If the Earth isn't 6,000 years old...

If you are seriously suggesting that moral and metaphysical issues should be left to scientists to decide, I think you should ask the scientists if they want the job. I certainly am not prepared to cede authority to anyone else to decide such issues for me.

I'm saying who, if anyone, can produce such evidence to investigate moral and metaphysical issues. You say with certainty that it's not scientists, but then...who else? I'm not saying to leave it to scientists let alone science itself to answer them. But they sure as hell can investigate it better than a philosopher could, or a religious figure. I don't see how you can dismiss it so quickly in favor of...what exactly? Seriously what makes such issues immune to scientific inquiry?
 
Last edited:
Sepp Blatter doesn't agree with that. Also, there's no evidence he actually likes the game. :boxedin:

(sorry, couldn't resist)

I'd sooner have Dinwar running football according to scientific principles than Sepp Blatter.
 
Because you have lots to tell 'the atheists' on the boards. So it's only fair you tell us a bit about what you think.

I'm telling you what I think. You're asking what I believe - which is irrelevant.

Is it so hard to tell the readers whether or not you think the Bible is fallible?

Kind of a yes or no question.



Heh.

Every yes or no question has more than two answers.
 
Completely disingenuous. I was referring to your statements to the effect that whether gods exist is not a question scientists can address.

Which remains perfectly true. That's a metaphysical issue.
 
I'm saying who, if anyone, can produce such evidence to investigate moral and metaphysical issues. You say with certainty that it's not scientists, but then...who else? I'm not saying to leave it to scientists let alone science itself to answer them. But they sure as hell can investigate it better than a philosopher could, or a religious figure. I don't see how you can dismiss it so quickly in favor of...what exactly? Seriously what makes such issues immune to scientific inquiry?

I find the concept of scientists running moral experiments, or publishing metaphysical papers perfectly ludicrous. I can't think of any examples of scientists producing moral insights that a layperson couldn't come up with. If you can, please indicate.

Naturally, scientists can produce science which has moral implications. They are no better fitted to produce moral guidance than anyone else.
 
I find the concept of scientists running moral experiments, or publishing metaphysical papers perfectly ludicrous. I can't think of any examples of scientists producing moral insights that a layperson couldn't come up with. If you can, please indicate.

Naturally, scientists can produce science which has moral implications. They are no better fitted to produce moral guidance than anyone else.

I'm sure you find it ludicrous. I'm not suggesting that a scientist can provide moral accuracy, but can investigate it, quantify it and then say "our calculation say this is better" not correct, but better. I don't find it ludicrous in the least and I have a hard time seeing how you do. That's what science does, and morality doesn't seem immune to it. You haven't brought any case of immunity of morality from scientific investigation.

How does metaphysics provide sound conclusions over science in this case? At the very least they're both equivalent in their quests but at least science has the rigor and tools to maintain veracity. Oh BTW, science =! scientists so I'd appreciate you not equivocating the two. Science is a method, much like metaphysics.
 
Last edited:
You want me to tell you what to think? Surely it's a matter of your own opinion. Or mine. Are you going to change your mind according to what I tell you?

I will answer your question by repeating that there are very wide differences among Christians as to the fallibility and literal truth of the Bible.

Another evasion noted. You are not interested in a real discussion. You are merely trolling.
 
Another evasion noted. You are not interested in a real discussion. You are merely trolling.

I'm engaging in the discussion. Stating my "beliefs" add nothing to it.

I fully understand why you'd rather not debate my position. If I could be induced to produce some half-baked insupportable proposition, it could be nicely shot down. That might be fun for you but what would I get out of it.

I decide my position according to what I consider to be objectively true. What I believe to be true might have no evidence to support it whatsoever. Why would I put forward "beliefs" to try to further an argument? I have no interest in "defending" my beliefs. Why should I? My opinions are another matter. My beliefs might have no basis at all.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom