Is there anything a person can do to justify torture?

Pretty much anything as long as it's part of a consensual relationship and they've come up with an easy to remember safeword. Otherwise, no.

Bolded part, not neccesary. Thats SSC, more seasoned and experienced practicioners use RACK, and torture as punishment is much more the domain of RACK than it is SSC
;)
 
Last edited:
The irony is that (IME) those that would condone this sort of eye for an eye punishment are also the ones who shriek the loudest when there is any hint of sharia law coming to their country.

Well Sharia punishes people for victimless crimes like being gay or immodest. It is also biased against women. For example the word of a man as a witness counts for more. Women cannot go out in public without a male chaperone. In fact women can be punished for being the victim of a crime, like being raped.
 
If that's the way you want to define "just punishment," then that's fine. However, you're not providing any reason why one ought to behave in a fashion that causes your idea of just punishment to be actualized.

Huh? I was also not explaining how to make coffee or change the oil in your car, but I wasn't asked to and didn't intend to.
 
Assuming you are addresssing the "torture as punishment" theme, disregarding torture for other purposes, I'd say any crime that inflicts pain would justify at least equal pain in return.

No, I said the punishment would exceed the injury to the victim, so maybe 2 eyes for an eye, or an eye and an ear.

Why? What's the upside?
 
Is there any act or series of acts that a person can do that would justify torturing that person as punishment?

For example, if that person himself tortured and then murdered dozens of innocent children, and this was proven beyond any shadow of a doubt, would that not justify him being tortured as a punishment for his crime?

Yes, it would. Kidnapping a child and placing that child in threat of death as a tool for lawyer to get immunity grant if he/she admits where child is should also - and for the lawyer. (Note: no smilies)
 
Yes, it would. Kidnapping a child and placing that child in threat of death as a tool for lawyer to get immunity grant if he/she admits where child is should also - and for the lawyer. (Note: no smilies)

Again, why? Once you had tortured the person, what would you have gained?
 
The person would know, without doubt, the he/she had been very naughty. No offense, but a right silly question. I do not argue your right to be against torture. Don't bother arguing against mine to be for it - in specialized cases. If it helps, I have not changed my view on this matter since I developed it some 57/8 years ago (born in 1946) (agreed with the Bros. Grimm in these matters (real Grimm, not the appropriatized stuff).
 
The person would know, without doubt, the he/she had been very naughty. No offense, but a right silly question. I do not argue your right to be against torture. Don't bother arguing against mine to be for it - in specialized cases. If it helps, I have not changed my view on this matter since I developed it some 57/8 years ago (born in 1946) (agreed with the Bros. Grimm in these matters (real Grimm, not the appropriatized stuff).

Do you have any evidence that torturing people is a more effective method of preventing people from repeating crimes than rehabilitation?
 
The person would know, without doubt, the he/she had been very naughty. No offense, but a right silly question. I do not argue your right to be against torture. Don't bother arguing against mine to be for it - in specialized cases. If it helps, I have not changed my view on this matter since I developed it some 57/8 years ago (born in 1946) (agreed with the Bros. Grimm in these matters (real Grimm, not the appropriatized stuff).

When we talk about proper actions, we must first establish some sort of purpose. Why should I pay my electric bill? Because I want my electricity to remain on, and doing so is an effective method of achieving this goal.

So when you are in favor of torture, even only "in specialized cases," what is your goal? Is this the ticking time bomb scenario we keep hearing about?
 
Puppycow, you haven't yet explained what the supposed goal is of torturing this bad person. Is it to cause him to suffer? If that's the case, then I would question why you feel he is deserving of punishment: Because he had the same goals as you?

No, the goals are not the same. His goal was to torture innocent children, mine was justice.
 
No, the goals are not the same. His goal was to torture innocent children, mine was justice.

Actually, his action was torturing innocent children. I suppose that when someone does that, their goal is to enjoy the experience.

"Justice" is kinda like "morality." Lots of people talk about it, but rarely with any clear understanding of just what it is they mean. So please, elaborate on your goal of justice.
 
A few posters have mentioned their belief that justice demands an equal or greater punishment for a criminal. I'd be curious to know where exactly this concept of justice comes from. Is it based on the Bible, or does it have some other source? Also, do you believe that this justice is something that should form the basis for personal ethics? How about legislation?

ETA: A bit of a cross post with Scum. No need to respond to the same question twice.
 
No, the goals are not the same. His goal was to torture innocent children, mine was justice.

Can you define justice in a way that is distinguishable from vengeance?

Whatever his goal (a sense of power and control most likely), his means to that end is torture.

Whatever your goal (justice? vengeance? sense of power and control?), your means to that end is the same as his.

Are you saying that the ends justify the means for you, but not for him?
 
Is there any act or series of acts that a person can do that would justify torturing that person as punishment?

For example, if that person himself tortured and then murdered dozens of innocent children, and this was proven beyond any shadow of a doubt, would that not justify him being tortured as a punishment for his crime?

This is a silly question, asking only if the self gratification of one person is shared by another person. Something like a character quiz, meaning nothing.
 
Can you define justice in a way that is distinguishable from vengeance?

Whatever his goal (a sense of power and control most likely), his means to that end is torture.

Whatever your goal (justice? vengeance? sense of power and control?), your means to that end is the same as his.

Are you saying that the ends justify the means for you, but not for him?

a reasonable question
 
Torture should be (remain?) illegal, so should the Death Penalty. The State should not be in the "Punishment" or "Vengeance" business, but rather in the "Protection" business. Besides the ethical concerns, there is always the very real possibility the State has the wrong guy/gal. And it sets a bad example for the rest of us to follow.

Not to mention that allowing the State to have such power undermines Civil Rights and institutionalizes immoral, unethical, criminal, and ineffective behaviour. Torture has never been shown empirically to be consistently effective as an information gathering tool; under torture, most people will say whatever they think the torturer wants to hear. Many false confessions of heresy and witchcraft were elicited by the Inquisition. And false confessions are regularly obtained through this sort of criminal behaviour by local, state, and national law enforcement personnel, and by Military and Intelligence personnel.

Having said that, In the scenario's that some have proposed, like witnessing the rape/torture/murder of a family member, I'm all for personal vendettas, and I think it should be seen as justifiable under the law. However, if your vendetta goes awry and targets the wrong person, you should be prepared to be held criminally liable.

GB
 
Torture should be (remain?) illegal, so should the Death Penalty. The State should not be in the "Punishment" or "Vengeance" business, but rather in the "Protection" business. Besides the ethical concerns, there is always the very real possibility the State has the wrong guy/gal. And it sets a bad example for the rest of us to follow.

Not to mention that allowing the State to have such power undermines Civil Rights and institutionalizes immoral, unethical, criminal, and ineffective behaviour. Torture has never been shown empirically to be consistently effective as an information gathering tool; under torture, most people will say whatever they think the torturer wants to hear. Many false confessions of heresy and witchcraft were elicited by the Inquisition. And false confessions are regularly obtained through this sort of criminal behaviour by local, state, and national law enforcement personnel, and by Military and Intelligence personnel.

Having said that, In the scenario's that some have proposed, like witnessing the rape/torture/murder of a family member, I'm all for personal vendettas, and I think it should be seen as justifiable under the law. However, if your vendetta goes awry and targets the wrong person, you should be prepared to be held criminally liable.

GB

I agree with everything except the last little "justifiable under the law" bit. I don't think we need a loophole. Courts and juries can find a person guilty under the law, but choose minimal (or even not inflict any further) civil penalty/fine upon an individual it understands is not an ongoing threat to society.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom