bookitty
Philosopher
- Joined
- Jul 26, 2009
- Messages
- 5,732
I don't know exactly but I think there is good evidence that prostitution itself is very dangerous. When it comes to the opinions in society, well, that's not an excuse for a sex buyer. The opinions are what they are. If you do something that makes people look down on a person, then you are responsible for that, even if the general attitudes are wrong. Like I compared earlier, outing a homosexual in Uganda is wrong, even though there is nothing wrong with homosexuality.
I believe that it is in fact a nuanced and pragmatic move. I'm willing to change my mind if someone can show that there would be forms of prostitution that are not typically harmful, but so far the evidence I have seen does not support that.
Yes, in the sense that I believe it should be a crime. But of course if the current law in your country says it is not a crime, then sex buyers in that country should not be 'treated' as criminals. I would still strongly disapprove of buying sex in those countries, however.
The obvious harm in prostitution - sexually transmitted disease, violence, murder, rape, trafficking - can all be reduced by legalization, if that legislation is set up to protect sex workers. In The Netherlands legalization primarily benefits brothel owners, landlords, johns and the state which receives taxes. The rate of violent crime and trafficking is growing. In New Zealand where the laws focus on protection and not profit, violence and trafficking have been reduced.
We can not immediately address the ills that lead to people to sex work - lack of opportunity or education, and an overly sexualized society that teaches young people (especially girls) that their body is of more value than their mind. Until we do, it seems a bit backwards to penalize the people who have been affected enough to make this choice.
Making sex work illegal is costly. Cops get paid to arrest people, couthouses to try them. In the UK, NHS picks up the tab for sexually transmitted diseases and the affects of violence. in the the US, the uninsured go to emergency rooms. That money would be better spent on programs to reduce trafficking, prevent STD's and find other options for those sex workers who are driven to it by necessity alone or those who will need other options. (Even under the best circumstances, sex work does not have a very good retirement plan and doesn't always look good on a resume.)
Illegal prostitution creates an environment for sex-trafficking to thrive because victims can't go to the police and it takes too long for police to discover new traffickers. Trafficking is slavery. If we could take all the police effort that goes to embarrassing some lonely guy or harassing a street walker and focus it on the pimps, traffickers and other scum, we would protect far more people.
There are no easy answers to this. Very few people would want their daughter to be a prostitute because the job carries inherent risk both physical and psychological. Pushing sex workers outside the bounds of society creates greater risk, makes no sense, is unhealthy and more expensive. It also creates opportunities for traffickers and it creates barriers to getting out. We can't make prostitution safe but we shouldn't support making it more dangerous.
ETA: Sorry, got a call from a dear old client* and the thread moved on without me.
*Who buys books. Sheesh.
Last edited: