westprog said:
That's what metaphysical means.
And it's quite convenient that you get to define the term, at least under your rules, isn't it?
You mean, when it comes down to it "in a way that can be detected by science".
It's even more convenient that you get to dictate the opposition's argument to them. If you couldn't, you may have to actually discuss things with people!
"Science", by the way, isn't some tool you use to detect things. It's systematic and rigorous observation, coupled with experimentation (either actual experiments or observation of natural experiments). So when something isn't "detectable by science" that means that it changes every time it's observed, or at least so frequently that no conclusions can be drawn from it. It's a thing without a definition, without form--without existence.
Except that in this case, you prefer to do the opposite. Rather than consider the entire gamut of biblical analysis by Christians, you prefer to stick with a literalist interpretation that has never been part of mainstream Christianity. And when contfronted with the facts, you tell us you don't care anyway.
100% bovine excrament. I tend to go by what the RCC states. The RCC has the longest tradition of Biblical interpretation, after all, and it's the one I know best. When someone argues for Creationism, yes, I expect them to be Biblical literalist--there's no other options, not to an honest person. But after that, I either differ to them on their beliefs and merely point out the inconsistencies (at which point people like you scream that I'm telling them what they believe), or I go by what others who have studied the Bible believe it to say (at which point I'm called a liar).
Good to know that your only argument is to dump poison in the well, though. You can't attack my reasons directly, so you try to imply (without any supporting evidence) that my arguments are dishonest. Here's a helpful hint: even if the argument is dishonest, if it's right it's right.
And so you construct a totally mythical, non-existent field of scientific analysis of ethical issues.
Right. Because psychology and the like are mythical. I'm sure the psychologists I know would LOVE to hear that!
You are, as usual, merely making crap up, westprog. I've had enough of that recently, and don't wish to add to the pile of cow manuer I'm forced to wade through. If you wish to play these games, I wish you all the best of luck--I will not participate further. Your dishonesty and shameful debate tactics are perfectly clear for anyone who wishes to see them. Good day, sir.