I experience, therefore I am

The limited tools of knowledge of the (idealised) materialist:

So, we can at least conclude this:

When you ask a pure materialist:
How do you discover that you had a certain dream last night?
Did you follow the math? Or did you use a detector or a measuring device?

When he is intellectually honest, he would say: indeed 'my own experience' was my only portal to this fact in Nature.

Or when you ask a materialist how he checked the evidence when a friend told him: I have an image of a big sculpture in my mind I want to make.

A materialist must admit that he uses 'to believe' to accept this idea.

(I don't want to see him open your head and detect some pulses in your brain. How would he do that?)

No mathematics at all can reveal us this information. No detector can reveal us the content of this image in the mind of his friend.So, this whole 'believe' that 'the math' is the only tool in life to proof something is not true.
It's also not true that 'your own experience' or 'to believe' or not good tools for knowledge. These things are the first tools, when it comes to our most precious things in life: Consciousness, Awareness, Feelings, Imagination and its content etcetera.
But it's sad that some materialists can't admit that their materialistic tools of knowledge (following the math and detecting objects) fail to discover these things like 'Awareness, Consciousness, Feelings etc... Because the materialistic language is limited. Some of them call these things nonsense. (unbelievable isn't it?).
But we all know that 'dreams' or 'an image in our mind' or 'consciousness' or 'feelings' is no 'nonsense'. We live by it every day.
It's actually verys sad that the materialst can't admit the fact that 'to experience' or 'to believe in the Invisible' are the only tools of knowledge for these kind of 'things' in Nature.
In my opinion, such a materialist is a fool, or at least: stubborn as hell.

The hilited part can in the future become problematic if science/technology continues to evolve towards more refined measurements of what goes on in brains.

With regards
Tommy
 
Tommy said:
The hilited part can in the future become problematic if science/technology continues to evolve towards more refined measurements of what goes on in brains.

Of course you are right. But that's not what I mean.
Without humans (or animals) or conscious objects in general in this world, this detector, on its own, can never discover such things like conscousness, awareness, experiening, believing, imagination, etc... in the chemistry he is anilizing.

Only when it's a conscious object itself.


This is an epistemological issue.

Have you ever considered the fact that 'consciousness' is only one phenomenon of a whole category of phenomena.
Our sort of matter has awareness. When you are such an object, you discover what 'awareness' is. (that's your only tool)

But how would you exclude the fact that other materials, totally different from brains or computers in this world have something like conscousness or awareness too, but different. They look different and are at the same time something else, but different from awareness.
How would our instruments be able to discover such thing? How would we be able to know what these immaterial things of some sort of non-brainlike materials are?

Not. That's an objective limit about what we can know.

How would you exclude that electromagnetic radiation is 'something else too'? That light is not only what we can measure when we are studying the properties of electromagnetic radiation or fields?

How would you be able to exclude that a wave is not only a wave?
 
Last edited:
The boundless knobs of knowledge of the dreamish immaterialist:

When you ask a pure immaterialist:
How do you dream that you discovered last night?
Did you follow the path? Or did you use a de-psictor or an immmeasuring revice?

When he is emotionally honest, he would say: indeed 'my own inexperience' was my only portal to this feel in Metanature.

Or when you ask an immaterialist how he checked the sensation when a friend told him: I have an image of a big sculpture in my mind I want to inflate.

An immaterialist must admit that he uses 'to believe' to deflect this idea.

(I'd like to see him open your karmic matrix and entangle some etheric pulses in your solopsiverse. How would he do that?)

No mathemagics at all can reveal us this inflammation.

No theoscific device in the world can reveal us the content of this image in the mind of our friends.

But it's sad that some immaterialists can't admit that their immaterialistic tools of fauxledge (following the empath and deflecting objects) fail to define these things like 'Awareness, Consciousness, Feelings etc... Because the immaterialistic language is so meta.

In my opinion, such an immaterialist is a blinded fool by the holyness of his intangible fools.
 
How would you be able to exclude that a wave is not only a wave?

How do you exclude that a not-only-wave is not only a not-only-wave? What if it's not only a not only wave, but a not only not only wave that's more than not only?

I am not only being flippant.
 
So, we can conclude that there is at least one sort of chemistry in this world wich has an invisible nature.

And it revealed its Invisible nature to us because we are these electrochemicals.

Based on "this solid evidence" (or own experience) we may be a little suspecious about some materials in Nature.

There is more than the eye can see or the detector can measure in this world.

But these 'things' of non-brainlike materials, who cannot communicate their immaterial side to us, stay in the dark.

Their Nature cannot reveal itself to us.

But there are good reasons to be suspicious about these objects.

I suspect light. Indeed. A very strange object. It has absolute properties in this world.
 
Last edited:
Let us play with subjective and objective in relationship to processes. First the processes of two or more different observable scenarios. I am standing on a beach facing the ocean in front of me, the shoreline is somewhat straight and behind me is flat land.
  • I can remain standing and if I do so indefinitely I will fall down due to lack of water, food and/or sleep.
    I can turn around, but not left nor right at the same time and in the same sense. Likewise I can turn in any one direction I like, but not several at same time and in the same sense.
    I can walk forward, but I can't walk on water.
    Before I make up my mind/brain I could e.g. become unable to decide because of massive brain hemorrhage.

For the word subjective and objective in relationship to these and other physical process I could start there and expand with the dictionary explanation of e.g. objective and derive out of the these kinds of observations of the processes involved an usage for the word subjective, yet still describe it as a physical process as opposed to an objective and physical process.
But rather right now I choose not to do so, so you could choose to play objective/subjective and describe my choice using physical, biological, subjective, objective and other relevant and irrelevant words. ;)

With regards
Tommy

What?
 
But how would you exclude the fact that other materials, totally different from brains or computers in this world have something like conscousness or awareness too, but different.

Name some of these materials. Answer a straight question, just for a change.
 
Okay, Maartenn100. As long as your consciousness is your only tool you can't think outside the box of one tool and only one tool because you limit tools and usefulness to consciousness alone, I will leave you alone to your part of reality. :)
I.e. consciousness is necessary and sufficient versus consciousness is necessary but not sufficient in trying to understand reality.

With regards
Tommy
 
Last edited:
Your mathematical language is wordsalad to them.. Gibberish.
So, you need to translate these meaningless symbols (meaningless to them) in their language.

I seriously doubt that a species that doesn't understand mathematics will ever master interstellar travel.
 
So, we can conclude that there is at least one sort of chemistry in this world wich has an invisible nature.

And it revealed its Invisible nature to us because we are these electrochemicals.

Based on "this solid evidence" (or own experience) we may be a little suspecious about some materials in Nature.

There is more than the eye can see or the detector can measure in this world.

But these 'things' of non-brainlike materials, who cannot communicate their immaterial side to us, stay in the dark.

Their Nature cannot reveal itself to us.

But there are good reasons to be suspicious about these objects.

I suspect light. Indeed. A very strange object. It has absolute properties in this world.

It's suspicious that light happens to be tuned to the frequencies we can see with our eyes plus why is the atmosphere designed so that it is transparent to just those frequencies we need to see by?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom