Is there any good reason for prostitution being illegal?

So Merko, who would the rapists be raping if they weren't raping prostitutes?

As Merko has pointed out, prostitution creates opportunities for an opportunistic crime. Women who are not prostitutes have a difficult time getting people to take them seriously when a consensual sexual act turns non-consensual, for sex workers it's even easier.

More disturbing is the implication that sex-workers are doing some sort of community service by "protecting" other people from sexual assault. Sex-workers don't have any special protection from the horror of rape. Non-consensual sex isn't less bad because one has a greater amount of consensual sex.
 
There is an underlying reasoning behind that question which is simply absurd. The rate of rape is not constant. Opportunity makes the thief, opportunity also makes the rapist. Calling on a prostitute to join him in a safe (for him) location is very easy. Luring or kidnapping some other person is much more dangerous and also requires advance planning. Rape of prostitutes does not have to be planned, it may for example be people who are mentally disturbed, who are using drugs, or who are just completely lacking empathy and who do not respect other people.

Firstly, far more women who are not prostitutes have been raped than women who are prostitutes. Secondly, rapists are generally repeat offenders. Finally, while I agree attacking prostitutes is somewhat easier, what would such men do if prostitutes weren't there? Would they become good citizens and start treating women with respect?
 
More disturbing is the implication that sex-workers are doing some sort of community service by "protecting" other people from sexual assault.
Yes, thank you for pointing this out, this is indeed the much more disturbing problem with that line of thought. It seems to assume that prostitutes are somehow not fully human, that they are there for us to use and abuse.
 
Firstly, far more women who are not prostitutes have been raped than women who are prostitutes. Secondly, rapists are generally repeat offenders. Finally, while I agree attacking prostitutes is somewhat easier, what would such men do if prostitutes weren't there? Would they become good citizens and start treating women with respect?
First, what does it matter?

Second, I believe that if they were not able to attack prostitutes so easily, they would simply rape much fewer people, prostitutes and others. I see every 'successful' rape as the nurturing of a monster. A repeat offender has to start somewhere.

For the obviously disturbed type of rapist, it is often difficult to enter into normal relations, so prostitutes are likely first victims. Moreover, prostitutes often serve as an opportunity to act out sexual fantasies that men cannot satisfy within their normal relationship. I would expect this to be true also for the socially capable rapist, who may also have normal relationships, but who may start to abuse prostitutes because of the lower social risks involved.
 
Yes, and I also suspect it will cause physical damage, from assaults and/or STDs. I do not believe these damages always occur to every prostitute. I simply believe that it happens often enough to be wholly unacceptable.

I would add that I can see things from the perspective of the prostitute who is not at all suffering. I can understand that it must be frustrating that I want a law which is intended to reduce the extent of that industry. I respect that, but in the end, these different interests must be weighed together and I find again that the ills of prostitution are simply not acceptable and there is no way, at least not in the short term, and I doubt ever, to make them acceptable. I certainly do want to do other things to improve conditions for prostitutes, as I have no illusions that it can ever be completely abolished, so in practice I don't believe that the ban on buying sex has to be much of a problem for those who want to be prostitutes. In the Swedish case, we already have this ban so I think it is important now to focus on harm reduction for prostitutes. This is certainly done, but I would agree that this is focused too much on those who want to leave, and not enough on those who want help to make conditions in the industry better.

I can also see things from the perspective of the sex buyer who does not want to be criminalized, but frankly I don't give a damn about that.
You can only see what your society induced filter allows you to see.

This is true for all of us. Still, in my country, prostitution is not illegal. And no matter how I parse this, it still feels right.
 
As Merko has pointed out, prostitution creates opportunities for an opportunistic crime. Women who are not prostitutes have a difficult time getting people to take them seriously when a consensual sexual act turns non-consensual, for sex workers it's even easier.

I think you mean harder, and I agree. That's why laws which push prostitution underground are a bad idea. Decriminalize prostitution and allow small groups of prostitutes to work together.

More disturbing is the implication that sex-workers are doing some sort of community service by "protecting" other people from sexual assault. Sex-workers don't have any special protection from the horror of rape. Non-consensual sex isn't less bad because one has a greater amount of consensual sex.

I'd guess that sex workers probably do reduce the incidence of rape of non-prostitutes to some extent. There are probably a lot of men who don't like or respect women very much who at least get to blow off steam with a prostitute rather than attacking "normal" women.
 
No I do not think that the ban does or should make life more unpleasant and certainly not more dangerous for the individual prostitute. If it does, I would favour a repeal of the law.

I have seen these hypotheses before, but the data I have seen does not seem to support them. I will give you credit anyway for also citing the claims that show Ms Lund isn't exactly portraying the industry as some rosy-happy 'just another job' where the only major problem is negative attitudes in society.

Seems we are at a bit of an impasse here.
If the information supplied cannot convince you of the negative effects of a ban there is likely nothing that will.
 
Seems we are at a bit of an impasse here.
If the information supplied cannot convince you of the negative effects of a ban there is likely nothing that will.
Anything is information. But really, you have not supplied me with anything else than the opinions of one woman. Why would you expect that to change anyone's mind?

If you had any statistics supporting any of her hypotheses, sure. The statistics I've seen do not support her hypotheses.

Now, there is surely one negative effect of the ban for those selling sex. Sometimes, someone will tell them that they would want to buy sex, but that they won't because it's illegal. But that is a purely financial damage, which is in my opinion simply not comparable with physical and psychological damage. Certainly, the prostitute who is not feeling any physical of psychological damage may be worried about the financial damage. To me, such damage can be accepted if the incidence of more serious damage can be significantly reduced.
 
Oh, I forgot. On planet X, marrying someone is the ultimate sign of disrespect. Welcome to Earth.

...my criteria for whether or not I would consider marrying someone is whether or not we were in love. I certainly don't have lists of former jobs that I use to disqualify people. You remind me of a racist who insists his racist jokes are funny "because he has lots of black friends."

Listening? You're only seeing what you want to see, and ignoring the rest.

Odd. The NZ Prostitutes Collective clearly support the Prostitution Law Reform. Why do you think that would be? Do you think they are wrong? Do you think NZ should repeal the law? Considering the report you cited states that prostitutes are more likely to report crimes against them under the new law than before, what do you think the effect of that law change will be?

3% had been raped in the last 12 months. Let us do some math. Let us first assume that all prostitutes have an equal risk of being raped. That is of course not the case--so some prostitutes have much worse outcomes. So what does 3% rape per year mean, in the optimistic case?

- 14% risk of being raped at least once within 5 years
- 26% risk of being raped at least once within 10 years
- 37% risk of being raped at least once within 15 years
- 46% risk of being raped at least once within 20 years
- 53% risk of being raped at least once within 25 years
- 60% risk of being raped at least once within 30 years
- 66% risk of being raped at least once within 35 years
- 70% risk of being raped at least once within 40 years
- 75% risk of being raped at least once within 45 years

Let us also do the math for assault, 9.8% prevalence within the last 12 months gives:
- 40% risk of being assaulted at least once within 5 years
- 64% risk of being assaulted at least once within 10 years
- 79% risk of being assaulted at least once within 15 years
- 87% risk of being assaulted at least once within 20 years
- 92% risk of being assaulted at least once within 25 years
- 95% risk of being assaulted at least once within 30 years
- 97% risk of being assaulted at least once within 35 years
- 98% risk of being assaulted at least once within 40 years
- 99% risk of being assaulted at least once within 45 years

More comedy. Basic statistics fail.

To be honest I'm not particularly interested in your cobbled together entirely made up numbers based on static populations.

See above. Practically everyone gets raped, abducted or assaulted, probably several times over during their 'career'.. unless they get out of this 'job' very soon.

Your assertions. Now provide some proof. Plucking numbers out of thin air is not proof. You used NZ numbers initially: provide a cite that practically everyone gets raped, abducted or assaulted several times over their career or concede you have no basis to make those assertions.
I don't find that claim in the report. How would you even quantify such different problems as stigmatization versus rape? We seem to be in agreement that stigmatization must be reduced. Yes, I know you make stuff up and claim that I'm not, but that's nonsense. And frankly I don't trust your will to do so, given how you claim that the situation today is 'not horrible at all' and 'just another job'.

I cited the relevant part. My "not horrible today" was simply put forth to counter your "its all horrible now" that you put forth. The truth is that like any other job there are good things and bad things. The "fines" system that used to be put in place by brothel owners has been all but stamped out. Manager used to "fine" prostitutes who refused to sleep with clients. Pimps are illegal. Child prostitution is illegal. You don't have a clue what it used to be like before the law change here.

I mean: seriously, read through this page from the Prostitutes Collective:

http://www.nzpc.org.nz/page.php?page_name=Law

I cannot understand for the life of me why anyone would object to these laws. There are even OSH guidelines on the industry:

http://www.osh.govt.nz/order/catalogue/pdf/sexindustry.pdf

Its just maddening that you want to take this progress and throw it all away based on your "gut feelings." Why on earth would you want to throw away all this progress? Why would you not want these protections for the men and women who work in the industry in your country? I just cannot understand it.

But you don't trust me. Fair enough. Why don't you contact the NZPC and see what they think about it? Here are there contact details:

http://www.nzpc.org.nz/page.php?page_name=Contact Us

Forget about everything I've said. Feel free to send them an email. Cite this discussion. Get their opinion. Ask them if they would like to see the law changed and prostitution made illegal again. Let us know what they say.
 
I think you mean harder, and I agree. That's why laws which push prostitution underground are a bad idea. Decriminalize prostitution and allow small groups of prostitutes to work together.
I agree but I don't think that is in any way contrasted to a ban on buying sex.

I'd guess that sex workers probably do reduce the incidence of rape of non-prostitutes to some extent. There are probably a lot of men who don't like or respect women very much who at least get to blow off steam with a prostitute rather than attacking "normal" women.
I disagree, but if that was true, so what? You seem to be suggesting that this would somehow be better than the alternative?
 
...my criteria for whether or not I would consider marrying someone is whether or not we were in love. I certainly don't have lists of former jobs that I use to disqualify people.
Well I do. I would not marry a former mercenary killer, mafia boss, major drug dealer or even top tobacco executive. I do have a list of former jobs that I despise and that would disqualify a woman even if I found her otherwise attractive. Prostitute is not on that list.

Odd. The NZ Prostitutes Collective clearly support the Prostitution Law Reform. Why do you think that would be? Do you think they are wrong? Do you think NZ should repeal the law? Considering the report you cited states that prostitutes are more likely to report crimes against them under the new law than before, what do you think the effect of that law change will be?
I also support that reform vs the status quo, so I don't think they are wrong, and I certainly don't think the law should be repealed. I think this just proves that you're not capable of reading what I actually write, you just make stuff up and insult me.

Basic statistics fail.
Please explain what you mean. My calculations are extremely basic and accurate.

To be honest I'm not particularly interested in your cobbled together entirely made up numbers based on static populations.
You mean you are not interested in facts.

Your assertions. Now provide some proof. Plucking numbers out of thin air is not proof. You used NZ numbers initially: provide a cite that practically everyone gets raped, abducted or assaulted several times over their career or concede you have no basis to make those assertions.
That is the meaning of those numbers. You can't ignore that just because you don't like reality.

Your theory seems to be that yes, this is the case today.. but since everything is going to be heavenly happiness in just a few years, we can't extrapolate. Or maybe Jesus will come down from heaven or something. Yeah, maybe. But those are the facts today. If you disregard any predictions about the future based on the current situation, then you can't make any fact-based arguments at all about any law change. Supporters of a ban on prostitution could equally argue that we have absolutely no way of knowing what will happen and therefore we should just assume that in the future everything is going to be perfect and cozy and fine.

The facts are.. practically everyone gets raped, abducted or assaulted, probably several times over during their 'career'.. unless they get out of this 'job' very soon. That is the situation today.
 
Anything is information. But really, you have not supplied me with anything else than the opinions of one woman. Why would you expect that to change anyone's mind?

I were referring to all the information supplied in this tread, not that it makes any difference in the face of your hand-waving skills. :(

I see you are going on about Sweden not being NZ and the experince on legislation therefore irrelevant?
 
I find it easier to believe people whose argument is based on 'principles', and I find it more fruitful to debate such arguments.

And what principles would that be? Since I'm neither a civil servant trying to devise the best strategy to improve the situation for prostitutes nor a naive do-gooder thinking i can make the world better I'm left only with one principle: to do what i want to do. I also feel that when you make a choice you should take responsibility for it, whether it turned out to be a crappy one or not. You only deserve what you get so don't come with any tirade about how prostitutes 'deserve better' than what they got now.

For the record: I've never been to a prostitute nor do i have any plans of doing that in the foreseeable future for multiple reasons, mostly because i enjoy mutual enjoyment (and especially giving pleasure) when having sex but also because of practical reasons, such as avoiding paying for things i can get totally free (being a student doesn't exactly pay well). However, if i ever find myself traveling throughout Europe in the future i might very well consider coughing up the money and visit a classy brothel, if only for the brothel experience and not the sex. Sadly, the only 'gay' brothels I've ever heard has been on the news about some underage boys being kept and worked like slaves in Southeast Asia until they get too old, which doesn't exactly sound sexy in my opinion but i guess that's an subjective assessment. Then again i guess trying something new won't hurt, so we'll see if women are what they are cracked up to be.

Also, I'm sick and tired of this sanctimonious ********. If prostitutes are so god damn miserable and hate every single second of their work then why don't they work towards getting out? In this country, unless they are being physically kept in a locked basement like cattle or threatened by pimps, what excuses do they have? That they don't know anything but how to suck dicks? How am i supposed to be able to feel pity for someone who squandered ever single opportunity to better themselves?!

Now don't mistake me because of this rant. I have all the respect in the world for someone who found out that being a prostitute maybe wasn't such a nice choice of a career as they had though and got out, even if their life afterwards is by all reasonable accounts utter ****. But if there's one thing I'm not going to do it's cry crocodile tears.
 
And what principles would that be? Since I'm neither a civil servant trying to devise the best strategy to improve the situation for prostitutes nor a naive do-gooder thinking i can make the world better I'm left only with one principle: to do what i want to do. I also feel that when you make a choice you should take responsibility for it, whether it turned out to be a crappy one or not. You only deserve what you get so don't come with any tirade about how prostitutes 'deserve better' than what they got now.

For the record: I've never been to a prostitute nor do i have any plans of doing that in the foreseeable future for multiple reasons, mostly because i enjoy mutual enjoyment (and especially giving pleasure) when having sex but also because of practical reasons, such as avoiding paying for things i can get totally free (being a student doesn't exactly pay well). However, if i ever find myself traveling throughout Europe in the future i might very well consider coughing up the money and visit a classy brothel, if only for the brothel experience and not the sex. Sadly, the only 'gay' brothels I've ever heard has been on the news about some underage boys being kept and worked like slaves in Southeast Asia until they get too old, which doesn't exactly sound sexy in my opinion but i guess that's an subjective assessment. Then again i guess trying something new won't hurt, so we'll see if women are what they are cracked up to be.

Also, I'm sick and tired of this sanctimonious ********. If prostitutes are so god damn miserable and hate every single second of their work then why don't they work towards getting out? In this country, unless they are being physically kept in a locked basement like cattle or threatened by pimps, what excuses do they have? That they don't know anything but how to suck dicks? How am i supposed to be able to feel pity for someone who squandered ever single opportunity to better themselves?!

Now don't mistake me because of this rant. I have all the respect in the world for someone who found out that being a prostitute maybe wasn't such a nice choice of a career as they had though and got out, even if their life afterwards is by all reasonable accounts utter ****. But if there's one thing I'm not going to do it's cry crocodile tears.

Children of the Night, a non-profit that rescues under-aged prostitutes in the US often has an easier time getting them out than keeping them out. They come to the shelters because they had a bad experience. They get fed, cleaned up and safe.

And then, if they are lucky enough to have a home to go back to, they go there. Back to where they don't fit any more, where they say inappropriate things, where the problems with their parents start again, where they get whispered about by their peers. Suddenly, life on the street doesn't seem so bad. They had friends who understood them, they could get high, they could go places and do things. With the vivid imagination of the teen, they figure out how they'll do it better this time, it'll be different. All of the good, none of the bad.

Then they're back on the street with all of the bad and the good doesn't happen and it's been a full year, they're 16 or 17 and someone has been telling their parents about tough love. How it's better to tell them that they can't come home. How parents deserve to take care of themselves, too. Another year goes by and they're a legal adult with a 9th grade education, poor social skills, a big fat habit and dreams of winning the lottery some day so that they can go home. Finally do it right, do it different.
 
Again, a bald assertion.

Helping people has proven benefit. Rehabilitation works better than punishment to lower recidivism rates. Drug abusers have a better chance of quitting when they get professional help, back to work programs have helped people get off welfare, smaller classrooms raise the grade point average of the school and so on.

We also rehabilitate homosexuals for whatever reason. I don't see that working too great. Some people get in the field because they need the money for food. Others get into the field because they love sex. Whatever the case, I find little logical reason to punish people for being industrious and coming to their own decisions as adults. Is prostitution drug addiction? I smell secret feminism in the post. I won't do this ergo other women should not as well. This is inherently flawed logic because you are arguing that what is right for you or your emotional wellbeing is right for every other woman’s emotional wellbeing and self-esteem. There is simply no way to objectively measure the barrier for any individual’s wellbeing.

As for rehabilitation in the America our programs are terrible and many people relapse back into drug addictions and prior habits. Helping people develop new skills and hobbies is perhaps the most effective way to get rid of an old hobby. As for prostitution, I ask this question, why is it bad? What is so inherently wrong about prostitution that it should be stopped? So far I've heard no sound reasoning other than "it can" be dangerous.

I think the dangers can be well avoided if the industry is regulated by the government and well taxed to keep up maintenance and security. Sorry I haven't been convinced yet; let's see what you come up with.
 
Children of the Night, a non-profit that rescues under-aged prostitutes in the US often has an easier time getting them out than keeping them out. They come to the shelters because they had a bad experience. They get fed, cleaned up and safe.

And then, if they are lucky enough to have a home to go back to, they go there. Back to where they don't fit any more, where they say inappropriate things, where the problems with their parents start again, where they get whispered about by their peers. Suddenly, life on the street doesn't seem so bad. They had friends who understood them, they could get high, they could go places and do things. With the vivid imagination of the teen, they figure out how they'll do it better this time, it'll be different. All of the good, none of the bad.

Then they're back on the street with all of the bad and the good doesn't happen and it's been a full year, they're 16 or 17 and someone has been telling their parents about tough love. How it's better to tell them that they can't come home. How parents deserve to take care of themselves, too. Another year goes by and they're a legal adult with a 9th grade education, poor social skills, a big fat habit and dreams of winning the lottery some day so that they can go home. Finally do it right, do it different.


Do you have evidence that suggests that if the government regulates the industry that circumstances would still occur in this fashion? I see a lot of U.S. bias in this post. I'm from the states too, but I'm just not seeing an objective argument as to why prositution should not be legal if the industry was well regulated. All of these circumstances occur in my opinion because the government punishes those in these situations and forces them into an underground type states. I think if this industry were regulated all would be avoided.
 
Where I live (Finland) if I have understood the laws correctly offering sex for money and buying it is legal, but "pimping" (ie. benefiting from another person's prostitution) is criminalized.
Seems to work ok. There was even recently a story in the newspaper about a female who had registered a company with the "industry" specified as "sex services". So she pays taxes etc.

This way we get the criminalized elements under control and the law can intervene there (the usage of sex workers from another countries for example), but if someone wants to earn money trading for sex it's ok.
 
Do you have evidence that suggests that if the government regulates the industry that circumstances would still occur in this fashion? I see a lot of U.S. bias in this post. I'm from the states too, but I'm just not seeing an objective argument as to why prositution should not be legal if the industry was well regulated. All of these circumstances occur in my opinion because the government punishes those in these situations and forces them into an underground type states. I think if this industry were regulated all would be avoided.

I have been arguing for legislation and legalization, specifically legislation that primarily benefits and protects sex-workers, not legalization that benefits tax collectors, pimps and brothel owners.
 
It seems pretty obvious why countries like the US don't legalize prostitution.
There is a common sentiment that a woman isn't entirely free yet, and needs to be controlled, ie. she can't decide what to do with her body. Prostitution and abortion laws.
The christian fundies just don't like it that a woman can decide against gods wishes (or their "superior" morals and beliefs), as simple as that. Different rationalizations then follow.
The people who think this probably aren't a majority, but a large and vocal enough group.
And in addition those who would be ok with legalizing prostitution don't think that much about it, I mean who really wants to have that as a cause even if they think its ok. It's still sex so a touchy subject most people don't want to discuss so openly.
 
I have been arguing for legislation and legalization, specifically legislation that primarily benefits and protects sex-workers, not legalization that benefits tax collectors, pimps and brothel owners.

Then I don't understand how we got into the argument in the first place because we're on the same wave length.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom