I experience, therefore I am

MaartenVergu

Illuminator
Joined
Nov 19, 2010
Messages
3,146
Imagine yourself that aliens visit Earth.

The first thing they do is ask us for our model of the Universe.

You give them a nice picture of 'the Universe' and the mathematical language of science to explain it.

Your mathematical language is wordsalad to them.. Gibberish.
So, you need to translate these meaningless symbols (meaningless to them) in their language.

Of course: they see the structure of logic in it and can translate it to their symbols.
You see that their equations are shorter. Very short, actually.

You thought that math was 'universal'. No, they don't understand one bit of it.

The second thing they ask is:

"where are you in your model of Nature?"
"Show 'us' in your model?"

You can't. You don't know what this alien means and you try to explain that 'consciousness' or 'awareness' is gibberish for your scientists. It's wordsalad for physicists.

They throw away your little model of the Universe and they say: "useless". and you don't know why.

Why are aliens throwing away my mathematical model of Nature? you ask yourself.

Because you are part of Nature and you have not even a descent language to describe yourself in your own model.

You know that consciousness exists, but do you know that 'because you followed the math'?
Do you know that 'dreams' exist, because you have some sort of LUX-detector for dreams?

No, you didn't. You only know that you exist in this world, because:

You experience, therefore you are.

Experience, ergo sum.

There is no computer or detector who can discover you in this world.
You are invisible for every measuring device.
You cannot be deduced, based on the study of nerv-systems alone with a detector, without a mind.

The tools of science and physics are limited to describe the whole Nature of reality. Does it mean that 'consciousness' or 'awareness' can't exist, because physicists don't have the language nor the tools to describe it?

Consciousness or awareness is part of nature and it has a lawful connection with the other laws of Nature. It must have such connection, because we are part of Nature. But our scientific tools for knowledge and the mathematical language are poor tools in order to describe this part of Nature.
There is no way we can discover such thing in nature with the sciences.

But, even when you did not follow 'the math' or used a detector to know that 'images in your mind' are part of Nature, you are more certain about the existence of your mind than you are certain about the existence of dark matter and dark energy.
Because:

I experience, therefore I am..
 
Last edited:
Thank you.
Awareness or experiencing is nonsense of course, Adman.

Do you know that you have dreams, Adman?
Did you follow the math to discover 'dreams' or did you use the LUX-detector?
 
Last edited:
Thank you.
Awareness or experiencing is nonsense of course, Adman.

Do you know that you have dreams, Adman?
Did you follow the math to discover 'dreams' or did you use the LUX-detector?

You think you're postulating "profound" and "true" ideas, but all you doing is pulling them out of your ass, in order to cover up what you don't understand.
 
Go talk to Deepak Chopra and compare your loony metaphysical beliefs. I'm sure you'll have a lot in common.
 
You avoid the question, Adman.

You believe in the existence of dreams, don't you?

Second question: How did you discover that fact: by following the math?
How do you discover that you feel an object?

Do you believe your experiences exist? Or do you think it's New age-nonsense to believe that you have a mind?

Do you discover the existence of your awareness in this world by following the math or by using a detector or another tool of physics?

Why do you believe in such gibberisch wordsalad thing, Adman, as your own mind?
 
Last edited:
Thank you.
Awareness or experiencing is nonsense of course, Adman.

Do you know that you have dreams, Adman?
Did you follow the math to discover 'dreams' or did you use the LUX-detector?

Yes, it is nonsense as it applies to reality, science and math. With no offense, your perceptions/abilities/processing in those three are missing incredibly important information, processes and skill sets. Doesn't make you a bad person, but it does make you incompetent for such discussions/considerations.
 
You avoid the question, Adman.

You believe in the existence of dreams, don't you?

Second question: How did you discover that fact: by following the math?
How do you discover that you feel an object?

Do you believe your experiences exist? Do you discover their existence by following the math of by using a detector or another tool of physics?

Why do you believe in such gibberisch wordsalad thing, Adman, as your own mind?

Your first mistake was in thinking that math is not universal.

The language that we use to describe math is not universal, but math itself is. And it is likely that mathematical languages can be be translated.

Dreams have nothing to do with it. You are just spewing wooish nonsense.
 
Last edited:
See how Adman can't even answer a simple question:

How did you discover that 'dreams' are part of Nature, Adman.
By following the math or with a detector?

Adman: "error. My mind or my awareness is nonsense." "error"

Adman, when an image of James Randi pops up in your mind, how do you 'discover' the existence of this image in your mind?

With a brainscanner or by following the math?

Or do you have enother tool to discover the existence of this image in your mind of James Randi?
Your own consciousness?
 
Last edited:
See how Adman can't even answer a simple question:

How did you discover that 'dreams' are part of Nature, Adman.
By following the math or with a detector?

Adman: "error. My mind or my awareness is nonsense." "error"

Straw man argument.

Dreams are a natural manifestation of our brain's activity. As such, they obviously are part of nature.

I'm not sure what point you are trying to get at.
 
Last edited:
Adman, when an image of James Randi pops up in your mind, how do you 'discover' the existence of this image in your mind?

With a brainscanner or by following the math?

Or do you have enother tool to discover the existence of this image in your mind of James Randi?
Your own consciousness?


An electrochemical process going on in my brain, which my brain can comprehend.

What do you think it is?
 
An electrochemical process going on in my brain, which my brain can comprehend.

What do you think it is?

What does 'comprehend' mean? It's gibberish or wordsalad to me.

Adman believes in something he calls 'to comprehend'.

I don't know what that is.

Show me the mathematical description of it. What can't of math did you follow to discover 'to comprehend' in this world.
Please show me the verifiable evidence for such strange gibberisch wordsalad word like 'comprehend'.
 
Last edited:
What does 'comprehend' mean? It's gibberish or wordsalad to me.

Adman believes in something he calls 'comprehend'.
I don't know what that is.

Show me the mathematical description of it. Please show me the verifiable evidence for such strange gibberisch wordsalad word like 'comprehend'.


:rolleyes: Look it up if you can't understand what I meant.

Else what is your alternate explanation? More metaphysical nonsense?
 
Last edited:
What I mean is:

No tool of science (scanner or math) can discover or describe 'dream' or 'consciousness' or 'comprehension' or 'your existence in general' in this world.

It can only detect and map the lawful interaction between chemicals.
That's it.

The most sophisticated computing robot with the most finetuned devices and scanners cannot discover your existence in this world, Adman and SezMe.
It can only discover the chemical system and map its lawful interactions.
That's about it.

The tools of science are very good, but limited in order to describe everything in Nature.

Imagine a very sophisticated computer-robot with scanners, scientists and engineers only can dream about.

How is this thing going to discover 'dreams' in Nature on its own?
It's a computer wich can generate information and integrate this information is better mathematical models.

By mapping the world on it's own, it can make maps of our nervesystem and brain with mathematical models you only can dream about.
It can scan things in this world, our best tools can't scan.

But it can never discover 'dreaming' in this world.
It will never be able to discover 'consciousness' in this world.
It will never find 'Us' in the material world.

Because it has no language for it and we have no language to explain Us to him. (it)

We are gibberisch to this thing.
And IT will interprete your word 'pane' or 'being sad' as gibberish or foolish nonsense from idiotic inferior bad information gathering systems.
 
Last edited:
Imagine yourself that aliens visit Earth.

The first thing they do is ask us for our model of the Universe.

You give them a nice picture of 'the Universe' and the mathematical language of science to explain it.

Your mathematical language is wordsalad to them.. Gibberish.
So, you need to translate these meaningless symbols (meaningless to them) in their language.

Of course: they see the structure of logic in it and can translate it to their symbols.
You see that their equations are shorter. Very short, actually.

You thought that math was 'universal'. No, they don't understand one bit of it.

The second thing they ask is:

"where are you in your model of Nature?""Show 'us' in your model?"

You can't. You don't know what this alien means and you try to explain that 'consciousness' or 'awareness' is gibberish for your scientists. It's wordsalad for physicists.

They throw away your little model of the Universe and they say: "useless". and you don't know why.

Why are aliens throwing away my mathematical model of Nature? you ask yourself.

Because you are part of Nature and you have not even a descent language to describe yourself in your own model.

You know that consciousness exists, but do you know that 'because you followed the math'?
Do you know that 'dreams' exist, because you have some sort of LUX-detector for dreams?

No, you didn't. You only know that you exist in this world, because:

You experience, therefore you are.

Experience, ergo sum.

There is no computer or detector who can discover you in this world.
You are invisible for every measuring device.
You cannot be deduced, based on the study of nerv-systems alone with a detector, without a mind.

The tools of science and physics are limited to describe the whole Nature of reality. Does it mean that 'consciousness' or 'awareness' can't exist, because physicists don't have the language nor the tools to describe it?

Consciousness or awareness is part of nature and it has a lawful connection with the other laws of Nature. It must have such connection, because we are part of Nature. But our scientific tools for knowledge and the mathematical language are poor tools in order to describe this part of Nature.
There is no way we can discover such thing in nature with the sciences.

But, even when you did not follow 'the math' or used a detector to know that 'images in your mind' are part of Nature, you are more certain about the existence of your mind than you are certain about the existence of dark matter and dark energy.
Because:

I experience, therefore I am..

X = 1
 
What I mean is:

No tool of science (scanner or math) can discover or describe 'dream' or 'consciousness' or 'comprehension' or 'your existence in general' in this world.

It can only detect and map the lawful interaction between chemicals.
That's it.

The most sophisticated computing robot with the most finetuned devices and scanners cannot discover your existence in this world, Adman.
It can only discover the chemical system and map its lawful interactions.
That's it.

The tools of science are very good, but limited in order to describe everything in Nature.


Who has said that science can currently fully describe how the human brain works in creating human consciousness?

But the fact that we cannot describe it fully yet does not mean that we cannot ever understand it.

You are simply arguing from ignorance--your assumption is that because we can't currently explain it fully, we will never be able to.

So you turn to silly new-wave, wooish explanations that are just easy answers and simply avoid the question.
 
You avoid the question, Adman.

You believe in the existence of dreams, don't you?

Second question: How did you discover that fact: by following the math?
How do you discover that you feel an object?

Do you believe your experiences exist? Or do you think it's New age-nonsense to believe that you have a mind?

Do you discover the existence of your awareness in this world by following the math or by using a detector or another tool of physics?

Why do you believe in such gibberisch wordsalad thing, Adman, as your own mind?

I discovered the existence of my awareness about the time I quit filling my diapers.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom