Is there any good reason for prostitution being illegal?

I don't know exactly but I think there is good evidence that prostitution itself is very dangerous. When it comes to the opinions in society, well, that's not an excuse for a sex buyer. The opinions are what they are. If you do something that makes people look down on a person, then you are responsible for that, even if the general attitudes are wrong. Like I compared earlier, outing a homosexual in Uganda is wrong, even though there is nothing wrong with homosexuality.


I believe that it is in fact a nuanced and pragmatic move. I'm willing to change my mind if someone can show that there would be forms of prostitution that are not typically harmful, but so far the evidence I have seen does not support that.


Yes, in the sense that I believe it should be a crime. But of course if the current law in your country says it is not a crime, then sex buyers in that country should not be 'treated' as criminals. I would still strongly disapprove of buying sex in those countries, however.

The obvious harm in prostitution - sexually transmitted disease, violence, murder, rape, trafficking - can all be reduced by legalization, if that legislation is set up to protect sex workers. In The Netherlands legalization primarily benefits brothel owners, landlords, johns and the state which receives taxes. The rate of violent crime and trafficking is growing. In New Zealand where the laws focus on protection and not profit, violence and trafficking have been reduced.

We can not immediately address the ills that lead to people to sex work - lack of opportunity or education, and an overly sexualized society that teaches young people (especially girls) that their body is of more value than their mind. Until we do, it seems a bit backwards to penalize the people who have been affected enough to make this choice.

Making sex work illegal is costly. Cops get paid to arrest people, couthouses to try them. In the UK, NHS picks up the tab for sexually transmitted diseases and the affects of violence. in the the US, the uninsured go to emergency rooms. That money would be better spent on programs to reduce trafficking, prevent STD's and find other options for those sex workers who are driven to it by necessity alone or those who will need other options. (Even under the best circumstances, sex work does not have a very good retirement plan and doesn't always look good on a resume.)

Illegal prostitution creates an environment for sex-trafficking to thrive because victims can't go to the police and it takes too long for police to discover new traffickers. Trafficking is slavery. If we could take all the police effort that goes to embarrassing some lonely guy or harassing a street walker and focus it on the pimps, traffickers and other scum, we would protect far more people.

There are no easy answers to this. Very few people would want their daughter to be a prostitute because the job carries inherent risk both physical and psychological. Pushing sex workers outside the bounds of society creates greater risk, makes no sense, is unhealthy and more expensive. It also creates opportunities for traffickers and it creates barriers to getting out. We can't make prostitution safe but we shouldn't support making it more dangerous.

ETA: Sorry, got a call from a dear old client* and the thread moved on without me.

*Who buys books. Sheesh.
 
Last edited:
My aunt has Parkinson's dementia. We've recently had to move her into a nursing home which specialises in care for elderly people with dementia and other mental illnesses.

If I had to choose between spending 2-3 days working there or sucking a guy's condom-covered cock until he climaxed, I'd be on my knees in a second.
I know of one woman on the board here who work in such a nursing home.
Different people have different attitudes/preference of work, we don't need that many who would prefer prostitute over other unskilled labour.
 
Over the last few years we have had several cases where polish people were brought into Denmark, worked for peanuts and lived under horrible conditions.

Somehow that have not lead to a ban of the professions carpenter and mason? :rolleyes:

Why should similar problems with prostitutes be easier to solve by banning the profession?
How about making it a honest trade instead?

Actually in way, yes. Trafficking takes all forms. Sex-trafficking gets most of the attention because it happens to hopeful, naive young girls and makes for good copy.

Inescapable indentured servitude is popular all over the world. Children are sold to factories, women sent to be unpaid maids, men tricked into brutal labor. it happens more frequently in the west then is suspected. Because the victims come from horrible conditions, people assume that they will be grateful to be treated like animals so long as they have a roof and some food so they look the other way. It's xenophobia for profit.
 
If the "well, it's not the career path I would want for my daugher, but..." attitude take hold, there are two possiblities:

1). It will not be the career path for middle-class daughters, who have other options, but will be the one for poor daughters, who have no other similarly-paying job; hence it will be another step in turning the poor into those who will remain forever more in the underclass of the ghetto in the name of "nonjudgmentalism".

2). Or else the middle-class daugher will consider prostitution to be perfectly legitimate, a better option than some of those boring and/or non-well-paying jobs. Because, you know, it's so judgmental and wrong to think any damage might be caused from sleeping with twenty strangers a day for years.

In which case I only hope that, in the interest of fairness, it would be the daughters of those who say "there is nothing wrong with it" who would be the first to choose this career path, you know, just in case they are wrong.
 
You know, I agree with everything you write. I want it to be illegal to buy sex, but not to sell sex. I do not believe this is everything we should do, or even necessarily the most important, but it does seem to have a positive effect.

But in this thread, I think what I'm arguing mostly is that prostitution appears to be dangerous and harmful, and this appears to be inherent to prostitution, and therefore we should strive to minimize prostitution. I oppose those who describe prostitution, usually for theoretical reasons, as something that is not a problem and which should not only be legal, but even socially acceptable.

For instance, we have seen in Sweden that acceptance of buying sex has decreased clearly, and surely we should expect that this also has an effect on how many people are actually buying sex, and thus on how many people are hurt by prostitution. So these attitudes matter a great deal in my opinion. But of course it is also important to fight prejudice against prostitutes and make people understand that they are not always stupid, uneducated, drug addicted, irresponsible or miserable victims. However there is a difference between fighting such prejudice and glorifying prostitution.
 
Because the victims come from horrible conditions, people assume that they will be grateful to be treated like animals so long as they have a roof and some food so they look the other way.
I'm not sure that is the most important explanation for how it is possible. We had a case recently in Sweden where two famous footballers were convicted for buying sex from some young Romanian girls. Some other Romanians were convicted for pimping. However, there were quite clear signs of trafficking, for instance the pimps had transfered large sums of money to a 'boyfriend' of one of the girls back in Romania. It wasn't enough for a trafficking sentence however, I don't know if that was due to a lack of evidence, or because there are requirements for 'trafficking' that go beyond what most people might assume, for example the same person has to travel with the victims over the border, if A sells B to C but only B crosses the border, they can basically get away only with pimping.

Now, maybe I'm naïve, but I don't think these guys would have gotten involved if they suspected trafficking. It seems more likely to me that they simply did not understand what was going on, and they had this rosy picture of horny girls who didn't much mind having sex with a couple of attractive footballers anyway.
 
<snip>

2). Or else the middle-class daugher will consider prostitution to be perfectly legitimate, a better option than some of those boring and/or non-well-paying jobs. Because, you know, it's so judgmental and wrong to think any damage might be caused from sleeping with twenty strangers a day for years.
In which case I only hope that, in the interest of fairness, it would be the daughters of those who say "there is nothing wrong with it" who would be the first to choose this career path, you know, just in case they are wrong.

As has already been pointed out, a middle of the road price for an escort is £100/hour. Some charge much more than this. 8 hours work a week brings in more money per month than I do as a professional electronics engineer working 37-40 hours a week.

Many women choose escort work because it gives them a good income and plenty of time to do other things, such as look after children or further their education.
 
So what was a man such as myself to do?

I'm not very attractive, I have a boring/repulsive personality and a speech impediment. I have very few friends none of which want to socialise with me and of the women I do know, none want a short or long term relationship with me. I tried online dating with numerous profiles for over 4 years with no success. I was a virgin until the age of 32 until I had sex with an independent escort who was advertising online. She was a nice person.

Was/Am I supposed to suppress all desires I have for physical intimacy for the rest of my life even though there are women who are willing to have sex with me for payment?


I've always thought it odd that so much of modern culture thinks that a man who has trouble getting a woman to have sex with him is a pathetic loser.

If anything makes a pathetic loser, it is being so desperate for sex that one will pay a stranger for it.
 
Note that, if selling sex is fine, there is no way to morally consider the man who buys sex to be morally wrong, either. (As opposed to being pathetic, which is not the same thing).

There is also something else. One of the main reasons people concentrate on the prostitute and not the John is that there are (a) far more Johns, which in contrast (b) spend much less time, individually, actually buying sex than the prostitue spends selling it. It's like drug enforcement concentrating on the sellers, the pushers, more than on the buyers.

If the situation were different -- if the average prostitute would only have sold sex once in a month or so (? I suppose? I have no idea how often the average John visits a prostitute) -- it would be something else, and people would care much less about it.
 
Last edited:
I wonder if trafficking would be easier to detect/prevent if all brothels were registrated companies with employment contracts, payslips, VAT, income tax, etc?
What do you think?

"nonjudgmentalism"
This sounds like a drooling hippie strawman.
 
If anything makes a pathetic loser, it is being so desperate for sex that one will pay a stranger for it.
I think that was a bit uncalled for. Ivor has not exactly tried to portray himself as a successful macho man. I think he is putting himself down too much, however I would agree with you that paying for sex is probably part of that problem. It sort of means you've given up, I'd say.
 
You know, I agree with everything you write. I want it to be illegal to buy sex, but not to sell sex. I do not believe this is everything we should do, or even necessarily the most important, but it does seem to have a positive effect.

<snip>

I'm sure for people looking to blackmail clients it's fantastic.
 
Note that, if selling sex is fine, there is no way to morally consider the man who buys sex to be morally wrong, either.
Apparently, about 75% of male Swedes and about 90% of female Swedes have found such a way.
 
Note that, if selling sex is fine, there is no way to morally consider the man who buys sex to be morally wrong, either. (As opposed to being pathetic, which is not the same thing).

Now you mention it, I have never had moral trouble about visiting brothels in ports around the world.
 
I'm sure for people looking to blackmail clients it's fantastic.
That was a worry I had before our law was instituted. But it does not seem to be a huge problem. Yes, there are definitely cases and there are people on the internet pretending to be prostitutes and then blackmailing the prospective 'client' when they have identified him. However, this usually seems to involve more serious offenses like posing as underage, so I'm not really convinced it's much to do with the newish law.

Also, I'm not too sure these crimes are a huge problem in the first place. Men with high reputations and a lot of money chasing underage girls.. I don't feel too sorry for them.
 
Apparently, about 75% of male Swedes and about 90% of female Swedes have found such a way.

I fail to see how. If it's OK to SELL X, how can it be wrong to BUY X? It's like saying that man marrying a woman is fine, but a woman marrying a man is wrong. Bizzare.
 
I fail to see how. If it's OK to SELL X, how can it be wrong to BUY X? It's like saying that man marrying a woman is fine, but a woman marrying a man is wrong. Bizzare.
You probably think that prostitution is wrong because you believe that it is a crime against society or God or something like that. I believe that it is a crime against the prostitute, similar to putting a person at risk.

In the same vein, I believe it should be illegal to sell drugs, but not to buy them for personal use. The drug addict is the ultimate victim of the drug dealer, he should not be punished.
 
I think that was a bit uncalled for. Ivor has not exactly tried to portray himself as a successful macho man. I think he is putting himself down too much, however I would agree with you that paying for sex is probably part of that problem. It sort of means you've given up, I'd say.

It means as a man with a moderately high sex drive I was frustrated at not having had sex with a woman, fed up with masturbating and my prospects of meeting a woman for a relationship in the foreseeable future for sex or something more significant were very low to nonexistent.

As I'm still single and not had sex without paying for it, it appears the latter assessment was correct.

Obviously I'd be in even a better position if I now had a criminal record as Merko would like men such as myself to have for 'harming' the woman I had consensual sex with. ETA: and funding the running costs of her luxury sports car and mortgage on a 5-bedroom detached house.
 
Last edited:
I've always thought it odd that so much of modern culture thinks that a man who has trouble getting a woman to have sex with him is a pathetic loser.

If anything makes a pathetic loser, it is being so desperate for sex that one will pay a stranger for it.

Well that's a fat lot of bullpucky right there. Everyone is desperate for sex. Sex is awesome and physical contact of any sort has well-researched benefit.

If the sex-worker is completely autonomous and there is no coercion of any sort, prostitution is a viable option for people who have a difficult time finding a partner. Of course, it would be lovely if we could all find perfect partner(s) and I wish that for everyone. In the meantime, there is nothing wrong with a mutually respectful relationship based on cash.

My biggest concern is that men who have a difficult time dating women can become biased or aggressive towards women in general and this could put a sex worker in danger. (The "forced loneliness" boards have some pretty scary stuff.) The attitude that finding solace is emasculating can also increase the danger to prostitutes. If paying for sex is emasculating, beating up a woman could be seen as empowering.
 
If you don't believe that money tempts prostitutes to prostitute themselves, then how about this. Let's agree to have a law that says it's legal to have sex with prostitutes, as long as you don't pay them any money.

Of course money 'tempts' people to prostitute themselves in the sense that they are willing to have sex for it whereas they (probably) wouldn't do it for free. It's about money (except apparently in some emotionally unstable youths who are apparently looking for attention or something).

However i find it unreasonable to say that it's invariably the customer (or john or whatever the hell you want to call it) that's tempting the the prostitute, when a prostitute can very well try and solicit someone to pay them for sex, as in the example with the escort who advertises on a public website or when an annoying **** tries to make you pay for sex when they contact you on a dating site.

If anything makes a pathetic loser, it is being so desperate for sex that one will pay a stranger for it.

Sometimes it's not about pure desperation but out of convenience. When you're rich or just have money to spare then doing it with a hooker or an escort just saves time and hassle. This is especially true if you have specific tastes in your partners and what you want to do with them.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom