If the Earth isn't 6,000 years old...

You want me to tell you what to think? Surely it's a matter of your own opinion. Or mine. Are you going to change your mind according to what I tell you?

I will answer your question by repeating that there are very wide differences among Christians as to the fallibility and literal truth of the Bible.

Evasion noted. Once again you prove that you're not worth anyone's time.
 
I will answer your question by repeating that there are very wide differences among Christians as to the fallibility and literal truth of the Bible.

Get away!! An amazing revelation. How much faith do you place in the literal truth of the bible? What kind of a believer are you? When will you answer a question? let me ask you another. Would you call yourself a Christian?
 
Last edited:
If they think the Earth is 6000 years old, none of them are right

A valid point. It's perfectly acceptable to tell Christians "Your entire belief system is based on something that cannot be substantiated, and which contradicts known facts; therefore you are wrong." In fact, in science it's obligatory to tell people they're wrong when the facts don't support their assertions. And history and archaeology are science.

At the point where you're going "yes, but THAT story isn't intended to be literal!" for every story in the Bible, the fact that you're trying to avoid the obvious conclusion is pretty clear. And that's the point that anyone who argues that all of the stories in the Bible are allegorical is at.
 
A valid point. It's perfectly acceptable to tell Christians "Your entire belief system is based on something that cannot be substantiated, and which contradicts known facts; therefore you are wrong." In fact, in science it's obligatory to tell people they're wrong when the facts don't support their assertions. And history and archaeology are science.

At the point where you're going "yes, but THAT story isn't intended to be literal!" for every story in the Bible, the fact that you're trying to avoid the obvious conclusion is pretty clear. And that's the point that anyone who argues that all of the stories in the Bible are allegorical is at.

True, The Earth is either six thousand years old or it isn't. No allegory to be seen.
 
No, I'm not, and you know it.

I'm claiming that only those participating in a group have a right to determine what that group is, and that those who violate that are not, by any rational definition, a member of that group. If you want to define what science is, become a scientist. It's fairly hard, and you're going to run into reviewers and colleagues that make me look downright polite and courteous, but it's hardly impossible. Trying to define categories of questions that science can't answer from the outside, which is your usual MO, is going to upset scientists--for precisely the same reason that trying to define, say, Catholicism is going to annoy Catholics.

A world where scientists were allowed to abrogate issues as only capable of scientific judgement would be a scary one indeed, but of course it doesn't exist. Scientists have exactly the same obligation to laymen to justify their conclusions as they do to other scientists. The reason that creationists and climate-change deniers do not follow scientific reasoning is not because they are scientifically ignorant, but because they reason incorrectly.

Scientists are not able to suddenly tell laymen that the existence of god, or the choice of the morally correct path are now something of which they are to be informed as a matter of indisputable fact. They cannot make claims of scientific certainty without providing scientific proof.

Judgements of Catholic doctrine are a matter for the Catholic community. Judgements on science are for the scientific community. Who's the scientific community? Everybody.

Neither is what you posted, so let's not get snippy about pedantic issues, shall we? Otherwise, people like me might be tempted to get snippy with you, and all of the errors and flat-out heresies you've committed.

Heresies? That's a telling word. Not just errors then. That speaks to a mindset all right.

So you're claiming that football is a private area for football players only? :boggled:

I'm claiming it's a matter for people who want to watch or play football. I don't think people who dislike the game should be able to claim what the offside rule should be.

Seems you understand the concept I'm getting at perfectly well, but refuse to apply that concept to science.

Everybody who accepts cause and effect is involved in science.
 
I know, however, that there will be atheists who will continue to insist on biblical inerrancy. They don't go for flat earthism or geocentricity, however. It seems to be an American thing. I don't think European atheists have the same attachment to the literal bible.

The only Christian litteralist I *ever* encoutnered were american. It thus make sense to discuss the absurdity of litteralism with them. So I dispute your"atheist insist on biblical innerancy". It is actually a reaction to christian "literalist". Just like you don't discuss virginity of mary as an argument with protestant, litteralism is quite useless with all christian using the bible as a giant allegory agreeing with coincidentally what they think it should say, but OTOH a real argument to take up with the litteralist christian.

If you dig a bit around you will find atheist don't care a bit on bible innerancy litteracy orwhatnot, because basically it is all hokum no matter the way you turn it.
 
Get away!! An amazing revelation. How much faith do you place in the literal truth of the bible? What kind of a believer are you? When will you answer a question? let me ask you another. Would you call yourself a Christian?

What did you have for breakfast this morning? What are you wearing? When did you last have your haircut?

I think I'm entitled to an answer.
 
The only Christian litteralist I *ever* encoutnered were american. It thus make sense to discuss the absurdity of litteralism with them. So I dispute your"atheist insist on biblical innerancy". It is actually a reaction to christian "literalist". Just like you don't discuss virginity of mary as an argument with protestant, litteralism is quite useless with all christian using the bible as a giant allegory agreeing with coincidentally what they think it should say, but OTOH a real argument to take up with the litteralist christian.

If you dig a bit around you will find atheist don't care a bit on bible innerancy litteracy orwhatnot, because basically it is all hokum no matter the way you turn it.

What I find strange is that when encountering Christians from the broad tradition of the church, which is not based on the bible, there are atheists who insist on the debate proceeding as if they were dealing with bible literalists. I don't understand the justification.
 
A world where scientists were allowed to abrogate issues as only capable of scientific judgement would be a scary one indeed, but of course it doesn't exist. Scientists have exactly the same obligation to laymen to justify their conclusions as they do to other scientists. The reason that creationists and climate-change deniers do not follow scientific reasoning is not because they are scientifically ignorant, but because they reason incorrectly.

Scientists are not able to suddenly tell laymen that the existence of god, or the choice of the morally correct path are now something of which they are to be informed as a matter of indisputable fact. They cannot make claims of scientific certainty without providing scientific proof.

Judgements of Catholic doctrine are a matter for the Catholic community. Judgements on science are for the scientific community. Who's the scientific community? Everybody.

Simple question: If not scientists, then who? What grounds anyone else in moral decisions or the existence of God. What discipline has that ability and can maintain veracity. So far science has just as much, if not more ability of veracity than does philosophy or religion in general.
 
What I find strange is that when encountering Christians from the broad tradition of the church, which is not based on the bible, there are atheists who insist on the debate proceeding as if they were dealing with bible literalists. I don't understand the justification.

Source material
 
I'm claiming it's a matter for people who want to watch or play football. I don't think people who dislike the game should be able to claim what the offside rule should be.
Sepp Blatter doesn't agree with that. Also, there's no evidence he actually likes the game. :boxedin:

(sorry, couldn't resist)
 
You want me to tell you what to think? Surely it's a matter of your own opinion. Or mine. Are you going to change your mind according to what I tell you?

I will answer your question by repeating that there are very wide differences among Christians as to the fallibility and literal truth of the Bible.

I was asking for YOUR opinion on whether or not the Bible was fallible.
 
Simple question: If not scientists, then who? What grounds anyone else in moral decisions or the existence of God. What discipline has that ability and can maintain veracity. So far science has just as much, if not more ability of veracity than does philosophy or religion in general.

If you are seriously suggesting that moral and metaphysical issues should be left to scientists to decide, I think you should ask the scientists if they want the job. I certainly am not prepared to cede authority to anyone else to decide such issues for me.
 
I know you were. I understood your request perfectly well.

Perhaps you could tell me why you wished to know this?
Because you have lots to tell 'the atheists' on the boards. So it's only fair you tell us a bit about what you think.

Is it so hard to tell the readers whether or not you think the Bible is fallible?

Kind of a yes or no question.

.
It's THE SUBJECT OF THE THREAD!

Heh.
 
Last edited:
westprog said:
If you are seriously suggesting that moral and metaphysical issues should be left to scientists to decide, I think you should ask the scientists if they want the job. I certainly am not prepared to cede authority to anyone else to decide such issues for me.
Completely disingenuous. I was referring to your statements to the effect that whether gods exist is not a question scientists can address.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom