If the Earth isn't 6,000 years old...

.
Some of the rules they lived by are still universal.

Precisely. That's what's important about it.

Others were barbaric, and not usually followed today.

Most of the rules dealt with issues of hygeine, plus assorted prejudices. Largely to be found in Leviticus.

And the supernatural stuff is just silly.

Without the supernatural, there's no particular basis for the rules, except utility.
 
Precisely. That's what's important about it.



Most of the rules dealt with issues of hygeine, plus assorted prejudices. Largely to be found in Leviticus.



Without the supernatural, there's no particular basis for the rules, except utility.
.
That "utility" has a name... functioning society.
No rules no society.
Ever read the Code of Hammurabi? Older than the OT, it is.
 
If I'd wanted to say that, I'd have said that. If we are discussing the influence of the illiterate goat-herders, then that includes Judaism, Christianity and Islam - all of whom consider Mosaic law as more or less binding. If you can point to a corresponding religious/moral code that lists most of the precepts now generally accepted in such a compact form as the Ten Commandments, I'd like to see it.

Really?

Hammurabi's Code, the golden rule...all of Taoism and Confucianism (and some would say the works of Sun Tzu)? Jainism, Mohism, Baha'i, Hinduism, buddhism...do you get the idea? Is it that it could fit in a paragraph that makes it profound? Is that the ultimate test here? Hey if that's the case then the Native Americans probably had one even more succint, as per their style.

One can try to shoehorn right and wrong into an atheist philosophy, but it's a difficult business. In the end, Christian and atheist morality is usually founded on the same principle - other people matter.

Christian morality is concerned with the judgment of afterlife for transgressions of now. Atheists are only concerned with now (and possibly the future of humanity; depends on the person sometimes). If anything the Christians steal the atheist philosophy* and add onto it. To say that it's a "difficult business" is absurd.

*It is unfair to say its the atheist philosophy as it echoes more of humanism. Humanism is atheistic in philosophy however, as is the Golden Rule.
 
Last edited:
The claim that the bible is a scientific text dictated by god is clearly debunked. However, many of the moral rules starting with the decalogue remain appropriate guidelines today, even among atheists.

I dont think one could seriously claim that the bible is a/the source of those appropriate moralities.

It would be like me drawing a 747 and then claiming the design as my own.
 
Check out Chinese culture sometime, westprog. I'm pretty sure they got along just fine without Moses and Abraham. They even had laws against killing and stealing and such that were every bit as binding as those of the Big Three! And Hamurabi's Code, written by a pagan with no influence from the Abrahamic traditions, includes many of the precepts. And again, the Iroquois had a moral and political system that made Christianity of the time look downright brutal (much of the Constitution and the foundational documents for the United States was modeled, not off of anything in Christiandom, but off of that pagan nation, and the Founding Fathers were quite open about it).

The reason the moral code seems influential is because people recognize the universality of the valid precepts and ignore the rest. That doesn't make the code influential; it merely means that people generally realize that a society based on theft, murder, and the like won't function.

If you want to prove that your list of rules had a significant influence, prove that the ruels that AREN'T unviersal were commonly held by cultures after encountering your religion, but not before that. If the other cultures only accept the ideas they already accepted anyway, your religion isn't influential. The other culture just adopted the name for tax purposes, so to speak.

One can try to shoehorn right and wrong into an atheist philosophy, but it's a difficult business.
No, it's not. And morality need not be based on altruism. Objectivism, love it or hate it, disproved both notions (that atheism cannot have a moral code, and that altruism is necessarily the foundation of morality).

Without the supernatural, there's no particular basis for the rules, except utility.
GIBHOR is trying to argue that in another thread. It's not going well at all for him, and it's not going to go well for you either. Theists who try to argue that atheism cannot be moral (which is what you're very carefully dancing around to avoid saying, but which is what you almost certainly mean) tend to get cheesed in these debates.
 
OK, so if you agree with me that God - the all-good, all-benevolent wonderbeing - created the lord of all evil, lies and malice, then we have to ask a follow-up: WHY? Why not just create a perfect Eden-like existence for humankind and just leave it at that?

Because the inhabitants of the matrix crashed the program.
 
GIBHOR is trying to argue that in another thread. It's not going well at all for him, and it's not going to go well for you either. Theists who try to argue that atheism cannot be moral (which is what you're very carefully dancing around to avoid saying, but which is what you almost certainly mean) tend to get cheesed in these debates.

*rolls up sleeves*

Do I have to start this noise again?
 
.
One of the things the Gutenburg Bible achieved was letting the illiterate (non-Latin speaking) population read what's there, in their language.

No, it didn't as you are confusing Gutenberg with Luther. Gutenberg printed his major works in Latin as he intended to sell them to the already-established market of monasteries and churches (for Bible) and university students (for Donatus). He printed some texts in German but they were mostly short pamphlets.
 
No, it didn't as you are confusing Gutenberg with Luther. Gutenberg printed his major works in Latin as he intended to sell them to the already-established market of monasteries and churches (for Bible) and university students (for Donatus). He printed some texts in German but they were mostly short pamphlets.
.
OK.
I'd heard it as popularizing the text, which led to Luther's event.
 
How do we know Moses even existed.........where is the evdence outside of the Bible, which in itself as only a religioustract, is not reliable as a source of historical fact
 
How do we know Moses even existed.........where is the evdence outside of the Bible, which in itself as only a religioustract, is not reliable as a source of historical fact

That's one of the central issues. If you're a believer, the Bible itself is sufficient evidence. If you're not, there's nothing else to support it. There's actually a fair bit to contradict the Biblical story (Mr. Dunning has done a wonderful job showing that the popular [and incorrect] version of the Hebrews making pyramids is wrong, and also mentions some of the evidence that the Hebrews-were-Egyptial-slaves thing is silly).

Simply put, the evidence is only there if you already believe it's there. If you don't already believe it, it won't convince you.
 
There is no Flanders bible belt and I feel sorry for the country that has one.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bible_Belt_%28Netherlands%29. Sniff. And the government pays for religious schools.

We also had a Catholic minister of Education a couple of years ago who blogged that she found ID an "interesting idea". Yes, that seemed out of character for me too for a catholic. Fortunately, the discussion was fairly quickly shot down.

As to talking snakes: in 1926, the Reformed Churches in the Netherlands decided at a synod that the passage was to be taken literally, and the church split over that issue. This is serious stuff we're discussing! :D
 
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bible_Belt_%28Netherlands%29. Sniff. And the government pays for religious schools.

We also had a Catholic minister of Education a couple of years ago who blogged that she found ID an "interesting idea". Yes, that seemed out of character for me too for a catholic. Fortunately, the discussion was fairly quickly shot down.

As to talking snakes: in 1926, the Reformed Churches in the Netherlands decided at a synod that the passage was to be taken literally, and the church split over that issue. This is serious stuff we're discussing! :D

We snakes can, of course, talk it's just that after that incident in the garden we've found it better to keep silent.

tsig*

*talking snake in the grass
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom