I experience, therefore I am

Just to try to whelp you with this: theoscience* would be the science of god(s) = science of nothing as for their to be a science of it it would necessarily exist. You cannot have science if something (or the result of it's presence on other things) are not observable and measurable. You only have guesswork and silliness. That's the world of philosophy, not science. This should not be taken to mean philosophy cannot be fun when used to tie up the weaker minds with conundrums and plausible implausibility (or, worse, impossibilities). Oddly certain accepted definitions in math are marvelous in their capability for doing that/allowing that to be done!!! :D:D:D:D








*colour courtesy of wordogod,ltd. coloring and philosophical sophistry
 
Last edited:
Imagine yourself that aliens visit Earth.

The first thing they do is ask us for our model of the Universe.

You give them a nice picture of 'the Universe' and the mathematical language of science to explain it.

Your mathematical language is wordsalad to them.. Gibberish.
So, you need to translate these meaningless symbols (meaningless to them) in their language.

Of course: they see the structure of logic in it and can translate it to their symbols.
You see that their equations are shorter. Very short, actually.

You thought that math was 'universal'. No, they don't understand one bit of it.

The second thing they ask is:

"where are you in your model of Nature?"
"Show 'us' in your model?"

You can't. You don't know what this alien means and you try to explain that 'consciousness' or 'awareness' is gibberish for your scientists. It's wordsalad for physicists.

They throw away your little model of the Universe and they say: "useless". and you don't know why.

Why are aliens throwing away my mathematical model of Nature? you ask yourself.

Because you are part of Nature and you have not even a descent language to describe yourself in your own model.

You know that consciousness exists, but do you know that 'because you followed the math'?
Do you know that 'dreams' exist, because you have some sort of LUX-detector for dreams?

No, you didn't. You only know that you exist in this world, because:

You experience, therefore you are.

Experience, ergo sum.

There is no computer or detector who can discover you in this world.
You are invisible for every measuring device.
You cannot be deduced, based on the study of nerv-systems alone with a detector, without a mind.

The tools of science and physics are limited to describe the whole Nature of reality. Does it mean that 'consciousness' or 'awareness' can't exist, because physicists don't have the language nor the tools to describe it?

Consciousness or awareness is part of nature and it has a lawful connection with the other laws of Nature. It must have such connection, because we are part of Nature. But our scientific tools for knowledge and the mathematical language are poor tools in order to describe this part of Nature.
There is no way we can discover such thing in nature with the sciences.

But, even when you did not follow 'the math' or used a detector to know that 'images in your mind' are part of Nature, you are more certain about the existence of your mind than you are certain about the existence of dark matter and dark energy.
Because:

I experience, therefore I am..

Well, if aliens came down and landed at certain doorsteps they certainly would get word salad, wouldn't they?
 
<snipped the discussion for brevity>

In other words, just because someone has learned to do science without subjective/cognitive biases, it doesn't follow that this someone can do so for all her/his existence. That is measurement as a bias for good and bad! Now here it is in everyday words for a part of the "game" we always play!
Someone to me: TJ, you are wrong, because...
Me: "Stop right there!!! What does wrong look like???"

So to you if you are a non-believer and can understand science, what is the scientific measurement standard of wrong???

With regards
Tommy


My biggest objection to this claim is the fact that it is relatively easy to objectively change what you subjectively feel. Drugs or physical trauma can affect personality, opinion, and even beliefs in a way that is measurable and repeatable. It is possible (although I would consider it unethical) to change someone's "right" into a "wrong", or vice versa.

Another objection I have to this claim is that you are treating a process as if it were an object or property of an object. While it is true one cannot directly measure "wrong", one can easily measure the effects of "wrong", just the way you can't measure "running", but you can measure its effects. Experience is a process or a verb, not a thing or a noun, although for ease in communication, we treat it that way.

As Calvin once noted to Hobbes regarding the opposite issue, "Verbing weirds language."
 
Straw man argument.

Dreams are a natural manifestation of our brain's activity. As such, they obviously are part of nature.

I'm not sure what point you are trying to get at.
Nor me! (I'm involved in a discussion about dreams on the GH forum at the moment too.)
 
My biggest objection to this claim is the fact that it is relatively easy to objectively change what you subjectively feel. Drugs or physical trauma can affect personality, opinion, and even beliefs in a way that is measurable and repeatable. It is possible (although I would consider it unethical) to change someone's "right" into a "wrong", or vice versa.

Another objection I have to this claim is that you are treating a process as if it were an object or property of an object. While it is true one cannot directly measure "wrong", one can easily measure the effects of "wrong", just the way you can't measure "running", but you can measure its effects. Experience is a process or a verb, not a thing or a noun, although for ease in communication, we treat it that way.

As Calvin once noted to Hobbes regarding the opposite issue, "Verbing weirds language."

I suspect that we functionally both at some level "play" in part a fallacy of equivocation, namely that all usages of the words objective and subjective amount to the same respectively for both words individually.

As to "you are wrong", yes I know that it is not a property of you as you being wrong! Now please explain that to all you observe doing that within the contexts of the group of functional non-believers. Ask them, what wrong looks like???

So back to subjective and objective; I can if you want treat subjective and objective as processes and the same with experience as long you don't treat all experiences as the same. I.e. for the words objective and subjective in toto they overlap in some sense, but in others they differ:
  • I experience a computer screen in front of me.
  • I experience love for my wife.

So I will give you a choice well knowing that it is in part a false dichotomy in a sense, because you have other options; you can choose to list as many different usages of objective and subjective as you are able to or you can ask me to do so. If we then can agree somewhat upon those, we can start with measurement and what that is as a process, because we will be running in circles if we use the words objective and subjective differently together with the word measurement.

With regards
Tommy
 
The main question is an epistemological question.

"What can we know?"

A philosophical question about what we can discover in reality.

What is our first tool to discover the existence of 'dreaming' in Nature.

You dream at night, don't you?

Let me guess: you just had a course on philosophy, or read an essay on it ?
 
I experience, therefore I am

I am. Therefore I experience.

Those are neither mutually exclusive, nor opposites.

I am, therefore I experience. Obvious in a materialistic worldview.
I experience, therefore I am. An observational verification of the first statement.

Hans
 
Irrelevant. The experience is the same regardless. The explanation is simpler if we don't assume an extra layer of reality. So that's what science does.

So you don't consider it worthwhile to differentiate between subjective and objective as to different kinds of processes of if you like all of reality works the same because a material explanation amounts to exactly the same as both an objective and subjective explanation.

I know - keep it simple (but not to simple) ;) :) :)
 
I have read the remainder of the thread, but I still elect to answer the OP:

Imagine yourself that aliens visit Earth.

The first thing they do is ask us for our model of the Universe.

Scenario accepted.

You give them a nice picture of 'the Universe' and the mathematical language of science to explain it.

Your mathematical language is wordsalad to them.. Gibberish.

Since our symbolic language will be unknown to them, accepted.

So, you need to translate these meaningless symbols (meaningless to them) in their language.

Of course: they see the structure of logic in it and can translate it to their symbols.

This implies that the structure of their math is very similar to ours. Otherwise, translation would be impossible.

You see that their equations are shorter. Very short, actually.

You thought that math was 'universal'. No, they don't understand one bit of it.

That is an unbased assumption. Math is basically the most simplified way to describe reality. Assuming that those aliens occupy the same reality as ours (your scenario seems to imply that), once symbol language differences are overcome, their math should be neigh identical to us.

The second thing they ask is:

"where are you in your model of Nature?"
"Show 'us' in your model?"

OK.

You can't. You don't know what this alien means and you try to explain that 'consciousness' or 'awareness' is gibberish for your scientists. It's wordsalad for physicists.

Yes, I can. I may not be able to completely and conclusively describe consciousness, but I am able to give a good picture.

They throw away your little model of the Universe and they say: "useless". and you don't know why.

Correct, I would not know why. How should I know?

Why are aliens throwing away my mathematical model of Nature? you ask yourself.

My model of nature is not primarily mathematical, it is observational.

Because you are part of Nature and you have not even a descent language to describe yourself in your own model.

I assume you mean 'decent'. I do not agree. I have a rather good model. I am not claiming that it cannot be wrong, but why should your model (or that of those seemingly superfluous aliens) be more correct?

You know that consciousness exists, but do you know that 'because you followed the math'?
Do you know that 'dreams' exist, because you have some sort of LUX-detector for dreams?

No, you didn't. You only know that you exist in this world, because:

You experience, therefore you are.

Experience, ergo sum.


As I say, our knowledge of nature is mainly observational. We did not use math do discover it, only to describe it.


There is no computer or detector who can discover you in this world.
You are invisible for every measuring device.

Demonstrably wrong. You are here presuming duality, but all you end up arguing is that duality is undetectable. My material existence is easily detectable, and according to materialism, that is all that exists.

You cannot be deduced, based on the study of nerv-systems alone with a detector, without a mind.

Wrong.

The tools of science and physics are limited to describe the whole Nature of reality. Does it mean that 'consciousness' or 'awareness' can't exist, because physicists don't have the language nor the tools to describe it?

You are presuming that awareness is not part of natural reality, but that is an unsupported claim.

Consciousness or awareness is part of nature and it has a lawful connection with the other laws of Nature. It must have such connection, because we are part of Nature. But our scientific tools for knowledge and the mathematical language are poor tools in order to describe this part of Nature.
There is no way we can discover such thing in nature with the sciences.

But, even when you did not follow 'the math' or used a detector to know that 'images in your mind' are part of Nature, you are more certain about the existence of your mind than you are certain about the existence of dark matter and dark energy.
Because:

I experience, therefore I am..

Your basic arguing is circular and false. In short, you are arguing:

1) Our consciousness is something undetectable by scientific means.
2) Scientific means have not discovered something it cannot discover.
3) Thus, 1) is true.

Hans
 
So you don't consider it worthwhile to differentiate between subjective and objective as to different kinds of processes of if you like all of reality works the same because a material explanation amounts to exactly the same as both an objective and subjective explanation.

I know - keep it simple (but not to simple) ;) :) :)

To simple what?
 
To simple what?

Let us play with subjective and objective in relationship to processes. First the processes of two or more different observable scenarios. I am standing on a beach facing the ocean in front of me, the shoreline is somewhat straight and behind me is flat land.
  • I can remain standing and if I do so indefinitely I will fall down due to lack of water, food and/or sleep.
    I can turn around, but not left nor right at the same time and in the same sense. Likewise I can turn in any one direction I like, but not several at same time and in the same sense.
    I can walk forward, but I can't walk on water.
    Before I make up my mind/brain I could e.g. become unable to decide because of massive brain hemorrhage.

For the word subjective and objective in relationship to these and other physical process I could start there and expand with the dictionary explanation of e.g. objective and derive out of the these kinds of observations of the processes involved an usage for the word subjective, yet still describe it as a physical process as opposed to an objective and physical process.
But rather right now I choose not to do so, so you could choose to play objective/subjective and describe my choice using physical, biological, subjective, objective and other relevant and irrelevant words. ;)

With regards
Tommy
 
The limited tools of knowledge of the (idealised) materialist:

So, we can at least conclude this:

When you ask a pure materialist:
How do you discover that you had a certain dream last night?
Did you follow the math? Or did you use a detector or a measuring device?

When he is intellectually honest, he would say: indeed 'my own experience' was my only portal to this fact in Nature.

Or when you ask a materialist how he checked the evidence when a friend told him: I have an image of a big sculpture in my mind I want to make.

A materialist must admit that he uses 'to believe' to accept this idea.

(I don't want to see him open your head and detect some pulses in your brain. How would he do that?)

No mathematics at all can reveal us this information.

No scientific device in the world can reveal us the content of this image in the mind of our friends and family memebers.

"to believe in the Invisible" is our only way to accept this part of reality.

So, this whole idea that 'the math' is the only tool in life to proof something is not been disproven by this fact.

It's also not true that 'your own experience' or 'to believe' or not good tools for knowledge.

These things are the first tools, when it comes to our most precious things in life: Consciousness, Awareness, Feelings, Imagination and its content.

But it's sad that some materialists can't admit that their materialistic tools of knowledge (following the math and detecting objects) fail to discover these things like 'Awareness, Consciousness, Feelings etc... Because the materialistic language is limited.

Some of them call these things nonsense. (unbelievable isn't it?).

But we all know that 'dreams' or 'an image in your mind' or 'awareness' or 'feelings' or 'experiences' are no 'nonsense'. We live by it every day.


It's actually very sad that the (pure) materialst can't admit the fact that 'to experience' or 'to believe in the Invisible' are the only tools of knowledge to discover these kind of 'things' in Nature.

In my opinion, such a materialist is a blinded fool by the holyness of his tools, or at least: stubborn as hell.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom