If the Earth isn't 6,000 years old...

But god said that it was his true and infallible word.

Which it of course doesn't do. Nowhere in the Bible does it say that the Bible consists of the following texts, and no others, all of which are the divinely inspired infallible literally-interpreted word of God. That's a meta-belief about the Bible, which is constructed out of nothing in particular.

The bible doesn't say ''and god created the earth in six days but you guys do realize that this is an allegory, right?'' If a person considers it to be allegorical then they are not a true Christian.

I love the atheists deciding who the true Christians are. Sorry, St. Augustine - some good stuff there, but you fail on Biblical symbolism.
 
I love the atheists deciding who the true Christians are. Sorry, St. Augustine - some good stuff there, but you fail on Biblical symbolism.
Just a quick question, then.

Is the Bible fallible?
 
westprog said:
I love the atheists deciding who the true Christians are.
Probably about as much as we scientists love it when non-scientists like yourself tell us what we can and cannot talk about. When you stop doing that, maybe we'll stop reminding you Christians of what your religion states.
 
I love the atheists deciding who the true Christians are. Sorry, St. Augustine - some good stuff there, but you fail on Biblical symbolism.

Certainly can't be worse than christians deciding who the true christians are.
 
Which it of course doesn't do. Nowhere in the Bible does it say that the Bible consists of the following texts, and no others, all of which are the divinely inspired infallible literally-interpreted word of God. That's a meta-belief about the Bible, which is constructed out of nothing in particular.



I love the atheists deciding who the true Christians are. Sorry, St. Augustine - some good stuff there, but you fail on Biblical symbolism.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chicago_Statement_on_Biblical_Inerrancy

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dei_Verbum

Seems there are quite a few church leaders who favour infallibility.

Too bad God forgot to include a table of contents.
Too bad God forgot to shield the scores of copyists from making errors.
Too bad God forgot to include a map and a title deed to the "Holy Land" for the Jews advancing that argument.

Pretty crappy guy, that God, for someone who's supposed to be omnipotent. :rolleyes:
 
I love the atheists deciding who the true Christians are. Sorry, St. Augustine - some good stuff there, but you fail on Biblical symbolism.

I'm not too well up on the symbolism of any collection of fairy stories. Reality is good enough for me.
 
Certainly can't be worse than christians deciding who the true christians are.

That might be annoying and silly, but it at least makes some kind of sense. The footballers get to set the rules of football, and say that if you throw the ball through a hoop, it isn't football. When the local golf club posts it's opinion, it's a bit silly.
 
Probably about as much as we scientists love it when non-scientists like yourself tell us what we can and cannot talk about. When you stop doing that, maybe we'll stop reminding you Christians of what your religion states.

So you're claiming that science is a private area for scientists only?
 
That might be annoying and silly, but it at least makes some kind of sense. The footballers get to set the rules of football, and say that if you throw the ball through a hoop, it isn't football. When the local golf club posts it's opinion, it's a bit silly.

Since when were sports based on the story of a dead guy coming back to life?
 
So you're claiming that science is a private area for scientists only?

No, only for those who actually know something about the subject. Visit some creationist sites and you will soon discover that their knowledge of science could be written on the back of a postage stamp.
 
That might be annoying and silly, but it at least makes some kind of sense. The footballers get to set the rules of football, and say that if you throw the ball through a hoop, it isn't football. When the local golf club posts it's opinion, it's a bit silly.

Problem is, the presbyterians want a different sort of ball, the pentecostalists want a talking ball, the baptists want to constantly wash the ball, and the catholics want to eat the ball.
 
No, only for those who actually know something about the subject. Visit some creationist sites and you will soon discover that their knowledge of science could be written on the back of a postage stamp.

That's not what he said.
 
Problem is, the presbyterians want a different sort of ball, the pentecostalists want a talking ball, the baptists want to constantly wash the ball, and the catholics want to eat the ball.

And in the past they have often killed each other to prove that they have the true ball.
 
westprog, care to take a stab at my question to you?

You want me to tell you what to think? Surely it's a matter of your own opinion. Or mine. Are you going to change your mind according to what I tell you?

I will answer your question by repeating that there are very wide differences among Christians as to the fallibility and literal truth of the Bible.
 
Problem is, the presbyterians want a different sort of ball, the pentecostalists want a talking ball, the baptists want to constantly wash the ball, and the catholics want to eat the ball.

It's still absurd to wander in and tell them they are all wrong, but that one lot of them are right.
 
So you're claiming that science is a private area for scientists only?
No, I'm not, and you know it.

I'm claiming that only those participating in a group have a right to determine what that group is, and that those who violate that are not, by any rational definition, a member of that group. If you want to define what science is, become a scientist. It's fairly hard, and you're going to run into reviewers and colleagues that make me look downright polite and courteous, but it's hardly impossible. Trying to define categories of questions that science can't answer from the outside, which is your usual MO, is going to upset scientists--for precisely the same reason that trying to define, say, Catholicism is going to annoy Catholics.

That's not what he said.
Neither is what you posted, so let's not get snippy about pedantic issues, shall we? Otherwise, people like me might be tempted to get snippy with you, and all of the errors and flat-out heresies you've committed.

That might be annoying and silly, but it at least makes some kind of sense. The footballers get to set the rules of football, and say that if you throw the ball through a hoop, it isn't football. When the local golf club posts it's opinion, it's a bit silly.
So you're claiming that football is a private area for football players only? :boggled:

Seems you understand the concept I'm getting at perfectly well, but refuse to apply that concept to science.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom