If the Earth isn't 6,000 years old...

Backing up a bit-
The only Christian litteralist I *ever* encoutnered were american. It thus make sense to discuss the absurdity of litteralism with them. So I dispute your"atheist insist on biblical innerancy". It is actually a reaction to christian "literalist". ...

Nigeria has a fair number of christian literalists.
Try the religion section at the Nairaland forum if you want a good time.
 
Which remains perfectly true. That's a metaphysical issue.

Convenient. Simply define anything as "metaphysical" when you don't want science to touch it.

Of course, that means admitting that your god doesn't interact with the universe in any meaningful or consistent way. But that's a small price to pay for defining yourself into being correct.

SezMe said:
westprog, party of one! westprog, party of one!
That really is the insurmountable problem people like westprog, Gaetan, GIBHOR, AvalonXQ, and others always run into: they are the only ones who interpret their holy book the way they do. This doesn't make them wrong, necessarily; but it does require them to explain why they're right, while 2k years of intense study of their holy books has failed to yield the correct results. In science, this is relatively easy: we simply show the data. In mysticism it's impossible--as westprog has demonstrated, the very concept of mysticism removes the possibility of any systematic analysis of the issues at hand.

So those of us who don't believe are left with two choices when it comes to figuring out how to interpret these holy books: take the word of some individual who breaks from all tradition, or take the word of the experts who've devoted their lives to studying the book in question and the commentaries on said book.

westprog said:
I can't think of any examples of scientists producing moral insights that a layperson couldn't come up with. If you can, please indicate.
Game Theory. Reciprocal Altruism. The Prisoner's Dilemma. Neurobiology. Psychology.

Allow me to re-write your post to its equivalent in another field, so that you can get a sense of what you sound like to other people: "I can't think of any examples of scientists producing medical insight that a layperson couldn't come up with. If you can, please indicate." What you're saying is that a systematic and rigorous examination of morality cannot yield any insights, but a disorganized, haphazard analysis based entirely on anecdotes will. I cannot imagine what would justify such a position, I really can't. What field could POSSIBLY suffer when examined rigorously and systematically? Answer: Only those fields which don't have any validity anyway.
 
Trolling. On ignore you go.

Yes. I note that this little diversion has achieved its primary aim - to avoid dealing with my actual unanswered arguments. I gave a very clear statement of my thoughts on the topic. I can see why addressing those arguments wouldn't be to your taste. However, dodging and hiding isn't so unusual. I won't answer that because I already answered it. Because that's wasting time. Because the thread is off-topic. Because religion is so silly I don't bother to be accurate.

Stick your head over the parapet, lob something and run away.
 
I fully understand why you'd rather not debate my position. If I could be induced to produce some half-baked insupportable proposition, it could be nicely shot down. That might be fun for you but what would I get out of it.
The realization that your position is half-baked, and thus needs adjustment? The only reason you don't want to put forward your beliefs I can think of is that you're actually unsure of them but are afraid to be confronted with that.
 
The realization that your position is half-baked, and thus needs adjustment? The only reason you don't want to put forward your beliefs I can think of is that you're actually unsure of them but are afraid to be confronted with that.

That hits the nail on the head.
 
The realization that your position is half-baked, and thus needs adjustment? The only reason you don't want to put forward your beliefs I can think of is that you're actually unsure of them but are afraid to be confronted with that.

Well, you carry on psychoanalysing. I'm sure you'll end up being reassured, which is the object of the exercise. You can pretend that I'm not engaging with the argument, and feel good about yourself. Why else would you be here?

What I find particularly *****ng hilarious is that given the number of posts complaining about Christians forcing their beliefs down people's throats, when someone tries to debate objectively and dispassionately, it gets them upset.
 
Last edited:
Convenient. Simply define anything as "metaphysical" when you don't want science to touch it.

That's what metaphysical means.

Of course, that means admitting that your god doesn't interact with the universe in any meaningful or consistent way. But that's a small price to pay for defining yourself into being correct.

What do you mean "meaningful"? You mean, when it comes down to it "in a way that can be detected by science". Of course it's inherent in a personal god that behaviour won't be consistent. If a god interacted with the universe in a consistent and detectable way,

That really is the insurmountable problem people like westprog, Gaetan, GIBHOR, AvalonXQ, and others always run into: they are the only ones who interpret their holy book the way they do. This doesn't make them wrong, necessarily; but it does require them to explain why they're right, while 2k years of intense study of their holy books has failed to yield the correct results. In science, this is relatively easy: we simply show the data. In mysticism it's impossible--as westprog has demonstrated, the very concept of mysticism removes the possibility of any systematic analysis of the issues at hand.

So those of us who don't believe are left with two choices when it comes to figuring out how to interpret these holy books: take the word of some individual who breaks from all tradition, or take the word of the experts who've devoted their lives to studying the book in question and the commentaries on said book.

Except that in this case, you prefer to do the opposite. Rather than consider the entire gamut of biblical analysis by Christians, you prefer to stick with a literalist interpretation that has never been part of mainstream Christianity. And when contfronted with the facts, you tell us you don't care anyway.

Game Theory. Reciprocal Altruism. The Prisoner's Dilemma. Neurobiology. Psychology.

Allow me to re-write your post to its equivalent in another field, so that you can get a sense of what you sound like to other people: "I can't think of any examples of scientists producing medical insight that a layperson couldn't come up with. If you can, please indicate." What you're saying is that a systematic and rigorous examination of morality cannot yield any insights, but a disorganized, haphazard analysis based entirely on anecdotes will. I cannot imagine what would justify such a position, I really can't. What field could POSSIBLY suffer when examined rigorously and systematically? Answer: Only those fields which don't have any validity anyway.

And so you construct a totally mythical, non-existent field of scientific analysis of ethical issues. Of course there's a field of scientific ethics - it deals with issues of plagiarism and fake evidence. There's sociological analysis of behaviour. A scientific view of ethics, telling us how to behave? There's no such thing. You prefer your imaginary world to the way things are done in the real one. Now that's ironic.
 
You have to support why something is metaphysical and not subject to scientific inquiry if you are going to use that definition
 
westprog said:
That's what metaphysical means.
And it's quite convenient that you get to define the term, at least under your rules, isn't it?

You mean, when it comes down to it "in a way that can be detected by science".
It's even more convenient that you get to dictate the opposition's argument to them. If you couldn't, you may have to actually discuss things with people!

"Science", by the way, isn't some tool you use to detect things. It's systematic and rigorous observation, coupled with experimentation (either actual experiments or observation of natural experiments). So when something isn't "detectable by science" that means that it changes every time it's observed, or at least so frequently that no conclusions can be drawn from it. It's a thing without a definition, without form--without existence.

Except that in this case, you prefer to do the opposite. Rather than consider the entire gamut of biblical analysis by Christians, you prefer to stick with a literalist interpretation that has never been part of mainstream Christianity. And when contfronted with the facts, you tell us you don't care anyway.
100% bovine excrament. I tend to go by what the RCC states. The RCC has the longest tradition of Biblical interpretation, after all, and it's the one I know best. When someone argues for Creationism, yes, I expect them to be Biblical literalist--there's no other options, not to an honest person. But after that, I either differ to them on their beliefs and merely point out the inconsistencies (at which point people like you scream that I'm telling them what they believe), or I go by what others who have studied the Bible believe it to say (at which point I'm called a liar).

Good to know that your only argument is to dump poison in the well, though. You can't attack my reasons directly, so you try to imply (without any supporting evidence) that my arguments are dishonest. Here's a helpful hint: even if the argument is dishonest, if it's right it's right.

And so you construct a totally mythical, non-existent field of scientific analysis of ethical issues.
Right. Because psychology and the like are mythical. I'm sure the psychologists I know would LOVE to hear that!

You are, as usual, merely making crap up, westprog. I've had enough of that recently, and don't wish to add to the pile of cow manuer I'm forced to wade through. If you wish to play these games, I wish you all the best of luck--I will not participate further. Your dishonesty and shameful debate tactics are perfectly clear for anyone who wishes to see them. Good day, sir.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom