If the Earth isn't 6,000 years old...

That is very likely the case. However, this was where they were explicitly laid out, and the fact of laying the rules out may have been of some value and influence. It shows that regardless of their technological backwardness, those goatherders might well have had something to offer.


Yep, like how hard to beat your slave. Like 'Don't worry what goes in your mouth'. Like 'Don't worry for the morrow'.
Nice.:boggled:
 
It also doesn't mean that it's morally superior. And as I've said before, if you're comfortable with a god that's omnipotent and omniscient but can't take the time to explain something as simple as "No, no, lobsters are different from fish--see? No bones", that's fine. But to anyone outside of your belief, it looks exactly like what would happen if a bunch of people with no knowledge of the issue wrote a book pretending it was authored by their god.

Added emphasis because that's the heart of the matter.
 
Mine is not -- we try to get back to the root languages as much as we can.

I entirely accept that. I'm talking in generalities - and part of my point is that there's a wide range of interpretations, even when supposedly literal.
 
But to anyone outside of your belief, it looks exactly like what would happen if a bunch of people with no knowledge of the issue wrote a book pretending it was authored by their god.

Added emphasis because that's the heart of the matter.
Indeed.

And Christians understand this, but only when it comes to examining the beliefs of the other guy's religion. Then they quite suddenly become atheists, skeptics and critical thinkers regarding religious belief.
 
So why the need for salvation, then?

If humans after 'the fall' were not created in sin, then (as another poster said) Jesus is really irrelevant.

Do you believe that? If not, what are your beliefs on this point?

Can't you both have sin and a need for salvation without either Christianity or the Bible?
 
I don't know - can you?

I am asking you.

The reason I'm asking is that there are non-biblical and non-religious books, movies, plays, works of art, etc concerned with the issues of personal salvation or personal redemption with the intercession of quasi-authority figures. I have to assume they're not all inspired by the book of Genesis as some of them were likely written prior to that work.
 
I am asking you.

The reason I'm asking is that there are non-biblical and non-religious books, movies, plays, works of art, etc concerned with the issues of personal salvation or personal redemption with the intercession of quasi-authority figures. I have to assume they're not all inspired by the book of Genesis as some of them were likely written prior to that work.
Gimme a few examples of this, if you could.
 
Gimme a few examples of this, if you could.

How about Dashiel Hammett's The Maltese Falcon? I would think you'd be able to locate vast shelves of examples at the library. The "bad guy" experiences a life-changing event at the climax and things get better for him afterwards. I could probably write a short example myself for you if you'd like.
 
How about Dashiel Hammett's The Maltese Falcon? I would think you'd be able to locate vast shelves of examples at the library. The "bad guy" experiences a life-changing event at the climax and things get better for him afterwards. I could probably write a short example myself for you if you'd like.
Or maybe Javert from Les Mis?

Wait...maybe that's a bad example.

;)
 
If you take it as a bundle of mythological stories and cosmological errata then it's of no particular value, that's true. The insights offered are ethical, if anything. I'm not aware of similarly sourced guidelines being as influential.

Really? You're not aware of ANY cultures that have thrived and now include billions of people without the influence of Christianity? None at all?

I'm sorry, but this says far more about your biases than about the world as it is.

It shows that regardless of their technological backwardness, those goatherders might well have had something to offer.
What? Don't kill, don't steal, and the rest of the instructions that are considered universal were written down numerous times throughout the ages, from Ur to the Forbidden City to the Iroquois Nation, often without the benefit of the Bible or even anything like the book. The things truly unique to the Abrahamic religions are precisely those things which most people ignore--rules for preparing food, rules for running households, etc. And the good stuff is lost in so much dross that it's not, from the perspective of a non-believer, worth wading through. You can get better moral instructions from Transmetropolitan and a better story from Atlas Shrugged.

stilicho said:
Can't you both have sin and a need for salvation without either Christianity or the Bible?
Yes. Islam and the Jewish faith both include concepts such as sin. Leviticus gives the types of sacrifices to be made for different transgressions, for example. If you want to play the game AvalonXQ is playing and define "sin" as only that which has the word "sin" attached to it than no, sin is a Christian concept; however, if you want to look at it from a more defensible standpoint (ie, sin is some moral transgression) than you don't even need theism for the concept to be valid. While Objectivism won't call it sin the philosophy certainly recognizes the concept of moral transgression, for example.

The reason I'm asking is that there are non-biblical and non-religious books, movies, plays, works of art, etc concerned with the issues of personal salvation or personal redemption with the intercession of quasi-authority figures.
No kidding. It's one of the few main concepts we can build stories around--someone screws up and makes up for it. It's right up there with "Boy meets girl" and "Hero with 1,000 Faces".
 
To paraphrase the inestimable Jonathan Meades:
... Christian mythology, which claims to be other than mythology, decrees that this Earth - mountains, oceans, and all - was created by the one God in six days. Fair enough, we all know the lad's got a great engine on him; his 100% work-rate; a celestial Scholesy1. But what if God's day is anyone else's couple of million years? What if his conception of clock time and calendars does not correspond to the mundane artifices invented by emperors, popes, and Swiss-watch makers?

The quaint misattribution of the Earth's provenance, the denial of fact in favour of creation myth should not bother us - for the wonders of evolution are far more subtle and far more fascinating than the coarse fabrications of those repositories of ignorance called sacred texts. Forgivable two thousand years ago, as a means of trying to understand our physical environment, but quite inexcusable today.

(1) Paul Scholes is a notably dedicated, hard-working English soccer player
 
Last edited:
That is very likely the case. However, this was where they were explicitly laid out, and the fact of laying the rules out may have been of some value and influence. It shows that regardless of their technological backwardness, those goatherders might well have had something to offer.
.
Some of the rules they lived by are still universal.
Others were barbaric, and not usually followed today.
And the supernatural stuff is just silly.
 
Really? You're not aware of ANY cultures that have thrived and now include billions of people without the influence of Christianity? None at all?

If I'd wanted to say that, I'd have said that. If we are discussing the influence of the illiterate goat-herders, then that includes Judaism, Christianity and Islam - all of whom consider Mosaic law as more or less binding. If you can point to a corresponding religious/moral code that lists most of the precepts now generally accepted in such a compact form as the Ten Commandments, I'd like to see it.

I'm sorry, but this says far more about your biases than about the world as it is.

What? Don't kill, don't steal, and the rest of the instructions that are considered universal were written down numerous times throughout the ages, from Ur to the Forbidden City to the Iroquois Nation, often without the benefit of the Bible or even anything like the book. The things truly unique to the Abrahamic religions are precisely those things which most people ignore--rules for preparing food, rules for running households, etc. And the good stuff is lost in so much dross that it's not, from the perspective of a non-believer, worth wading through. You can get better moral instructions from Transmetropolitan and a better story from Atlas Shrugged.

I do not claim that the injunctions of the Bible were unique or unprecedented. However, as a moral code, (as opposed to a legal one) it's certainly influential. I can't think of an equivalent to the Ten Commandments in the other major religions, though.

Of course the precepts are universal. That doesn't mean that it wasn't worth while listing them down.

Yes. Islam and the Jewish faith both include concepts such as sin. Leviticus gives the types of sacrifices to be made for different transgressions, for example. If you want to play the game AvalonXQ is playing and define "sin" as only that which has the word "sin" attached to it than no, sin is a Christian concept; however, if you want to look at it from a more defensible standpoint (ie, sin is some moral transgression) than you don't even need theism for the concept to be valid. While Objectivism won't call it sin the philosophy certainly recognizes the concept of moral transgression, for example.

One can try to shoehorn right and wrong into an atheist philosophy, but it's a difficult business. In the end, Christian and atheist morality is usually founded on the same principle - other people matter.

No kidding. It's one of the few main concepts we can build stories around--someone screws up and makes up for it. It's right up there with "Boy meets girl" and "Hero with 1,000 Faces".
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom