How many things have we been taught were true but aren't?

Mercury used to used to process felt for hats, poisoning the hatters and causing dementia.. The mad Hatter in Alice in Wonderland.
 
When I was at school I had a big blob of mercury collected from broken thermometers in physics class. I kept it in a little holder in my pencil case, and used to play with it on top of the desk in dull lessons.

This may explain a lot....

Rolfe.
 
Seatbelts save lives.

Read http://www.cato.org/pubs/pas/pa335.pdf for an explanation of why seatbelts do not, on average, save lives. (Capsule summary, people wearing seatbelts drive more recklessly and the two effects almost perfectly offset each other.)
Get a life dude, just look at the stats of fatal accidents with and without seatbelts.

I'm sorry but this kind of woo is dangerous and frankly angers me having lost a loved one who wasn't wearing his seatbelt.


I'm not sure I accept the data in this paper at face value but even if true it merely says
During those three years, the Department of Transport reduced the claim for lives saved from 1,000 a year to 200.6
So whether their figures are actual or the 1,000 was an estimate and the 200 the actual measurement, they still credit the seatbelts for saving 200 lives. And why were the back seat passengers still dying? Didn't they have seatbelts on? And we aren't told how many fatalities were passengers and how many were pedestrians. It could be the 1,000 was an estimate that would have been accurate if only back seat passengers had belts on too or had shoulder straps.

The author simply puts forth an hypothesis about increased high risk driving but the evidence doesn't address the details of the accidents that would actually test the hypothesis.

So you have an hypothesis being claimed as supported by the evidence but one could easily argue the evidence didn't address the hypothesis in any kind of definitive way.

Seventy-three percent of the people who were in a fatal crash in 2001 and were restrained survived; of those who were not restrained, only 44 percent survived. [NHTSA, Annual Assessment of Motor Vehicle Crashes, 2001]...In fatal crashes, 75 percent of all passenger car occupants who were totally ejected were killed. Only 1 percent of those occupants had been using a safety belt. [NHTSA, Traffic Safety Facts Overview, 2001]
 
Last edited:
Consider a car crash much loved by conspiracy nuts this side of the Atlantic:

100mph crash in a tunnel; Fayad and Diana in back seat, not wearing seat belts - killed; driver, not wearing seat belt - killed; bodyguard in front passenger seat, wearing seat belt - survives.
 
Mercury used to used to process felt for hats, poisoning the hatters and causing dementia.. The mad Hatter in Alice in Wonderland.

Did Carroll explicitly state that this was the inspiration for the Mad Hatter? I'm always sceptical of things that sound like retrospective explanations for things.

Here's one I was taught as a kid that I heard again only the other day being told to some children at a museum by their father - that the fuller or "blood groove" in a bayonet or sword blade was designed to prevent the blade sticking in your victim's body. Utter nonsense - it's an engineering technique to allow for the same blade strength with less metal and therefore less weight (like an I-beam). Though there are secondary purposes, such as making a better fit in the scabbard (for C20th bayonets), and creating a whistling noise (for Japanese medieval swords).

My personal theory about that myth is that returning GIs and Tommies had been taught or told this out of ignorance as to bladesmithing, and possibly as a way of geeing them up for battle (bayonet drill being an important part of what some would call kill-conditioning). It's classic reasoning applied without the requisite knowledge. Our stock-in-trade around these parts!
 
Seatbelts save lives.

Read http://www.cato.org/pubs/pas/pa335.pdf for an explanation of why seatbelts do not, on average, save lives. (Capsule summary, people wearing seatbelts drive more recklessly and the two effects almost perfectly offset each other.)


On the contrary, studies show that wearing a seat belt significantly increases your chances to survive a car crash.

See:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seat_belts

Look at the references here, and follow the links to the PubMed papers.

Cheers,
TGHO
 
I used the 'seat-belt myth' in a homework exercise in my forensics class this term. Kids were presented with the claim that they do more damage than save lives, and they had to either agree or disagree with it on account of their homework.

Those who did it found adequate refutation for the claim.

Athon
 
I was taught in second grade how the Earth and its inhabitants were made in 6 days. Kinda hilarious if you think about it....

And during a first-aid course, I learned a variant of the 'blue blood' myth. Apparently the blood is red when leaving the heart and blue when returing, because all the oxygen has been absorbed by the body. It made sense at the time.

Re: the Mad Hatter. The guy in Alice in Wonderland is named the Hatter. The Mad Hatter is a DC Comics villain. I think the expression 'mad as a hatter' is at least a century older than the book, so I suppose it could be an inspiration for Carroll's hatter.
 
Seatbelts save lives.

Read http://www.cato.org/pubs/pas/pa335.pdf for an explanation of why seatbelts do not, on average, save lives. (Capsule summary, people wearing seatbelts drive more recklessly and the two effects almost perfectly offset each other.)

Get a life dude, just look at the stats of fatal accidents with and without seatbelts.

I'm sorry but this kind of woo is dangerous and frankly angers me having lost a loved one who wasn't wearing his seatbelt...


I see that you (and a bunch of other people) beat me to it. This looks like anti-seatbelt propaganda rather than a legitimate claim about false information taught in schools.

Look at the source: Cato Institute. They're a "free market" think tank specializing in rhetorical arguments against any government regulation of industry. They tend to be less interested in the merits of an issue and more interested in finding a way to spin things to show that regulation is unnecessary and that the free market will magically do what's best for everyone.

Take a look at their positions on global warming, for instance. The Cato Institute tends to dismiss the bulk of research, since it leads to conclusions they don't like. They strain at any gnat in the work of qualified scientists whose work indicates global warming is a problem while swallowing any bull which says it isn't. In general they prefer to put their faith in what economists say rather than what scientists show. If they are doing the same thing with seat belts, then I'm not surprised they have concluded that seat belts don't save lives. It was, for them, a foregone conclusion.

With regard to seat belts, studies done with crash test dummies have shown that a person wearing a seat belt will in general suffer less injury in a crash than a person not wearing a seatbelt. I don't think that's in dispute. So if that is what schools are teaching, then what schools are teaching is correct.

It sounds (from Ben Tilley's post) as if the Cato Institute is arguing that people wearing seat belts will drive more dangerously and have more serious crashes than people not wearing seat belts. That's possible, but I'd like to see an explanation of how that was determined. It's fairly easy to design tests which will measure how much damage a test dummy sustains in comparable crashes (a) when wearing a seat belt and (b) when not wearing a seat belt. It's a lot harder to test how fast and how dangerously people drive (a) when wearing seat belts and (b) when not wearing seat belts.

I'm not saying this can't be studied scientifically. I am saying I doubt the Cato Institute's ability to do a valid scientific test of such a question. They have never shown such a capability in the past. Their specialty is economics and rhetorical argument -- not scientific testing.

And, no, I am not going to click on the Cato Institute link to wade through their article to try to dig out precisely what it is they are asserting regarding seat belts and what evidence they have to support their assertions. That's the responsibility of the person posting the claim. If Ben Tilley seriously believes that schools teach incorrect information about seat belts, it is his responsibility to post what it is that schools are teaching and what the evidence is which shows this to be wrong.

Posting a link is not an acceptable substitute for stating clearly what one's claim is and what the evidence supporting one's claim is. Simply waving a link around, without quoting or summarizing the specific items at the link which one wishes to offer into evidence, is what people tend do when they don't actually have good evidence to support their point.
 
Last edited:
I was told that seat belts increased your chances of being injured in a car crash. The reason was that for every person seat belts saved from injury it also saved more than one person's life. However they would be injured. I cannot give any sources.

Yes, seat belts do save lives. When Australia made seat belts compulsory the number of people killed on the roads went down. As this was a state legislation it happened at different times in different states.

No I do not have any links for you.
 
I know "common sense" can be a dirty word/phrase around here (and with good reason), but seatbelts=livesaving is about as common sense as it gets. The idea that we drive less safely with belts on is patently ludicrous. That might be a genuine effect in the first few years after introduction, but seatbelts are now as much a part of automotive ritual as looking in the mirror.

In fact, you might just as well say that we shouldn't have rear-view mirrors, because we'll drive more safely without them!
 
People in England (and I suspect elsewhere in the UK) are taught, and largely believe that the Wars of The Roses were a series disputes/ civil wars between the Counties of Lancashire and Yorkshire. They were not, they where a series disputes/ civil wars between those that were loyal to (or supported) the House of York and those that where loyal to or supported the House of Lancaster- geographic location was a very poor indicator of which house a particular feudal lord would support. Many areas in Yorkshire were Lancastrian and many areas in Lancaster were Yorkist. The fact the people kept switching sides doesn’t make understanding the situation any easier.

Other pet peeves of mine; people are often taught that the UK has no constitution, and that the House of Commons is a building.
 
Where can I find the UK's constitution? Is it written down? My Mum tells me the UK has no written constitution.

Ah, now that's changing the question slightly ;)


The Uk's constitution is a collection of documents, treaties laws and conventions- amased over centuries. It is not one document, although many (but not all) of the documents which make up the UKs constitution are stored in an old bell tower above the entrance to Westminster Hall of the palace of Westminster. Most written on goat hide.

The UK's constitution is written what it is not is codified. Even getting constitutional experts to agree which documents for part of the constitution is tricky...
 
My dad taught me that blood lubricates the joints and cabbage cleanses the blood. For years I had visions of joint capsules filled with blood and blood vessels clogged with regular clumps of vegitation seiving out impurities.

Excellent - I love my dad!

Yuri
 
People in England (and I suspect elsewhere in the UK) are taught, and largely believe that the Wars of The Roses were a series disputes/ civil wars between the Counties of Lancashire and Yorkshire. They were not, they where a series disputes/ civil wars between those that were loyal to (or supported) the House of York and those that where loyal to or supported the House of Lancaster- geographic location was a very poor indicator of which house a particular feudal lord would support. .


I went to school in Yorkshire and was not taught that it was between Yorkshire and Lancashire!

Other things that people know about the UK that ain't so:

1. The monarchy is hereditary. In fact, while the post of king/queen is normally for life, successors are chosen by Parliament.

2. The Prime Minister is elected. In fact s/he is appointed by the monarch. It is the usual practice for the monarch to appoint the leader of the biggest faction in Parliament because due to our FPTP system, the biggest faction usually has an overall majority and thus will be able to form a government. In a hung parliament, there'd be nothing to stop the monarch appointing the leader of an alliance of smaller parties as PM.
 
I remember being taught about the Brontosaurus, then several years later it was said, ”oops we made a mistake” there is no Brontosaurus. Pluto is a planet, oh, wait, no it’s not. 30 years ago I rented a house that had a set of Encyclopedia Britannica from around 1890. Virtually every bit of science in it was wrong. It makes you think, what will be fact in 100 years? Will everything we know right now be proved wrong?

I think Firesign Theater said it along time ago…Everything you know is wrong.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom