I experience, therefore I am

Indeed, isn't it. gibberish. Experience. Not even worth mentioning.
If you say so.

Because we didn't follow the math or have no equations to describe it.
Theoscience has no language or tools to describe or discover our material existence in this world.
It has no spells for Us. All it can do is: inveigling and wrapping a chymerical abscess in Metanature.

But it isn't even capable of derriving the existence of something like 'Awareness' or 'Consciousness' while it is fauxvestigating chemical and physical systems in this world.

It can only see the Invisible. And the Unmeasurable. It's actually a very poor tool to describe the whole Nature of things in this world.

Theoscience can't see The Universe. The fool.
 
Last edited:
Thank you Tommy. Indeed intresting.


What is theoscience, Donn? What's that? I never found that word in the dictionary.

So, the final answer will not come from math nor from physics at all.
We are metaphysical nonsense, said Adman. Our existence is gibberish to him.

The philosopher has another conclusion:
He answers: there is this other mind problem in Nature.

We have to believe in the existence of other minds when we observe brainlike materials like us.
We have to believe that our family and friends have a mind, feelings, Awareness, Consciousness etc...
But every mind for him- or herself can say: I experience, therefore I am.

So, 'to believe' or 'to experience' is what we must do, when it comes to the most valuable things in our lives.


To believe, yes indeed. No evidence, nor math, but 'to believe'.
Remember this...

But we cannot be sure about other materials, wich are not like brains at all, can we?

Things who only let see their material side. We have to believe that we are not the only type of materials in this world with 'minds'.
It would be antropocentric to think that only brainlike materials are minds.

Where are the other minds in non-brainlike materials.
Read first about the other mindproblem.

Where is The Invisible?
Where is the Unmeasurable?

This problem must be solved, before we can give Ourselves a more descent and more accurate model of Nature.

The materialist fool does not understand that 'to believe' in minds is part of the deal.
That 'to believe' in Awareness, Consciousness, etc. must be part of his approach of reality.

He will not assume the Invisible nature of certain things in this world is worth mentioning.
He believes that Awareness or Conscousness has no lawful connection with the other laws of Nature at all.
The fool.
 
Last edited:
Thank you Tommy. Indeed interesting.

What is theoscience, Donn? What's that? I never found that word in the dictionary.

So, the final answer will not come from math nor from physics at all.
We are metaphysical nonsense, said Adman. Our existence is gibberish to him.

The philosopher has another conclusion:
He answers: there is this other mind problem in Nature.

We have to believe in the existence of other minds when we observe brainlike materials like us.
We have to believe that our family and friends have a mind, feelings, awareness, consciousness etc...

So, 'to believe' is what we must do, when it comes to the valuable important things in our lives.

But we cannot be sure about other materials, wich are not like brains at all.

Things who only let see their material side. We have to believe that we are not the only materials in this world with 'minds'.
It would be antropocentric to think that only brainlike materials are minds.

Where are there other minds in non-brainlike materials.
Read first about the other mindproblem.

If you really want to play theoretical philosophy why don't you just prove that you exist as you and not e.g. exist as a brain in a vat???

That you think you exist e.g. with memories about the past connected directly to the rest of reality, doesn't rule out that you are a computer program turned on 25 seconds ago and that you will be turned off in 25 seconds. In short you don't have a mind with experiences, but rather something has you as a mind. How that mind is actually connected to the rest of reality is unknown, but that you believe you have a mind with memories about the past will not make it so just because you believe it. That is called magical thinking and is easy to test within 50 seconds. Close your eyes and think the monitor in front of you away, then open them.

In other words if you believe everything is fair to you, me and everybody else and we are not just computer programs you can start sorting out subjective, inter-subjective and objective without ever getting close to what reality really is. But it won't apparently help you in turning a subjective fact into an objective fact, rather you will learn to differentiate between subjective, inter-subjective and objective.
You have to learn the difference between different usage of such words as believe and know and not just think that I believe I have an experience of a computer screen in front of me is the same as I believe everything is physical or I believe everything is from God. The latter 2 cases of believe are not the same as the first.

Further when dealing with naturalists you have to learn the difference between metaphysical/ontological and methodological naturalism. I.e. there are different kinds of beliefs and just because they all involve the word believe it doesn't apparently make them exactly the same.
So do you want to "play" philosophy??? Okay, do you know or believe that you exist as you???
 
What is theoscience, Donn? What's that? I never found that word in the dictionary.
It's like comprehend or experience. Gibberish. (But the most important thing of all.)

We are metaphysical nonsense, said Adman. Our existence is gibberish to him.
Adman, is our existence gibberish to you?

This problem must be solved, before we can give Ourselves a more descent and more accurate model of Nature.
This already hit bottom.

The immaterialist fool does one over understand 'to accept' in minds is part of the deal. That to believe Awareness, Consciousness, etc. is already part of of reality.

He believes that Couscousness has no awful connection with the other foodstuffs of Nature at all.

The fool.
 
That's right. But that's not the point.
The point is, that computer and its devices can't discover 'consciousness' or 'dreams' or 'feelings' or 'images in your minds' by mapping or investigating chemicals and electric interactions. It is unable to deduce your existence based on the investigation and mapping of the interactions of these materials.

You need to be such materials in order to know that these chemical and electric interactions are at the same time also 'consciousness' and 'dreams'.

Ergo:
the scientific tools are not even able to discover Us in this world.

We have actually made some surprising progress in reconstructing "'images in your minds' by mapping or investigating chemicals and electric interactions."

 
I wrote here why I think it is true.

That's not what I asked.

You didn't describe what you think would explain those things, you said science can't do it. You then said to imagine an unimaginably better computer, and simply claimed that couldn't do it either, without saying why, what that means, or what could do what you want.
 
If you really want to play theoretical philosophy why don't you just prove that you exist as you and not e.g. exist as a brain in a vat???

When solipsism is being used as a counter-argument, there's a problem... but even as useless as it is, solipsism is still more thought-provoking and sensible. :boggled:

I suppose I'll just walk out, instead of asking questions that will never be answered.
 
When solipsism is being used as a counter-argument, there's a problem... but even as useless as it is, solipsism is still more thought-provoking and sensible. :boggled:

I suppose I'll just walk out, instead of asking questions that will never be answered.

If you are a brain in a vat it is not a case of solipsism. Rather it is the "exact" opposite, the rest of reality is there but you are not you as you are not directly connected to the rest of reality.
 
Why are aliens throwing away my mathematical model of Nature? you ask yourself.

Because you are part of Nature and you have not even a descent language to describe yourself in your own model.

Our models include us.

You experience, therefore you are.

Experience, ergo sum.

It does not follow, however, that the experience is the source of the world. It seems to be the other way around, in fact, so experience is not, in and of itself, anything special. However, you are correct that if you experience anything, it probably at least means that you exist.
 
Science has no language or tools to describe or discover our non-material existence in this world.

How do you know that this undetectable non-materialistic existence exists? More to the point, what do the words 'our non-materialistic existence' mean?
 
If I came across some alien system that had high computational capability and engaged in complex behaviors suggesting purposeful self-preserving context-responsive activity, and on further investigating its workings I found that it utilized the ability to dynamically construct narrative from memory and that the narratives it so constructs include representations of itself as causal agents in the narrative, I would conclude that it is conscious. Depending on circumstances, I might reach this conclusion before being able to communicate with the system in any way, and I certainly would not have to experience its consciousness myself to justify that conclusion.

I don't understand, therefore, why an alien would not be able to reach the same conclusion about me, by the same observations. Are we assuming aliens are dim?

Respectfully,
Myriad

ETA: Interesting post, Tommy. I sum things up this way:

- The material universe is all there is.
- My subjective experience is all I have.

I don't find any real contradiction between those two ideas, and have no reason to disregard either one or elevate one above the other in general importance. Of course, I cannot prove that either one is strictly true.
 
Last edited:
...
ETA: Interesting post, Tommy. I sum things up this way:

- The material universe is all there is.
- My subjective experience is all I have.

I don't find any real contradiction between those two ideas, and have no reason to disregard either one or elevate one above the other in general importance. Of course, I cannot prove that either one is strictly true.

Is that I material? Or is it subjective experience?

More later

Tommy
 
something...something...quantum vibrations....something...something.....transdimensional
 
Last edited:
A mirror
A camera
An Xray machine
A CT scan
A thermometer
A voice recorder
A weight scale
An ultrasound machine
etc
etc

Hahaha. Or you could even poke your own ``chemicals`` with a pin. Or better yet, put a tack, point up, on a chair, and sit. Then you`d not only know you exist, but you`d know WHERE you exist.
 
Thousands of years ago, men looked at the Sun and the Moon. How did they get up there? Obviously, the gods did it, using a boat or a chariot or some such device. Pretty obvious really, that was what people experienced. But some humans always look at things and say "No, lets try and figure this out". We are a pretty ornery species that way. And so now we know about planets, satellites and stars. We have a pretty good idea of how they move through space, thanks to gravity which we understand at least a little thanks to the work of people like Newton, Einstein and Hawkins. And every year we understand a little bit more.

Consciousness is part of the natural world. People aren't uniquely gifted with consciousness, as anyone who has spent any time with animals will tell you. It may operate on a different level and in a different way, but all the cats and dogs I have ever owned think and act on that thought. So, we as a race will study consciousness, it is already being done. Slowly over time we will discover more and understand more. We will do this using scientific methods, How can I be so sure? Because that is what has happened whenever the scientific community have put their minds to something. Look at finding the evidence of the Higgs Boson. This is why Maartens is wrong, again!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom