I experience, therefore I am

So, Maartenn, you have no response to my claim of being a p-zombie?

This is not a joke, nor is it a claim for purposes of discussion. I believe myself to be a p-zombie, exactly as defined in the Wikipedia link:

A philosophical zombie or p-zombie in the philosophy of mind and perception is a hypothetical being that is indistinguishable from a normal human being except in that it lacks conscious experience, qualia,* or sentience.
Am I wrong? I want to be a "normal human being." What is different about you, a normal human being, from me, a p-zombie?

*I had to look up "qualia." The definition did not help me much.
 
And herein with hit the primary brick wall of all these stupid solipsistic arguments, they only work if one is massively, massively egotistical.

The idea that your own existence is fundamentally more "real" then everyone else's sorta only works if you are operating under the idea that you are somehow more special then everyone else.

I mean the whole idea that everyone else is only an actor in your own personal play... wow that takes an ego.
 
Likewise (returning to my original point), whatever we discover about the nature of time, even if it differs significantly from our subjective experience of time, the prevailing everyday mental model of time won't change. We won't all start sounding like Doctor Who or Dr. Manhattan. Even though it might be kind of fun. ("Yes, I'm late for our appointment. I always have been too late, and I always shall be too late. It's what we call a fixed point in time, like every other point. Shall I apologize for the inalterable shape of the universe?")

I want to point out two things:

First, we don't really "experience" linear time. Human thought is actually horrible at experiencing, never mind understanding, time as a linear thing. Our memories have no temporal information at all, as a matter of fact.

Instead, we process the world as a long sequence of environmental changes. The question "how long did you stay in France?" is really "based on the dates you remember, what is the delta between the entry and exit date of your trip to France?" We certainly don't hold a contiguous time span of, say 2 weeks, in our memory such that we can easily access the duration. If you didn't remember the dates of your trip, you wouldn't be able to easily answer the question -- unless you systematically tried to remember the sequence of days based on what you did each day. In that case, it is still change and not time -- you did this on day 1, that on day 2, this on day 3, that on day 4, etc.

Second, our perception of the present has little to do with time besides the fact that time is our word for "the rate at which things happen." The "present" is really just our minds evaluating the very latest sequences of change that make it to our perception. To the extent we associate time values with those sequences it is only a learned behavior -- we know about 'this' much stuff can happen in a minute, an hour, etc. But when the amount of changes deviate much from our learned standards, our sense of "time" goes out of whack.

So personally I don't see the difficulty in adjusting to radically different notions of time and even entropy driven cause/effect. Were entropy to reverse and the laws of physics operate backwards, we would be essentially moving backwards through time and ( if you subscribe to the purely physicalist views of consciousness ) everyone would consider it natural -- causes still lead to effects ( or in that case, effects lead to causes, but its the same thing mathematically ).
 
Another meaningless post. You know as much about reality as you know about relativity.

I think he's saying "Ik ben Verborgen werkzaam" doesn't mean "I am hidden activity" as you translated but something like "I work hidden" or "I am working from the shadows" so to speak.

<naïvité>Is this a Halloween oriented thread?</naïvité>
 
Is Maartenn100 suggesting that because there are some things, such as consciousness, that we cannot (yet) describe in terms of mathematics, it is just as valid to use non-mathematical descriptions of those things that we can describe using maths?

It's a bit like someone who has dropped his keys under a streetlight insisting that we should search for them with our eyes closed because it is dark under the bushes on the other side of the street.

Let us say that it is something with limited equivalence to that but less well thought out.
 
I think he's saying "Ik ben Verborgen werkzaam" doesn't mean "I am hidden activity" as you translated but something like "I work hidden" or "I am working from the shadows" so to speak.

<naïvité>Is this a Halloween oriented thread?</naïvité>
Can't be - it has clearly not been weaned and it has no even partial orientation.
 
I think he's saying "Ik ben Verborgen werkzaam" doesn't mean "I am hidden activity" as you translated but something like "I work hidden" or "I am working from the shadows" so to speak.


He's looking for his keys over in the bushes.
 
Ok, people, to be clear: I have no bad intentions. I don't want to sell books or starting some cult or profiling myself as some guru or something like that. But, I'm very open about myself now (don't abuse that fact) I am in a hospital now for health-reasons because I have a real psychosis. So, don't take the content serious. It doesn't mean that these ideas have no meaning at all. These ideas can, at least, tell us something about how 'religious thinking' can rise.

So, for me: topic closed. And I'm sorry for the trouble.
 
Last edited:
If you really are in hospital, for values of reality that makes sense to me, then I hope you are not suffering and that the outcome is positive. Get well soon.
 
Maartenn100, I also thought that you had behaved strangely lately. I am relieved to hear that this was not your normal mode of thinking, and I hope you will get well soon and return to entertain us with wacky physics theories :)
 
Ok, people, to be clear: I have no bad intentions. I don't want to sell books or starting some cult or profiling myself as some guru or something like that. But, I'm very open about myself now (don't abuse that fact) I am in a hospital now for health-reasons because I have a real psychosis. So, don't take the content serious. It doesn't mean that these ideas have no meaning at all. These ideas can, at least, tell us something about how 'religious thinking' can rise.

So, for me: topic closed. And I'm sorry for the trouble.

Get well soon.
 
Thank you very much. I'm sorry for my forum behavior.
I'm sensitive for psychosis (that's what my medical doctor says).
 
But, I'm very open about myself now (don't abuse that fact) I am in a hospital now for health-reasons because I have a real psychosis. So, don't take the content serious.
You are very brave to admit this. This is a good sign for your ultimate recovery. Good luck and do what the doctors say!
 
Indeed, I sincerely hope your experiences improve, Maartenn100, as well as you perception of "I am" certainly seem to have done already.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom