How many things have we been taught were true but aren't?

So far the results of my lit review are maddening.

I have found cold matters, cold doesn't matter; vit C works, vit C doesn't work; Echinacea works, Echinacea doesn't work; zinc lozenges have an effect, zinc lozenges have no effect; .....

About the only thing that was consistent, was these studies' value should be questioned with so many inconsistent results. What's an NP to do?

Wikipedia has this:

Wikipedia said:
...If cold weather were directly linked to the spread of the common cold, then it could possibly be demonstrated by comparing the infection rates of people who live in colder climates (such as Iceland or Greenland) with people who live in warmer climates (such as countries close to the equator). Studies done in the 1960s found no significant increase in infection rates in people who live in colder climates.[30]
 
It was my understanding until today that cold, vit C and Echinacea had been ruled out as affecting upper respiratory infections; zinc lozenges were equivocal; and stress had an effect. After the lit review in PubMed I just did, my certainty of these research results now wanes. And I got tired. :D I'll have to go on with this quest later.

While I didn't copy all I reviewed, I had started collecting some citations before giving up. Here's what I had so far, in no particular order:

Rhinovirus infections in an isolated antarctic station.
Transmission of the viruses and susceptibility of the population. In brief, this isolated polar group was not especially susceptible to respiratory illness, and virus movement through the group was deliberate.

RESULTS:
The overall incidence of ARTI was 545 cases per 10,000 person-years, suggesting that, in the Dutch population, an estimated 900,000 persons annually consult their general practitioner for respiratory complaints. Rhinovirus was most common in case patients (24%), followed by influenza virus type A (11%) and coronavirus (7%). Viruses were detected in 58% of the case patients, beta -hemolytic streptococci group A were detected in 11%, and mixed infections were detected in 3%. Pathogens were detected in approximately 30% of control subjects, particularly in the youngest age groups. CONCLUSION: This study confirms that most ARTIs are viral and supports the reserved policy of prescribing antibiotics. In both case and control subjects, rhinovirus was the most common pathogen. Of bacterial infections, only group A beta-hemolytic streptococci were more common in case patients than in control subjects. Furthermore, we demonstrated that asymptomatic persons might be a neglected source of transmission.
I was looking at the cold bringing on symptoms in an asymptomatic but infected person hypothesis.

Subjects were traced for 1 year
to detect episodes of common cold, the diagnosis of which was based on symptoms and was validated by additional clinical signs. We detected 1,667 cases of common cold in 79,240 person-weeks of follow-up. Intake of vitamin C and zinc was not related to the occurrence of common cold.

Although the role of vitamin C
in common cold incidence had been studied extensively, the level of vitamin C intake has not been unequivocally shown to affect the incidence of colds. In the present study the six largest vitamin C supplementation (> or = 1 g/d) studies, including over 5000 episodes in all, have been analysed, and it is shown that common cold incidence is not reduced in the vitamin C-supplemented groups compared with the placebo groups (pooled rate ratio (RR) 0.99; 95% CI 0.93, 1.04). Consequently these six major studies give no evidence that high-dose vitamin C supplementation decreases common cold incidence in ordinary people. Nevertheless, the analysis was continued with the hypothesis that vitamin C intake may affect common cold susceptibility in specific groups of people. It was assumed that the potential effect of supplementation might be most conspicuous in subjects with low dietary vitamin C intake. The average vitamin C intake has been rather low in the UK and plasma vitamin C concentrations are in general lower in males than in females. In four studies with British females vitamin C supplementation had no marked effect on common cold incidence (pooled RR 0.95; 95% CI 0.86, 1.04). However, in four studies with British male schoolchildren and students a statistically highly significant reduction in common cold incidence was found in groups supplemented with vitamin C (pooled RR 0.70; 95% CI 0.60, 0.81). Thus, these studies with British males indicate that vitamin C intake has physiological effects on susceptibility to common cold infections, although the effect seems quantitatively meaningful only in limited groups of people and is not very large.

CONCLUSIONS:
This meta-analysis suggests that standardized extracts of Echinacea were effective in the prevention of symptoms of the common cold after clinical inoculation, compared with placebo. Further prospective, appropriately powered clinical studies are required to confirm this finding.

These findings suggest that psychological stress is a risk factor for the common cold.

Meta-analysis
CONCLUSION: Clinical trial data support the value of zinc in reducing the duration and severity of symptoms of the common cold when administered within 24 hours of the onset of common cold symptoms. Additional clinical and laboratory evaluations are warranted to further define the role of ionic zinc for the prevention and treatment of the common cold and to elucidate the biochemical mechanisms through which zinc exerts its symptom-relieving effects.


Cochrane database:
Echinacea for preventing and treating the common cold
Preparations of the plant Echinacea are widely used in some European countries and in North America for common colds. Echinacea preparations available on the market differ greatly as different types (species) and parts (herb, root or both) of the plant and different manufacturing methods (drying, alcoholic extraction or pressing out the juice from fresh plants) are used, and sometimes also other herbs are added. We reviewed 16 controlled clinical trials investigating the effectiveness of several different Echinacea preparations for preventing and treating common colds. Two trials investigated whether taking Echinacea preparations for 8 to 12 weeks prevents colds but found no clear effect. The majority of trials investigated whether taking Echinacea preparations after onset of cold symptoms shortens duration or decreases severity of symptoms, compared with placebo. It seems that some preparations based on the herb of Echinacea purpurea might be effective for this purpose in adults, while there is no clear evidence that other preparations are effective and that children benefit. Side effects were infrequent but rashes were reported in one trial in children.

Vitamin C in doses as high as 2 grams daily is not a panacea for prevention or treatment of the common cold, but it may reduce the risk of colds in people exposed to heavy physical or cold stress, and a small reduction in symptoms warrants further study
The term "the common cold" does not denote a precisely defined disease, yet the characteristics of this illness are familiar to most people. The common cold is the leading cause of acute morbidity and of visits to a physician in Western countries, and a major cause of absenteeism from work and school. The common cold is usually caused by respiratory viruses, and therefore antibiotics are useless for a typical acute common cold episode. Other potential treatment options are of substantial public health interest.

Since the isolation of vitamin C in the 1930s, it has been repeatedly suggested that it might affect respiratory infections. The possible role of vitamin C on the common cold became particularly popular in the 1970s, when Nobel Prize winner Linus Pauling concluded from the earlier placebo-controlled trials that large dose vitamin C supplementation would substantially reduce the incidence of colds. Pauling's activity led the initiation of new trials focusing on the role of vitamin C on colds.

This review was restricted to placebo-controlled trials in which at least 200 mg per day of vitamin C was administered to the study group.

The trials analyzed here show that regular ingestion of vitamin C has no effect on common cold incidence in the ordinary population. Nevertheless, six trials with participants exposed to short periods of extreme physical and/or cold stress (including marathon runners and skiers) showed reduction in common cold risk by half.

Regular vitamin C supplementation was fairly consistently associated with a small reduction in the duration and severity of common cold symptoms pointing to a definite physiological effect in respiratory defense mechanisms. However, the magnitude of the effect was small and raises doubt about its clinical usefulness.

When high doses of vitamin C have been administered therapeutically, starting after the onset of cold symptoms, there has been no consistent effect on either the duration or severity of symptoms. However, few such therapeutic trials have been carried out and their quality has been variable. One large trial reported equivocal benefit from an 8 gram therapeutic dose at onset of symptoms, and two trials using five-day supplementation reported benefit, pointing to the need for further therapeutic trials to examine the effects of large vitamin C doses. Finally, none of the therapeutic trials carried out so far examined children, even though the regular supplementation trials reported substantially greater effect on duration in children.
 
Last edited:
An old Mythbusters story showed that adding sugar to a car gas tank does not stop it going. Yet I for one was taught that this would work. Even read it in at least one novel.
 
One that is STILL being taught in the U.S. today is that the King of England, because he wanted a divorce, FOUNDED the Church of England.

The fact is, the Anglican Church existed long before he did; he merely adopted it as his own (and, of course, as the State Church) over the R.C. Church.

Another gem is that the Episcopalean Church is Protestant. Our History teacher threw that gem at us.

Of course, she also said that an object dated to be 3000 years old was made in 3000 B.C. So I guess the extra 2K years didn't much matter?
 
One that is STILL being taught in the U.S. today is that the King of England, because he wanted a divorce, FOUNDED the Church of England.

The fact is, the Anglican Church existed long before he did; he merely adopted it as his own (and, of course, as the State Church) over the R.C. Church.

Another gem is that the Episcopalean Church is Protestant. Our History teacher threw that gem at us.

Of course, she also said that an object dated to be 3000 years old was made in 3000 B.C. So I guess the extra 2K years didn't much matter?

...and Henry VIII did _not_ have 6 wives. I think the correct figure is 2.
 
I did a quick review on the sunscreens and skin cancer. They don't prevent cancer entirely and should supplement other measures, hats, clothing, avoiding mid-day Sun. Also, there was a problem with the studies if one stayed in the Sun longer because one was using sunscreen then that could counteract the benefit. Nothing said sunscreen was useless, especially if you are out in the Sun and have no choice or no better options.
 
My eighth-grade science teacher tried to teach us Velikovsky's Worlds in Collision. Luckily I had the sense...okay, okay, laziness... to not read it.
 
...Another gem is that the Episcopalean Church is Protestant. Our History teacher threw that gem at us....
Well. in the US, the official name is the Protestant Episcopal Church of the United States of America. She was right there.
 
My favourite one from University (and don't ask for references- even at the time we were told of an awful science cover up) was this

ATP isn't an energy storing molecule (It's a co-factor apparently). This was a subject taught to us during a long hot summer lecture by our head of Biochemistry and included lots of technical explanations and descriptions of the workings of HSDSC (his speciality)

I'm still unsure to this day but in the absence of any strong evidence I have remained decidedly undecided about the subject.
 
An old Mythbusters story showed that adding sugar to a car gas tank does not stop it going. Yet I for one was taught that this would work. Even read it in at least one novel.


The basis of the myth was that sugar would dissolve, go throught the carb, and totally gum up the insides of the engine. But,The sugar does not dissolve in gas. It just sits there. It will plug up filters. But all you have to do is flush it out with the garden hose, then dry the water out. I learned this as a mechanic who made my own Kahklua out of grain alcohol- the alcohol won't dissolve the sugar, you need to add water, or use vodka.
 
It will not prevent skin cancer
- Just sitting in the bottle,
- If you are outdoors more often
- Not properly applied.
- There is little evidence that it does prevent any skin cancer.

It prevents sunburn. It is assumed that thereby it also prevents cancer. But since it may cut cancer by a small percent, but also allows the subject to spend more time in the sun, there has been no decrease in the overall skin cancer rate since the marketing began.
 
How many things have we been taught were true but aren't?

"I love you" means "forever."

:cry1 :v:
 
One that is STILL being taught in the U.S. today is that the King of England, because he wanted a divorce, FOUNDED the Church of England.

To be fair, that's still taught in Britain as well.

...and Henry VIII did _not_ have 6 wives. I think the correct figure is 2.

That argument doesn't really work. If you go through various technicalities then some were annulled and some shouldn't have been legal in the first place. The point is that he married 6 different women and had them all as his wife for every sensible meaning of the word. Unless you're a lawyer or the pope, he had 6 wives.
 
I had an argument in 10th grade with a teacher. She said that I was wrong to be an atheist, because men have one less rib than women, and this fact "proved" Christianity to be true.

After picking my jaw up off the floor, I made xeroxes from an anatomy book talking about this myth. I showed it to her, and she became very flustered. Then I highlighted the rest of the xeroxes and hung them throughout the school. Just to mess with her. :cool:
 
My high school biology teacher thought that red blood cells had the little dent in the centre because the cell acted like a little bowl for carrying oxygen.
 
Well. in the US, the official name is the Protestant Episcopal Church of the United States of America. She was right there.

Not entirely accurate, though. The term was used during a time when 'protestant' referred to anything that was not strictly Roman Catholic. In practice the church is via median - a middle ground between Catholic and Protestant ways, though the majority of its rituals and practices are staunchly Catholic.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom