Is there anything a person can do to justify torture?

Please explain how a year in jail is equal to stealing a TV set.
These two things are not similar, so it is difficult to assess whether they are "equal", otherwise than by observing people's statistical offer and demand behaviour. If we make a public offer that people get a free television if they agree to spend one year in federal prison, not many would take the offer, so it seems that the punishment is more severe than the crime.

And if you think it is not an equal punishment, what is in your opinion an "equal punishment" for stealing a TV set?
See above.

Another thing is the statistical success rate of the police in solving each particular type of crime. Organized crime lives off the fact that the compensation or punishment for a _solved_ crime is less severe than the profits of _unsolved_ crimes. When designing a legislation, I would pay attention to the statistical profitability of crime: it does not help much to punish theft of a TV set with a fine worth 2 TV sets, if organized criminals are able to steal 3 of them for each 1 theft solved by the police. In that case stealing them would be statistically profitable business, even if you know that you will get caught.

if I use a gun to kidnap someone for two days (and treat the person fairly well - no beating or raping), then I will probably end up doing 5-18 years. Under the system you describe I would do 48 hours of jail time.
Here the crime and punishment pretend to be equal, but their impact on the victim very different. People who have been kidnapped or otherwise threatened with death typically suffer from depression, fear and other life-changing or disabling psychological effects for a long time, some for the rest of their lives. This problem must be addressed by the punishment and compensation system. It would be "equal justice" to inflict the same life-changing psychological fear and feeling of helplessness to the criminal as he caused to his victim, but how that can be done in each case is more difficult. Send them unarmed to the front line in Afghanistan for two days might do the trick, so we don't even cross the time limit, if we get him back alive. Which the original victim didn't know either.

Can you define justice in a way that is distinguishable from vengeance?
Justice obviously implies some reasonable and carefully balanced vengeance, except maybe if you forget what has happened in the past, and discuss the future only.
 
Last edited:
I agree with everything except the last little "justifiable under the law" bit. I don't think we need a loophole. Courts and juries can find a person guilty under the law, but choose minimal (or even not inflict any further) civil penalty/fine upon an individual it understands is not an ongoing threat to society.

When I say "justifiable under the law," I simply mean that killing or beating the hell out of someone you witnessed murdering/torturing etc, your family member should be considered as extenuating circumstances, and that jail time, fines, or punishment for such acts may be inappropriate in those cases.

Of course I don't think people should be unaccountable for such acts; the circumstances should be investigated on a case by case basis, and a reasonable court/jury should take those circumstances into account. And in some cases "justifiable homicide" may be an appropriate ruling.

In other words, I'm not suggesting making new laws or setting new precedents to legitimize Vigilantism. What I am suggesting is something that in many cases already has some judicial precedence.

So I think we are pretty much in agreement here too. :)

GB
 
A few posters have mentioned their belief that justice demands an equal or greater punishment for a criminal. I'd be curious to know where exactly this concept of justice comes from. Is it based on the Bible, or does it have some other source? Also, do you believe that this justice is something that should form the basis for personal ethics? How about legislation?

ETA: A bit of a cross post with Scum. No need to respond to the same question twice.
No, not the Bible, just my instincts. I think you will find that this belief predates the Bible and is not unique to our culture.
I do not think it should form the basis for personal ethics. Ethics should primarily be based on love and respect for non-evil human beings. I do however think that people who commit evil acts should be punished accordingly with the cruelty of their act taken as one of the parameters in setting the punishment.
Where does your concept of justice come from?

Can you define justice in a way that is distinguishable from vengeance?
To me, vengeance is a component of justice. I'll not try to pretend otherwise. The idea of a villain getting away with villainy does not sit well with me. Do you not feel the same?

Whatever his goal (a sense of power and control most likely), his means to that end is torture.

Whatever your goal (justice? vengeance? sense of power and control?), your means to that end is the same as his.

Are you saying that the ends justify the means for you, but not for him?
Some ends justify some means. Evil ends do not justify any means. Just ends justify just means.

This is a silly question, asking only if the self gratification of one person is shared by another person. Something like a character quiz, meaning nothing.
I really don't know what this means.

Torture should be (remain?) illegal, so should the Death Penalty. The State should not be in the "Punishment" or "Vengeance" business, but rather in the "Protection" business. Besides the ethical concerns, there is always the very real possibility the State has the wrong guy/gal. And it sets a bad example for the rest of us to follow.

Not to mention that allowing the State to have such power undermines Civil Rights and institutionalizes immoral, unethical, criminal, and ineffective behaviour. Torture has never been shown empirically to be consistently effective as an information gathering tool; under torture, most people will say whatever they think the torturer wants to hear. Many false confessions of heresy and witchcraft were elicited by the Inquisition. And false confessions are regularly obtained through this sort of criminal behaviour by local, state, and national law enforcement personnel, and by Military and Intelligence personnel.

Having said that, In the scenario's that some have proposed, like witnessing the rape/torture/murder of a family member, I'm all for personal vendettas, and I think it should be seen as justifiable under the law. However, if your vendetta goes awry and targets the wrong person, you should be prepared to be held criminally liable.

GB
I seriously object to this idea because this takes the responsibility for justice out of the hands of the state and puts it in the hands of people with vendettas.
Besides, only the strong can hope for justice under this system. Those with the physcal strength or weapons to carry out thir vendettas can get justice; th weak cannot.
 
No, not the Bible, just my instincts. I think you will find that this belief predates the Bible and is not unique to our culture.
I do not think it should form the basis for personal ethics. Ethics should primarily be based on love and respect for non-evil human beings. I do however think that people who commit evil acts should be punished accordingly with the cruelty of their act taken as one of the parameters in setting the punishment.
Where does your concept of justice come from?

I've no such thing. I consider the concept of justice outdated and unnecessary. Moreover, I've yet to come across a concept of justice that amounts to anything more than bald assertion of this and that being just.

Why is it just for a criminal to suffer as well? I can't understand it. No-one benefits from that suffering, yet apparently justice demands it anyway. In my opinion, what matters is that the criminal won't do it again.

Now, if the best method to achieve that is punishing criminals, then fair enough - although studies do tend to show harsher punishments do not lessen crime. But if there is a better method, such as incarceration, why does justice still demand blood? Why is this the one instance where the law should make an exception to accommodate a primitive and harmful desire?

As I've pointed out before, I don't see any major difference between the desire for vengeance and the desire to rape. Both are part of human nature, both are destructive and neither serves a good purpose. So why should one be considered special?
 
Torture should be (remain?) illegal, so should the Death Penalty. The State should not be in the "Punishment" or "Vengeance" business, but rather in the "Protection" business. Besides the ethical concerns, there is always the very real possibility the State has the wrong guy/gal. And it sets a bad example for the rest of us to follow.

Not to mention that allowing the State to have such power undermines Civil Rights and institutionalizes immoral, unethical, criminal, and ineffective behaviour. Torture has never been shown empirically to be consistently effective as an information gathering tool; under torture, most people will say whatever they think the torturer wants to hear. Many false confessions of heresy and witchcraft were elicited by the Inquisition. And false confessions are regularly obtained through this sort of criminal behaviour by local, state, and national law enforcement personnel, and by Military and Intelligence personnel.

Having said that, In the scenario's that some have proposed, like witnessing the rape/torture/murder of a family member, I'm all for personal vendettas, and I think it should be seen as justifiable under the law. However, if your vendetta goes awry and targets the wrong person, you should be prepared to be held criminally liable.

GB



I seriously object to this idea because this takes the responsibility for justice out of the hands of the state and puts it in the hands of people with vendettas.
Besides, only the strong can hope for justice under this system. Those with the physcal strength or weapons to carry out thir vendettas can get justice; th weak cannot.

No it doesn't. What I am proposing is pretty much the judicial standard of most civilized countries in which State Torture and Capital Punishment are illegal (as in most democracies except the US). You seem to be reading something into my statement which doesn't exist.

I don't think the State should have the power to Torture and Murder (and most civilized countries agree), but I never suggested the State shouldn't be responsible for arresting and incarcerating persons that commit violent crimes to protect the rest of us. That's what I call State Justice.

I just went on further to suggest that if someone killed my family in front of me and if I had the means available, I would kill the killers--Personal Justice. Then I went on to suggest that such an action could be considered justifiable homicide and that I shouldn't be incarcerated for killing the scum that just murdered my family. Again, there is legal precedence for this.

Now, if I were to come across my family dead, and I went off half-cocked and killed someone who I thought likely to have committed the crime, but it turned out that I was mistaken, I should be incarcerated for committing a murder (or at least voluntary manslaughter).

If the police find and arrest the alleged killers of my family, then I would hope the best forensic evidence available would be used to determine that the alleged killer was the actual killer and that person be incarcerated. And if it later turns out that exculpatory evidence proves the person incarcerated was not the killer after all, they can be set free, which can't happen if they execute the guy.

So all I'm really arguing for is a Just Judicial System that is able to rectify the inevitable mistakes caused by human error and/or police negligence or corruption. You can't rectify those mistakes once a person has been Tortured or Executed.

This seems like the sanest, and the most moral standard for upholding Justice to me.

GB
 
I've no such thing. I consider the concept of justice outdated and unnecessary. Moreover, I've yet to come across a concept of justice that amounts to anything more than bald assertion of this and that being just.

Why is it just for a criminal to suffer as well? I can't understand it. No-one benefits from that suffering, yet apparently justice demands it anyway. In my opinion, what matters is that the criminal won't do it again.

Now, if the best method to achieve that is punishing criminals, then fair enough - although studies do tend to show harsher punishments do not lessen crime. But if there is a better method, such as incarceration, why does justice still demand blood? Why is this the one instance where the law should make an exception to accommodate a primitive and harmful desire?

As I've pointed out before, I don't see any major difference between the desire for vengeance and the desire to rape. Both are part of human nature, both are destructive and neither serves a good purpose. So why should one be considered special?

I quite agree with this. The State should not be in the Vengeance business. We are all in danger in a judicial system prone to human error, negligence and corruption if the State is allowed to Torture and Execute at will.

GB
 
Why? What's the upside?

Are you asking how we benefit from my version of "justice"?

The same way we benefit from any version of what we'd call a "justice" system - (assuming detection and implementation) we achieve deterrence, retribution and prevention, which covers 3/4 of the ultimate goals of punishment.
 
I quite agree with this. The State should not be in the Vengeance business. We are all in danger in a judicial system prone to human error, negligence and corruption if the State is allowed to Torture and Execute at will.

GB

I believe the state got into the "vengeance business" as the lesser of evils. The only other realistic alternative is individual vengeance, which lacks the formal system for determining guilt, just punishment, correcting mistakes, etc. If anything "human error, negligence and corruption" would be much greater if the state was not in the business. We are in a LOT more danger in the private vengeance world.

The flower-child alternative, of course, is that people wouldn't want vengeance if not for the state - feel freee to support that nonsense if you want. File it with the communi-anarchists who believe we'd all live in peace and harmony without government.
 
As I've pointed out before, I don't see any major difference between the desire for vengeance and the desire to rape. Both are part of human nature, both are destructive and neither serves a good purpose. So why should one be considered special?

To the contrary, vengeance serves positive purposes. That seems so obvious I wonder if you are lying aboput not getting it, just to extend an argument.

Vengeance for a wrong encourages the wrong-does not to do it again and deters others from similar conduct. Beyond deterrence and prevention, it may also be educational and rehabilitative, by reinforcing what conduct society does not approve of. A large part of civilized society is based on that idea and it is very effective, compared to the alternative.
 
I just went on further to suggest that if someone killed my family in front of me and if I had the means available, I would kill the killers--Personal Justice. Then I went on to suggest that such an action could be considered justifiable homicide and that I shouldn't be incarcerated for killing the scum that just murdered my family. Again, there is legal precedence for this.

Now, if I were to come across my family dead, and I went off half-cocked and killed someone who I thought likely to have committed the crime, but it turned out that I was mistaken, I should be incarcerated for committing a murder (or at least voluntary manslaughter).

So wait, what if you find out your family is dead, and you succesfully hunt down and murder the killers? You seem to believe that you should go off unpunished in that scenario. Sorry, but that doesn't seem like a good idea to me. I can understand the desire for vengeance, but surely you would not want to live in a country where it is legal for people to go on murderous rampages? What if someone were to murder your family, only to then go "oh oops, I thought your family murdered mine but I got the wrong one. Sorry."? Oh sure, you could then legally go on a murderous rampage yourself to exact revenge for your family, but then.... you can see where this would lead, surely.
 
Last edited:
I don't see the point of torturing someone, period.

"I guess I shouldn't rape and murder those children, I might be tortured in jail!"

Right.

Also, justice is when you apply punishments based on the crime committed equally, so that people who commit the same crimes receive the same punishment, regardless of social status, etc. It has little to do with the actual punishment.
 
Time to visit an optician?

I did ask you once already to explain it to me. Where does your "true justice" come from? Is it handed to you by a divinity, or is it just what your instincts tell you? And if the latter, what makes this instinct special?

And if you're going to invoke logic, you're going to have to show the premises instead of just stating "This is obviously true justice".
 
Vengeance for a wrong encourages the wrong-does not to do it again and deters others from similar conduct. Beyond deterrence and prevention, it may also be educational and rehabilitative, by reinforcing what conduct society does not approve of. A large part of civilized society is based on that idea and it is very effective, compared to the alternative.

Those things are not at all limited to vengeance. Vengeance is simply the desire to bring harm to those who you perceive as having done wrong to you. People who seek to exact vengeance will generally not pause for wisdom or reason, and will have no intention of improving the situation by discouraging others, to educate nor to rehabilitate. Often they will inflict just as much harm as the original perpetrator, who unlike the avenger may not even have intended to do any wrong in the first place. Vengeance thus needs to be curbed by the state, not encouraged.

The logical alternative to vengeance is punishment by law, and it is much more effective than vengeance. The law is ideally based on reason rather than emotion, and as such can achieve such things as discouragement and rehabilitation much more effectively than vengeance by basing punishments on their effectiveness rather than the emotional satisfaction derived from vengeance.
 
To the contrary, vengeance serves positive purposes. That seems so obvious I wonder if you are lying aboput not getting it, just to extend an argument.

Vengeance for a wrong encourages the wrong-does not to do it again and deters others from similar conduct. Beyond deterrence and prevention, it may also be educational and rehabilitative, by reinforcing what conduct society does not approve of. A large part of civilized society is based on that idea and it is very effective, compared to the alternative.

I thought I addressed that issue quite clearly. Yes, if vengeance is the best way to deter and prevent, then it's the smart thing to do. But as I've pointed out, it clearly isn't. And I find it hard to believe you consider an eye-for-an-eye system to be more educational and rehabilitative than a humane prison system.

When people speak of vengeance, they don't mean prison sentences and rehabilitation; they speak of inflicting pain upon the criminal. Moreover, vengeance, almost by definition, means that the pain is the goal, not a means to an end. And again, if the goal is to maximize the benefit of the society, it's quite clear that pursuing vengeance at every opportunity is not the best method.

I am rather confused as to what you mean by "the alternative" in your post; after all, it's clear that an alternative to blind vengeance - a judical system focused on rehabilitation and deterrent instead of punishment - is more effective.

All in all, it is your post that gives a strong impression of dishonest argumentation. But perhaps the more likely explanation is simply a misunderstanding. Would you mind explaining what exactly you mean by "vengeance", in case it's a different definition from the one I use?
 
I believe the state got into the "vengeance business" as the lesser of evils. The only other realistic alternative is individual vengeance, which lacks the formal system for determining guilt, just punishment, correcting mistakes, etc. If anything "human error, negligence and corruption" would be much greater if the state was not in the business. We are in a LOT more danger in the private vengeance world.

The flower-child alternative, of course, is that people wouldn't want vengeance if not for the state - feel freee to support that nonsense if you want. File it with the communi-anarchists who believe we'd all live in peace and harmony without government.

Did you even bother to read my previous posts to put this statement in context? Apparently not, or you wouldn't have made such an idiotic response.

GB
 
So wait, what if you find out your family is dead, and you succesfully hunt down and murder the killers? You seem to believe that you should go off unpunished in that scenario. Sorry, but that doesn't seem like a good idea to me. I can understand the desire for vengeance, but surely you would not want to live in a country where it is legal for people to go on murderous rampages? What if someone were to murder your family, only to then go "oh oops, I thought your family murdered mine but I got the wrong one. Sorry."? Oh sure, you could then legally go on a murderous rampage yourself to exact revenge for your family, but then.... you can see where this would lead, surely.

Selective reading comprehension. I thought intelligent people populated JREF. Read my posts in context.

GB
 
People, there are only 3 pages so far. Is it too much to ask that you read all the posts and put a person's statements all together for context?

GB
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom