I experience, therefore I am

What I mean is:

No tool of science (scanner or math) can discover or describe 'dream' or 'consciousness' or 'comprehension' or 'your existence in general' in this world.

This is almost certainly false, but ok. Go on. What do you think describes these things?
 
I discovered the existence of my awareness about the time I quit filling my diapers.

Tsig believes in 'awareness'.
Why Tsig? Why do you believe something based on ... no verifiable evidence and no math? Why do you believe in such nonsense word as 'awareness'?
What kind of tool of knowledge dit you use? Did you follow the math? Did you follow the verifiable evidence of a brainscanner in order to believe in awareness? Or did you just believe it, without evidence?
What was the tool you used to get knowlegde about 'awareness', Tsig?
 
Last edited:
:rolleyes: Look it up if you can't understand what I meant.

Else what is your alternate explanation? More metaphysical nonsense?

I've ate too much of this metaphysical mush.

This all sounds like sour grapes. "Since I can't understand the math the math must be worthless".
 
Tsig believes in 'awareness'.
Why Tsig? Why do you believe something based on ... no verifiable evidence and no math? Why do you believe in such nonsense word as 'awareness'?
What kind of tool of knowledge dit you use? Did you follow the math? Did you follow the verifiable evidence of a brainscanner in order to believe in awareness? Or did you just believe it, without evidence?
What was the tool you used to get knowlegde about 'awareness', Tsig?


You haven't really thought this through, have you?
 
Originally Posted by Maartenn100 View Post
There is no computer or detector who can discover you in this world.
A mirror
A camera
An Xray machine
A CT scan
A thermometer
A voice recorder
A weight scale
An ultrasound machine
etc
etc

Nope, the computer only discovers a bunch of interacting chemicals.
It cannot discover 'dreams' nor 'consciousness'.
 
Tsig believes in 'awareness'.
Why Tsig? Why do you believe something based on ... no verifiable evidence and no math? Why do you believe in such nonsense word as 'awareness'?
What kind of tool of knowledge dit you use? Did you follow the math? Did you follow the verifiable evidence of a brainscanner in order to believe in awareness? Or did you just believe it, without evidence?
What was the tool you used to get knowlegde about 'awareness', Tsig?

A hammer, I hit my thumb and became aware of pain. If you hit yourself in the head with it you will become aware of a good feeling when you stop.

Good tool, that hammer, smarter than the majority of woos and you can use it to drive nails.
 
Ok, another question. Let's assume that 'a brain and a nerv-system' is one example of a whole category of things wich have some kind of awareness. (but these things cannot communicate this to us).

How can a computing robot with its superior math-skills and supertools discover 'consciousness' or 'awareness' in non-brainlike interacting chemical materials in this world?

Before you answer:
Read about other mind problem.
 
Nope, the computer only discovers a bunch of interacting chemicals.
It cannot discover 'dreams' nor 'consciousness'.

"Dreams" and "consciousness" are a combination of chemical and electric reactions.
 
Tsig said:
A hammer, I hit my thumb and became aware of pain. If you hit yourself in the head with it you will become aware of a good feeling when you stop.

and blablablabla

Indeed, you discovered it without any tool of science at all. Without following the math and without a detector.
QUOD ERAT DEMONSTRANDUM

Thank you Tsig for proving my point.
 
Indeed, you discovered it without any tool of science at all. Without following the math and without a detector.
QUOD ERAT DEMONSTRANDUM

Thank you Tsig for proving my point.

You don't understand the point you are apparently trying to make.
 
Adman said:
"Dreams" and "consciousness" are a combination of chemical and electric reactions.

That's right. But that's not the point.
The point is, that computer and its devices can't discover 'consciousness' or 'dreams' or 'feelings' or 'images in your minds' by mapping or investigating chemicals and electric interactions. It is unable to deduce your existence based on the investigation and mapping of the interactions of these materials.

You need to be such materials in order to know that these chemical and electric interactions are at the same time also 'consciousness' and 'dreams'.

Ergo:
the scientific tools are not even able to discover Us in this world.
 
Last edited:
Nope, the computer only discovers a bunch of interacting chemicals.
It cannot discover 'dreams' nor 'consciousness'.

YET

Just like we once could not detect electrons or atoms.

And Im afraid your little fantasy is going to work the exact opposite way. Should aliens visit earth our dreams and language are most likely going to be complete gibberish to them and possibly even revolting.
But the mathematics describing a hydrogen atom will work the same for us as for them. It will most likely be our one thing in common
 
Nope, the computer only discovers a bunch of interacting chemicals.
It cannot discover 'dreams' nor 'consciousness'.

The CT scan and MRI scans detect brain activity, which is evidence of consciousness.

Or are you trying to tell us "consciousness" is all imaginary? That's what it looks like.
 
So, we all know that when we scan a chemical and electric process in the brain, that the mathematical model we make of this process and the chemical system is not the only thing there is.

There is something else too at the same time.

We know this.
Because we are such materials.
We know that these materials are also consciousness, dreams, awareness, mind...

The only tool we have to discover this part of reality is
being these materials.
 
That's right. But that's not the point.
The point is, that computer and its devices can't discover 'consciousness' or 'dreams' or 'feelings' or 'images in your minds' by mapping or investigating chemicals and electric interactions. It is unable to deduce your existence based on the investigation and mapping of the interactions of these materials.

Maybe so far.

You need to be such materials in order to know that these chelectric interactions are at the same time also 'consciousness' and 'dreams'.

Ergo:
the scientific tools are not even able to discover Us in this world.


No. Non sequitur.
 
The CT scan and MRI scans detect brain activity, which is evidence of consciousness.

'evidence of consciousness is not the same thing is 'discovering the existence of consciousness in this world'.

There is a distinction.

How did you discover conscousness in this world in the first place?

With a brainscanner or by following the math?

Or by being these conscious materials?
 
Last edited:
There is only one tool that can lead us to the discovery of consciousness in this world.

Being conscious materials.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom