JJM 777
Illuminator
- Joined
- Jun 25, 2004
- Messages
- 4,060
These two things are not similar, so it is difficult to assess whether they are "equal", otherwise than by observing people's statistical offer and demand behaviour. If we make a public offer that people get a free television if they agree to spend one year in federal prison, not many would take the offer, so it seems that the punishment is more severe than the crime.Please explain how a year in jail is equal to stealing a TV set.
See above.And if you think it is not an equal punishment, what is in your opinion an "equal punishment" for stealing a TV set?
Another thing is the statistical success rate of the police in solving each particular type of crime. Organized crime lives off the fact that the compensation or punishment for a _solved_ crime is less severe than the profits of _unsolved_ crimes. When designing a legislation, I would pay attention to the statistical profitability of crime: it does not help much to punish theft of a TV set with a fine worth 2 TV sets, if organized criminals are able to steal 3 of them for each 1 theft solved by the police. In that case stealing them would be statistically profitable business, even if you know that you will get caught.
Here the crime and punishment pretend to be equal, but their impact on the victim very different. People who have been kidnapped or otherwise threatened with death typically suffer from depression, fear and other life-changing or disabling psychological effects for a long time, some for the rest of their lives. This problem must be addressed by the punishment and compensation system. It would be "equal justice" to inflict the same life-changing psychological fear and feeling of helplessness to the criminal as he caused to his victim, but how that can be done in each case is more difficult. Send them unarmed to the front line in Afghanistan for two days might do the trick, so we don't even cross the time limit, if we get him back alive. Which the original victim didn't know either.if I use a gun to kidnap someone for two days (and treat the person fairly well - no beating or raping), then I will probably end up doing 5-18 years. Under the system you describe I would do 48 hours of jail time.
Justice obviously implies some reasonable and carefully balanced vengeance, except maybe if you forget what has happened in the past, and discuss the future only.Can you define justice in a way that is distinguishable from vengeance?
Last edited: