Is there any good reason for prostitution being illegal?

The Swedish model of punishing men for buying sex seems to be working (although it also seems to be most effective in years when there are less police enforcing it.) Street prostitution is down and the reports suggest that internet transactions have not completely made up the difference. But prostitution is not gone, and I fail to see how jailing someone for a year for having consensual sex with a willing adult is a general good.
The way I see it, it's mostly about changing people's attitudes. No one needs to pay for sex. If it's generally considered acceptable, like in Denmark, you'll have lots of prostitution, like in Denmark. If it's generally considered un-manly and creepy to pay for sex, fewer people will pay for sex.

Of course that should not be the only focus and I think I've made it clear many many times in this thread that I believe Sweden should do much more to support prostitutes, including by using the prostitution ban in a smart way that supports prostitutes rather than making life even more difficult for them.

There is plenty of evidence that laws can help changing people's attitudes. It's not automatic, it certainly requires much more than just the law. A good previous example is the ban on corporal punishment for children in 1979. Nowadays, using corporal punishment on a child is completely unaccepted in the Swedish society, and that's just 32 years ago. An example where it doesn't work would be software piracy, where harsher laws have just undermined public respect for the law in general. The ban on paying for sex seems to have a high and increasing support though.
 
.....But if we agree that 'things are horrible', how can it not be the logical conclusion that we should strive to reduce the prevalence of prostitution?...

The problem is that bans have been tried all through history without much success. I find it more sensible to accept that there will be prostitution and come up with the best way to mitigate the damages it can cause.

A legalisation with "seamstress guild" or such looks like the best way to me.

Do you know that most of the illegal and mistreated polish tradesmen have been helped by the Danish tradesmen unions?
(The carpenters and masons mentioned uptread, and in the nomination tread*.)
*Not that I am currying votes at all. :D
 
Last edited:
However, even proponents of this law admit that their research is hindered by the law and that it is nearly impossible to get a completely accurate picture. For example, their statistics on men leaving the country to purchase sex are from a series of interviews. If it is illegal to purchase sex, it seems doubtful that men would volunteer that information.
It is not illegal for Swedish people to purchase sex abroad. And it's impossible to get a completely (or even nearly) accurate picture anywhere. The main problem here is not that sex buyers are trying to be secret (which they always did) but that sex sellers are trying to be secret, which they also always did, and that has nothing with the law to do, it's because for the vast majority of sex sellers, it's not something they want anybody to know, except their clients. This is the reason why most studies have always (nothing to do with the newish law) focused on prostitutes in the street, because these are easier to find and they tend to care less about their privacy. So the criticism has always been that this gives too much weight to prostitutes that are seriously harmed, and too little on 'luxury escort girls' or whatever. And there's certainly some grain of truth in that.

All of this proves that sex-work has been driven farther underground. Although they say that less demand has reduced profits for would-be traffickers, they have made it more to discover whether that is actually true. They have also made it more difficult to judge the health and well-being of sex-workers and to enforce safe sex practices. They are jailing people without being able to prove that it works.
I have seen no evidence that sex-work has been driven farther underground. Moreover, I believe it is easier both to find and to punish traffickers, for two reasons. First, since the typical cover for a trafficker's brothel is a legal brothel, it's harder to hide if no legal brothels exist. Second, it's very hard to prove trafficking, but when it's always illegal to buy sex, it's easier to bust them because that's much easier to prove, especially if the prostitutes are cooperating.

I don't much believe in the talk about 'deep underground' trafficking prostitution. It's in the nature of prostitution that they need to find customers, and therefore they can't be completely secret. If customers can find them, then so can the police. Because overall tolerance of trafficking is very low, it's not going to spread far by word of mouth before someone calls the cops. What is of course harder to expose is independent prostitutes who have only a few clients. But that's also much less serious so I don't see the big problem here.

All in all, I think banning payment for sex is a useful tool in the box, not nearly the single solution to all prostitution related problems.
 
The problem is that bans have been tried all through history without much success. I find it more sensible to accept that there will be prostitution and come up with the best way to mitigate the damages it can cause.
The problem I have with that argument is that it assumes it does not matter if there are 5000 or 20000 prostitutes in Sweden. But of course that matters very much, perhaps more than any mitigation of damages could ever hope to do.

A legalisation with "seamstress guild" or such looks like the best way to me.
They tried that in Germany but they have almost no members. I think the basic problem there is that since the vast majority of prostitutes want to stop selling sex, very few will organize themselves for the long term.

And, of course, there is nothing to stop Swedish prostitutes from organizing themselves, so it's a completely unrelated argument.
 
<snip>

No one needs to pay for sex.

<snip>

Experiencing physical intimacy is not a need as in food or water, but life is *a lot* less pleasant without it. Partners in a marriage don't need to be physically intimate, but if one person goes off sex it often ruins the marriage.

Perhaps you believe there is someone for everyone who they will one day bump into and that everyone should wait until that happens? Or maybe you think some people don't deserve to experience physical intimacy because they're just not trying hard enough?
 
Last edited:
The way I see it, it's mostly about changing people's attitudes. No one needs to pay for sex. If it's generally considered acceptable, like in Denmark, you'll have lots of prostitution, like in Denmark. If it's generally considered un-manly and creepy to pay for sex, fewer people will pay for sex.

Of course that should not be the only focus and I think I've made it clear many many times in this thread that I believe Sweden should do much more to support prostitutes, including by using the prostitution ban in a smart way that supports prostitutes rather than making life even more difficult for them.

There is plenty of evidence that laws can help changing people's attitudes. It's not automatic, it certainly requires much more than just the law. A good previous example is the ban on corporal punishment for children in 1979. Nowadays, using corporal punishment on a child is completely unaccepted in the Swedish society, and that's just 32 years ago. An example where it doesn't work would be software piracy, where harsher laws have just undermined public respect for the law in general. The ban on paying for sex seems to have a high and increasing support though.

The ban on paying for sex does get one thing right, it takes the criminality off the sex-worker. Until recently in California, the police would go after the prostitutes. A 14 year-old girl could be arrested for being a street-walker and her pimp could stroll casually into the police station to get her out and put her back on the street. A buyer having sex with that 14-year-old was charged with pandering, a misdemeanor instead of sex with a minor, a felony.

The laws have been slowly changing but they were all based on the idea that the sex-worker was the guiltiest party, no matter their age or situation. This made it nearly impossible to rescue exploited and trafficked children.

But turning all of the criminality onto the buyer is just a dramatic swing in the other direction. The best way to protect sex-workers is to allow them to work safely in the open. if either buyer or seller is forced to hide, there is no way to get an accurate idea of what is going on.
 
<snip>

All in all, I think banning payment for sex is a useful tool in the box, not nearly the single solution to all prostitution related problems.

For politicians who need to win votes around election time it's excellent.

Do you think a man such as myself losing his job and being put in prison for having consensual sex with an escort would make the world a better place?

Does that represent justice?

Or would he just be collateral damage in your and sex-negative feminists' crusade for the greater good?
 
Last edited:
The problem I have with that argument is that it assumes it does not matter if there are 5000 or 20000 prostitutes in Sweden. But of course that matters very much, perhaps more than any mitigation of damages could ever hope to do.
The legitimizations effect on numbers of prostitutes is not really documented.

They tried that in Germany but they have almost no members. I think the basic problem there is that since the vast majority of prostitutes want to stop selling sex, very few will organize themselves for the long term.

And, of course, there is nothing to stop Swedish prostitutes from organizing themselves, so it's a completely unrelated argument.
It could be that unions is not the solution.
 
Experiencing physical intimacy is not a need as in food or water, but life is *a lot* less pleasant without it. Partners in a marriage don't need to be physically intimate, but if one person goes of sex it often ruins the marriage.

Perhaps you believe there is someone for everyone who they will one day bump into and that everyone should wait until that happens? Or maybe you think some people don't deserve to experience physical intimacy because they're just not trying hard enough?

Focusing on the buyer is a bit backwards. The buyer does not face the same risks and the buyer has no way of knowing whether or not the sex-worker is being coerced. Outside of the Swedish model, the potential harm to the buyer is negligible.

Unless sex-work is legal, protected, and safe, there is great risk of harm to the sex worker. Defending prostitution in a country where sex-work is illegal and sex-workers are at risk for violence, trafficking, and arrest because the buyer's life would be less pleasant without it is a bit selfish.
 
<snip>

Defending prostitution in a country where sex-work is illegal and sex-workers are at risk for violence, trafficking, and arrest because the buyer's life would be less pleasant without it is a bit selfish.

:confused:

Are you claiming I have done that? If so, in what post or thread?
 
Or maybe you think some people don't deserve to experience physical intimacy because they're just not trying hard enough?
I don't think anyone deserves physical intimacy. It's something you should consider yourself lucky and thankful if you can get. In my opinion, if you start looking at noncommittal sex as some kind of human right, you're getting it so wrong I find it rather disturbing.
 
Btw: it should be noted that prison sentences are not the norm for buying sex in Sweden. Rather you get a fine, it's more than a parking ticket but by far the biggest punishment is the shame. Of course this can be much worse for people who are married or who are leading otherwise successful lives.
 
The best way to protect sex-workers is to allow them to work safely in the open. if either buyer or seller is forced to hide, there is no way to get an accurate idea of what is going on.
I think that's not realistic. In that case you would probably need to have some really odd law that made prostitution illegal unless it was public. Most people selling sex are very discreet about it. They don't want their family or friends to know. That has very little to do with legality.
 
I think that's not realistic. In that case you would probably need to have some really odd law that made prostitution illegal unless it was public. Most people selling sex are very discreet about it. They don't want their family or friends to know. That has very little to do with legality.

I'm not talking about posting notices in the paper or making anyone wear a scarlet SW. Just having an area set aside for completely legal and protected sex-work. Look at the legal brothels here in Nevada. The workers are completely safe, have a place to meet clients, have the option to refuse, can be tested, pay their taxes, etc. The situation is so conducive to positive sex-work that some of their girls appeared on TV and some of those were obviously proud of their work.

I've also been to parties held by various dungeons. The pros aren't ashamed or hiding, quite the opposite. They are proud of their ability to create a positive sexual experience. (And they have the best clothes!)

Positive and even meaningful sex work is possible and much, much easier when it is legal, accepted and protected.
 
:confused:

Are you claiming I have done that? If so, in what post or thread?

Quick, without google, name an association in the UK that is fighting for the rights of sex-workers.

I'm sure that you were very pleasant to the nice girl you paid for sex. You followed the rules and a lovely time was had by all. But what happens when she meets up with someone who isn't so nice. What options does she have? She can't go to the police and say "I was giving him the blowjob he paid for when he decided to force unprotected anal." Women who aren't prostitutes don't often have that option.

By paying for services in a country where sex-work is illegal, you supported the system that puts your very nice girl at risk. That is the cost of modern life. If I buy a pair of sneakers, I am at risk for supporting the exploitation of children in sweatshops. But it would be a bit selfish of me to justify that by saying that the sneakers are comfortable.
 
I'm not talking about posting notices in the paper or making anyone wear a scarlet SW. Just having an area set aside for completely legal and protected sex-work. Look at the legal brothels here in Nevada. The workers are completely safe, have a place to meet clients, have the option to refuse, can be tested, pay their taxes, etc. The situation is so conducive to positive sex-work that some of their girls appeared on TV and some of those were obviously proud of their work.
I don't doubt that for a moment, but I don't believe that is the typical situation at all. I've seen a number of studies all indicating upwards of 90% of prostitutes want to stop selling sex. So it's all good trying to help the remaining 10% or so but that can't really be the number one concern. Also I would guess that Nevada is rather special because afaik there are not many other places like that in North America, so presumably those prostitutes who have decided they are happy about a 'career' in that field are rather likely to move to Nevada. If all US states had similar laws, I really doubt you'd find such a concentration of 'happy' sex workers.
 
And what do you think would move voters and legislators to support change, if it is not pity, compassion, empathy or whatever you want to call it?

You obviously have a very strange view of my attitudes to prostitutes. You seem to think I have no respect for them. Seriously, I'd have absolutely no doubts about marrying an ex-prostitute. If she survived that, she's might very well be the right kind of material for me.

...see? No respect. Condescending. "If she survives." Just so you know, most prostitutes "survive." And here you are admitting you would only consider marrying an "ex-prostitute." And please excuse me for not using your willingness to marry someone as a barometer of your respect levels. Stop pretending you have respect for an industry that you couch in such contempt. Stop talking down to them.

But if we agree that 'things are horrible', how can it not be the logical conclusion that we should strive to reduce the prevalence of prostitution?
I don't believe we should try and reduce the prevalence of prostitution. Women and men should have the right to do what they want with their bodies within the law. The New Zealand legislation allows for that. They are safer. Things are much less horrible. In fact, I wouldn't consider it to be horrible now at all.

How could you possibly get the idea that I want to do nothing? In fact I think the NZ example is very interesting and I believe we here in Sweden should look at that and see what is worth copying.

I got the idea by quoting your words. "I believe that because prostitution is dangerous today, buying sex should not be considered acceptable today. If at some point in the future it turns out that we have made prostitution adequately safe and it's perfectly normal to put prostitution on your CV, then fine, we can change our attitudes then. But that doesn't matter now."

How do you think this magical future you talk about is going to happen? You oppose prostitution today because you claim it is dangerous, but are willing to support it if suddenly societies attitudes magically change.

Here's a clue: society won't change on its own. The people have to change. Your attitude has to change. And if it doesn't change today, it won't change tomorrow.

My whole point is that since today prostitution is to a significant extent just horrible, it is not ok today to put money into this industry. It's no excuse that "in 1000 years maybe it's fine". I doubt that, but it's anyway irrelevant today.

...yeah, lets throw our hands up in the ear and say its not going to happen. Its not "horrible" right now in NZ. Do we have your approval to put money into the industry down here?

You are arguing morality, and pretending to be arguing safety. It would be much better if you just came out and said that. The NZ experience shows that if you treat the industry and the participants with respect (both sides: the people who are selling and the people who are buying), remove the criminal element, remove the pimps, remove the incentive for illegal activity, then what you get is...meh. Its just just another job.
 
I don't doubt that for a moment, but I don't believe that is the typical situation at all. I've seen a number of studies all indicating upwards of 90% of prostitutes want to stop selling sex. So it's all good trying to help the remaining 10% or so but that can't really be the number one concern. Also I would guess that Nevada is rather special because afaik there are not many other places like that in North America, so presumably those prostitutes who have decided they are happy about a 'career' in that field are rather likely to move to Nevada. If all US states had similar laws, I really doubt you'd find such a concentration of 'happy' sex workers.

Right, but the goal should be primarily happy sex workers. Start from there and figure out how to make that happen in addition to addressing the ills of prostitution.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom