Is there anything a person can do to justify torture?

Puppycow, you haven't yet explained what the supposed goal is of torturing this bad person. Is it to cause him to suffer? If that's the case, then I would question why you feel he is deserving of punishment: Because he had the same goals as you?

How often do you suppose it has ever been the case that the murderer showed any similar concern for his victim?

How often do you suppose it has ever been the case that this argument has been the slightest bit relevant?
 
I think the entire concept of "perfect justice", or "deserving" punishment, or even "punishment" itself is nonsense. They are an integral part of most cultures, to be sure, and they're very likely an integral part of human nature. But still nonsense.

The logic behind punishment is basically that by inflicting pain on the criminal, somehow the original crime will be wiped away, or that a victim of a crime, for some reason, has the "right" to inflict similar pain on the criminal. But what on Earth is the use in that? The original crime won't go away - all a punishment does is cater to the sadistic desire for revenge that most of us unfortunately display.

Of course, deterrent is a whole another thing. It makes perfect sense to have harsh punishments in place for crimes, because that way people will have much less incentive to commit them - and it's clear it's in our common interest to make crimes as unappealing as possible. That's why it's perfectly sensible to punish criminals according to their crimes.

That also happens to be the reason why it's sensible to punish criminals humanely and attempt to rehabilitate them. After all, a rehabilitated prisoner is worth much more to the society than one incarcerated for life is. Death penalty is another matter, of course, but there are several reasons why it's also a bad idea, and not all of those are moral issues.

But wanting to kill, torture or imprison for life a criminal because "they deserve it" or because "justice demands it" is nothing but sadism, the primitive desire to destroy or subjugate anyone perceived as an enemy. It's archaic, it's disgusting, it's ineffective and it's illogical - yet otherwise logical and moral people still defend the practice.

Still, it is my hope that one day people will realize that a crime is not a crime when, and only when, it causes more good than it does harm. And, of course, that causing pain in itself is never "good", although it can sometimes be necessary.
 
Last edited:
Is there any act or series of acts that a person can do that would justify torturing that person as punishment?

For example, if that person himself tortured and then murdered dozens of innocent children, and this was proven beyond any shadow of a doubt, would that not justify him being tortured as a punishment for his crime?

Seems like just a personal opinion question. OK - yes, plenty of things justify torture. What kind of torture would depend on its purpose.
 
For almost any situation, there can be a case made. For example, if you knew for certain that a person had information that a nuclear bomb was about to be detonated in an urban area, but you didn't know where, you would be justified in trying to torture the information out of the person. Millions of lives are worth more than one person's civil rights. But of course, you'd have to know for certain, so this is a hypothetical situation.

Even that example presupposes that torture is an effecctive way to extract information unknown to the questioner, which is far from proven. You would certainly be justified in using whatever was the most likely means of eliciting the information, however unethical in isolation that means might be, but there's no particularly good reason - as far as I'm aware - to believe that torture is that means.

Dave
 
Seems like just a personal opinion question. OK - yes, plenty of things justify torture. What kind of torture would depend on its purpose.

What kind of things?
 
What kind of things?

Assuming you are addresssing the "torture as punishment" theme, disregarding torture for other purposes, I'd say any crime that inflicts pain would justify at least equal pain in return.
 
Is there any act or series of acts that a person can do that would justify torturing that person as punishment?

For example, if that person himself tortured and then murdered dozens of innocent children, and this was proven beyond any shadow of a doubt, would that not justify him being tortured as a punishment for his crime?
No give him a trial and sentence to the maximum punishment. We have to be civilized even to the type of scum you just described.

Dennis Rader killed ten people including an 11 year old girl whom he hung while she was begging for her life and while she was choking to death he pulled her panties down. Does he deserve to be tortured? Well the system didn't do it but it wouldn't bother me if he got some of what he gave out at the hands of his fellow inmates.

In his case and in other cases like him we'll just have to satisfy ourselves that he is living in a closet sized cell for the rest of his worthless life. We're civilized and we can't torture him.
 
Last edited:
Assuming you are addresssing the "torture as punishment" theme, disregarding torture for other purposes, I'd say any crime that inflicts pain would justify at least equal pain in return.

So long as you're sure to use metric units of pain on both sides (or both imperial, of course), since those conversion tables are never accurate.
 
Is there any act or series of acts that a person can do that would justify torturing that person as punishment?

For example, if that person himself tortured and then murdered dozens of innocent children, and this was proven beyond any shadow of a doubt, would that not justify him being tortured as a punishment for his crime?

them harmed should own you.


ie.. when i was a kid, if you stoled something from the store, the parent takes you back and makes the kid face the accounting directly, asking to be forgiven and often spending the day sweeping the floors with a sign on their back.

What few do not comprehend of being humbled is the lesson to themselves and to others.


Torture is not necessary but if the life wants to think it is cancer (of self) and continue being cancer, then cut it out.


compassion is not allowing monsters to continue as they harm others (children) who live their whole lives with that 'torture' (the experience of the event).


but if you really want to see the bad old nasty in action, then 'lies' or false witness, is the most prevelant 'torture' to mankind. They harm us all by sending us to a false direction of knowing (an experience).


as far as i can tell, the irresponsibility of human being to believe they can lie by choice, is about as cruel as anything that ever was 'created' by the words, mankind created.


i look at the dichotomy of freedom being so dear and the evil it enables.

can and able; conscious life
 
Ahh...hypotheticals...

Okay. We have this fellow on film kidnapping a child, and we have this fellow on film burying the child alive in a small pine box. We are certain we have the right fellow. He is clearly visible on film committing the acts. However, the film does not tell us where the child has been buried. We can see what happened, who did it, and who the victim is, but we cannot determine where from the film.

We have captured the perp, the child is slowly dying in the pine box, and he won't talk.

Do you try torturing him? Will he give you the correct info, or just toy with you?
 
The irony is that (IME) those that would condone this sort of eye for an eye punishment are also the ones who shriek the loudest when there is any hint of sharia law coming to their country.
 
Ahh...hypotheticals...

Okay. We have this fellow on film kidnapping a child, and we have this fellow on film burying the child alive in a small pine box. We are certain we have the right fellow. He is clearly visible on film committing the acts. However, the film does not tell us where the child has been buried. We can see what happened, who did it, and who the victim is, but we cannot determine where from the film.

We have captured the perp, the child is slowly dying in the pine box, and he won't talk.

Do you try torturing him? Will he give you the correct info, or just toy with you?

start with a professional who can talk to folks capable of such cruelty, if that dont work, then give him to the family members to feed em to their dogs!

put that doggy eatin' scream on film and lets see how many think compassion means 'i can claim insantity'.


when people see what cruelty does to others, then each will be less cruel

until the population begins to understand liability to their own actions, then justice may seems cruel

but be certain; justice is right, when justice is done
 
The irony is that (IME) those that would condone this sort of eye for an eye punishment are also the ones who shriek the loudest when there is any hint of sharia law coming to their country.

sharia is religiously based.

i rather like the idea of each seeing it as if the damage was done to themselves.

ie... what if that was your kid in the box? (YOUR NEXT GENERATION).... Sure, ill let the pro do his part, if that dont work, then what i do, is my business and any within "community" should have the same right and know it.
 
Last edited:
My only answer to the ticking time bomb case is to keep it illegal. If you are that sure, and it is that important, it would be worth breaking the law over, and suffering the punishment for it.
 
sharia is religiously based.

i rather like the idea of each seeing it as if the damage was done to themselves.

ie... what if that was your kid in the box? (YOUR NEXT GENERATION).... Sure, ill let the pro do his part, if that dont work, then what i do, is my business and any within "community" should have the same right and know it.

The torture as punishment idea is a completely seperate one from the ticking time bomb scenario, please don't conflate them.
 
The irony is that (IME) those that would condone this sort of eye for an eye punishment are also the ones who shriek the loudest when there is any hint of sharia law coming to their country.
Blah what a non-argument. The problem with sharia is not "eye for eye" or "life for life", it is "life for sexual immorality", "life for sacrilege", "hand for stealing", "maximum 4 wives per husband, maximum 1 husband per wife", etc.

We're civilized and we can't torture him.
Good to have an authoritative definition of what "civilized" is, we can add it to our encyclopedia next to "holy" and "righteous".

A penny for your thoughts what USA is doing in Guantanamo, and by proxy in numerous other countries around the world.
 
We put kidnappers in jail, don't we? Is this not equally “hypocritical”?

more ironic than hypocritical, but there is a big difference between depriving someone of their freedom for a limited time period, and killing a human being.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom