Is there anything a person can do to justify torture?

Well, the principle is very simple. With any judicial system, a certain amount of people will fall victim to violent crimes. Let's call this amount V. Now, in any judicial system, a certain amount of innocent people fall victims to faulty judgment, since no judicial system is perfect. Let's call this amount J.

To simplify the model, let's only concentrate or people who are killed. Assault and torture could be added in, but it wouldn't really change much. So V is the number of people murdered and J the amount of people wrongly executed.

Now the question is, how does changing the policy on capital punishment affect these values?

The value of J will be determined by the effectiveness and harshness of the judicial system. In other words, the more people are sentenced to death, the more innocents are, as well, and the better the cases are investigated, the less innocents go to jail.

What determines V is more difficult to determine. Luckily, in this model the value is assumed.

I don't think we can agree that V and J are equal even if both are the same, numerically. That evil people kill other people is one thing. That we empower the state itself to do it knowingly is another. The risk of being abused by criminals is inherent in any society. Let's not add to it the risk of being abused by the state itself, please.

Besides, as we've already discussed under the "deterrent" issue, we have no idea if J affects V in a positive way.

In other words I think you proceed from a false premise; namely that V and J are equivalent.

The point of this is that it does not matter how cruel the model sounds, or how it appears to violate individual liberties. What does matter is minimizing the risk to citizens.

And under that pretense you can pass any number of unconstitutional laws designed to "benefit society".

If by slightly increasing the risk of being executed one can greatly decrease the risk of being murdered, it is a good deal.

Speak for yourself. Being executer by the state seems more ironic, to me, because I'm part of the system that condones such barbarity.
 
That kid in the 2011 Toyota Highlander commercial. I think waterboarding is in order.
 
The risk of being abused by criminals is inherent in any society. Let's not add to it the risk of being abused by the state itself
Also the risk of being abused by someone who represents the State is inherent in any society. Normally under strict secrecy, but Israel is proof that the state can allow things as outrageous as letting traffickers of sex slaves operate undisturbed, and publicly report it in newspapers as a routine policy of the army "because it is better that they bring humans than guns to terrorists", without public political outrage.
 
Last edited:
Also the risk of being abused by someone who represents the State is inherent in any society. Normally under strict secrecy, but Israel is proof that the state can allow things as outrageous as letting traffickers of sex slaves operate undisturbed, and publicly report it in newspapers as a routine policy of the army "because it is better that they bring humans than guns to terrorists", without public political outrage.

And the US is proof that State Intelligence Agencies can participate in Drug Running, Arms Dealing to Terrorists, State Sponsored Terrorism, Toppling Democratically Elected Governments, Death Squads, Assassinations, and Torture with impunity.

How does this help your case again? :confused:

GB
 
Last edited:
Also the risk of being abused by someone who represents the State is inherent in any society.

And one we are directly responsible for making. We have a much greater, direct control over that one.

Normally under strict secrecy, but Israel is proof that the state can allow things as outrageous as letting traffickers of sex slaves operate undisturbed, and publicly report it in newspapers as a routine policy of the army "because it is better that they bring humans than guns to terrorists", without public political outrage.

The what on who, now ?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom