Is there any good reason for prostitution being illegal?

Right, but the goal should be primarily happy sex workers. Start from there and figure out how to make that happen in addition to addressing the ills of prostitution.

To a degree some people who voluntarily prostitute themselves can't really be 'happy'. For example: i read about these 'young people' who apparently prostitute themselves as some kind of punishment and as a part of a generally self-destructive behavior. I doubt you can make someone like that a 'happy' prostitute, although i also doubt you could stop them from prostituting themselves without working on their emotional problems, which is obviously something that you can't legislate away.
 
To a degree some people who voluntarily prostitute themselves can't really be 'happy'. For example: i read about these 'young people' who apparently prostitute themselves as some kind of punishment and as a part of a generally self-destructive behavior. I doubt you can make someone like that a 'happy' prostitute, although i also doubt you could stop them from prostituting themselves without working on their emotional problems, which is obviously something that you can't legislate away.

It isn't much fun to die at 45 because of the chemicals you were exposed to as a roofer or coal miner, either. Or be gut-shot as a soldier. Or dozens of other legal trades.
 
To a degree some people who voluntarily prostitute themselves can't really be 'happy'. For example: i read about these 'young people' who apparently prostitute themselves as some kind of punishment and as a part of a generally self-destructive behavior. I doubt you can make someone like that a 'happy' prostitute, although i also doubt you could stop them from prostituting themselves without working on their emotional problems, which is obviously something that you can't legislate away.

...cite? There are all sorts of studies alluded throughout the thread: it would be interesting to examine the evidence.
 
I'd rather see my theoretical daughter play Russian roulette once for a million dollars, than make her living as a prostitute for five years.

What you'd prefer for your daughter is quite irrelevant to this discussion, and shouldn't guide public policy.

Selling herself once.. not a big problem. Ten times? Probably fine. But that doesn't really pay a lot of bills. Nor does it satisfy a lot of the demand, especially if we're supposed to make prostitution more acceptable. I think prostitution advocates are not really living in the real world, no.

But who says that one has to live exclusively as a prostitute? Someone may simply do it sometimes, to make easy cash. Someone might prefer it as their occupation. In my opinion, it should really be the individual's choice.

Just do the maths. If you're going to have a significant percentage of men satisfy their sex drive even partially through prostitution, then either a significant percentage of women will have to sell sex, which is just not going to happen, or those who do need to sell sex a lot.

Just learn how a market functions. If the demand is very high compared to the supply, the price is going to rise, and those who don't think it's worth that much money won't consider buying. The market finds an equilibrium. Just like the market for milk. If demand for milk was to suddenly rise without a proportionate increase in supply (or if supply was to suddenly decrease without a proportionate decrease in demand) then the price for milk would rise. And an equilibrium different from the current one would take place on the milk market.

So no, there would not be necessary for a significant portion of women to sell, or for those who sell to sell a lot. You seem to assume that people will be forced to do it.

The latter is what is happening. And that is why it is so dangerous, physically and psychologically.

Again, not a shred of evidence for your assertion.

No, you wouldn't care anyway. You're still dodging my other questions regarding what evidence you would accept, so I'm not going to waste any time digging up stuff that you're not interested in anyway.

I think our difference utlimately boils down to values. Reading your posts, you seem to think that the authorities should promote virtue and prevent vice, and try to change people's attitudes into what you consider proper. My value on the matter is based on the harm principle. I doubt we will be able to find common ground on the issue. I notice that you seem to reject metaphysical mumbo-jumbo like "inherently degrading", which shows some promise, but our values are still very different.

One thing that used to be common not all that long ago was claiming that the pictures or videos would only be sold in Japan, not here. Strangely enough people fell for that. But anyway 'tricked' was perhaps not the best word, 'seduced' might be better.

Then that is fraudulent and could be prosecuted. Though one should of course keep in mind that piracy can occur so there is no guarantee either way.

Ever been with a woman who regretted it the morning after? It's like that, except these images never go away so they have to live with that mistake for life. To me, that seems very unnecessary.

But it's virtually impossible to know such things. I hope you agree on that if one person rejects it the morning after, the sexual partner should not be prosecuted for rape.

I think you're just blind to the massive documentation about women who are seriously hurt by prostitution. Read the Georgina Beyers quote above, for instance. I find that quite moving. Or any of the plenty of reports you find from women's shelters etc. It is true that some people who work with such cases get a skewed image of prostitution and assume that all prostitutes are like the ones they end up helping. That is not the case. But you just seem to conveniently ignore that these problems exist, or you just assume that it's nothing to do with prostitution even though it quite obviously is.

Is the harm because of prostitution, or because of something else?

Well, the prostitution-romantics in the blogosphere of course immediately assumed that these were just some naturally horny girls who loved to do this and no one should trample on their rights. Like I already said, two people were convicted for pimping, and if you read the verdict, a lot of red lights should go off regarding trafficking.

I see. But I don't see how it is relevant for the bigger discussion, as nobody is advocating that trafficking and sex slavery should be legalized.

So your attitude is that because these women already have self-injury behaviour, great, then we can use their bodies because that's what they 'want'?

*Sigh* No. My attitude is that they should get help with their self-injuring behavior.

No, that's probably not what you think that you believe. But really, what do you believe? It's not our problem and we should look the other way while other people use these girls? Because of some 'holy principle' that we should never interfere if at least 1 person sells sex and is happy about it?

"Believe" is the wrong word I think. I've already laid out my moral views above.

You agreed previously that we should ban Russian roulette. That is only harmful for 16.7% of contestants, for the others it is completely safe.

But Russian roulette can kill you. Prostitution can't.

No, that is unrealistic. But I support pragmatic regulation to achieve harm reduction without causing significant problems for responsible drinkers. Such as the Swedish alcohol monopoly which has good effects, and high taxes which demonstrably lowers alcohol consumption.

Why aren't you willing to think the same way about prostitution?

I believe that it is quite possible to keep peanuts away from people with serious allergy. If hundreds of people per year died from peanut traces floating through the air, then yes, I'd definitely consider banning peanuts. You're dealing in absolutes and principles, I'm looking at realities.

I'll grant your point that if the very smell of peanuts could kill a significant part of the population, some serious measures like banning should be considered. But prostitution can't kill you. That's the difference.
 
Quick, with the aid of google check out the legal status of prostitution in the UK.;)

Point to Ivor! :D

My American bias is showing. That does change the situation a bit. Give me a moment to readjust my thinking on that. It's a very good start to the laws and I'm glad your short term friend doesn't have the same legal issues that she would face here. She sounds nice.
 
It isn't much fun to die at 45 because of the chemicals you were exposed to as a roofer or coal miner, either. Or be gut-shot as a soldier. Or dozens of other legal trades.

Yes, and? In both examples that you gave we have put things in place in order to assist the workers, give them health-care, make their trade safer and better for all people involved. We could, and we SHOULD, do the same with prostitution rather than having a dogmatical approach where trying to make prostitution disappear is the most important, if not the only goal.

...cite? There are all sorts of studies alluded throughout the thread: it would be interesting to examine the evidence.

There was no study but it was apparently based on the accounts of a couple of people who sold sex when they were young and then made into a book. I'm sure that those who are ideologically against prostitution would hype and exaggerate accounts like this in order to make sure that the public perception of prostitutes is that they are all near suicidal, self loathing human beings.

Here's the link: http://www.aftonbladet.se/nyheter/article13336528.ab

It's in Swedish and, unless you speak Swedish, you're going to have to translate the text by itself rather than the whole page because of that god awful website.
 
What you'd prefer for your daughter is quite irrelevant to this discussion, and shouldn't guide public policy.



But who says that one has to live exclusively as a prostitute? Someone may simply do it sometimes, to make easy cash. Someone might prefer it as their occupation. In my opinion, it should really be the individual's choice.



Just learn how a market functions. If the demand is very high compared to the supply, the price is going to rise, and those who don't think it's worth that much money won't consider buying. The market finds an equilibrium. Just like the market for milk. If demand for milk was to suddenly rise without a proportionate increase in supply (or if supply was to suddenly decrease without a proportionate decrease in demand) then the price for milk would rise. And an equilibrium different from the current one would take place on the milk market.

So no, there would not be necessary for a significant portion of women to sell, or for those who sell to sell a lot. You seem to assume that people will be forced to do it.



Again, not a shred of evidence for your assertion.



I think our difference utlimately boils down to values. Reading your posts, you seem to think that the authorities should promote virtue and prevent vice, and try to change people's attitudes into what you consider proper. My value on the matter is based on the harm principle. I doubt we will be able to find common ground on the issue. I notice that you seem to reject metaphysical mumbo-jumbo like "inherently degrading", which shows some promise, but our values are still very different.



Then that is fraudulent and could be prosecuted. Though one should of course keep in mind that piracy can occur so there is no guarantee either way.



But it's virtually impossible to know such things. I hope you agree on that if one person rejects it the morning after, the sexual partner should not be prosecuted for rape.



Is the harm because of prostitution, or because of something else?



I see. But I don't see how it is relevant for the bigger discussion, as nobody is advocating that trafficking and sex slavery should be legalized.



*Sigh* No. My attitude is that they should get help with their self-injuring behavior.



"Believe" is the wrong word I think. I've already laid out my moral views above.



But Russian roulette can kill you. Prostitution can't.



Why aren't you willing to think the same way about prostitution?



I'll grant your point that if the very smell of peanuts could kill a significant part of the population, some serious measures like banning should be considered. But prostitution can't kill you. That's the difference.

Prostitution carries inherent risk. In the US we have had several serial killers who focus specifically on street walkers. A recent google search on prostitution in the UK turns up two convicted serial murderers of prostitutes. (With an unmentioned bonus Jack the Ripper.)

Even when practiced religiously, safe sex is not 100% effective. The more partners, the greater risk of incurable STD's like AIDS or hepatitis. The US porn industry is the closest thing we have to legal prostitution outside of Nevada. Actors are routinely tested and, to some degree, practice safe sex. There have been a few notable AIDS scares lately.

Prostitution can't kill you, but the lifestyle can.
 
Yes, and?

Well, and this:

There seem to be two camps here, as there usually are in these debates:

1) Prostitution should be legal, and this would have many benefits, including safety of the workers, control of disease, etc.

2) Prostitution is icky, bad, degrading, desperate, unpleasant, dangerous, or whatever.

Now, I'm in camp 1. So, I assume from your response, are you. So there isn't much point in lecturing me.

What I see is that people in camp 2 seldom if ever argue why they think that then, therefore, prostitution should be illegal. It's a part of the argument that is notably missing. And so I point out other things that are icky, bad, degrading, desperate, unpleasant, dangerous, or whatever that people don't consider making illegal to show contrast.

I do this because I care about the soundness and validity of arguments on a site that is about skepticism and reason. In fact, I care about this much more than what camp a person is in, because I think that if these things are absent, you can't even begin to have a rational discussion about anything, and positions become indistinguishable from mere opinion. So I point out, sometimes directly and sometimes obliquely, when I don't see that arguments are complete.

I can at least respect a sound, valid, complete argument, even if I do not like the conclusion. It's part of a rational discussion. Then I can go through the argument and take a look at whether the evidence supports the premises or not. That can be interesting. When there are missing pieces to arguments, I can't do that.

Maybe you don't see the point of doing this, and this is the source of your confusion. I don't know. A lot of threads, especially about emotive topics, seem to be missing significant components, so maybe it's popular to do this. However, trying to fetter out problems with arguments is, I think, at least permitted on this forum, and it may also be more in line with skepticism than a simple, unsupported difference of opinion.
 
I got to post three then all the talk became of child prostitution, which isn't what the thread was about at all.

When you're at 'Won't someone think of the children' on the first page, you know it's not going to get any better.

I shall now read the rest of the thread and hope that I am wrong.
 
If prostitution is legalized and no longer stigmatized, whatever twinge of morality they have left in thinking it might be wrong to encourage girls to go into prostitution will be eradicated.

You've just begged the question asked in the OP. You've just dumped the whole argument by presuming that prostitution is wrong.
 
Oh, then i misunderstood you. I agree with what you said, especially this:

What I see is that people in camp 2 seldom if ever argue why they think that then, therefore, prostitution should be illegal. It's a part of the argument that is notably missing. And so I point out other things that are icky, bad, degrading, desperate, unpleasant, dangerous, or whatever that people don't consider making illegal to show contrast.
 
Well, and this:

There seem to be two camps here, as there usually are in these debates:

1) Prostitution should be legal, and this would have many benefits, including safety of the workers, control of disease, etc.

2) Prostitution is icky, bad, degrading, desperate, unpleasant, dangerous, or whatever.

Now, I'm in camp 1. So, I assume from your response, are you. So there isn't much point in lecturing me.

What I see is that people in camp 2 seldom if ever argue why they think that then, therefore, prostitution should be illegal. It's a part of the argument that is notably missing. And so I point out other things that are icky, bad, degrading, desperate, unpleasant, dangerous, or whatever that people don't consider making illegal to show contrast.

I do this because I care about the soundness and validity of arguments on a site that is about skepticism and reason. In fact, I care about this much more than what camp a person is in, because I think that if these things are absent, you can't even begin to have a rational discussion about anything, and positions become indistinguishable from mere opinion. So I point out, sometimes directly and sometimes obliquely, when I don't see that arguments are complete.

I can at least respect a sound, valid, complete argument, even if I do not like the conclusion. It's part of a rational discussion. Then I can go through the argument and take a look at whether the evidence supports the premises or not. That can be interesting. When there are missing pieces to arguments, I can't do that.

Maybe you don't see the point of doing this, and this is the source of your confusion. I don't know. A lot of threads, especially about emotive topics, seem to be missing significant components, so maybe it's popular to do this. However, trying to fetter out problems with arguments is, I think, at least permitted on this forum, and it may also be more in line with skepticism than a simple, unsupported difference of opinion.

Golly, I wish the world was that black and white. Everything would be all nifty or not. Easy to deal with. Unfortunately social issues are grey areas.

Even if there was a magic wand that would make all prostitution legal and protected, we wouldn't end up in a world of bunny ranches run by Dolly Parton. (As much as I wish it could.)

We would still have people turning to a job that has very little longevity and a super crappy retirement plan. You start with an impressionable 18 year old, constantly give them affirmation that their body is the only thing they have to offer for 10 -15 years and then when that goes, toss them out into the world with no other options and completely messed-up sense of self-worth.

In this magical world of legal & safe prostitution, you would still have religion, prudes and johns with a messed-up view of sexuality, especially other people's. Making it safe and legal won't make it respectable. Prostitutes will still be seen as a lower class and they will absorb that message. It also puts them at risk for violence.

New Zealand, which is being held up as some sort of working model, still has problems with gangs, drugs, violence and under-aged sex-workers.

Prostitution can be icky, bad, degrading, desperate, unpleasant, dangerous, whatever, even if it is legal. Making it legal seems to be the best way to reduce harm, not create utopias.
 
I don't like that formulation. I find it likely that it is causes serious psychological damage, probably in and of itself, for a significant proportion of prostitutes, especially long-term. I also think the risk for STDs, even when using the best available protection, is very significant for a long-term prostitute. I also think that we have to see the effects of prostitution today for what they are today, not for what they possibly could be in some ideal society where no one looks down on prostitutes.

I believe that because prostitution is dangerous today, buying sex should not be considered acceptable today. If at some point in the future it turns out that we have made prostitution adequately safe and it's perfectly normal to put prostitution on your CV, then fine, we can change our attitudes then. But that doesn't matter now.

I also think that it is very important to focus the debate on typical prostitution, that is, what does it look like most of the time when someone buys sex? It's not so interesting with these girls or boys who have sold sex perhaps 5 times when they were students. This type of prostitution may not very often cause extremely serious problems, but it also doesn't supply the market for prostitution to any significant extent.

So your reasons for opposing prostitution are:
1. You personally suspect it will cause psychological damage to the prostitute
2. You feel deep empathy for the poor prostitutes as you feel it is a dangerous occupation.
3. ?

Kindly explain if my summation was wrong.
 
Stop pretending you have respect for an industry that you couch in such contempt. Stop talking down to them.
Just because you disagree with me does not entitle you to make stuff up and be rude.

I think that you are being disrespectful to prostitutes and to women in general, but I'd be happy to see that I'm wrong.

I don't believe we should try and reduce the prevalence of prostitution.
In your own words: "things are horrible". So it's horrible, but you don't want to reduce its prevalence? You know, a straight reading of this really suggests that you hate women.

But I'm willing to give you the benefit of the doubt. Perhaps you are just confused, or engaging in wishful thinking.

The New Zealand legislation allows for that. They are safer. Things are much less horrible. In fact, I wouldn't consider it to be horrible now at all.
Oh. Let's look at some figures then, from the Prostitution Law Review Committee:

Within the last 12 months:
- 3.0% had been raped
- 4.7% had been held against their will
- 9.8% had been physically assaulted
- 15.9% had been threatened with physical violence

Just another job, eh? Not horrible at all?

Here's a clue: society won't change on its own. The people have to change. Your attitude has to change. And if it doesn't change today, it won't change tomorrow.
I think your attitude has to change. If you're not outright misogynistic, you're clearly uninterested in the well being of prostitutes.

It is a complicated issue and reasonable people can disagree on how to best improve conditions for prostitutes. Resorting to name calling simply because someone disagrees with you is not very mature. However, since you don't even think the situation is bad, how can you even claim to want to improve it?

Its just just another job.
Yeah, just another job.. where practically everyone gets raped, abducted or assaulted, probably several times over during your 'career'.. unless you get out of this 'job' very soon.
 
Who would the rapists be raping if they hadn't raped prostitutes?

If a person only rapes prostitutes, what may be the cause of that? Could it be that person thinks prostitutes are less than human? Where might such an idea come from?
 
Ivor, what do your family think to you using the services of a prostitute? And your workmates?

If it happened to be reported in a newspaper, what would you feel about that?
 
But who says that one has to live exclusively as a prostitute? Someone may simply do it sometimes, to make easy cash. Someone might prefer it as their occupation.
There's a serious flaw in this reasoning. Either it is easy cash, or it is not. If it is easy cash, why would someone do it 'sometimes' rather than as their main occupation? Conversely, if it is not seen as easy work, it is logical that people would do it 'sometimes'. More exactly: they would only do it when that was the only way to get the money.

Just learn how a market functions. If the demand is very high compared to the supply, the price is going to rise, and those who don't think it's worth that much money won't consider buying. The market finds an equilibrium. Just like the market for milk.
You don't seem to understand as much about markets as you think. First, sure, let's consider the milk market. As you may be aware, people in Sweden consume much more milk than in many other countries, such as Spain for example. Still, the milk price is actually slightly higher in Spain than it is in Sweden.

The reason people consume more milk in Sweden is because of attitudes. Specifically, we drink milk, which Spaniards seldom do.

It's the same thing with prostitution. Demand depends on attitudes. Prices are not simply a function of total demand, it's much more complicated than that. Specifically, we should not expect prices for prostitution to be higher in Denmark compared to Sweden because demand is higher in Denmark. Feel free to find data and disprove my reasoning if you wish.

However, my point was this. If our attitudes change, and it becomes socially accepted to buy sex, then many more men will do so. In fact, there is every reason to believe a very large percentage, perhaps the majority would do so at least during some part of their lives. Now simply consider the volume of sex acts that need to be produced. How is this going to happen? Mathematically, there are only two ways: either there are nearly as many people selling sex as there are people buying, or those who sell sex need to sell to a lot of people. Sure, one thing that could happen is that eventually prices go up and therefore the volume does not quite reach projected levels. It's possible. But as we can see from other countries where prostitution is more prevalent, it would not happen until the total prevalence has increased quite significantly.

So my argument is this: because we can be fairly sure that most women will not want to sell sex, even though there are certainly some women who want that, this means that either ideas of prostitution being a common and accepted practice is an unrealistic expectation, as I believe, or you would have to assume that those willing to sell sex would be willing to do take on an absolutely huge number of clients.

You seem to assume that people will be forced to do it.
No, I'm assuming that prostitution cannot become really accepted and common, because there is no way to meet that demand without coercion, which we will never accept.

Reading your posts, you seem to think that the authorities should promote virtue and prevent vice, and try to change people's attitudes into what you consider proper.
Absolute nonsense. I much prefer vice and I find 'virtue' or general ideas of what is 'proper' to be conservative baloney. There is simply no way you're going to find support for putting me into that category. I believe you are just trying to shoehorn me into that faction because you falsely assume that anyone who is opposed to prostitution must necessarily be some moralistic conservative at heart.

My value on the matter is based on the harm principle.
I don't think it is. I think you are rather engaging in wishful thinking: because you are generally opposed to government interference, you are predisposed to believe that prostitution is harmless, therefore you do not see the harm, even though the dispute among scholars is not if there is massive harm, but exactly how massive it is.

But it's virtually impossible to know such things. I hope you agree on that if one person rejects it the morning after, the sexual partner should not be prosecuted for rape.
Of course I agree. But I proposed a concrete remedy. Because it is virtually impossible to know who will change their mind, yet we know this happens and causes serious grief, we need another solution. My suggestion was to have a 2 week period of remorse, so that pornographers could not release the material unless they got a signature 2 weeks after recording. This would give pornographers incentive first of all to only use models that they had good reason to believe would not change their mind. It would also give them incentive to not throw new models into extensive sessions, but rather to try out with something quick which does not represent so much wasted investment if the model has a change of heart.

I think my proposal is very pragmatic. I would also point out that it is based on market principles: we do not burden the government with the task of finding out who will change their mind or not, but we rather leave this to independent parties on the market. We simply skew the market to provide an incentive away from seduction and exploitation.

But I don't see how it is relevant for the bigger discussion, as nobody is advocating that trafficking and sex slavery should be legalized.
I think it is relevant in part to explain my frustration with this debate. Proponents of prostitution seem to have an attitude of 'see no evil'. Perhaps I am mistaken and there is somewhere a reasonable proponent who does not immediately assume that every prostitute is happy and is acting completely voluntarily. But I have not found any.

I will of course readily grant that there are also many on the anti-prostitution side who will assume the reverse, that all prostitutes are miserable, helpless, and/or drug-addicted, and that no one ever comes out of the experience unharmed. But I think I have stressed very often in this thread that I do not believe this. If you are even trying to argue against what I say rather than what you expect me to say, you should not put me in that category.

But Russian roulette can kill you. Prostitution can't.
It can't? Murder, STDs, suicide, drug overdose.. yes it certainly can. Or I could argue that Russian roulette can't kill you, it's the brain damage that does it!

Just because the causal links A->B->C are more intricate does not mean they are not there. Besides, death is not the only societal ill worth regulating against, most of our criminal laws do not deal with things that kill a lot of people.

Why aren't you willing to think the same way about prostitution?
Because using alcohol is generally accepted, buying sex is not. Therefore, a ban on buying sex is realistic (as overwhelming public support proves), while banning alcohol is unrealistic, at least in Sweden. In some Muslim societies, there seems to be at least significant public support for very strict laws against alcohol. I don't know enough to say whether such laws are beneficial, but I won't dismiss the possibility.
 
Oh. Let's look at some figures then, from the Prostitution Law Review Committee:

Within the last 12 months:
- 3.0% had been raped
- 4.7% had been held against their will
- 9.8% had been physically assaulted
- 15.9% had been threatened with physical violence

Just another job, eh? Not horrible at all?

These statistics would have been more insightful if they compared them with how many non-prostitutes (women of course) that have been raped, 'held against their will', assaulted or threatened within the same time period. If the difference is negligible then i fail to see how working as a prostitute would be more 'risky' than not.
 
This board (and much of the free-thought movement) leans towards science, which is terrific. Both science and skepticism (defined as asking questions, not stating answers) offer very useful tools for discovering truths or testing a hypothesis. Unfortunately, what works for science is overly simplistic when it comes to philosophy. Pure reason is a game for psychopaths. Every complex problem has an easy solution if you distance it from emotion. Starving children? Let them die and there will be more food for the rest. It is simple, easy and morally abhorrent.


Lies, this is not the opinion of all persons engaged in the free movement. Things are more complex than you're making it. Everyone has different reasoning. How do we know if it’s a good thing to feed starving children? Or to try and stop a man or woman from being a prostitute. People inherently have free will and some people don't want to be helped, nor should you try.
 
Last edited:
There seem to be two camps here, as there usually are in these debates:

1) Prostitution should be legal, and this would have many benefits, including safety of the workers, control of disease, etc.
I find it interesting and a tad revealing that you start with 'prostitution should be legal', and then you come up with reasons to support this.
2) Prostitution is icky, bad, degrading, desperate, unpleasant, dangerous, or whatever.
I took out the parts that are subjective and/or conclusions. It's dangerous, and that is what makes it 'bad' (in toto), and often (but certainly not always) 'unpleasant', 'icky', 'degrading' or even (in the worst cases) 'desperate'.

What I see is that people in camp 2 seldom if ever argue why they think that then, therefore, prostitution should be illegal.
I don't actually believe prostitution should be illegal, I believe it should be illegal to buy but not to sell sex. Unfortunately, the OP, and the wiki article it references, classifies this as a ban on prostitution, even when it clearly is not, although for a lot of people who don't appear to have considered this very carefully, it might seem to be.
And so I point out other things that are icky, bad, degrading, desperate, unpleasant, dangerous, or whatever that people don't consider making illegal to show contrast.
I may have missed that, but there are two differences:
1. We should not legislate against people harming themselves. So even if something is extremely dangerous, such as base jumping.. well, it's a free society, it's your life. The situation is different when it is someone else that is being put into danger. A person buying sex is putting someone else into danger, and that is not acceptable.
2. It is the degree of harm. We cannot argue on principles alone. Throwing stones from a bridge over a highway probably will not kill anyone, yet we do not allow it, even if you don't intend to harm anyone. Mining is not perfectly safe, yet we do allow it, because at least in advanced societies the risks are actually not overwhelming.

Some people instantly resort by demanding that I 'prove' that prostitution is really so dangerous. I don't have time to do that, and I don't even claim to be able to do so conclusively. I can honestly say that I'm willing to change my mind. However, I will also say that I can't quite believe that people who argue that prostitution is 'just another job' have actually looked at any amount of serious research into the area. I find it easier to believe people whose argument is based on 'principles', and I find it more fruitful to debate such arguments.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom