Is there anything a person can do to justify torture?

A perfectly just punishment is equal to the crime committed. (If the punishment is more severe than the crime, then the legislation is partial against criminals, and if the punishment is less severe than the crime, then the legislation is partial in favour of criminals.)

If a person has tortured others, then it is a perfectly just punishment to torture the person equally as he had done to others.
Please explain how a year in jail is equal to stealing a TV set.

And if you think it is not an equal punishment, what is in your opinion an "equal punishment" for stealing a TV set?
 
I think the entire concept of "perfect justice", or "deserving" punishment, or even "punishment" itself is nonsense. They are an integral part of most cultures, to be sure, and they're very likely an integral part of human nature. But still nonsense.

The logic behind punishment is basically that by inflicting pain on the criminal, somehow the original crime will be wiped away, or that a victim of a crime, for some reason, has the "right" to inflict similar pain on the criminal. But what on Earth is the use in that? The original crime won't go away - all a punishment does is cater to the sadistic desire for revenge that most of us unfortunately display.

Of course, deterrent is a whole another thing. It makes perfect sense to have harsh punishments in place for crimes, because that way people will have much less incentive to commit them - and it's clear it's in our common interest to make crimes as unappealing as possible. That's why it's perfectly sensible to punish criminals according to their crimes.

That also happens to be the reason why it's sensible to punish criminals humanely and attempt to rehabilitate them. After all, a rehabilitated prisoner is worth much more to the society than one incarcerated for life is. Death penalty is another matter, of course, but there are several reasons why it's also a bad idea, and not all of those are moral issues.

But wanting to kill, torture or imprison for life a criminal because "they deserve it" or because "justice demands it" is nothing but sadism, the primitive desire to destroy or subjugate anyone perceived as an enemy. It's archaic, it's disgusting, it's ineffective and it's illogical - yet otherwise logical and moral people still defend the practice.
Seconded!

Yes, I think the whole concept of "punishment" is outdated. It is nothing but institutionalization of desire of revenge, which was at one time a very useful emotion in a social primate -- antisocial behaviour unrestrained by retribution was detrimental to tribe's survival, -- but which we should at least try to overcome by now.

Goal of justice should be rehabilitation. Failing that, removal of antisocial individual from society. Possibly even death if the individual is too dangerous to keep around -- which happens in some extreme cases. But not revenge, and certainly not torture.
 
I disagree with your formulation. It is not always wrong to kill.
Do you think it is wrong to kill in self-defense or defense of the innocent?

Yes, it is wrong. If I choose to accept and bear that wrong that is a choice made and generates consequences that must be lived with. It is never "Right" to take a human life. If society, other people, or the divine choose to forgive, overlook, or even honor those who have taken lives, those are choices others make, but it does not mitigate one's personal responsibility for their own actions.

Heros are individuals that sometimes choose to commit wrongful acts to achieve results that they consider better. The ends do not justify the means, however, and heroism most often isn't about facing overwhelming odds, it's about accepting the burden of living with the consequences of one's actions
 
Is a desire for revenge abnormal? So scumbag tortures a child to death because he thinks its fun like Dennis Rader did makes me want something horrible to happen to him. Its not going to happen because we are civilized.

Some time ago I posted a story about a man who caught a rapist red handed trying to rape his 14 year old daughter and the father pistol whipped him so hard that he broke the trigger guard on the felons head and caused him to have permanent brain damage. Do I care about the felon? Nope. I care about the father who was not punished even slightly.
 
Last edited:
Is a desire for revenge abnormal? So scumbag tortures a child to death because he thinks its fun like Dennis Rader did makes me want something horrible to happen to him. Its not going to happen because we are civilized.
No, it is an entirely normal primate emotion, possibly common to all social mammals. Which does not mean one should act on it.
 
Ahh...hypotheticals...

Okay. We have this fellow on film kidnapping a child, and we have this fellow on film burying the child alive in a small pine box. We are certain we have the right fellow. He is clearly visible on film committing the acts. However, the film does not tell us where the child has been buried. We can see what happened, who did it, and who the victim is, but we cannot determine where from the film.

We have captured the perp, the child is slowly dying in the pine box, and he won't talk.

Do you try torturing him? Will he give you the correct info, or just toy with you?

And since the hypotheses seem without bound, how do we know that the "perp" isn't a victim as well, who is committing the onscreen action under the threats and direction of offscreen agent(s). He may not even know where the burial took place...

Torture does not produce reliable information. It may or may not be accurate, but there generallly is no way to verify that status accurately.
 
A perfectly just punishment is equal to the crime committed. (If the punishment is more severe than the crime, then the legislation is partial against criminals, and if the punishment is less severe than the crime, then the legislation is partial in favour of criminals.)

If a person has tortured others, then it is a perfectly just punishment to torture the person equally as he had done to others.

Many people and legislations are against such punishments. They choose to hold something else than perfect justice as their highest priority in legislation and punishment policies. Interestingly, Hollywood movies cater sweet and cruel revenge and justice to people, while politicians cater very different principles of what-remains-of-justice to the same people, and people swallow these both with a great appetite.


Fascinating. Under current U.S. jurisprudence, if I use a gun to kidnap someone for two days (and treat the person fairly well - no beating or raping), then I will probably end up doing 5-18 years. Under the system you describe I would do 48 hours of jail time.

ETA: If I point a loaded gun at someone and spend 10 minutes convincingly telling the person that I am going to murder him, I will spend 3-12 months in jail. What would the penalty be in the proposed system? A cop points a gun and me and tries to convince me that I will be executed for my crime?
 
Last edited:
Please explain how a year in jail is equal to stealing a TV set.

And if you think it is not an equal punishment, what is in your opinion an "equal punishment" for stealing a TV set?

Being forced to watch one for a few years?!
 
Fascinating. Under current U.S. jurisprudence, if I use a gun to kidnap someone for two days (and treat the person fairly well - no beating or raping), then I will probably end up doing 5-18 years. Under the system you describe I would do 48 hours of jail time.

Masochists with abduction fantasies would stop hiring scene professionals to assist them to live their fantasy and get the law to do it for free

This will cause me loss in revenue, whos going to pay for that eh, what about the despair my Domme partner would feel when I can no longer afford to buy her pretty things, imagine the tears of my slave girl when I tell her "no my little pony adult nappies this week"

like all hastily imagined plans this one wasn't thought through to the suffering you would cause my wallet
:D
 
Last edited:
Well, to begin with I would like to state that I feel torture is a terrible way of getting information out of someone.

Put yourself in the position of the person being tortured. The people who have captured you are evil enough to put you through all this pain, your death is just a tiny step for them. So you are dead already, why give them the pleasure of getting anything out of you? Send them on wild goose chases and have the last laugh as you lie bleeding in your cell.

Or possibly you really don't have any information for them. It is a recorded face that people who don't have any information will start making up stories of whatever they think the torturers want to hear just to make the pain stop. This is why the stories of witches and werewolves and blood sabbaths got so elaborate and strange in the middle ages. Many of these stories were told under torture and some even have notes from the torturers themselves talking about all the false stories the prisoner told before they hit on the one the torturer wanted.

As far as torture for retribution goes, I think it serves no purpose. It may feel good to see someone get back what they did to another but it doesn't give anything back to society. I wish my country didn't consider making prisoners work "cruel and unusual". It would b nice to make people pay their debt to society by actually paying.
 
Good to have an authoritative definition of what "civilized" is, we can add it to our encyclopedia next to "holy" and "righteous".

Oh, the irony. Didn't you just present an authoritative definition of "true justice"? What makes your bald assertion somehow better than other people's?
 
Is a desire for revenge abnormal?

It's not; it's a common human tendency. Much like desire to rape, violence and prejudice are common human tendencies. The point is that despite being common, none of these behaviours should be allowed.

So scumbag tortures a child to death because he thinks its fun like Dennis Rader did makes me want something horrible to happen to him. Its not going to happen because we are civilized.

Out of curiosity, what exactly do you mean when you say "civilized"? It seems to me that to you, civilization is some annoying manacle that keeps us from doing what we really want to do. In my opinion, however, that's not at all the way it should go. Civilization doesn't prevent us from being cruel - it's because we're civilized that we understand why being cruel is a bad idea.
 
more ironic than hypocritical, but there is a big difference between depriving someone of their freedom for a limited time period, and killing a human being.


Not so big a difference. Same thing, different scale. Putting someone to death is a more severe punishment than putting someone in jail for a limited time; just as murder is a more severe crime—worthy of a more severe punishment—than kidnapping.
 
Not so big a difference. Same thing, different scale. Putting someone to death is a more severe punishment than putting someone in jail for a limited time; just as murder is a more severe crime—worthy of a more severe punishment—than kidnapping.

You have vastly different considerations of killing and punishment than I do. As far as I can tell, the differences are irreconcilable.
 

Because the question asked for a subjective opinion and my background and philosophical beliefs convince me that a just punishment is one that inflicts injury to the criminal slightly in excess of that inflicted on the victim.
 
Assuming you are addresssing the "torture as punishment" theme, disregarding torture for other purposes, I'd say any crime that inflicts pain would justify at least equal pain in return.

Eye for an eye then?
 
Because the question asked for a subjective opinion and my background and philosophical beliefs convince me that a just punishment is one that inflicts injury to the criminal slightly in excess of that inflicted on the victim.

If that's the way you want to define "just punishment," then that's fine. However, you're not providing any reason why one ought to behave in a fashion that causes your idea of just punishment to be actualized.
 
Is there any act or series of acts that a person can do that would justify torturing that person as punishment?

Pretty much anything as long as it's part of a consensual relationship and they've come up with an easy to remember safeword. Otherwise, no.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom