deserve vengeance!

Oh yes! In fact, you could say that the entire state is to blame! So that means that every single person responsible for upholding the law (judges, policemen, lawyers, politicians and so on) is to blame as they make up the state. So obviously they would have to go to jail for an equal period of time as the one sent to jail unjustly.

Alternatively, if the state is seen as a single entity rather than a collection of individuals, I think that disestablishing the state itself and creating anarchy would be entirely justified.


(Yeh, usually I try to give people the benefit of the doubt, even if their views do seem crazy, but in this case I think mockery is the only reasonable answer)
 
I haven't heard democracy called "mob rule" in a while.

What you described is NOT democracy, JJM, but power of majority. I'll remind you that this is NOT how laws are made in neither your country nor mine.

Since 10,000 BC?

I did not ask for your opinion or hyperbole. Your comments thus far in this thread are incompatible with reality.

Justice isn't about punishment: it's about solving a problem, namely a crime. Yes, some justice systems have decided to do this by punishing the guilty. This, of course, achieves nothing except the hardening of the criminal, who otherwise might not have repeated his crime at all. In civilized societies, however, justice should do both of the following:

1) Provide reparation and comfort for the victim(s) and/or their families.
2) Ensure that the odds of the crime being repeated by the offender are minimized.

(2), of course, would be better served by not creating a situation where you have to go through (1) all over again (see Death Penalty). We already know harsh measures don't amount to much as deterrents, so the best hope we have is either rehabilitation for the regular crooks, and isolation from society (and labor, in my opinion) for the hopeless.

In no way does a desire to hurt the criminal enter the equation. And satisfying that desire helps neither of those goals.

By writing a debt in the name of the person, with monthly payments automatically from his salary bank account.

Assuming he stole millions, he'll theoretically never be rid of that debt. So why bother ?

If this arrangement fails, then forced labour.

Force labour should be automatic, I think. Instead of paying to keep these guys in cages, we'd actually make them work, possibly for prison credits or something.

Prison guards turning a blind eye know a lot of what happens to molesters in some prisons.

That doesn't answer my question.

With a death sentence and confiscation of all his property.

So if you kill one person, better go for several. They can't kill you twice.

Just killing a murderer is not useful for the society

Nothing of what you describe is useful for society. It just serves to make _you_ feel better. But it doesn't solve the problem, either way.

Many possibilities do exist, such as experimenting with new surgery techniques, new medicines, etc.

Ah, yes. Acting inhumanely towards criminals will make us appear so much better than them. :rolleyes:
 
Any crime should be punished by an exact equal amount of suffering to the criminal, right? So if I break someone's leg, and then my leg is broken as punishment, those things 'cancel each other out'.

Maybe we could even follow the path of homeopathy: if we dilute the punishment, we can break your leg 10E-18 times and call it even for all eternity.
 
I live in a world full of evidence to the contrary, yet your response is just a conclusion with no stated basis.

I'll use myself as an example.

How about you don't, and instead of personal opinions and testimonies we go with actual numbers ?

It's a known fact that the existence of the death penalty in some states and countries does NOT lower the crime rate there. You'd think putting their lives at risk by murdering someone would make them think twice about it, but somehow they don't seem that much intimidated by it. Funny that.
 
Ahh...hypotheticals...

Okay. We have this fellow on film kidnapping a child, and we have this fellow on film burying the child alive in a small pine box. We are certain we have the right fellow. He is clearly visible on film committing the acts. However, the film does not tell us where the child has been buried. We can see what happened, who did it, and who the victim is, but we cannot determine where from the film.

We have captured the perp, the child is slowly dying in the pine box, and he won't talk.

Do you try torturing him? Will he give you the correct info, or just toy with you?
Unless his nervous system doesn't work I promise I can have him begging to tell withing 10 minutes. And not a qualm will I have. But, If he is too late to save the child and his body is basically healthy he will live in hell for a week or so. I am not a physician, but.....
 
Unless his nervous system doesn't work I promise I can have him begging to tell withing 10 minutes. And not a qualm will I have. But, If he is too late to save the child and his body is basically healthy he will live in hell for a week or so. I am not a physician, but.....

Have him begging to tell what exactly...? The Truth...?

GB
 
some justice systems have decided to do this by punishing the guilty. This, of course, achieves nothing
Punishments are designed (this seems to be new for you that they are carefully designed after assessing several different proposals) to achieve many objectives, including:
- removing the dangerous person from the society for a while (or for good)
- making the victims and general population feel that the criminal has received a deserving punishment
- motivating the general population to avoid doing the forbidden act, in fear of the decreed punishment

This is much more than "nothing".

1) Provide reparation and comfort for the victim(s) and/or their families.
I generally don't mix the criminal and his punishment with the victim and his compensation. I thin that the victim of a crime (that evidently has taken place) should receive _immediate and full_ compensation, even if:
- investigating the crime and the following lawsuit takes a lot of time
- the criminal is never found by police
- the criminal is found but he has no means to pay

I think there should be a national insurance paying immediate compensation to the victims, when a crime has evidently taken place. The criminal has no place in this scenario, except paying what he must and can to the national insurance fund.

Assuming he stole millions, he'll theoretically never be rid of that debt. So why bother?
By taking from the criminal as much as he can pay, we:
- find a payer for as much as possible of the damage that has been done (otherwise, the taxpayers would have to pay for it)
- create a situation where causing small damage is a small bad idea, and causing big damage is a big bad idea, a moment to think twice before you choose to cause damage

So if you kill one person, better go for several. They can't kill you twice.
If the criminal is in such a state of mind that he thinks like this, hardly any reasonable punishment scale would change that fact. Besides, you just insinuated above that it is not worth chargin milions from a robber, so a robber would think that better try to steal as much as possible, if the punishment is the same no matter what the stolen amount was.

Nothing of what you describe is useful for society.
I disagree. Surprising that nearly all human societies have done so and still continue to.
 
Punishments are designed (this seems to be new for you that they are carefully designed after assessing several different proposals) to achieve many objectives, including:
- removing the dangerous person from the society for a while (or for good)
- making the victims and general population feel that the criminal has received a deserving punishment
- motivating the general population to avoid doing the forbidden act, in fear of the decreed punishment

This is much more than "nothing".

That's because you are equating "punishment" with "justice", again. I've told you already that they are not strictly equivalent.

I generally don't mix the criminal and his punishment with the victim and his compensation. I thin that the victim of a crime (that evidently has taken place) should receive _immediate and full_ compensation, even if:
- investigating the crime and the following lawsuit takes a lot of time
- the criminal is never found by police
- the criminal is found but he has no means to pay

And what do you do later if it's discovered the victim lied or was mistaken ? Do you take the compensation back ?

By taking from the criminal as much as he can pay, we:
- find a payer for as much as possible of the damage that has been done (otherwise, the taxpayers would have to pay for it)
- create a situation where causing small damage is a small bad idea, and causing big damage is a big bad idea, a moment to think twice before you choose to cause damage

That's a fine theory. In practice it doesn't work.

If the criminal is in such a state of mind that he thinks like this, hardly any reasonable punishment scale would change that fact.

The criminal is not the issue: YOUR justice system would create such a mindset. Once you've killed once, there can't possibly be a worse scenario. There is no reason to try to deal with the prosecutor, for instance. Might as well go all the way and kill any police officer who tries to arrest you.

Besides, you just insinuated above that it is not worth chargin milions from a robber, so a robber would think that better try to steal as much as possible, if the punishment is the same no matter what the stolen amount was.

No, because in my realistic justice system, the sentence need not be the same as the crime. You're the only one here who proposes that nonsense.

I disagree. Surprising that nearly all human societies have done so and still continue to.

No, they don't. You don't seem to understand the point of a judiciary system.
 
Unless his nervous system doesn't work I promise I can have him begging to tell withing 10 minutes. And not a qualm will I have. But, If he is too late to save the child and his body is basically healthy he will live in hell for a week or so. I am not a physician, but.....

What makes you think that torture is a reliable means of acquiring information?
 
How about you don't, and instead of personal opinions and testimonies we go with actual numbers ?

It's a known fact that the existence of the death penalty in some states and countries does NOT lower the crime rate there. You'd think putting their lives at risk by murdering someone would make them think twice about it, but somehow they don't seem that much intimidated by it. Funny that.

I can't argue that the death penalty is little deterrent. It has nothing to do with whether "torture" "vegeance" or plain old punishment is a deterrent (execution is a long way from torture). Every crime involves some waying of the gain from committing the crime against the likely punishment and the liklihood of getting caught. Unfortunately, the likelihood of getting caught and sentenced to death and actually executed is so small the deterrent value can't help but be tiny. However, you again argued a conclusion without a supporting basis or even the "actual numbers" you mentioned.

"It's a known fact"? I agree and I still can't prove it. neither can the advocates who regularly oppose the death penalty, other than by some smoke and mirrors that doesn't hold up to examination.

You also neglected to respond as to whether you are deterred from doing things to people for fear of vengeance or punishment. Since you are human, alive and not in prison, we can probably guess the answer.
 
I can't argue that the death penalty is little deterrent. It has nothing to do with whether "torture" "vegeance" or plain old punishment is a deterrent (execution is a long way from torture). Every crime involves some waying of the gain from committing the crime against the likely punishment and the liklihood of getting caught. Unfortunately, the likelihood of getting caught and sentenced to death and actually executed is so small the deterrent value can't help but be tiny. However, you again argued a conclusion without a supporting basis or even the "actual numbers" you mentioned.

You are making a bald assertion without offering any evidence. The idea that every crime is a rational decision based on risks and gains is, in my opinion, rather silly. Do you believe that a man who murders another man in a drunken rage truly thought the satisfaction he got from the murder was worth the chance of being caught?

You are on the right track on one thing; what is important is how often criminals get caught. If you know you'll almost certainly be caught and punished for your crime, there is a strong deterrent. But there's no reason to believe the harshness of the punishment affects the deterrent effect.

"It's a known fact"? I agree and I still can't prove it. neither can the advocates who regularly oppose the death penalty, other than by some smoke and mirrors that doesn't hold up to examination.

What do you mean? Are you claiming that the crime rates in states which use the death penalty are impossible to know, and that suggesting they are, in fact, not lower than those in other states, is "smoke and mirrors"?

You also neglected to respond as to whether you are deterred from doing things to people for fear of vengeance or punishment. Since you are human, alive and not in prison, we can probably guess the answer.

Are you really suggesting that if there were no prisons, every human would be committing crimes? That is a rather bleak worldview, and fortunately one not supported by evidence.
 
And what do you do later if it's discovered the victim lied or was mistaken ? Do you take the compensation back?
That is called insurance fraud, a crime that is punished not only by taking back the stolen money, but also with further legal consequences to the person. With this in mind my previous comment included the phrase "that evidently has taken place", requiring some evidence that a crime has taken place at all. Insurance companies have standard fact checking practices that keep fraud in tolerable control.

That's a fine theory. In practice it doesn't work.
You can argue that no theory whatsoever works in practice. In reality they do, with varying outcomes. Then politicians fine-tune their policies as they learn more about the connection between policy and actual outcome.

The criminal is not the issue: YOUR justice system would create such a mindset.
The criminal is the issue, because the criminal is the author of crimes, unlike the mainstream population. The criminal is _the problem_ that must be taken care of to avoid further damage, and to give the mainstream population peace of mind that dangerous persons have been removed from the society.

Once you've killed once, there can't possibly be a worse scenario. (...) Might as well go all the way and kill any police officer who tries to arrest you.
Such extreme scenarios happen also when the criminal _does_ have more to lose. For example robbers or drug traffickers "might as well go all the way and kill any police officer who tries to arrest you", so your theory does not help so much as you assume. A careful murderer does it in secret, and maintains a hope that his guilt cannot be proven with the necessary perfection of proof. Any doubt in the proof would weaken the punishment, so there is a lot to win in the legal process, by acting angelic and innocent and thus sowing doubt into the minds of the jurors. (A safe practice for the police then would be not to reveal all their cards, all the incriminating evidence they have found, before the suspect is in safe custody. Arrest the suspect by surprise in a shopping mall using agents in civilian dress, rather than driving 5 police cars in front of his door with alarms ringing.)
 
Last edited:
Do you believe that a man who murders another man in a drunken rage truly thought the satisfaction he got from the murder was worth the chance of being caught?
No, but nevertheless alcohol does not commit crimes, people do. Some strong drugs might cause hallucinations that change the reality enough so the person believes that something else is happening than what he in reality is doing, but alcohol does not qualify for that no matter how much you drink it.

what is important is how often criminals get caught. (...) But there's no reason to believe the harshness of the punishment affects the deterrent effect.
It certainly has a role. Drop the sentences for drug trafficking or rape or violent assault to 5 days instead of 5 years, and see what happens. When the punishment becomes no punishment at all, then there is no punishment at all.
 
No, but nevertheless alcohol does not commit crimes, people do. Some strong drugs might cause hallucinations that change the reality enough so the person believes that something else is happening than what he in reality is doing, but alcohol does not qualify for that no matter how much you drink it.

So you are saying a person under the influence of alcohol won't do anything they wouldn't do sober? That seems like a poorly thought out idea, especially as we were discussing the question whether all people carefully rationalize their actions before committing crimes.

The answer is simply no, they don't. The vast majority of crimes are committed spontaneously, by people who don't really think of the consequences. Not people who decide the crime is worth the risk of going to jail, but people who don't think about possibly going to jail.

The calculating, smart criminals commit a small minority of all crimes, and even they aren't deterred by harsher punishments, as crime rates in states with death penalty show. People sometimes - not often - think about the chances of being caught and decide whether or not a crime is worth it. But they don't think "well, it's only 20 years in jail, no big deal".

It certainly has a role. Drop the sentences for drug trafficking or rape or violent assault to 5 days instead of 5 years, and see what happens. When the punishment becomes no punishment at all, then there is no punishment at all.

That doesn't support your position at all. Of course dropping the sentences completely would mean dropping the sentences completely, losing any deterrent effect. But that has no bearing on the idea that making a harsh prison sentence an even harsher death sentence, or torture sentence, if you will, would increase the deterrent effect. And indeed, no data supports the idea, while a lot of data opposes it.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom