Is there any good reason for prostitution being illegal?

I'm just going to note that, like almost every thread on this topic, somehow we've decided that only women are sex workers. Is this an emotional ploy along with the talk of daughters? Or are we accepting that it is okay for men to be sex workers :p ?
 
I'm just going to note that, like almost every thread on this topic, somehow we've decided that only women are sex workers. Is this an emotional ploy along with the talk of daughters? Or are we accepting that it is okay for men to be sex workers :p ?

Ew. That's disgusting. It should be illegal.

QED
 
I'm just going to note that, like almost every thread on this topic, somehow we've decided that only women are sex workers. Is this an emotional ploy along with the talk of daughters? Or are we accepting that it is okay for men to be sex workers :p ?

Good call. I'll be more careful in the future.

There are a greater number of female sex-workers but both male and transgendered are represented. Each of these groups has general similarities and each has unique issues. There are a greater percentage of transgendered sex-workers who turn to prostitution because of discrimination in the workforce, for example.

There are also greyer areas, like teens who are survival prostitutes, (including boys who are gay for pay) because they are runaways, drug addicts or both. Issues of protection, health and safety are the same but their situation is closer to victims of trafficking.

If you focus on reducing harm for the major group (adult women who primarily support themselves through sex-work) the results will be applicable to all. If we are speaking in broad generalities perhaps "she" can be used the way that "he" or "men" is often used to generally denote humans? Although the ramifications of that are depressing in the extreme.
 
I'm just going to note that, like almost every thread on this topic, somehow we've decided that only women are sex workers. Is this an emotional ploy along with the talk of daughters? Or are we accepting that it is okay for men to be sex workers :p ?

I once read an article in a Swedish newspaper where it said that there was double the amount of male youth (I'm uncertain what ages they exactly meant but i assume they meant teenagers or something) prostitutes than girl ones in Sweden. That just seemed counterintuitive to me considering that women aren't exactly known for going to prostitutes and there aren't that many homo/bisexuals.

Since they didn't cite any source i couldn't investigate any further to see if there was some common reason why there were more. Anyone have a clue?
 
I heard of one 1800-something study of prostitutes in London coming up with 1/3 boys.
Maybe the homosexual numbers are not correctly reported?
It would match some half-remembered arab saying about a goat for daily use and a boy for festive occasions.
 
Since they didn't cite any source i couldn't investigate any further to see if there was some common reason why there were more. Anyone have a clue?
This recently made the news. Authorities asked institutionalized boys and girls whether they had sold sex. 38 out of 567 said yes. This was 12% of girls and 4% of boys.

I very, very strongly doubt that more men than women sell sex. However, I don't think young men selling sex to older men is rare. I've had several offers myself on dating sites even though it has been quite clear that I'm straight, suggesting there is quite a market.

I've never been able to find more than anecdotal evidence for men selling sex to women, and in those cases it seems more like selling 'company' or 'fake relationships', which may or may not include sex. It should be noted that such relationships, even if they included sex, would not fall under the Swedish prostitution law. Basically, a 'sugar daddy' (or 'sugar mommy') can not be prosecuted because the law only covers straight transactional sex involving immediate payment. Well, there is this story about female sex tourism to somewhere in West Africa, can't remember where, but I haven't investigated whether it's true or just some urban legend / tabloid fake.
 
One reason I could think of for relatively more male sex sellers compared to the rate of homosexuality, is that because homosexuality itself has been taboo and to some extent still is, and because of the relatively low number of homosexuals, it's simply harder for homosexuals to hook up with each other.

The rate of homosexual single males compared to heterosexuals should be a good test for this theory.
 
One reason I could think of for relatively more male sex sellers compared to the rate of homosexuality, is that because homosexuality itself has been taboo and to some extent still is, and because of the relatively low number of homosexuals, it's simply harder for homosexuals to hook up with each other.

The rate of homosexual single males compared to heterosexuals should be a good test for this theory.

Also in the US, LGBT youth are at greater risk for homelessness, either because they are throw out or they are escaping abuse. In Los Angeles, it's estimated that 25% of homeless teens are LGBT. My own work in homeless shelters would lead me to believe it is higher.

The statistic for homeless teens who turn to survival prostitution varies. The Children of the Night foundation has said 50% (although they may have updated that), other studies show it is around 33%.

When it comes to people aged 11 -17 who are prostituting themselves or being exploited, there may be less difference between male/female.
 
I very, very strongly doubt that more men than women sell sex.

As do i, but that was what the article claimed. However, I don't think that Aftonbladet places journalistic integrity higher than sensationalism. I couldn't find the article though, so i might be mistaking myself but i recall that it said something like that.

One reason I could think of for relatively more male sex sellers compared to the rate of homosexuality, is that because homosexuality itself has been taboo and to some extent still is, and because of the relatively low number of homosexuals, it's simply harder for homosexuals to hook up with each other.

Not really hard to find someone for casual sex but if you're looking for a serious relationship then it's going to get harder, and i doubt you go to a prostitute for that.

Also, many people who claim to be 'straight' apparently stop being 'straight' for a while when they come across a really cute and pretty boy so that might skew the results a bit.

I always smile whenever i see someone posts "I'm straight but this is pretty hot" online...
 
I think you're just blind to the massive documentation about women who are seriously hurt by prostitution. Read the Georgina Beyers quote above, for instance. I find that quite moving. Or any of the plenty of reports you find from women's shelters etc. It is true that some people who work with such cases get a skewed image of prostitution and assume that all prostitutes are like the ones they end up helping. That is not the case. But you just seem to conveniently ignore that these problems exist, or you just assume that it's nothing to do with prostitution even though it quite obviously is.

...you miss the point of Georgina Beyers speech.

In the eyes of the law prior to the law reform act, prostitutes were not seen on an equal footing. It was perfectly legal for me to go up to a woman and offer money in exchange for sex. It was illegal for a woman (or man) to sell their services for sex.

Georgina's message wasn't "things are horrible, please pity us." It was "Things are horrible, let us take control of our own destiny."

Last year a policeman was jailed for coercing a prostitute to have sex with him. This would have been unthinkable under the old laws and under the old way of thinking: in the "bad old days" it would be unlikely that a complaint would even have been laid with police, and doubtful it would have been taken seriously.

I believe that because prostitution is dangerous today, buying sex should not be considered acceptable today. If at some point in the future it turns out that we have made prostitution adequately safe and it's perfectly normal to put prostitution on your CV, then fine, we can change our attitudes then. But that doesn't matter now.

What a bizarre way to think! How on earth do you think change happens? Do you think that by doing nothing, magically one day prostitution will suddenly become a safe occupation?

Prostitution is a much safer job in NZ now because the people decided to make changes in law to make the job safer. If you keep living in the "today" then you will get the same results as yesterday. I think that you need to stop feeling sorry for people who engage in prostitution and stop treating them like victims or second class citizens, and start listening to them. Because unless you start to make changes now, it won't get any safer in the future.
 
There are precious few virtues in prostitution. It goes against everything we want for our child. But if they were in it, we would want them to be safe, to have recourse against harm and to have as much respect as possible.

The problem is that, while I wholly agree with this sympathy, to undestand and have compassion here usually is to excuse and accept. Sure, we should try to get our children out of prostitution and drug use. But for the state to legitimize it -- to have social workers distribute condoms to 12-year-old prostitutes -- is wholly misplaced. It is precisely the "bandying compliments with pimps" Stephans is talking about.

You yourself see on this very board what the next step is: the very fact that prostitution is made safer by "compassionate" laws is then used to "prove" that now there is "really" nothing wrong with it: that what is "really" wrong with prostitution is not that it is having sex with dozens of strangers a day for money, but that it is "unsafe", that "society is biased against it", etc., etc.

On this Stephans correctly says, "... a kind of ingenuity which carries its own refutation on its face. How can the State or the public be competent to determine any question whatever if it is not competent to decide that gross vice is a bad thing?"
 
Last edited:
The problem is that, while I wholly agree with this sympathy, to undestand and have compassion here usually is to excuse and accept. Sure, we should try to get our children out of prostitution and drug use. But for the state to legitimize it -- to have social workers distribute condoms to 12-year-old prostitutes -- is wholly misplaced. It is precisely the "bandying compliments with pimps" Stephans is talking about.

You yourself see on this very board what the next step is: the very fact that prostitution is made safer by "compassionate" laws is then used to "prove" that now there is "really" nothing wrong with it: that what is "really" wrong with prostitution is not that it is having sex with dozens of strangers a day for money, but that it is "unsafe", that "society is biased against it", etc., etc.

On this Stephans correctly says, "... a kind of ingenuity which carries its own refutation on its face. How can the State or the public be competent to determine any question whatever if it is not competent to decide that gross vice is a bad thing?"

You know, people have questioned these assertions here...
 
<snip>

When sex is transactional, the ability to negotiate boundaries is weakened. A sex-worker can set boundaries but she has no way of enforcing them, aside from refusing to participate. If she relies on sex work to pay her bills, that may not be a possibility. If she is over-powered that may not be a possibility. When someone crosses our boundaries and gets away with it, we are impacted.

<snip>

Why is that specific to prostitution? Everyone who is being paid for their services faces a similar dilemma when asked to do things they don't want to do. I agree the potential for harm with prostitution is often greater than other occupations (e.g., rape or other violent assault), but that to me is a case for making prostitution safer, not driving it further underground.

I think the idea of turning men such as myself into criminals for having sex with an independent escort advertising her services does not make the world a better place. If anything it dissuades people such as myself and so encourages prostitutes to have sex with people they otherwise would not to compensate for their reduced income.
 
You know, people have questioned these assertions here...

Yes, but that condoms are thus distributed I have given evidence for, and as for the professed "skepticism" whether having sex with dozens of strangers for money is "really" bad, my reply is precisely Stephans': "There is a kind of ingenuity which carries its own refutation on its face."
 
Yes, but that condoms are thus distributed I have given evidence for, and as for the professed "skepticism" whether having sex with dozens of strangers for money is "really" bad, my reply is precisely Stephans': "There is a kind of ingenuity which carries its own refutation on its face."

Many prostitutes have regular clients. Many of their clients are otherwise normal people who are greatful for the service prostitutes provide. Many of those clients are those with barriers to forming conventional sexual relationships with other people for a variety of reasons.

What should those people in society who are mostly prevented from forming conventional sexual relationships do to meet their desire for physical intimacy? Would it be better if such people were made to beg for sympathy sex?
 
The problem is that, while I wholly agree with this sympathy, to undestand and have compassion here usually is to excuse and accept. Sure, we should try to get our children out of prostitution and drug use. But for the state to legitimize it -- to have social workers distribute condoms to 12-year-old prostitutes -- is wholly misplaced. It is precisely the "bandying compliments with pimps" Stephans is talking about.

You yourself see on this very board what the next step is: the very fact that prostitution is made safer by "compassionate" laws is then used to "prove" that now there is "really" nothing wrong with it: that what is "really" wrong with prostitution is not that it is having sex with dozens of strangers a day for money, but that it is "unsafe", that "society is biased against it", etc., etc.

On this Stephans correctly says, "... a kind of ingenuity which carries its own refutation on its face. How can the State or the public be competent to determine any question whatever if it is not competent to decide that gross vice is a bad thing?"

This is one of the reasons why I pointed out that survival prostitution by teens should be considered closer to trafficking. Personally, I think that teens who are engaged in survival prostitution should be treated like victims of trafficking, steps should be taken to get them out as soon as their situation is discovered, regardless of cost.

Passing out condoms will reduce the harm until this can happen but it is obviously a symptom of an underfunded and understaffed social services system.

Adults who are engaged in prostitution are a different group. The current situation in New Zealand shows that compassionate laws make a difference. This difference can be used to benefit society in general. Those engaged in legal, protected sex-work might be willing to work with police and social serviced to rescue exploited children. They are less likely to pass on sexually transmitted disease (although they still have some work to do in that area) and they can self-police for trafficking. They are less drain on the state and monies saved can be directed in helping them find different work if they chose or need to retire.

The Swedish model of punishing men for buying sex seems to be working (although it also seems to be most effective in years when there are less police enforcing it.) Street prostitution is down and the reports suggest that internet transactions have not completely made up the difference. But prostitution is not gone, and I fail to see how jailing someone for a year for having consensual sex with a willing adult is a general good. Even if a man goes to jail, the woman* is still a prostitute (sans one customer.) Neither has benefited from the law, but the state has in the form of income tax on the sex-worker. The results - less street prostitution and fewer sex workers - are good but the method is a moral quagmire.


*Although the wording is gender neutral, the laws in Sweden are based on the idea protecting women.
 
<snip>

The Swedish model of punishing men for buying sex seems to be working (although it also seems to be most effective in years when there are less police enforcing it.) Street prostitution is down and the reports suggest that internet transactions have not completely made up the difference.

Which begs the question what are the clients doing instead? It's rare for sticks to change people's long-term behaviour if people don't think they're going to get caught.

But prostitution is not gone, and I fail to see how jailing someone for a year for having consensual sex with a willing adult is a general good. Even if a man goes to jail, the woman* is still a prostitute (sans one customer.) Neither has benefited from the law, but the state has in the form of income tax on the sex-worker.

How much does it cost to keep a person in jail for a year? How much does it cost to fund people's social security payments after they are released from prison because they lost their jobs?

The results - less street prostitution and fewer sex workers - are good but the method is a moral quagmire.


*Although the wording is gender neutral, the laws in Sweden are based on the idea protecting women.

I view such results with a great deal of caution. I suspect clamping down on prostitution has or will push it further underground beyond the view of those doing the research.
 
Georgina's message wasn't "things are horrible, please pity us." It was "Things are horrible, let us take control of our own destiny."
And what do you think would move voters and legislators to support change, if it is not pity, compassion, empathy or whatever you want to call it?

You obviously have a very strange view of my attitudes to prostitutes. You seem to think I have no respect for them. Seriously, I'd have absolutely no doubts about marrying an ex-prostitute. If she survived that, she's might very well be the right kind of material for me.

But if we agree that 'things are horrible', how can it not be the logical conclusion that we should strive to reduce the prevalence of prostitution?

What a bizarre way to think! How on earth do you think change happens? Do you think that by doing nothing, magically one day prostitution will suddenly become a safe occupation?
How could you possibly get the idea that I want to do nothing? In fact I think the NZ example is very interesting and I believe we here in Sweden should look at that and see what is worth copying.

My whole point is that since today prostitution is to a significant extent just horrible, it is not ok today to put money into this industry. It's no excuse that "in 1000 years maybe it's fine". I doubt that, but it's anyway irrelevant today.
 
Which begs the question what are the clients doing instead? It's rare for sticks to change people's long-term behaviour if people don't think they're going to get caught.



How much does it cost to keep a person in jail for a year? How much does it cost to fund people's social security payments after they are released from prison because they lost their jobs?



I view such results with a great deal of caution. I suspect clamping down on prostitution has or will push it further underground beyond the view of those doing the research.

According to the wiki article (with apologies for shallow research) men have not being going outside the country for sex and the number of sex-workers using the internet to find business is less than the number of sex-workers in the country when the laws were enacted.

However, even proponents of this law admit that their research is hindered by the law and that it is nearly impossible to get a completely accurate picture. For example, their statistics on men leaving the country to purchase sex are from a series of interviews. If it is illegal to purchase sex, it seems doubtful that men would volunteer that information.

All of this proves that sex-work has been driven farther underground. Although they say that less demand has reduced profits for would-be traffickers, they have made it more to discover whether that is actually true. They have also made it more difficult to judge the health and well-being of sex-workers and to enforce safe sex practices. They are jailing people without being able to prove that it works.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom