Is there any good reason for prostitution being illegal?

If the "well, it's not the career path I would want for my daugher, but..." attitude take hold, there are two possiblities:

1). It will not be the career path for middle-class daughters, who have other options, but will be the one for poor daughters, who have no other similarly-paying job; hence it will be another step in turning the poor into those who will remain forever more in the underclass of the ghetto in the name of "nonjudgmentalism".

2). Or else the middle-class daugher will consider prostitution to be perfectly legitimate, a better option than some of those boring and/or non-well-paying jobs. Because, you know, it's so judgmental and wrong to think any damage might be caused from sleeping with twenty strangers a day for years.

In which case I only hope that, in the interest of fairness, it would be the daughters of those who say "there is nothing wrong with it" who would be the first to choose this career path, you know, just in case they are wrong.

What a curious compilation of assumptions. I would write a response, but I really can't unravel it.
 
1). It will not be the career path for middle-class daughters, who have other options, but will be the one for poor daughters, who have no other similarly-paying job; hence it will be another step in turning the poor into those who will remain forever more in the underclass of the ghetto in the name of "nonjudgmentalism".

What if prostitutes are well paid? It might actually help poor people get OUT of the ghetto.

2). Or else the middle-class daugher will consider prostitution to be perfectly legitimate, a better option than some of those boring and/or non-well-paying jobs. Because, you know, it's so judgmental and wrong to think any damage might be caused from sleeping with twenty strangers a day for years.

In which case I only hope that, in the interest of fairness, it would be the daughters of those who say "there is nothing wrong with it" who would be the first to choose this career path, you know, just in case they are wrong.

I don't have any children but I wouldn't have trouble with them being a prostitute if they were safe, legal, and happy. Of course if any job becomes dangerous, illegal, or makes you unhappy, a career change might be a good idea. I would also worry about the likelihood of long term job availability and suggest they plan accordingly.

You are focusing on a "judgmentalism" straw man. Judging something as harmful or immoral is fine if you have appropriate evidence.
 
Last edited:
You probably think that prostitution is wrong because you believe that it is a crime against society or God or something like that. I believe that it is a crime against the prostitute, similar to putting a person at risk.

I don't disagree with the fact that it puts a person at risk, but if you base your morality on who is the victim -- as opposed to what is right or wrong -- it is problematic.

One obvious problem is that, once prostitution isn't wrong, but simply dangerous, there is only a technical difference -- what makes more prostitutes feel safer or better -- between deciding to end their victimhood by making sure there is no prostitution, and deciding to end their victimhood by making sure prostitution is more safe, more respected, more acceptable, etc.

Prostitution thus becomes just another high-risk job, like (say) coal mining or being a social worker to violent kids, only significantly higher paying.
 
Last edited:
What if they are offered a million dollars and they think it's worth the risk? Please answer my question: should we ban it?

Yes, we should ban it, on the same grounds that we ban duelling. If you think prostitution is anything like that, then we obviously live in different universes.

If you read my posts in this thread, heck, even just the bits you've quoted yourself, you'll see that I've made it very clear that both men and women sell sex. Just because make an example about the most common scenario doesn't mean you get to invent some kind of strawman that I would think it is always exactly like that.

Why then the reference to "my fantasy"?

Yes, there is plenty of evidence from interviews with current and former porn models. I have no idea if this is true for one percent, five percent, fifty percent or ninety percent of porn models. I don't believe doing porn is necessarily damaging. But there seems to be an obvious problem with people being lured into the industry, and if we can do something about that without causing any significant problems for anyone else, why not? I'm not saying my proposal should be law tomorrow, surely it needs to be examined and we should hear the opinions of experts etc. But I think your readiness to just dismiss it out of hands speak volumes about your attitude towards the well being of others.

Care to share some of that evidence? Also, how can you be "tricked" into the porn industry? It doesn't make sense. People can be tricked into prostitution, I know that, but tricked into making a porn movie?:confused:

You seem to have this black/white world view where there is only one problem and one must never do anything that does not directly strike at the 'root cause'. Certainly when it comes to trafficking, poverty would be most of the problem. But that does not mean we could not do anything else. If a cancer patient has chronic pain, should we then refrain from giving her pain killers, because it does not address 'the problem', but only symptoms?

I say, if it works, it works. Reducing poverty in Romania would be great to help women from ending up as sex slaves in Sweden, and I'm all for doing that. But it's not exactly easy and it's going to take a while. In the mean time, I think we should do what we can to reduce sex slavery also by taking action here in Sweden, not just in Romania.

I think that you view prostitution as a problem in itself, whereas I do not. That's the impression I get.

As for Romanians, do you have any evidence that they in the footballer case were trafficked sex slaves? I have only a passing memory, but it tells me that they were not. I could be wrong though.

Anyways, it's irrelevant to what we are discussing. Nobody is arguing that trafficking and sex slavery should be legal. It's a strawman. People are arguing for that voluntary purchase of sex should be legal.

Also, while poverty is certainly a major contributing factor, I do not believe it is the only factor. For instance, there definitely seems to be many women with a self-injuring behaviour (eg cutting themselves with razors etc) who also end up in prostitution in a way that is obviously not healthy.

Do you have any evidence for this, or is it prejudice again? Anyways, the problem is then their self-harm, not prostitution in itself.

But correlation is a clear indication that there is something we need to look at, don't you agree? If we're in 1940 and someone publishes a study showing that smokers often get lung cancer, would you just say that 'correlation does not prove causation!!!' and then refuse to agree that it might be prudent to provisionally conclude that smoking may in fact be very dangerous?

Sometimes, but sometimes not.

I know you're asking for 'evidence', but I'm not willing to go there at least until we've first agreed on what kind of evidence would be convincing, and what level of harmfulness you find acceptable.

I don't agree with your reasoning that if it's harmful to X% of the population, then it should be completely banned. Would you ban alcohol on the account on that 10% of our population are alcoholics? Or what about peanuts, that can be very dangerous to some people? Should we ban peanuts? Or is it a better idea that those who don't do well by it abstain from it, and get help to quit if they are trapped in abuse? And that those who don't fare ill by it are free to engage in it?
 
The obvious harm in prostitution - sexually transmitted disease, violence, murder, rape, trafficking - can all be reduced by legalization, if that legislation is set up to protect sex workers. In The Netherlands legalization primarily benefits brothel owners, landlords, johns and the state which receives taxes. The rate of violent crime and trafficking is growing. In New Zealand where the laws focus on protection and not profit, violence and trafficking have been reduced.

...one of the key movers for the Prostitution Law Reform bill were some of the key players: prostitutes themselves. The NZ Prostitutes Collective contributed greatly to the bill and is one of the reasons why the law makes so much damn sense. Seriously: I watch with abject horror the attempts around the world by people with no connection to the industry and no real understanding of what is going on writing laws based on perceived morality and not on what is best.

I think one of the turning points was this speech by NZ politician Georgina Beyers.

Georgina Beyers said:
I rise to make my contribution to the third reading of this bill, which I support. I would like to begin by expressing my gratitude to the members of this Parliament for a considered and varied debate from both sides and both points of view. Along with that, I congratulate supporters of both sides of the argument for their contribution, which expresses a fair view from both sides of the nation. I particularly congratulate and pay great credit to Tim Barnett, who has had the courage and commitment to see this bill through to this most important point.

I support the bill, because, as everybody knows, I have had experience in the sex industry—and I am the only member of this Parliament to have had it. If I had had a law like this to protect me and give me some teeth for redress when I was 16 and 17 years old—even on entering into the sex industry—then I might have been spared the 5 or so years I spent in that industry. Barriers would have been created against people who would coerce those under 18 to enter the sex industry in the first place. I support this bill for all the prostitutes I have ever known who have died before the age of 20 because of the inhumanity and hypocrisy of a society that would not ever give them the chance to redeem whatever circumstances made them arrive in that industry.

This bill provides some of that protection. It provides people like me at that time with some form of redress for the brutalisation that might happen when a client pulls a knife. The horror of that situation is that it could be a life and death one—one does not know—but it would have been nice to know that instead of having to deal out justice afterwards to that person myself, I might have been able to approach the authorities—the police in this case—and say: “I was raped, and, yes, I’m a prostitute, and, no, it was not right that I should have been raped, because I said no, and it was not paid attention to.”

I think of all the people I have known in that area who have suffered because of the hypocrisy of our society, which, on the one hand, can accept prostitution, while, on the other hand, wants to push it under the carpet and keep it in the twilight world that it exists in. We are bringing prostitution reform into the light with some of what is proposed in this bill, and the criminal element does not necessarily like to be standing in the glare of greater public influence over how an industry like this might be conducted within our society. It is about accepting that that occurs, and it is about accepting the fact that the people who work in this industry deserve some human rights. I plead with those members in this House who are wavering right up to the wire, to think, for heaven’s sake, of the people of whom I have just spoken, including myself, who might be spared some of the hideous nature of the way society treats prostitutes—because that is here with us.

But if one does have fears, this legislation will be reviewed in 5 years to see how it is operating and whether it is effective. If this bill passes tonight, in 5 years we will be able to reassess its worth. That is something that those who are wavering should be comforted by. But to do nothing now would be irresponsible of this Parliament, because the status quo would remain, and that is unacceptable. This is our one chance in perhaps 20 years to do something. Whatever side of the argument we take, I know we all come from a humanitarian point of view, but I beg members to consider the side I am on, and the side many others in this House are on also. It is the side I consider to be right. It does not diminish, in my opinion, the opinions of those who are against this bill, because some valid points have been made, but not to address this issue now, with this possibility, is not right.

I will conclude by saying that right now we have a sex industry, and we have legislation based on an outmoded double standard. Let us change, please, the part we can.

http://www.parliament.nz/en-NZ/PB/D...-Prostitution-Reform-Bill-Procedure-Third.htm ((hansard at New Zealand Parliament, reprinted in full in accordance with Section 27 of the NZ copyright act.)

Georgina was the former mayor of Caterton, and also a former member of Parliament. She was also a transexual, and a former sex worker. Having met her a couple of times can I also add that she was a fantastic person as well. She of course doesn't speak for all sex workers, but from my experience she sure speaks for a lot of them. And in debates like these it surely is a voice that isn't heard often enough.

More info:

http://www.nzpc.org.nz/
 
I don't disagree with the fact that it puts a person at risk, but if you base your morality on who is the victim -- as opposed to what is right or wrong -- it is problematic.

I forget, do you get your sense of "right or wrong" from religion? If you do, I suppose there is no reason to ask for evidence of harm.

Personally, I'm a consequentialist. Harm is all that matters.
 
Last edited:
Consequentialism utterly ignores issues such as human flourishing, society's self-respect, vitality, or sense of right, or the importance of virtue -- to name just a few -- when assessing if damage is caused or not. Anything that cannot be instantly translated into monetary or other sort of measurable damage doesn't matter.

So someone who opens a school to teach young women how to be successful prostitutes, so long as they also learn to protect themselves from drug abuse, say, is doing no more good -- or bad -- than someone who teaches young women to be Shakesprearian scholars or computer scientists. If anything, the prostitute is likely to be measurably doing better than the Shakespearian scholar, money-making wise, so the pimp should be more respected and honored than the professor.

This is not an increase in moral sophistication; it's a decrease, and in any case a dishonest one, since "can you give me evidence of damage?!" in mostly used as a rhetorical trick on the internet -- much like Ed Wood's (in)famous opening lines to Plan Nine from Outer Space, "These are the survivors' accounts... can you prove it didn't happen?!". Nobody ever allows their own daughter to become prostitutes based on the argument that, after all, no evidence of damage was presented to them.

Mill, famously, said that so long as soneone does not hurt or force other people to do anything, there is no moral objection to being a prostitute, or a pimp. This, replied James FitzJames Stephans in Liberty, Equality, Fraternity, is:

... a kind of ingenuity which carries its
own refutation on its face. How can the State or the
public be competent to determine any question what-
ever if it is not competent to decide that gross vice
is a bad thing ?

I do not think the State ought to
stand bandying compliments with pimps. ' Without
offence to your better judgment, dear sir, and with-
out presuming to set up my opinion against yours,
I beg to observe that I am entitled for certain pur-
poses to treat the question whether your views of
Life are right as one which admits of two opinions.
I am far from expressing absolute condemnation of
an experiment in living from which I dissent (I am
sure that mere dissent will not offend a person of
your liberality of sentiment), but still I am compelled
to observe that you arc not altogether unbiassed by
personal considerations in the choice of the course
of life which you have adopted (no doubt for reasons
which appear to you satisfactory, though tliey do not
convince me). I venture, accordingly, though with
the greatest deference, to call upon you not to exer-
cise your profession ; at least I am not indisposed to
think that I may, upon full consideration, feel myself
compelled to do so.'

My feeling is that if society
gets Its grip on the collar of such a fellow it should
say to him, 'You dirty rascal, it may be a question
whether you should be suffered to remain in your
native filth untouched, or whether my opinion about
you should be printed by the lash on your bare baclc.
That question will be determined without the small-
est reference to your wishes or feelings ; but as to
the nature of my opinion about you, there can be no
question at all.'

Truer words were never spoken. In all these long pseudo-sophisticated discussion of the "can you prove prostitution / pornography / polygamy / drug abuse / whatever vice one feels like promoting this week / is really bad?", the overall feeling is that it's a game, an ingenuity that "carries its own refutation on its face".
 
Last edited:
...one of the key movers for the Prostitution Law Reform bill were some of the key players: prostitutes themselves. The NZ Prostitutes Collective contributed greatly to the bill and is one of the reasons why the law makes so much damn sense. Seriously: I watch with abject horror the attempts around the world by people with no connection to the industry and no real understanding of what is going on writing laws based on perceived morality and not on what is best.

I think one of the turning points was this speech by NZ politician Georgina Beyers.



http://www.parliament.nz/en-NZ/PB/D...-Prostitution-Reform-Bill-Procedure-Third.htm ((hansard at New Zealand Parliament, reprinted in full in accordance with Section 27 of the NZ copyright act.)

Georgina was the former mayor of Caterton, and also a former member of Parliament. She was also a transexual, and a former sex worker. Having met her a couple of times can I also add that she was a fantastic person as well. She of course doesn't speak for all sex workers, but from my experience she sure speaks for a lot of them. And in debates like these it surely is a voice that isn't heard often enough.

More info:

http://www.nzpc.org.nz/

That speech was amazing, I got goosebumps reading it.

Earlier on in the thread someone suggested that we speak to sex workers before making the laws. It was the most empathetic suggestion so far, you've just proven it is the most common sense as well. Thank you for links.
 
Consequentialism utterly ignores issues such as human flourishing, society's self-respect, vitality, or sense of right, or the importance of virtue -- to name just a few -- when assessing if damage is caused or not. Anything that cannot be instantly translated into monetary or other sort of measurable damage doesn't matter.

So someone who opens a school to teach young women how to be successful prostitutes, so long as they also learn to protect themselves from drug abuse, say, is doing no more good -- or bad -- than someone who teaches young women to be Shakesprearian scholars or computer scientists. If anything, the prostitute is likely to be measurably doing better than the Shakespearian scholar, money-making wise, so the pimp should be more respected and honored than the professor.

This is not an increase in moral sophistication; it's a decrease, and in any case a dishonest one, since "can you give me evidence of damage?!" in mostly used as a rhetorical trick on the internet -- much like Ed Wood's (in)famous opening lines to Plan Nine from Outer Space, "These are the survivors' accounts... can you prove it didn't happen?!". Nobody ever allows their own daughter to become prostitutes based on the argument that, after all, no evidence of damage was presented to them.

Mill, famously, said that so long as soneone does not hurt or force other people to do anything, there is no moral objection to being a prostitute, or a pimp. This, replied James FitzJames Stephans in Liberty, Equality, Fraternity, is:



Truer words were never spoken. In all these long pseudo-sophisticated discussion of the "can you prove prostitution / pornography / polygamy / drug abuse / whatever vice one feels like promoting this week / is really bad?", the overall feeling is that it's a game, an ingenuity that "carries its own refutation on its face".

This board (and much of the free-thought movement) leans towards science, which is terrific. Both science and skepticism (defined as asking questions, not stating answers) offer very useful tools for discovering truths or testing a hypothesis. Unfortunately, what works for science is overly simplistic when it comes to philosophy. Pure reason is a game for psychopaths. Every complex problem has an easy solution if you distance it from emotion. Starving children? Let them die and there will be more food for the rest. It is simple, easy and morally abhorrent.

Our human emotions, our feelings aren't just the leftover remnants of a more superstitious age. They are the tools that help us sift through problems too complex to be fully understood and help us find answers. Empathy is often a greater tool for good than reason. We can easily explain the reasons behind letting a child die, empathy tells us to find the solution we would want for our child.

There are precious few virtues in prostitution. It goes against everything we want for our child. But if they were in it, we would want them to be safe, to have recourse against harm and to have as much respect as possible. Like most parents I would try to do everything to prevent it but if my child became a prostitute, she would still be allowed in my house, I would still love her and treat her with dignity. I would want the world to do the same.
 
Because it is an inherently degrading transaction that is mainly entertained by desperate women looking for a quick fix for their pimps.

You're bringing bias to the argument. I'm assuming most prostitutes in safe regulated countries have no pimps.

Can't think of a good reason for prostitution being illegal, so long as there is a professional body keeping prostitutes safe, like any other trade union / regulatory body.

My point exactly.
 
Prostitution is illegal in plenty of countries, as evident by this map:

[qimg]http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/b/be/Prostitution_in_Europe.png/400px-Prostitution_in_Europe.png[/qimg]
(In the red ones, it's illegal, in the exchange of sex for money is legal but brothels are illegal, and in the green ones prostitution is legal and regulated.)

What is the rationale from prohibitting prostitution? Judging from the case in Sweden, the politicians seem to view it as icky. They dislike the idea, and therefore don't want it to exist. To me it simply doesn't make sense. Even though I think the current approach to drugs is misguided, I can at least understand the rationale behind it, as drugs cause harm. But sex doesn't.

If you happen to understand Swedish, you can watch this discussion between a comedian and a Green politician discussing the issue. The latter illustrates just how squeamish the prohibitionists are.


Once the "disease spreadding" issue has been taken care of, I have no problem with prostitution as a normal means of income.
 
I don't disagree with the fact that it puts a person at risk, but if you base your morality on who is the victim -- as opposed to what is right or wrong -- it is problematic.
What 'is right' is just what you want to happen, so this is just a circular argument. If you don't have any argument for why it is right, you're just saying that you want what you want, which is completely useless.

One obvious problem is that, once prostitution isn't wrong, but simply dangerous, there is only a technical difference -- what makes more prostitutes feel safer or better -- between deciding to end their victimhood by making sure there is no prostitution, and deciding to end their victimhood by making sure prostitution is more safe, more respected, more acceptable, etc.
More safe, more respected, absolutely. Making sure there is no prostitution is just a pipe dream. It's like preaching abstinence only to counter STDs or unwanted pregnancy. It does not work and it risks making the problem worse.

I believe we should do two things: reduce the prevalence of prostitution, and make sure it is safer and less stigmatizing for those who still sell sex. We can reduce the prevalence by changing people's attitudes, and by helping women who want to get out of prostitution (by most studies I've seen this would be upward of 90%).

Prostitution thus becomes just another high-risk job, like (say) coal mining or being a social worker to violent kids, only significantly higher paying.
Not necessarily significantly higher pay. I've had offers from good-looking women in their mid 20's for about 1/3 of what a miner makes in a day. I suppose they would technically have time to go with more than 3 men per day but even assuming she's some kind of sex machine, that doesn't really sound like easy 'work' to me..

Now I suppose the average rates would be higher but I don't think most are that well paid really unless you compare with really low wage jobs. Just because you can see a lot of girls putting out ads for a high price doesn't mean they get a lot of customers at that price.

Anyway, I believe that being a prostitute is significantly more dangerous than being a coal miner. Also, while we can do some things to make it a bit safer, I'm not convinced we can ever make it even nearly safe. Mining accidents are very common in China where they don't care much, they are fairly frequent in the US where worker's protection exists but is fairly weak. In Sweden mining accidents claimed about 15 lives per year in the 60's, nowadays it's about 0.5 per year and I think the extent of mining is about the same.
 
Merko, do you feel that prostitution, as a job, is in and of itself degrading? No matter the society and its mores wherein it is found?
 
Yes, we should ban it, on the same grounds that we ban duelling. If you think prostitution is anything like that, then we obviously live in different universes.
I'd rather see my theoretical daughter play Russian roulette once for a million dollars, than make her living as a prostitute for five years. Selling herself once.. not a big problem. Ten times? Probably fine. But that doesn't really pay a lot of bills. Nor does it satisfy a lot of the demand, especially if we're supposed to make prostitution more acceptable. I think prostitution advocates are not really living in the real world, no. Just do the maths. If you're going to have a significant percentage of men satisfy their sex drive even partially through prostitution, then either a significant percentage of women will have to sell sex, which is just not going to happen, or those who do need to sell sex a lot. The latter is what is happening. And that is why it is so dangerous, physically and psychologically.

Care to share some of that evidence?
No, you wouldn't care anyway. You're still dodging my other questions regarding what evidence you would accept, so I'm not going to waste any time digging up stuff that you're not interested in anyway.

Also, how can you be "tricked" into the porn industry?
One thing that used to be common not all that long ago was claiming that the pictures or videos would only be sold in Japan, not here. Strangely enough people fell for that. But anyway 'tricked' was perhaps not the best word, 'seduced' might be better. Ever been with a woman who regretted it the morning after? It's like that, except these images never go away so they have to live with that mistake for life. To me, that seems very unnecessary.

I think that you view prostitution as a problem in itself, whereas I do not. That's the impression I get.
I think you're just blind to the massive documentation about women who are seriously hurt by prostitution. Read the Georgina Beyers quote above, for instance. I find that quite moving. Or any of the plenty of reports you find from women's shelters etc. It is true that some people who work with such cases get a skewed image of prostitution and assume that all prostitutes are like the ones they end up helping. That is not the case. But you just seem to conveniently ignore that these problems exist, or you just assume that it's nothing to do with prostitution even though it quite obviously is.

As for Romanians, do you have any evidence that they in the footballer case were trafficked sex slaves? I have only a passing memory, but it tells me that they were not. I could be wrong though.
Well, the prostitution-romantics in the blogosphere of course immediately assumed that these were just some naturally horny girls who loved to do this and no one should trample on their rights. Like I already said, two people were convicted for pimping, and if you read the verdict, a lot of red lights should go off regarding trafficking.

Do you have any evidence for this, or is it prejudice again? Anyways, the problem is then their self-harm, not prostitution in itself.
So your attitude is that because these women already have self-injury behaviour, great, then we can use their bodies because that's what they 'want'?

No, that's probably not what you think that you believe. But really, what do you believe? It's not our problem and we should look the other way while other people use these girls? Because of some 'holy principle' that we should never interfere if at least 1 person sells sex and is happy about it?

Yes, this is a very common problem and it's not hard to find documentation if you're really interested, which I doubt.

I don't agree with your reasoning that if it's harmful to X% of the population, then it should be completely banned.
You agreed previously that we should ban Russian roulette. That is only harmful for 16.7% of contestants, for the others it is completely safe.

Would you ban alcohol on the account on that 10% of our population are alcoholics?
No, that is unrealistic. But I support pragmatic regulation to achieve harm reduction without causing significant problems for responsible drinkers. Such as the Swedish alcohol monopoly which has good effects, and high taxes which demonstrably lowers alcohol consumption.

Or what about peanuts, that can be very dangerous to some people? Should we ban peanuts?
I believe that it is quite possible to keep peanuts away from people with serious allergy. If hundreds of people per year died from peanut traces floating through the air, then yes, I'd definitely consider banning peanuts. You're dealing in absolutes and principles, I'm looking at realities.
 
Merko, do you feel that prostitution, as a job, is in and of itself degrading? No matter the society and its mores wherein it is found?
I don't like that formulation. I find it likely that it is causes serious psychological damage, probably in and of itself, for a significant proportion of prostitutes, especially long-term. I also think the risk for STDs, even when using the best available protection, is very significant for a long-term prostitute. I also think that we have to see the effects of prostitution today for what they are today, not for what they possibly could be in some ideal society where no one looks down on prostitutes.

I believe that because prostitution is dangerous today, buying sex should not be considered acceptable today. If at some point in the future it turns out that we have made prostitution adequately safe and it's perfectly normal to put prostitution on your CV, then fine, we can change our attitudes then. But that doesn't matter now.

I also think that it is very important to focus the debate on typical prostitution, that is, what does it look like most of the time when someone buys sex? It's not so interesting with these girls or boys who have sold sex perhaps 5 times when they were students. This type of prostitution may not very often cause extremely serious problems, but it also doesn't supply the market for prostitution to any significant extent.
 
Truer words were never spoken.
I'm not sure I've ever seen a worse 'argument'. Actually there is none. He just repeats how much he disagrees. No one will ever be convinced by such an 'argument'.
 
:confused:

Earning fantastic money for a few hours work a week making clients feel happy, at least for a while.

;)

I do understand that aspect of it. Back when I was a massage therapist, one of my co-workers was perfectly comfortable and even a bit proud of her"happy endings." She was one of those ditzy hippy types who loved the world and wanted people to be happy. Masturbating a man to orgasm after a relaxing massage fit into her world-view.

Until one of her clients decided to forgo the massage portion, grabbed her hand, placed it on his penis and told her he was in a hurry. She complied and spent the rest of the day in the bathroom crying. (I regret to say that I was not immediately sympathetic. Her reputation had caused problems for the rest of us.)

When sex is transactional, the ability to negotiate boundaries is weakened. A sex-worker can set boundaries but she has no way of enforcing them, aside from refusing to participate. If she relies on sex work to pay her bills, that may not be a possibility. If she is over-powered that may not be a possibility. When someone crosses our boundaries and gets away with it, we are impacted.
 
I'll ask again, Skeptic. Do you get your sense of right and wrong from religion? It's relevant because my critique to your post may change.

Consequentialism utterly ignores issues such as human flourishing, society's self-respect, vitality, or sense of right, or the importance of virtue -- to name just a few -- when assessing if damage is caused or not.

Those "issues" are too vague to discuss. All of those things could mean almost anything to anyone in any time period.

Anything that cannot be instantly translated into monetary or other sort of measurable damage doesn't matter.

That is absolutely false and borderline insulting. It isn't that I don't feel or appreciate the "virtuous" joys of life. I am capable of feeling just as much outrage or love as you. The difference between me and you is that I try my best prioritize those feelings in a less arbitrary way.

Human brains have uncontrollable feelings of discomfort and disgust to different kinds of stimuli. Reactions fall on a spectrum with "pure nature" at one end and "pure nuture" on the other. Purely biological responses like pain, hunger, and sleepiness are common to all humans and are unavoidable. Purely sociological reactions include specific tastes in art and the sports. Sociological reactions vary widely from culture to culture and nearly as widely from person to person within each culture. The middle of the spectrum could be debated at length but as a guideline, but I'll just refer you to Maslow's heirarchy of needs. Biological reactions tend to stem from needs at the base of the pyramid while sociological reactions derive from the top.


I think it is trivial to conclude biological reactions should get priority over learned reactions for a number of reasons:
  • Biological needs are a prerequisite of all needs; art requires life but life doesn't require art.
  • Biological reactions are universal and immutable; I can't learn to enjoy starvation but I can learn to appreciate jazz.
  • The satisfaction of biological needs leads to highly predictable and quantifiable outcomes; a society failing to breathe will reach a "cultural low point" in roughly 10 minutes but a society failing to admire Robert Duvall's great acting talent will...uh...something...at some point in the future.
If I were to make a complete list of my priorities, I would call it my morality. Murder is wrong because the freedom to murder is less important than keeping my internal organs internal. Teaching creationism in school is wrong because the need to have a proper education is more important than your desire to spread an inaccurate doctrine. Prositution should not be illegal because personal autonomy, safe working conditions, and disease control are more important than your desire to impose your subjective, ethnocentric, uncritical, arbitrary definition of "sophistication" on an entire country.

(Obviously, the above is only a simplified explanation of my morality.)

So someone who opens a school to teach young women how to be successful prostitutes, so long as they also learn to protect themselves from drug abuse, say, is doing no more good -- or bad -- than someone who teaches young women to be Shakesprearian scholars or computer scientists. If anything, the prostitute is likely to be measurably doing better than the Shakespearian scholar, money-making wise, so the pimp should be more respected and honored than the professor.

I you are confusing consequentialism in the law with consequentialism in value judgments. Fred Phelps is a putrid human being and his message is disgusting. Even still, he should get the full protection of the 1st Amendment because a consistant application of civil rights is more important than briefly silencing a handfull of idiots.

No one is asking you to like prostitution. I'm asking you to set aside your personal subjective taste in a favor of a legal standard that reduces human suffering. Getting you to change how you feel about prostitution is something else entirely.

This is not an increase in moral sophistication; it's a decrease, and in any case a dishonest one, since "can you give me evidence of damage?!" in mostly used as a rhetorical trick on the internet -- much like Ed Wood's (in)famous opening lines to Plan Nine from Outer Space, "These are the survivors' accounts... can you prove it didn't happen?!". Nobody ever allows their own daughter to become prostitutes based on the argument that, after all, no evidence of damage was presented to them.

It's not a trick and apparently I'm a potential "nobody". I'd ask you to think differently but I don't know how I could possibly convince you.

Mill, famously, said that so long as soneone does not hurt or force other people to do anything, there is no moral objection to being a prostitute, or a pimp. This, replied James FitzJames Stephans in Liberty, Equality, Fraternity, is:



Truer words were never spoken. In all these long pseudo-sophisticated discussion of the "can you prove prostitution / pornography / polygamy / drug abuse / whatever vice one feels like promoting this week / is really bad?", the overall feeling is that it's a game, an ingenuity that "carries its own refutation on its face".

To summarize: "I dislike X because *insert vague feeling here*. I intend to impose my dislike of X on the law."
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom