I experience, therefore I am

So we can conclude that 'the math' and 'scientific devices' are worthless and totally useless in order to discover even Us in this world.

Afterwards we are able to provide 'socalled evidence' for the existence of consciousness by describing its matherialistic appearance.

But that's not how we discovered such thing in this world in the first place.

How exactly is your math or your tool of physics going to discover consciousness is non-brainlike materials?
 
Adman said:
What the hell does this mean?

You don't understand that you are a chemical interacting system? No?
What's difficult about that?
 
Last edited:
Not wrong at all.
I know that because I feel or experience things.

I experience, therefore I am.

How did you discover consciousness in this world?

Did you use a brainscanner or did you follow the math?

What kind of equation did you use?
When the scanner detected chemicals and electric signals, did you thought: "Hey, I just discovered 'conscousness' and 'dreaming' in this world, because I can deduce the existence of these things based on what I detect about the interacting chemicals here.
Now, I know what these things are!
:rolleyes:

No, your math is useless and your physics is worthless in order to discover your own existence in this world.
 
Last edited:
Indeed, you discovered it without any tool of science at all. Without following the math and without a detector.
QUOD ERAT DEMONSTRANDUM

Thank you Tsig for proving my point.

A hammer is a tool of science and I used it as a detector.
 
That's right. But that's not the point.
The point is, that computer and its devices can't discover 'consciousness' or 'dreams' or 'feelings' or 'images in your minds' by mapping or investigating chemicals and electric interactions. It is unable to deduce your existence based on the investigation and mapping of the interactions of these materials.

You need to be such materials in order to know that these chemical and electric interactions are at the same time also 'consciousness' and 'dreams'.

Ergo:
the scientific tools are not even able to discover Us in this world.

If you can't find yourself you can't play the game.
 
So, we all know that when we scan a chemical and electric process in the brain, that the mathematical model we make of this process and the chemical system is not the only thing there is.

There is something else too at the same time.

We know this.
Because we are such materials.
We know that these materials are also consciousness, dreams, awareness, mind...

The only tool we have to discover this part of reality is
being these materials.

Conscious chemicals considering themselves. That's all there is folks.
 
There is only one tool that can lead us to the discovery of consciousness in this world.

Being conscious materials.

You're saying that consciousness is something more than chemical reactions?
 
The main question is an epistemological question.

"What can we know?"

A philosophical question about what we can discover in reality.

What is our first tool to discover the existence of 'dreaming' in Nature.

You dream at night, don't you?

An investigation by a philosophical zombie robot with the perfect scientific tools and superior math skills will never be able to discover what 'dreams' are or that 'dreams' exist in this world based on his modelling techniques of the organic brain. He will be clueless about 'dreaming'.

It will be gibberish and foolish nonsense to him.

We will be gibberish and foolish nonsense in his model of the Universe.

But we know that 'dreaming' is part of this world.
We know that 'understanding' or 'images in our mind', 'feelings' or 'awareness' are part of this world, because we are such material beings.
We are that kind of system. This system of interacting chemicals and electic pulses.


So, we can witness the existence of things like 'being aware' or 'feeling', wich is nonsense for people like Adman, who only believe in one tool of knowledge: math and physics.

But in order to have a model of our whole Nature, we must be part of the description of Nature. We are the only ones who can witness the existence of minds.
The existence of 'awareness' cannot be reduced to just desribing the chemical interactions and its laws.
These laws and the description of the chemical interacting system, is not enough to describe the whole Nature of this thing.
It's more than its material appereance. And we know this, not thanks to our mathematical language or our physical devices. We know that only because we are these biochemical systems.

So, don't fool yourself with the socalled knowledge that math and physics are the holy roads to discover things in Nature.

These tools are worthless to discover the existence of feelings, observing, experiencing etc.
And to the robotscientist (the archetype of the pure materialist): your existence (being aware) is gibberisch.
It's wordsalad or nonsense. You can read it here on the forum. You are nonsense. Only your materialistic appearance is something worth to describe.

Fact is: science has no language for us. It has no language to describe consciousness or awareness. And we don't have the language to tell about our existence to a robotscientist (who is a philosophical zombie and has no mind at all).

So, what is a tool or model worth, when it cannot even describe or explain Our own existence in this world?
 
Last edited:
Once a robot scientist visited our city.
this thing, had no mind. It was a philosophical zombie.
It had superior math computing modelling skills and superior devices and scanners.

It began to map me. A perfect mathematical model of the nerv system. An amazing map of the brain with equations scientists only can dream about. It was beautiful with its intern consistency.

And I began to talk with this alienrobot about who I was and how I was amazed how smart IT was.
IT did not understand me. I told him again that I was a person and that I experienced things in this world.
I was gibberisch to him. Wordsalad for his tools. Language wich was not necessary for his model.
I told him that I felt pane, but he only discovered that my system was functioning well and the feedbacksystem (the pain) was also functioning . He did a few tests with my feedbacksystem (pain). It was very painful and I became sad, but he was convinced that I was functioning.
I was not able to explain my true Nature to this materialist. I had no language to explain my existence to IT and IT had no skills to understand my words. I was wordsalas to IT.

For IT, my material appearance was enough to have an mathematical intern consistent map of me.
The archetype of the pure materialist is not even able to discover our true Nature in this world.
IT is not capable of discovering the property of 'consciousness' or 'awareness' in electro-biochemical interacting systems in this world.

What a poor kind of 'tool of knowledge' is that.
 
Last edited:
Straw man argument.

Dreams are a natural manifestation of our brain's activity. As such, they obviously are part of nature.

I'm not sure what point you are trying to get at.
Unfortunately not unusual or unexpected.:rolleyes::eek::eek:
 
The point is very simple, the philosophical zombie with the most superior mathskills and most finetuned measuring devices (= the archetype of the pure materialist)
is not even capable of discovering consciousness when it is investigating some kind of interacting biochemicals.
The fool.

While investigating and mapping your nerv system and brainactivity, this fool ignores your existence.
By describing your material appearance and mapping it mathematically consistent, this fool thinks that he described your true Nature.

This tool of the materialist is misleaded by the material appearances of objects in this world and IT believes in IT's superior mathskills and devices.
He cannot discover the Invisible. The Unmeasurable.

This idiot is not capable of discovering 'Awareness' in this world while investigating material systems in Nature.
 
Last edited:
Not wrong at all.
I know that because I feel or experience things.

What does 'experience' mean? It's gibberish or wordsalad to me.

Maartenn100 believes in something he calls 'to experience'.

I don't know what that is.

Show me the mathematical description of it. What can't of math did you follow to discover 'to experience' in this world.
Please show me the verifiable evidence for such strange gibberisch wordsalad word like 'experience'.
 
Indeed, isn't it. gibberish. Experience. Not even worth mentioning. Because we didn't follow the math or have no equations to describe it.
Yet it's the most valuable thing of all of us. Science has no language or tools to describe or discover our non-material existence in this world.
It has no words for Us. All it can do is: investigating and mapping a chemical process in Nature, but it isn't even capable of derriving the existence of something like 'Awareness' or 'Consciousness' while it is investigating chemical and physical systems in this world.
It can not see the Invisible. Nor the Unmeasurable. It's actually a very poor tool to describe the whole Nature of things in this world.
IT can't see The Universe. The fool.
 
Last edited:
Appeal to imaginary aliens.

:D











(Actually, they have much longer equations.)
 
Okay, before I start I will try to explain something, the moment someone claims there is a limit to methodological naturalism and science, it seems to follow that this someone believes in some variant of theism, woo, new age or what ever. In other words you as the reader of this will have to watch your cognition so you don't fall into this "trap" - just because some people do the following invalid deduction as "science can't explain everything, therefore theism, woo, new age or what ever", it doesn't follow that I do that. So in caps that you might remember this if you choose to answer: I, TJ, AM AN ATHEIST, SKEPTIC AND NON-BELIEVER IN ALL THINGS SUPERNATURAL, PARANORMAL AND SO ON!!!

So what is it that some Believers seem to know and not just believe? Well, it is easy to spot once you learn to spot the over-reductive epistemology that some of us skeptics, atheists and science-"positivists" use. Here is the first example as you can find it on the internet; someone" "I only accept non-subjective evidence!"
Now use your ability to do critical thinking and skepticism and try to spot the absurd consequence of that claim. I am not saying it is a contradiction as such, but rather that it is open to reductio ad absurdum in the broad sense.
Me to that someone: "Would you please give non-subjective evidence to the fact that you only accept non-subjective evidence?"
Another variant, someone: "I only accept hard observational data!"
Me: "Would you please give hard observational data for the fact that you only accept hard observational data?"

This comes in many variants, but it seems to resolve around in part what science relies on as a methodology, namely repeatable and observation as "we observe", but we as we can't observe as see that something makes sense. So here is how I as a philosopher understand science - for the part of reality for which "we observe" works it makes sense to me to use science, but I don't think it makes to use it on that part of reality where "we observe" doesn't work in the strong sense.
In other words once you realize that "we observe" doesn't work on "it makes sense", because the former is a combination of inter-subjective for the "we" and objective for the "observe" where as "it makes sense" is first person singular subjective and can be shared inter-subjectively.

So here it is as applied to this exchange:
Someone: "Everything is physical!"
Me: "No, not in the over-reductive and simple version of everything can be explained through external observation and named a thing or property of a thing. Would you please explain what a no looks like and point to it? I don't mean that you can't point to the word no as the word, rather I mean point to no like you can point to e.g. a cat as a cat. The no as a no only takes place as a part of reality in an inter-subjective and subjective sense and in the strong sense of objective it has no referent. No is not a thing or a property of a thing like a cat or that the cat has legs, rather no is in part a mental, cognitive and qualitative word.
There is nothing new in this: "Man is the measure of all things: of things which are, that they are, and of things which are not, that they are not"; Protagoras. The word measure have two meanings, qualitative/mental/psychological/subjective and quantitative/physical/objective. So here is one aspect of the difference between subjective and objective - I can't do something which is objective unless it is an objective fact that I can in fact do so, but subjectively I can get away with claiming something is objective, for which it is in fact subjective:
Me: "I am so objective that no part of me is subjective and I can explain everything as everything using only mind(brain) independent, objective, physical and quantitative measurement!!!"

So here it is as how I have learned to do it as a philosopher and skeptic. You ought to learn in part, but not just to separate mind-dependent and non-mind-dependent facts. You have to learn to check your own thinking and feelings/emotions to that you don't "project" your thinking and feelings/emotions onto the rest of reality as an objective fact. You always have to check if need be every single word and its referent. Let me show you how that works:
Someone: "Science is the only and thus best form of knowledge we have!"
Me: "No - not just, but also as in part for everything as a part of everything how does the referent of the word best look like and how do we observe best?

Someone: "What goes on in your brain is physical and objective!"
Me: "No!!! It may be that we can in part explain it using methodological naturalism, but it is not objective like gravity is objective. If you want to "play everything, something, something else and/or nothing" learn to watch the human tendency to "over-reduce" complexity down to a single factor; i.e. everything is objective, because something is objective.

So for the Believer it goes like this: "Something is subjective, therefore everything is subjective because it is there for my sake!"
For the over-reductive variant of science it goes like this: "I think we ought to use science on everything as it works on something and therefor it works on everything!"
The problem for the latter is in part "I think we ought to..." as that is not objective as we observe, but subjective and inter-subjective for the I and we respectively.

So here it is as something I know; I know that I can only make sense of reality as something I do subjectively as me, but from that doesn't follow that reality as such is there for my sake. On the other hand it neither follows that because a part of reality is objective, that everything is objective. Rather to me as a philosopher it seems to follow in part as a part of reality that biological evolution in part but not just has a subjective element, because evolution in part takes place in individual organisms dependent on the actual DNA and genes present in each individual.
So here is a part of what subjective seems to be as a physical process; use science to explain what happens when you push one ball into another and then explain what happens when you throw a ball to a dog.

So here it is for everything - I treat everything not using ontological monism including solipsism but neither dualism, but rather as a inter-connected web of regularities, where all the regularities also are variants to each other and within a regularity there can be variants. So as a human in neutral descriptive sense I am partaking in a lot if regularities and I am also a variant. But it doesn't mean that I am special objectively as to purpose, meaning and value; rather that is only something I am if I treat myself so and in case I am treated so by others. That also applies to you and all other humans btw. In other words - the rest of the universe doesn't care for us, but it doesn't mean that we can't choose to care for each other.

Now I am not going to be nice, but here is it as some of us have learned in part to "play that we play everything, something, something else and/or nothing".
Would you please state the natural and physical law of ethics? Would you please state what kind of instruments are used to measure ethics and what international scientific measurement standard is used of ethics? What is ethics measured in?
"Man is the measure of all things: of things which are, that they are, and of things which are not, that they are not"; Protagoras.

As a piece of advise you don't need, because in all likelihood you cope and have a good enough life - never take for granted that you can reduce reality down to one universal methodology, because that one is as old as (western) philosophy and what makes you think that you are so special that you have succeed in something, where everybody else as failed???
Someone: "I can explain everything using rationality, logic, objectivity and scientific observation in a coherent and non-contradictory sense!!!"
Me: No!!!
Do you understand??? Science is not a monolithic "we" just because we can agree on non-belief as to the supernatural, paranormal and so on! It is and has always been in part, but not just a "fight" over ethics and whether that can be done in the strong sense of objective or if we have to settle for some variant of inter-subjectivity.

In other words, just because someone has learned to do science without subjective/cognitive biases, it doesn't follow that this someone can do so for all her/his existence. That is measurement as a bias for good and bad! Now here it is in everyday words for a part of the "game" we always play!
Someone to me: TJ, you are wrong, because...
Me: "Stop right there!!! What does wrong look like???"

So to you if you are a non-believer and can understand science, what is the scientific measurement standard of wrong???

With regards
Tommy
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom