If the Earth isn't 6,000 years old...

Where's Rikki Tikki Tavi when you need him
.
I read those stories many a year ago... and then, when I joined the Cub Scouts, I was appalled/irritated to see the American Indian boy whose experiences were being touted as things to do by us Cubs, was named Mowgli!
Made me suspect there was a crock of something in my future.
 
.
I read those stories many a year ago... and then, when I joined the Cub Scouts, I was appalled/irritated to see the American Indian boy whose experiences were being touted as things to do by us Cubs, was named Mowgli!
Made me suspect there was a crock of something in my future.

I remember the old Guinness Book of World Records had "the most successful postcard" or something like that, where the guy asks the girl, "How do you like Kippling?" and she says, "I don't know, you naughty boy, I've never kippled."

Always struck me odd as the most popular postcard of all time. I would have thought it would be the one with the big rabbit from Wall Drug or something.
 
I
It's not racism to make a true statement about a group of people. The ancient Hebrews were almost entirely illiterate. They had an oral history because of that fact. I've heard arguments that they likely made their living off of hearding goats, but 1) am aware that no culture can survive entirely in such a fashion (you need craftsmen and sedentary farmers, at minimum), and 2) am willing to be proven wrong here.

This statement isn't racism for another, more subtle reason, though: It wasn't JUST the Hebrews that were illiterate and largely herdsmen. EVERYONE in that time and in that place was. The Hebrews aren't singled out here; atheists don't believe what any of the other illiterate goat-herding tribes said either. The only difference is that no one expects us to take, say, the Babalonian religion seriously.
I object to say that "everyone was illiterate". For instance, the Babylonians had a quite profound understanding of mathematics that would not be misplaced in a nowadays highschool algebra class. See, e.g., this article on Pythagorean triples. The tablets discussed there predate any notion of Hebrew culture, which only arose after the Late Bronze Age Collapse (so calling them "bronze age goat herders" is technically incorrect).
 
I object to say that "everyone was illiterate". For instance, the Babylonians had a quite profound understanding of mathematics that would not be misplaced in a nowadays highschool algebra class

but the population on the whole were illiterate, to be able to read and write was a professionial vocation only available to the priestly classes. The same with math
;)
 
but the population on the whole were illiterate, to be able to read and write was a professionial vocation only available to the priestly classes. The same with math
;)

While I agree that such skills were not for the great unwashed masses, saying it was confined to the priestly class seems too confined to me. Ancient Babylon needed literate and math skills for its administration, taxation, for the planning and maintenance of irrigation systems etc., in short, it had a professional bureaucracy. From the British Museum:
School tablets have been found in almost all of the private houses in southern Mesopotamia of this date that have been excavated. This suggests that in wealthy families all the male children went to school.
 
Indeed.

And Christians understand this, but only when it comes to examining the beliefs of the other guy's religion. Then they quite suddenly become atheists, skeptics and critical thinkers regarding religious belief.

Exactly what happened to me.
 
While I agree that such skills were not for the great unwashed masses, saying it was confined to the priestly class seems too confined to me. Ancient Babylon needed literate and math skills for its administration, taxation, for the planning and maintenance of irrigation systems etc., in short, it had a professional bureaucracy.

The scribal schools were run by the priesthood and were associated with the God Nabu, the God of wisdom
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nabu
The administration was controlled by the priesthood as it served the King, the religious head of state
http://everything2.com/title/The+Babylonian+Priesthood
Taxation was controlled by the priesthood, tax was paid directly to the Temples, no trade was allowed without priestly overlook, just to make sure they got their cut. It was eventually priestly corruption which caused massive inflation which collapsed the civilisation.
http://www.campaigner-unbound.0catch.com/map_mediterranean_in_550_bc.htm
Planning and maintenance of irrigation systems was directly controlled by the priesthood as the temples owned most of the land. They rented the land out in parcels and took a percentage of the crop as taxation, citizens were regarded as tenants of gods. The penalties for failing to upkeep the irrigation was thus subject to religious law, which was severe, failing to maintain canals was punishable by death.
http://www.ancienttexts.org/library/mesopotamian/hammurabi.html
Even in the late period when Babylon was conquered by Cyrus the Persian, because of the tradition that no one could rule unless they had the divine right Cyrus had to meet the demands of the priesthood.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cyrus_Cylinder
The invention of the "cylinder seal" is a direct testament to the illiteracy of the culture, they were used in trade to identify the owner of goods by being rolled across a clay tablet which was then attached to the product. I've seen a few thousand of these in my time, I don't recall ever seeing one which didn't have a religious theme
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cylinder_seal
There were three classes, the amelu, the mushkenu and the wardu, the wardu were peasantry and slaves, the mushkenu were tradesmen, the amelu, were aristocracy, rich merchants and priests. This was true pretty much all over the ancient world, when religious fundamentalism is the norm, the priesthood is much more important, second only to Royalty and the Gods.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Babylonian_law#Three_classes

From your same British museum link,
Finally the pupil reached the stage of learning and writing Sumerian literature.
Sumerian literature is concerned mainly with the antics of the Gods, this was the last thing that scribes learned, this set them up for what type of career ?

Any way you look at it, from the top on down, religion was the main impetus for Mesopotamian civilisation, as belief in the Gods controlled the masses and the masses on the whole were illiterate, this is what Dinwar was talking about earlier, what we've proven here is that a very small percentage of the most civilised culture in the entire world at the time were literate, that was never really the question though was it, Dinwar was talking about the Hebrews being illiterate. We only got onto the subject of Babylon because of this statement
The only difference is that no one expects us to take, say, the Babalonian religion seriously.
Of course he's right, who'd take a religion seriously when its God never sent any floods, plagues and which didn't have a devil or hell
:D
 
Last edited:
In the May 21 issue, Humbaba was mistakenly identified as the secretary of Housing and Urban Development. He is actually the guardian of the Cedar Forest who was slain by the Sumerian hero-king Gilgamesh. The Onion regrets the error.
:D
 
I object to say that "everyone was illiterate". For instance, the Babylonians had a quite profound understanding of mathematics that would not be misplaced in a nowadays highschool algebra class.

Fair enough. I should have said "Nearly everyone was illiterate". The point's the same, though: it's not racist to point out that most Jews back then were illiterate, for precisely the same reason that it's not racist to say that most blacks in America have driver's licenses.

This raises an interesting archaeological question: Is there any evidence that any Hebrews of the time were literate? The presence of an oral history tends to suggest not, but it's not necessarily the case.
 
This raises an interesting archaeological question: Is there any evidence that any Hebrews of the time were literate? The presence of an oral history tends to suggest not, but it's not necessarily the case.

the claims for an oral history are based on the gap between God handing the law to Moses and it later appearing in the old testament. without a claim for an oral history, the divine origin of miuch of the old testament is invalid.
The term Halakha LeMoshe MiSinai, literally "Law [given] to Moses from Sinai", is used in classical Rabbinical literature to refer to oral law regarded as having been of direct Divine origin, transmitted to Moses at Mount Sinai at the same time as the written Torah, but not included in the Oral Torah's exposition of it. It is distinguished from the written Torah, on the one hand, and Rabbinical decrees, customs, and other man-made laws on the other hand.
As we know for a fact that this didn't happen the claim that the Hebrews had an oral history is nonsense. Written Hebrew didn't exist until 1100bce at the earliest. The oldest bible stories date from 700BCE and are well known to be derived from cultures which had a written language from 2500 years earlier.

so were the Hebrews illiterate, no not really, Hebrew is a linguistical definition, not a racial one. Nothing was stopping them from writing in Akkadian, every other culture of the time did, it was the lingua franca of that period of ancient history.

The claim of illiterate goat herders only stands up for the main population, in the same way that any peasant population were illiterate, the Rabbis were always literate, that was why they were called "Master" and why they were employed as translators by different civilisations.
;)
 
Last edited:
...then doesn't that make the Old Testament account of 'creation' in Genesis absolutely wrong as a point of fact?

And if there was no 'fall of man' as described in that story, then doesn't that mean there was no 'original sin' which is stamped onto every human being since that time?

And if there is no 'original sin' that man as a 'kind' (as the religious use the term) is guilty of, then isn't it then true that there is no need for Jesus to come and 'save' anyone from it?

And if that's the case, then isn't the entire salvation doctrine of Christianity null and void?

If the Earth isn't 6,000 years old, doesn't' that present a raft of theological problems for a whole swath of believers?
Correct. The bible is wrong and the morality in many places is bad. Very bad. If god exists I feel that its humans who need to forgive him instead of the other way around. If God exists he is responsible for all of mans problems and pain.
 
First of all, thanks for the lesson, Marduk, about Babylonian society.
the claims for an oral history are based on the gap between God handing the law to Moses and it later appearing in the old testament. without a claim for an oral history, the divine origin of miuch of the old testament is invalid.

As we know for a fact that this didn't happen the claim that the Hebrews had an oral history is nonsense. Written Hebrew didn't exist until 1100bce at the earliest. The oldest bible stories date from 700BCE and are well known to be derived from cultures which had a written language from 2500 years earlier.

so were the Hebrews illiterate, no not really, Hebrew is a linguistical definition, not a racial one. Nothing was stopping them from writing in Akkadian, every other culture of the time did, it was the lingua franca of that period of ancient history.

The claim of illiterate goat herders only stands up for the main population, in the same way that any peasant population were illiterate, the Rabbis were always literate, that was why they were called "Master" and why they were employed as translators by different civilisations.
;)

However, the Kings and Chronicles part of the Bible - about the Two Kingdoms - seems to be grounded in history, and that history spans back to 900-1000 BC. How do you reconcile that with the earliest stories being written around 700 BC without oral history?

Secondly, while Egypt and Mesopotamia have given us an abundance of written material in the period, there's a deafening silence in that respect from the Holy Land. How comes?
 
...then doesn't that make the Old Testament account of 'creation' in Genesis absolutely wrong as a point of fact?

And if there was no 'fall of man' as described in that story, then doesn't that mean there was no 'original sin' which is stamped onto every human being since that time?

And if there is no 'original sin' that man as a 'kind' (as the religious use the term) is guilty of, then isn't it then true that there is no need for Jesus to come and 'save' anyone from it?

And if that's the case, then isn't the entire salvation doctrine of Christianity null and void?

If the Earth isn't 6,000 years old, doesn't' that present a raft of theological problems for a whole swath of believers?

No, the book is considered by many to be allegorical. Skeptics who interpret it litteral are as silly as the fundies who do. Next topic.....
 
No, the book is considered by many to be allegorical. Skeptics who interpret it litteral are as silly as the fundies who do. Next topic.....

I don't interpret it literally.

It was a challenge to the Fundies that do, and beyond that, a challenge to the essential dogma of the religion itself (even if taken allegorically).
 
No, the book is considered by many to be allegorical. Skeptics who interpret it litteral are as silly as the fundies who do. Next topic.....

Nice straw man. That aside, what you're saying is essentially "Even if you disprove everything the book says I'm gonna believe it anyway", at least to an outside reader. This creates something of a problem. Further, it makes it impossible to actually convince anyone that the Bible is worth the paper it's written on, because it sets up a condition where you have to accept what it says before you read it.
 
I don't interpret it literally.

It was a challenge to the Fundies that do, and beyond that, a challenge to the essential dogma of the religion itself (even if taken allegorically).

yes you do, and I'm telling
 
No, the book is considered by many to be allegorical.

But god said that it was his true and infallible word. The bible doesn't say ''and god created the earth in six days but you guys do realize that this is an allegory, right?'' If a person considers it to be allegorical then they are not a true Christian.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom