Is there anything a person can do to justify torture?

I saw that movie too. :rolleyes:

Wonder how that would work in Real Life. And I wonder if that "interrogation technique" would hold up in court.

In any case, murder with the intent of suggesting that the other detainee is next is still a form of torture.

GB

In that case "American Idol" should be banned as a violation of the Geneva Convention.
 
Basically all here have already explained quite thoroughly, why they feel logically comfortable with the way how they think about crimes, punishments and justice. That is when discussions tend to calm down.
 
And what do you think of the links ?
I think that this quote from the second link sums up the practical value of any studies about the subject:

"One reason that there is no consensus on whether or not the death penalty is a deterrent is that it is used so rarely - only about one out of every 300 murders actually results in an execution."

In other words, it is not very useful information to calculate the deterrent effect of a death penalty law that in 99,7% of cases results in a life sentence and not death penalty.
 
I think that this quote from the second link sums up the practical value of any studies about the subject:

"One reason that there is no consensus on whether or not the death penalty is a deterrent is that it is used so rarely - only about one out of every 300 murders actually results in an execution."

In other words, it is not very useful information to calculate the deterrent effect of a death penalty law that in 99,7% of cases results in a life sentence and not death penalty.

Deterrent or not. I for one am not willing to even contemplate advocating the Death Penalty until the Justice System can guarantee 100% accuracy in convicting the right person.

Then maybe, I'll think about. But until then...

GB
 
I think that this quote from the second link sums up the practical value of any studies about the subject:

"One reason that there is no consensus on whether or not the death penalty is a deterrent is that it is used so rarely - only about one out of every 300 murders actually results in an execution."

In other words...

In other words you looked for a single sentence in the text that allowed you to actually NOT answer the question and bow out ?
 
I didn't expect to find anything as useful as this jewel turns out to be. I wanted to quickly check that the text doesn't contain proof of no-death-penalties being a _superior_ deterrent compared to having-a-death-penalty. If no-death-penalties is at most equal to (and probably inferor to) having-a-death-penalty in the deterrent effect, it neutralizes this aspect. Other aspects remain, such as the general public (and specifically, the victim) feeling of justice and security.
 
I didn't expect to find anything as useful as this jewel turns out to be. I wanted to quickly check that the text doesn't contain proof of no-death-penalties being a _superior_ deterrent compared to having-a-death-penalty. If no-death-penalties is at most equal to (and probably inferor to) having-a-death-penalty in the deterrent effect, it neutralizes this aspect. Other aspects remain, such as the general public (and specifically, the victim) feeling of justice and security.

I'll take that as a yes.
 
And what then?

Let's just assume for the sake of argument that there's not enough evidence either way that Torture and the Death Penalty act as "deterrents" to "bad behaviour (even though the highest murder rates seem to be in countries which have decriminalized State torture and have the death penalty).

Let us also leave aside the Morality of state sanctioned torture and the death penalty also for the sake of argument (even though it sets a bad exmple for the rest of us).

Can you or anyone else actually guarantee 100% accuracy in determining the guilt of those convicted of capital crimes or those detained and tortured as "criminal suspects" or "suspected terrorists"?

I know you can't, and I know the State can't, and that in and of itself is the "Practical" reason for not torturing or having the death penalty.

GB
 
Can you or anyone else actually guarantee 100% accuracy in determining the guilt of those convicted of capital crimes or those detained and tortured as "criminal suspects" or "suspected terrorists"?

I know you can't, and I know the State can't, and that in and of itself is the "Practical" reason for not torturing or having the death penalty.GB
You want me to throw my baby out with your bathwater. With the same debating strategy, I can ask you, can you build an underground road tunnel with 100% safety in any location on the planet, also in volcanic and geologically active areas, so no innocent lives will be lost while driving through your tunnel? I know you can't, and I know the State can't, but that in and of itself is _not_ a practical reason for not building _any underground road tunnels anywhere_.

There are murder cases where the criminal can be identified with as perfect certainty as science can know anything.
 
Can you or anyone else actually guarantee 100% accuracy in determining the guilt of those convicted of capital crimes or those detained and tortured as "criminal suspects" or "suspected terrorists"?

I know you can't, and I know the State can't, and that in and of itself is the "Practical" reason for not torturing or having the death penalty.

I disagree. The occasional execution or torture of an innocent person is bound to happen, but that's an acceptable risk. In fact, even punishment of an innocent person who is believed to be guilty serves many of the purposes of punishment, as a practical matter.
 
The occasional execution or torture of an innocent person is bound to happen
I wouldn't take it so lightly, this sounds a it Chinese, good of the Nation has priority over good of the individual.

A theoretical risk exists in everything and anything, you cannot even visit a doctor's clinic without theoretically risking wrong diagnosis and wrong treatment or hospital infection that will kill you instead of healing you.
 
You want me to throw my baby out with your bathwater. With the same debating strategy, I can ask you, can you build an underground road tunnel with 100% safety in any location on the planet, also in volcanic and geologically active areas, so no innocent lives will be lost while driving through your tunnel? I know you can't, and I know the State can't, but that in and of itself is _not_ a practical reason for not building _any underground road tunnels anywhere_.

There are murder cases where the criminal can be identified with as perfect certainty as science can know anything.

It is the MOST practical reason if that innocent person is you. Nice attempt to dodge though.

GB
 
It is the MOST practical reason if that innocent person is you. Nice attempt to dodge though.GB
So you suggest closing all hospitals, because innocent people get wrong diagnoses and lethal MRSA infections there? Nice attempt.

We design the society to function in a reasonable way, and life is never 100% perfect no matte what we do and decide.
 
So you suggest closing all hospitals, because innocent people get wrong diagnoses and lethal MRSA infections there? Nice attempt.

We design the society to function in a reasonable way, and life is never 100% perfect no matte what we do and decide.

Your argument is patently ridiculous. I'm not arguing merely to score a rhetorical point which is what you seem to be engaged in.

It all boils down to whether or not YOU want to live in a society where YOU could be Tortured or Executed even if YOU are completely innocent of all charges and wrongly suspected or convicted.

If YOU are happy enough to sacrifice YOURSELF because you think it's worth it for the good of society to keep Torture and the Death Penalty in place, then just say so and stop playing rhetorical games.

I don't have any patience for rhetorical BS.

GB
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom