There's a serious flaw in this reasoning. Either it is easy cash, or it is not. If it is easy cash, why would someone do it 'sometimes' rather than as their main occupation? Conversely, if it is not seen as easy work, it is logical that people would do it 'sometimes'. More exactly: they would only do it when that was the only way to get the money.
And you know that how?
You don't seem to understand as much about markets as you think. First, sure, let's consider the milk market. As you may be aware, people in Sweden consume much more milk than in many other countries, such as Spain for example. Still, the milk price is actually slightly higher in Spain than it is in Sweden.
I don't know about Spain, but if that is true, then probably milk is scarce there relative to the demand.
The reason people consume more milk in Sweden is because of attitudes. Specifically, we drink milk, which Spaniards seldom do.
Yes. Attitudes translate into demand.
It's the same thing with prostitution. Demand depends on attitudes. Prices are not simply a function of total demand, it's much more complicated than that. Specifically, we should not expect prices for prostitution to be higher in Denmark compared to Sweden because demand is higher in Denmark. Feel free to find data and disprove my reasoning if you wish.
Demand depends on attitudes, but if prices are too high, then some people who would like to hire prostitutes would not do it, as they feel that the price is not worth it. Exactly how price-sensitive (
price elasticity) consumers are vary from product to product, and I have no idea about the prostitution market. But if prodtitution costed 1 000 000 per hour (an extreme example, just to illustrate) then fewer would buy than if it costed 1000 per hour. A lot of people who would buy for 1000 would not consider it worth it at 1 000 000.
However, my point was this. If our attitudes change, and it becomes socially accepted to buy sex, then many more men will do so. In fact, there is every reason to believe a very large percentage, perhaps the majority would do so at least during some part of their lives. Now simply consider the volume of sex acts that need to be produced. How is this going to happen? Mathematically, there are only two ways: either there are nearly as many people selling sex as there are people buying, or those who sell sex need to sell to a lot of people.
Again, unless the supply increases (that is, more women
or men start to sell (and women buy as well, despite you pretending that not to be the case)) to increase and meet that demand, the prices would go up to a point where many consumers would consider it not worth it, and so there would be fewer consumers, and the market would find an equilibrium.
Sure, one thing that could happen is that eventually prices go up and therefore the volume does not quite reach projected levels. It's possible. But as we can see from other countries where prostitution is more prevalent, it would not happen until the total prevalence has increased quite significantly.
True, what would most likely happen with such high prices you predict is that others see opportunities to make money and join the industry. Eventually, if supply grows without increase in demand, the price would go down.
So my argument is this: because we can be fairly sure that most women will not want to sell sex, even though there are certainly some women who want that, this means that either ideas of prostitution being a common and accepted practice is an unrealistic expectation, as I believe, or you would have to assume that those willing to sell sex would be willing to do take on an absolutely huge number of clients.
No, I would not have to assume that. Higher demand than supply means that prices go up until the market finds an equilibrium.
No, I'm assuming that prostitution cannot become really accepted and common, because there is no way to meet that demand without coercion, which we will never accept.
Read the above.
Absolute nonsense. I much prefer vice and I find 'virtue' or general ideas of what is 'proper' to be conservative baloney. There is simply no way you're going to find support for putting me into that category. I believe you are just trying to shoehorn me into that faction because you falsely assume that anyone who is opposed to prostitution must necessarily be some moralistic conservative at heart.
But you seem to want the authorities to "change attitudes". Swedish politicians often think that way, and that is why the opposition to needle-exchange programs for heorinists was so strong: The politicians considered it more important to not "send the wrong signals" than to reduce harm.
I don't think it is. I think you are rather engaging in wishful thinking: because you are generally opposed to government interference, you are predisposed to believe that prostitution is harmless, therefore you do not see the harm, even though the dispute among scholars is not if there is massive harm, but exactly how massive it is.
Who are these mystical "scholars" you refer to? Zaida Catalan? You have been shown an example of a Swedish prostitute who is not happy with the Swedish legislation, and defends her job. Care to show a Swedish prostitute who likes the Swedish legislation?
Please, read
this. I think you could benefit...
Of course I agree. But I proposed a concrete remedy. Because it is virtually impossible to know who will change their mind, yet we know this happens and causes serious grief, we need another solution. My suggestion was to have a 2 week period of remorse, so that pornographers could not release the material unless they got a signature 2 weeks after recording. This would give pornographers incentive first of all to only use models that they had good reason to believe would not change their mind. It would also give them incentive to not throw new models into extensive sessions, but rather to try out with something quick which does not represent so much wasted investment if the model has a change of heart.
I think my proposal is very pragmatic. I would also point out that it is based on market principles: we do not burden the government with the task of finding out who will change their mind or not, but we rather leave this to independent parties on the market. We simply skew the market to provide an incentive away from seduction and exploitation.
I doubt the problem is as prevalent as you seem to think, but sure, it could be considered.
I think it is relevant in part to explain my frustration with this debate. Proponents of prostitution seem to have an attitude of 'see no evil'. Perhaps I am mistaken and there is somewhere a reasonable proponent who does not immediately assume that every prostitute is happy and is acting completely voluntarily. But I have not found any.
Really?
I will of course readily grant that there are also many on the anti-prostitution side who will assume the reverse, that all prostitutes are miserable, helpless, and/or drug-addicted, and that no one ever comes out of the experience unharmed. But I think I have stressed very often in this thread that I do not believe this. If you are even trying to argue against what I say rather than what you expect me to say, you should not put me in that category.
Not necessarily you, but many in that category proceeds from "inherently degrading to women" and such metaphysical nonsense. Somehow it's less degrading to have sex for free.
It can't? Murder, STDs, suicide, drug overdose.. yes it certainly can. Or I could argue that Russian roulette can't kill you, it's the brain damage that does it!
Seriously! By that logic, working in a store can kill you too, as it can be robbed by violent robbers. Ban store-work!
Just because the causal links A->B->C are more intricate does not mean they are not there. Besides, death is not the only societal ill worth regulating against, most of our criminal laws do not deal with things that kill a lot of people.
But is it worse among sex workers than other workers? Isabella Lund didn't think so...
Because using alcohol is generally accepted, buying sex is not. Therefore, a ban on buying sex is realistic (as overwhelming public support proves), while banning alcohol is unrealistic, at least in Sweden. In some Muslim societies, there seems to be at least significant public support for very strict laws against alcohol. I don't know enough to say whether such laws are beneficial, but I won't dismiss the possibility.
Laws banning alcohol in at least Iran are harmful as there is a big black market, resulting in many thousand deaths every year (as you probably are aware, poorly brewed alcohol even in small volumes are lethal). I don't know how big it is in Saudi Arabia, though they execute a few people every year caught for it. I don't think it is really illegal in (many) other Muslim countries.
KTB said:
The christian fundies just don't like it that a woman can decide against gods wishes (or their "superior" morals and beliefs), as simple as that. Different rationalizations then follow.
But Merko isn't a Christian fundamentalist, he is a feminist. Though Swedish feminism is in many cases Calvinism in a new dress...