Is there anything a person can do to justify torture?

Selective reading comprehension. I thought intelligent people populated JREF. Read my posts in context.

GB

I have read all your posts in this thread. Admittedly I have skimmed through other posts (not yours) to save time, so I may have missed a little context, but I do not see how I could have misunderstood your post. You say that having your family murdered in front of you should be seen as a mitigating circumstance if you then kill the killers. This I agree with. You then say that it would be justified if you hunted down and killed the killers a period of time after the act, and that you should be charged for this only if you kill the wrong ones by accident. This I vehemently disagree with. I do not believe there is anything wrong with my reading comprehension. If I misunderstood you, it would be more helpful if you explained how rather than just calling anyone who disagrees with you stupid.
 
Alrighty then, for all the folk that have a difficult time following a whole argument and contextualizing it, here are my significant posts (and you can click back to see who I was responding to):

Torture should be (remain?) illegal, so should the Death Penalty. The State should not be in the "Punishment" or "Vengeance" business, but rather in the "Protection" business. Besides the ethical concerns, there is always the very real possibility the State has the wrong guy/gal. And it sets a bad example for the rest of us to follow.

Not to mention that allowing the State to have such power undermines Civil Rights and institutionalizes immoral, unethical, criminal, and ineffective behaviour. Torture has never been shown empirically to be consistently effective as an information gathering tool; under torture, most people will say whatever they think the torturer wants to hear. Many false confessions of heresy and witchcraft were elicited by the Inquisition. And false confessions are regularly obtained through this sort of criminal behaviour by local, state, and national law enforcement personnel, and by Military and Intelligence personnel.

Having said that, In the scenario's that some have proposed, like witnessing the rape/torture/murder of a family member, I'm all for personal vendettas, and I think it should be seen as justifiable under the law. However, if your vendetta goes awry and targets the wrong person, you should be prepared to be held criminally liable.

GB

When I say "justifiable under the law," I simply mean that killing or beating the hell out of someone you witnessed murdering/torturing etc, your family member should be considered as extenuating circumstances, and that jail time, fines, or punishment for such acts may be inappropriate in those cases.

Of course I don't think people should be unaccountable for such acts; the circumstances should be investigated on a case by case basis, and a reasonable court/jury should take those circumstances into account. And in some cases "justifiable homicide" may be an appropriate ruling.

In other words, I'm not suggesting making new laws or setting new precedents to legitimize Vigilantism. What I am suggesting is something that in many cases already has some judicial precedence.

So I think we are pretty much in agreement here too. :)

GB

I quite agree with this. The State should not be in the Vengeance business. We are all in danger in a judicial system prone to human error, negligence and corruption if the State is allowed to Torture and Execute at will.

GB

So, taken altogether and in context, to sum up: I believe in Justice under the Law. I don't believe the State should be in the Torture and Capital Punishment business. I believe everyone should be held accountable for their crimes. And I believe that under certain circumstances such as self-defense or the defense of others killing can be justified.

And I also believe that personal vengeance if one has WITNESSED the Torture, Rape, or Murder of one's family, friends, or even strangers MIGHT be justifiable if you get the right person. However, I also believe that one should be held accountable in a court of law for such actions, but that the circumstances should be seen as extenuating on a case by case basis.

If it is determined that one's act of vengeance was properly targeted--i.e. you killed the killer--then the extenuating circumstances should merit a ruling of Justifiable Homicide. If one goes on an indiscriminate killing spree with a misplaced sense of vengeance then one should be charged with murder1, murder2, or voluntary manslaughter--depending on how extenuating the circumstances are.

And in fact, what I have just described already has legal precedence in most jurisdictions in most democratic States. The exception being the US, which IS one of the very few democratic States to have decriminalized State Torture and Institutionalized Capital Punishment.

The End :p

GB
 
Last edited:
I have read all your posts in this thread. Admittedly I have skimmed through other posts (not yours) to save time, so I may have missed a little context, but I do not see how I could have misunderstood your post. You say that having your family murdered in front of you should be seen as a mitigating circumstance if you then kill the killers. This I agree with. You then say that it would be justified if you hunted down and killed the killers a period of time after the act, and that you should be charged for this only if you kill the wrong ones by accident. This I vehemently disagree with. I do not believe there is anything wrong with my reading comprehension. If I misunderstood you, it would be more helpful if you explained how rather than just calling anyone who disagrees with you stupid.

I have now put all the relevant posts together, and I cannot find anywhere I made a statement such as: "You then say that it would be justified if you hunted down and killed the killers a period of time after the act, and that you should be charged for this only if you kill the wrong ones by accident."

No, indeed, I never suggested that it would be justified if I "killed the killers a period of time after the act". I spoke (typed) only of swift, immediate revenge if the circumstances made it possible. And I suggested that under those circumstances in a court of law, that I MIGHT reasonably expect a ruling of Justifiable Homicide.

However (since you brought it up), I suspect that if I did hunt down and kill the killers of my family a period of time after the original crime, as long as I actually took out the right people, that in a court of law with a sympathetic jury and a good lawyer, I might actually get a lenient sentence.

But I certainly wouldn't expect leniency for a random Vigilante Killing Spree, and I should definitely be locked up for the safety of the public in that case.

GB
 
Last edited:
You say you put together all relevant posts, but you specifically left out the part that I quoted.

You did indeed not say "killed the killers a period of time after the act". What you said was that "if someone killed my family in front of me and if I had the means available, I would kill the killers" and that you shouldn't be charged for that. You then said that if on the other hand you "killed someone who I thought likely to have committed the crime, but it turned out that I was mistaken" then you should be charged for murder. This seemed to say that you should only be charged in that scenario because you ended up killing the wrong one. So I asked, what if you do the same thing but end up getting the right one? Should you then still not be charged? Or should it only be considered extenuating circumstances if you kill the murderers right at the moment where they kill your family?

From your last post I guess you do consider murdering them at a later point as extenuating circumstances, which I suppose I might agree with. I can't say I agree with the whole "it's all right if they do it to you first" philosophy though. Having people seek vengeance should still be discouraged, as it is still murder, regardless of what they did to you in the past.
 
Last edited:
To me, vengeance is a component of justice. I'll not try to pretend otherwise. The idea of a villain getting away with villainy does not sit well with me. Do you not feel the same?

I don't feel the same way at all. I get no pleasure out of bad guys being tortured, I just see more pain. My concept of justice is preventing the "bad guy" from doing the same thing again, while taking into account their reasons for doing so, and providing the victim with whatever support they need as a result.
 
Those things are not at all limited to vengeance. Vengeance is simply the desire to bring harm to those who you perceive as having done wrong to you. People who seek to exact vengeance will generally not pause for wisdom or reason, and will have no intention of improving the situation by discouraging others, to educate nor to rehabilitate. Often they will inflict just as much harm as the original perpetrator, who unlike the avenger may not even have intended to do any wrong in the first place. Vengeance thus needs to be curbed by the state, not encouraged.

A. If a wrong-doer is punished, the preventive and deterrent value of the punishment has little to do with the subjective motivation of the punisher. A good example would be criminal gangs - i.e., the Crips or Hells Angels. The average criminal avoids causing trouble for members of those gangs, their friends, their property, etc., because of the deterrent effect of the retribution they have visited on others. It is no different than those who avoid stealing or killing because they don't want to go to prison, just administered informally.

B. I don't see how "vengeance" really differs from the retributive goal of legal punishment, except that vengeance implies non-government sanctioned punishment. Retributive Justice is when the government punishes somebody who steals from you and vengeance is when you do it yourself. So?

The logical alternative to vengeance is punishment by law, and it is much more effective than vengeance. The law is ideally based on reason rather than emotion, and as such can achieve such things as discouragement and rehabilitation much more effectively than vengeance by basing punishments on their effectiveness rather than the emotional satisfaction derived from vengeance.

I addressed those things in the post youy responded to, I believe. See the above example. I've spent much of my life around criminals in various capacities, either for or against them. I can tell you with some certainty that "vengeance" administered without government sanction is an excellent deterrent ("discouragement") - the Crips/Hells Angels mentioned above being a good example.
 
Last edited:
Did you even bother to read my previous posts to put this statement in context? Apparently not, or you wouldn't have made such an idiotic response.

GB

And?...your previous post makes my comment even more clearly applicable....speaking of "idiotic responses.":boggled:
 
These two things are not similar, so it is difficult to assess whether they are "equal", otherwise than by observing people's statistical offer and demand behaviour. If we make a public offer that people get a free television if they agree to spend one year in federal prison, not many would take the offer, so it seems that the punishment is more severe than the crime.

This is ridiculous.

Do you then conduct a survey asking how many years a person would be willing to spend in prison in exchange for raping a 10-year old girl?

It would be "equal justice" to inflict the same life-changing psychological fear and feeling of helplessness to the criminal as he caused to his victim, but how that can be done in each case is more difficult. Send them unarmed to the front line in Afghanistan for two days might do the trick, so we don't even cross the time limit, if we get him back alive. Which the original victim didn't know either.

What's to prevent the victim from lying about how psychologically damaging something is?

Vengeance can't even hypothetically be something the state gets into, because the state can't know the effects of a crime on the individual. The state can estimate the effect of the crime on society--but this is where it gets tricky, because some of us in society see institutionalized vengeance as harmful in itself.

What if I said that your ideas of vengeance are so barbaric that they cause me real fear that someone like you should ever come into power? Do I have a claim to vengeance against you?

Your "equal justice" idea is a non-starter.

Justice obviously implies some reasonable and carefully balanced vengeance, except maybe if you forget what has happened in the past, and discuss the future only.

The crux of the problem is that many don't regard vengeance as reasonable, because it achieves no purpose other than satisfying some primal need.
 
You say you put together all relevant posts, but you specifically left out the part that I quoted.

You did indeed not say "killed the killers a period of time after the act". What you said was that "if someone killed my family in front of me and if I had the means available, I would kill the killers" and that you shouldn't be charged for that. You then said that if on the other hand you "killed someone who I thought likely to have committed the crime, but it turned out that I was mistaken" then you should be charged for murder. This seemed to say that you should only be charged in that scenario because you ended up killing the wrong one. So I asked, what if you do the same thing but end up getting the right one? Should you then still not be charged? Or should it only be considered extenuating circumstances if you kill the murderers right at the moment where they kill your family?

From your last post I guess you do consider murdering them at a later point as extenuating circumstances, which I suppose I might agree with. I can't say I agree with the whole "it's all right if they do it to you first" philosophy though. Having people seek vengeance should still be discouraged, as it is still murder, regardless of what they did to you in the past.

First, a big fat OOOPS, :o I meant to also include post #86 in my "consolidation post". Mea Culpa!

However, it appears that I still can't be accused of making the statement that you suggested I did, and that you have acknowledged that. Though looking back through my posts again, I can see that it would not be unreasonable for you to make that inference. :boxedin:

Indeed I am mostly in agreement with you. Vengeance is not an act to be encouraged, though I do think it is an act that warrants some mitigation. I must say though, your signature quote by Machiavelli seems quite ironic in light of your Pacifism. ;)

As a general rule, I am opposed to Vigilantism, and I am not a "Second Amendment Solution" NRA spouting gun nut. I certainly don't believe in torture. Even if someone did murder my family (especially my dog ;) ), I might likely have the urge to kill that person in an act of vengeance, but I wouldn't have the stomach for torture.

And I do believe that even when there are extenuating circumstances, one should still be held to account.

But most of all to be held accountable are those that we give authority to uphold the laws, and the Classes that believe their wealth makes them above the law. Unfortunately, it appears that those in authority feel free to torture, feel free to commit acts of "vengeance", feel free to commit mass murder etc.

Not setting much of an example for the rest of us eh! Apparently Rule of Law only applies to "the populace."

GB
 
When I say "justifiable under the law," I simply mean that killing or beating the hell out of someone you witnessed murdering/torturing etc, your family member should be considered as extenuating circumstances, and that jail time, fines, or punishment for such acts may be inappropriate in those cases.

Of course I don't think people should be unaccountable for such acts; the circumstances should be investigated on a case by case basis, and a reasonable court/jury should take those circumstances into account. And in some cases "justifiable homicide" may be an appropriate ruling.

GB
On a case by case basis, I support anyone who kills, tortures, etc. someone they witnessed torturing,etc. a member of their family - with the sole but major proviso :UNLESS they are avenging a murder, etc. of someone in their own family commited by the person they are repairing. Ongoing family feuds not supported except where innocent victims occur. I add I would lie to be able to be on the jury in any case where the accused is accused of that so I could get them acquitted. This definitelyapplies to any family member of anyone killed or imprisoned due to a lawyer "ethically" not passing on knowledge of such exculpatory information so as not to harm his/her client's interests who kills and, hopefully, tortures such lawyer. Specific case came up in these threads a couple of years ago. Hoping I will hear the surviving lawyer's body has been found mutilated somewhere.

I really, really hate injustice.
 
When I say "justifiable under the law," I simply mean that killing or beating the hell out of someone you witnessed murdering/torturing etc, your family member should be considered as extenuating circumstances, and that jail time, fines, or punishment for such acts may be inappropriate in those cases.

Of course I don't think people should be unaccountable for such acts; the circumstances should be investigated on a case by case basis, and a reasonable court/jury should take those circumstances into account. And in some cases "justifiable homicide" may be an appropriate ruling.

GB
On a case by case basis, I support anyone who kills, tortures, etc. someone they witnessed torturing,etc. a member of their family - with the sole but major proviso :UNLESS they are avenging a murder, etc. of someone in their own family commited by the person they are repairing. Ongoing family feuds not supported except where innocent victims occur. I add I would lie to be able to be on the jury in any case where the accused is accused of that so I could get them acquitted. This definitelyapplies to any family member of anyone killed or imprisoned due to a lawyer "ethically" not passing on knowledge of such exculpatory information so as not to harm his/her client's interests who kills and, hopefully, tortures such lawyer. Specific case came up in these threads a couple of years ago. Hoping I will hear the surviving lawyer's body has been found mutilated somewhere.

I really, really hate injustice.
 
I've no such thing. I consider the concept of justice outdated and unnecessary.
That's a pretty amazing statement. Not just my concept of justice but any concept of justice is "outdated and unnecessary"?
Moreover, I've yet to come across a concept of justice that amounts to anything more than bald assertion of this and that being just.
Well that's true I suppose, but then again is there any concept of art or music that amounts to anything more than bald assertion of this and that being artistic or musical? Is there any concept of morality that amounts to anything more than bald assertion of this and that being moral or immoral? At some point to make any practical sense of the universe and our place and role in it, we have to start by making a few bald assertions.
Why is it just for a criminal to suffer as well? I can't understand it. No-one benefits from that suffering, yet apparently justice demands it anyway.
People who care about justice may benefit. Just because you do not personally care for a thing, does not mean that nobody does. Conversely, there may be some things that you care about which others have no use for.
 
Where does your "true justice" come from?
It is basic math, equal opposites. (Plus 1 USD + minus 1 USD = +-0.) What else than this could "perfect justice" possibly mean?

What we call "justice system" / law enforcement, is not claimed to be based on "perfect justice".
 
Do you then conduct a survey asking how many years a person would be willing to spend in prison in exchange for raping a 10-year old girl?
No, I would conduct a referendum on what the people want the punishment for each crime to be. Then so be it. I would also allow for local variation, if 60% of people want a death penalty for murder, and 40% want 20 years imprisonment for murder, the country can be divided into to areas where these two laws are in place, so people can choose to live under the style of legislation that makes them feel more secure, which is one of the main goals of legislation.

What's to prevent the victim from lying about how psychologically damaging something is?
Nothing, wherefore it is not very useful to listen to the criminal so much.

What if I said that your ideas of vengeance are so barbaric that they cause me real fear that someone like you should ever come into power? Do I have a claim to vengeance against you?
If you personally believe so, you would see most of the world at war with yourself, for various similar reasons. I would advise that one man against half of the world is not a match that you should go for, you would lose the match quite quickly.
 
That's a pretty amazing statement. Not just my concept of justice but any concept of justice is "outdated and unnecessary"? Well that's true I suppose, but then again is there any concept of art or music that amounts to anything more than bald assertion of this and that being artistic or musical? Is there any concept of morality that amounts to anything more than bald assertion of this and that being moral or immoral? At some point to make any practical sense of the universe and our place and role in it, we have to start by making a few bald assertions.

People who care about justice may benefit. Just because you do not personally care for a thing, does not mean that nobody does. Conversely, there may be some things that you care about which others have no use for.

Certainly people have different views of justice, just as people have different views of art. The difference is that only one of these groups is demanding the right to torture and murder people as they please.

You yourself admit that a concept of justice is personal, and that only people benefiting from retribution are the people who want it. Yet you also seem to suggest that because they want it, they should have the right to pursue retribution. To me, that does not make any sense. If my sense of justice demanded I kill a random person every now and then, would that be all right? If not, why should I allow others to kill people out of desire for vengeance?

It's true that moral systems are basically arbitrary, but that doesn't mean we should just allow everyone to hold and act according to any moral system that pleases them. In the end, functioning as a society requires compromises - acting in ways that benefit all, and not just pushing aside the rights of others whenever you feel your own brand of justice demands it.

As I've said before, the society benefits most from utilitarian justice. If you think retributive justice is more just, that's your right, just as it is your right to think it's wrong to suffer a witch to live. But if you decide to act on that belief, you're no different from all those other murderers who thought their victims deserved it.
 
It is basic math, equal opposites. (Plus 1 USD + minus 1 USD = +-0.) What else than this could "perfect justice" possibly mean?

What we call "justice system" / law enforcement, is not claimed to be based on "perfect justice".

I find it curious that you answered my question about "true justice" by switching the wording to "perfect justice". But I suppose it doesn't really change anything.

What you are describing is generally known as retributive justice. It's one common usage of the word, but it's in no way more "true" or "perfect" than utilitarian, or restorative justice. What I'm asking is why you consider it to be so far superior to the others as to be labeled "perfect". Did you read about true/perfect justice somewhere, or are these labels your own addition?
 
A perfectly just punishment is equal to the crime committed.

That makes no sense whatsoever.

First off, since when is punishment "justice" ? And second, how do you punish fraud, for instance, if the person has already spent the money ? How do you punish rape ? How do you punish multiple murders ? You kill the murderer more than once ?
 
"At least" ?

Yes, "at least" - in fact, given the culpability of a person who chooses to harm someone else, getting exactly the same harm is inadequate as a preventive and deterrent, much less retribution. Punishment should exceed the harm a person voluntarily causes to an unwilling victim.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom