Is there any good reason for prostitution being illegal?

So your reasons for opposing prostitution are:
1. You personally suspect it will cause psychological damage to the prostitute
2. You feel deep empathy for the poor prostitutes as you feel it is a dangerous occupation.
3. ?
Yes, and I also suspect it will cause physical damage, from assaults and/or STDs. I do not believe these damages always occur to every prostitute. I simply believe that it happens often enough to be wholly unacceptable.

I would add that I can see things from the perspective of the prostitute who is not at all suffering. I can understand that it must be frustrating that I want a law which is intended to reduce the extent of that industry. I respect that, but in the end, these different interests must be weighed together and I find again that the ills of prostitution are simply not acceptable and there is no way, at least not in the short term, and I doubt ever, to make them acceptable. I certainly do want to do other things to improve conditions for prostitutes, as I have no illusions that it can ever be completely abolished, so in practice I don't believe that the ban on buying sex has to be much of a problem for those who want to be prostitutes. In the Swedish case, we already have this ban so I think it is important now to focus on harm reduction for prostitutes. This is certainly done, but I would agree that this is focused too much on those who want to leave, and not enough on those who want help to make conditions in the industry better.

I can also see things from the perspective of the sex buyer who does not want to be criminalized, but frankly I don't give a damn about that.
 
These statistics would have been more insightful if they compared them with how many non-prostitutes (women of course) that have been raped, 'held against their will', assaulted or threatened within the same time period. If the difference is negligible then i fail to see how working as a prostitute would be more 'risky' than not.
You'd have to look up those stats yourself I'm afraid. I don't know them precisely, but I would say with confidence they are nowhere near those numbers.
 
Lies, this is not the opinion of all persons engaged in the free movement. Things are more complex than you're making it. Everyone has different reasoning. How do we know if it’s a good thing to feed starving children? Or to try and stop a man or woman from being a prostitute. People inherently have free will and some people don't want to be helped, nor should you try.

That is an interesting opinion. Do you have anything other than a bald assertion?
 
So I walk home through the park, and I see a woman being raped. But evidently I should not try to help her. After all, maybe she simply does not want to be helped.
 
Prostitution is illegal in plenty of countries, as evident by this map:

[qimg]http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/b/be/Prostitution_in_Europe.png/400px-Prostitution_in_Europe.png[/qimg]
(In the red ones, it's illegal, in the exchange of sex for money is legal but brothels are illegal, and in the green ones prostitution is legal and regulated.)

What is the rationale from prohibitting prostitution? Judging from the case in Sweden, the politicians seem to view it as icky. They dislike the idea, and therefore don't want it to exist. To me it simply doesn't make sense. Even though I think the current approach to drugs is misguided, I can at least understand the rationale behind it, as drugs cause harm. But sex doesn't.

If you happen to understand Swedish, you can watch this discussion between a comedian and a Green politician discussing the issue. The latter illustrates just how squeamish the prohibitionists are.


human dignity?
 
Merko,
If I understand you right you do realise that a ban will make life a lot more unpleasant and dangerous for the individual prostitute, but believe it will be offset by an overall reduction in prostitution?
 
Just because you disagree with me does not entitle you to make stuff up and be rude.

...exactly what did I make up?

I think that you are being disrespectful to prostitutes and to women in general, but I'd be happy to see that I'm wrong.

Yeah, right. I'm the one who said: "Seriously, I'd have absolutely no doubts about marrying an ex-prostitute." The disrespect just drips off that post.

In your own words: "things are horrible". So it's horrible, but you don't want to reduce its prevalence? You know, a straight reading of this really suggests that you hate women.

LOL!

But I'm willing to give you the benefit of the doubt. Perhaps you are just confused, or engaging in wishful thinking.

ROFL!

Oh. Let's look at some figures then, from the Prostitution Law Review Committee:

Within the last 12 months:
- 3.0% had been raped
- 4.7% had been held against their will
- 9.8% had been physically assaulted
- 15.9% had been threatened with physical violence

Just another job, eh? Not horrible at all?

Yep. Just another job. Did you know that machinists are more likely to have their hands crushed by machines? That tree pruners are more likely to fall off trees? That policeman are more likely to be assaulted and verbally abused by drunks? Every job has its own inherent risks. If people choose of their own free will to engage at a job, then there is always the possibility that something bad will happen. How many policeman do you think have been threatened with physical violence? Should we ban the police?

I think your attitude has to change. If you're not outright misogynistic, you're clearly uninterested in the well being of prostitutes.

Misogynistic? For believing that people have the right to do what they want with their bodies? For listening to the Prostitutes Collective, and respecting their opinions? For having had friends in the prostitution industry, and respecting their choice of lifestyle and career? Well, if you consider that misogynistic, I'd be proud to wear that as a title.

Do you want me to start lobbying against the collective? Will that make me a better person? Should I start preaching to the prostitutes I know, telling them that Merko thinks that they are not mature enough to make decisions for themselves?

It is a complicated issue and reasonable people can disagree on how to best improve conditions for prostitutes. Resorting to name calling simply because someone disagrees with you is not very mature. However, since you don't even think the situation is bad, how can you even claim to want to improve it?

I just reread my posts and saw no name calling. If you think that anything I've said crosses the line of this forum, feel free to report my posts.

Yeah, just another job.. where practically everyone gets raped, abducted or assaulted, probably several times over during your 'career'.. unless you get out of this 'job' very soon.

You didn't provide figures showing 100% of prostitutes in NZ have been raped. You haven't supplied figures that 50% of prostitutes in NZ have been raped. You haven't supplied figures that 25% of prostitutes in NZ have been raped. You haven't supplied figures that 10% of prostitutes in NZ have been raped. You haven't supplied figures that 5% of prostitutes have been raped. You provided figures that 3% of the survey group had claimed to be raped and of that group 30% reported those rapes to the police.

Yeah, its a problem. Lets not pretend it isn't. But stop making stuff up. Stop exaggerating the issue. How can you make claims that " practically everyone gets raped, abducted or assaulted," while citing figures that less than ten percent do? You accuse me of making stuff up, yet you make this claim?

From the cited report:

The CSOM report concludes that stigmatisation plays a key role in the non-reporting of incidents. The Committee has commented elsewhere that stigmatisation is still attached to the sex industry, and it will take time before it dissipates.

Stigmatisation:the act of disapproving or condemning.

The NZ Prostitution Law Reform was the result of lobbying by the Prostitutes Collective. In the face of collective outrage over since the law was passed from the extreme religious fanatics and the "I Know Best" paternalistic talk-back callers the Prostitution Collective has continued to support the law change and continues to battle the councils around the country that try and legislate around national law. I haven't met a prostitute that has opposed the law change and wants the law rolled back.

Yet for some reason you think you know better. I go back to my original post to you: you missed the point of Georgina Beyer's message. The industry won't get safer if we pretend it doesn't exist. It won't get safer if we just go after the "johns." It won't get safer if we just go after the working girls. There is nothing inherently wrong with sex and there is nothing inherently wrong with exchanging sex for money. If people decide that they want to participate in the sex industry then they deserve to have the full protection of the law. Rape, assault and abduction are illegal in New Zealand. Prostitution doesn't cause rape. It doesn't cause assault, and it doesn't cause abduction. Rapists cause rape, assaulter's assault and abductor's abduct. Thats who the law should focus on. That is where the real evil lies.

As shown by the report that YOU cited: the biggest problem behind the lack of reporting of crime is stigmatization. The solution to that is not to roll back the laws, roll back the protections and drive the industry underground again. We need to encourage the men and women involved in the industry to come forward and report crimes when they are committed to them. We need to let them know that they will be taken seriously and believed. We need to remove the stigma, and not treat them like second class citizens. As the report states: changing the attitudes takes time. We started the process in 2003. Eight years on we've come along way, but we still have a way to go. But at least we've made a start.
 
The problem is that, while I wholly agree with this sympathy, to undestand and have compassion here usually is to excuse and accept. Sure, we should try to get our children out of prostitution and drug use. But for the state to legitimize it -- to have social workers distribute condoms to 12-year-old prostitutes -- is wholly misplaced. It is precisely the "bandying compliments with pimps" Stephans is talking about.

You yourself see on this very board what the next step is: the very fact that prostitution is made safer by "compassionate" laws is then used to "prove" that now there is "really" nothing wrong with it: that what is "really" wrong with prostitution is not that it is having sex with dozens of strangers a day for money, but that it is "unsafe", that "society is biased against it", etc., etc.

On this Stephans correctly says, "... a kind of ingenuity which carries its own refutation on its face. How can the State or the public be competent to determine any question whatever if it is not competent to decide that gross vice is a bad thing?"

I agree wholeheartedly with Stephans on the pimps part of this. My theory is flay 'em and salt 'em. And then do something really painful for them.
 
Ivor, what do your family think to you using the services of a prostitute? And your workmates?

Some would find it icky, others wouldn't care.

If it happened to be reported in a newspaper, what would you feel about that?

Angry. A person's sex life is private. It should be up to the individuals concerned what and to whom they reveal anything about their private lives.
 
That is an interesting opinion. Do you have anything other than a bald assertion?

You can help people several times and they will always go back to the same situation they were in before. The best thing we can do is regulate the industry to make it safer.
 
Ivor, what do your family think to you using the services of a prostitute? And your workmates?

If it happened to be reported in a newspaper, what would you feel about that?

Go back a few years and try..

<Random name>, what do your family think to you being gay? And your workmates?


Just because 'society' thinks something is 'icky', it doesn't mean it's an evil thing.
 
You can help people several times and they will always go back to the same situation they were in before. The best thing we can do is regulate the industry to make it safer.

Again, a bald assertion.

Helping people has proven benefit. Rehabilitation works better than punishment to lower recidivism rates. Drug abusers have a better chance of quitting when they get professional help, back to work programs have helped people get off welfare, smaller classrooms raise the grade point average of the school and so on.

We have enough examples of different types of legalization to see what works. The Netherlands model - make it legal, tax it and don't ask questions - isn't working. Trafficking is a huge problem. The New Zealand model - regulate it with an eye towards protecting sex-workers is better but there are still problems. The Nevada model - regulate it, keep it limited, make it expensive and somewhat respectable - has the smallest amount of problems.
 
Go back a few years and try..

<Random name>, what do your family think to you being gay? And your workmates?


Just because 'society' thinks something is 'icky', it doesn't mean it's an evil thing.

True, but the same can be said about, say, pedophilia. That some social prejudices are wrong, or unfair, doesn't mean all are.
 
Merko,
If I understand you right you do realise that a ban will make life a lot more unpleasant and dangerous for the individual prostitute, but believe it will be offset by an overall reduction in prostitution?
No I do not think that the ban does or should make life more unpleasant and certainly not more dangerous for the individual prostitute. If it does, I would favour a repeal of the law.
 
No I do not think that the ban does or should make life more unpleasant and certainly not more dangerous for the individual prostitute. If it does, I would favour a repeal of the law.

http://www.prostitutescollective.net/sweden_has_not_made_it_safer_for.htm

Isabella Lund, SANS – Sexworkers and Allies Network in Sweden, 6 June 2007

“The law has increased the risks and violence against sexworkers …”

“Those who are worst afflicted are unfortunately the most vulnerable sexworkers, the street prostitutes, addicts and sexworkers from other countries. On the streets the negotiations must happen a lot faster than before since the police can be around the corner. … it is therefore hard to do a correct risk assessment.”

“The risk of infection has gone up because if a sexseller gets infected with a sexually transmitted disease, and the authorities advise her customers to contact them, many men are afraid to do so.”

“… if a customer meets a sexworker that he/she suspects is the victim of sexual trafficking, that person is today scared of going to the police. Before you could obtain evidence against traffickers and pimps based on customer’s testimony.”

“A lot of sexsellers on the street report being robbed and feel it's harder for them to contact clients outdoors. They therefore have to rely on other channels … and the likelihood of ending up in the hands of profiteers and pimps for those who need help increases.”

“Sexworkers feel more pressure from the police. … Police have also sometimes been reported to become heavy handed or brutal.”

“Sexworkers also report that the networks between sexworkers that existed before on certain known streets for prostitution have disappeared or weakened as a result of the sex-purchase law. Earlier you could warn each other for dangerous customers, fake cars, etc. … The "normal" clients have almost disappeared from the streets. Those who remain are the ones with a twisted mindset and street prostitutes today are more exposed to robbery, assault and rape than before.”

“When the prostitution market disappears underground it is harder for the authorities to intercept the persons that really need help. In Gothenburg many young women seek help to detoxify because of their addiction to heroin and almost all of them have sold sexual services. But the city’s prostitution group (social workers) seldom comes in contact with these women because they don't show up on the streets today. The same goes for the young drug addicts in Malmo.”

Recent correspondence from Ms Lund: “The police got an extra 7 million SKR to implement the law but there are no extra recourses to help sexworkers leave prostitution.”
 
Yeah, right. I'm the one who said: "Seriously, I'd have absolutely no doubts about marrying an ex-prostitute." The disrespect just drips off that post.
Oh, I forgot. On planet X, marrying someone is the ultimate sign of disrespect. Welcome to Earth.

For listening to the Prostitutes Collective, and respecting their opinions?
Listening? You're only seeing what you want to see, and ignoring the rest.

You didn't provide figures showing 100% of prostitutes in NZ have been raped. You haven't supplied figures that 50% of prostitutes in NZ have been raped. You haven't supplied figures that 25% of prostitutes in NZ have been raped. You haven't supplied figures that 10% of prostitutes in NZ have been raped. You haven't supplied figures that 5% of prostitutes have been raped. You provided figures that 3% of the survey group had claimed to be raped and of that group 30% reported those rapes to the police.
3% had been raped in the last 12 months. Let us do some math. Let us first assume that all prostitutes have an equal risk of being raped. That is of course not the case--so some prostitutes have much worse outcomes. So what does 3% rape per year mean, in the optimistic case?

- 14% risk of being raped at least once within 5 years
- 26% risk of being raped at least once within 10 years
- 37% risk of being raped at least once within 15 years
- 46% risk of being raped at least once within 20 years
- 53% risk of being raped at least once within 25 years
- 60% risk of being raped at least once within 30 years
- 66% risk of being raped at least once within 35 years
- 70% risk of being raped at least once within 40 years
- 75% risk of being raped at least once within 45 years

Let us also do the math for assault, 9.8% prevalence within the last 12 months gives:
- 40% risk of being assaulted at least once within 5 years
- 64% risk of being assaulted at least once within 10 years
- 79% risk of being assaulted at least once within 15 years
- 87% risk of being assaulted at least once within 20 years
- 92% risk of being assaulted at least once within 25 years
- 95% risk of being assaulted at least once within 30 years
- 97% risk of being assaulted at least once within 35 years
- 98% risk of being assaulted at least once within 40 years
- 99% risk of being assaulted at least once within 45 years

Stop exaggerating the issue. How can you make claims that " practically everyone gets raped, abducted or assaulted," while citing figures that less than ten percent do? You accuse me of making stuff up, yet you make this claim?
See above. Practically everyone gets raped, abducted or assaulted, probably several times over during their 'career'.. unless they get out of this 'job' very soon.

As shown by the report that YOU cited: the biggest problem behind the lack of reporting of crime is stigmatization.
I don't find that claim in the report. How would you even quantify such different problems as stigmatization versus rape? We seem to be in agreement that stigmatization must be reduced. Yes, I know you make stuff up and claim that I'm not, but that's nonsense. And frankly I don't trust your will to do so, given how you claim that the situation today is 'not horrible at all' and 'just another job'.
 
So Merko, who would the rapists be raping if they weren't raping prostitutes?
There is an underlying reasoning behind that question which is simply absurd. The rate of rape is not constant. Opportunity makes the thief, opportunity also makes the rapist. Calling on a prostitute to join him in a safe (for him) location is very easy. Luring or kidnapping some other person is much more dangerous and also requires advance planning. Rape of prostitutes does not have to be planned, it may for example be people who are mentally disturbed, who are using drugs, or who are just completely lacking empathy and who do not respect other people.
 
Btw, two clarifications: With regards to the New Zealand law, I'm absolutely convinced that the law was an improvement compared to the previous situation. If anyone got the impression that I would have opposed that law, when the alternative was the status quo, that is absolutely not the case.

Second, with regards to Ms Lund's opinions, again I am not completely opposed to Ms Lund and I definitely think she has many many valid points. I respectfully disagree with her about the ban on buying sex, but that is clearly not her only concern, and on these other points I would say that I largely agree on those issues where I have formed an opinion.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom