How many things have we been taught were true but aren't?

Although not taught formally in school, this seems to get passed on quite a bit and gets accepted as being true ...

Moist air is heavier than dry air.

If that were true, seems like we wouldn't have clouds. Although cooler air is heavier by volume than warm air, so we get fog via its moisture content.
 
Are you saying it doesn't weigh that much? I think it does. (Approximately, anyway. Atmospheric pressure is 14.7 psi, actually, not 16 psi.) Where does the pressure come from, if not weight? The atmosphere isn't sealed up in a closed container.

A column of air one centimeter square at the ground whose sides all intersected the center of the earth would weight 14.7 pounds, methinks. Less the higher the altitude, obviously.
 
A column of air one centimeter square at the ground whose sides all intersected the center of the earth would weight 14.7 pounds, methinks. Less the higher the altitude, obviously.

I think you mean a colum that is one inch square at sea level. 'cause centimeters would be mixing units.
 
...people think its them shooting the blood out like that, but veins just sort of leak when you poke a hole in them so a vaccuum is needed to make the proccess quick....
I believe average venous pressure depending on a healthy heart not in congestive failure is about 4-6 mm Hg. But it varies considerably, for example, in the chest as you inhale you create negative pressure and positive pressure when you exhale. Breathing is also moving venous blood back to the heart. And you can bear down without exhaling and increase venous pressure considerably.

If you had no valves in your veins then the pressure would also vary over the gradient of the vertical column of fluid. Thus if you stood up, the venous pressure in your feet would be considerably influenced by gravity. The one-way valves in your veins prevent that from occurring.
 
Actually substitute mass for weight and you are both close to being right. The % increase of mass of the Earth due to meteorites and the thousands of tons of space dust is very small. Also some mass is lost due to the atmosphere going into space.

My favourite is that the atmosphere weighs 16 pounds per square inch. That is the pressure of the atmosphere.
You mention mass then ignore the mass of the air molecules. Molecules whether in a gas, liquid or solid are acted on by the gravity of the Earth and therefore have weight when on Earth.

However, the gas molecules are also bouncing all around so they have pressure as well.

But thinking that through a bit more, the higher you go the less the air pressure. Why? because there are less molecules on top of you.


I understand your reasoning, the air molecules are not staying in one place. But regardless, each molecule has weight when close to Earth. The total weight then depends on how many molecules are overhead. There is space between them. But the molecules in liquids are moving and there is space between them and they also exert pressure on the sides of a container. Liquids also have weight. And when you are under water, the force of weight of the water and the water pressure are two ways of looking at the same thing.


So if liquids have weight, gases have weight. And if neither does and you call it pressure instead, what does a single molecule weigh? And wouldn't 2 weigh 2x as much and so on?


But you can have pressure from the mass of the gas, and not have weight if you are not on a planetary body.
 
Last edited:
Hmm. Not sure about that. As a planet is in orbit around the Sun, clearly gravitational force exists between the two bodies and since the weight of an object is the force exerted on it by gravity, a planet does have weight?

The force exerted on an object in circular motion is (mv^2)/r where m is the mass of the object, v is the radial velocity & r is the radius of rotation.

So for Earth:

m= 6 * 10^24 kg
v = 30,000 m/s
r = 1.5 * 10^11 m


So the weight of Earth is 3.6 * 10^19 newtons
Then way are people weightless in space? The Earth has mass. If the Earth were sitting on the Sun it would have weight. In free fall it is as weightless as an astronaut orbiting the Earth.
 
Old medical textbooks are fun.

In the early 1900s a hysterectomy was done to cure hysterical women.

As recently as the 50s medical texts claimed masturbation was unhealthy and dangerous.

An awful lot of kids had tonsillectomies for no good reason.
 
Glass is a very slow-lowing liquid, which is why old windows are thicker at the bottom than at the top.

I actually found that one in a textbook I was (briefly) considering adopting last month.

But old geography books are the best. I have ne that talks about how the various peoples of Austro-Hungary will probably get used to each other and develop a national feeling.
 
I had a teacher tell me that spiders were insects. Fortunately, I was an adult at the time, and she was not MY teacher, and I could tell her she was wrong. Unfortunately, everyone in the room agreed with her. I was too busy prying my jaw off the floor to come up with the word "arachnid".

Eric
 
Is an answer of "the many, many years that I was taught that religious people were good and moral" appropriate on the Science, Mathematics, Medicine, and Technology forum?
 
Old medical textbooks are fun.

In the early 1900s a hysterectomy was done to cure hysterical women.

As recently as the 50s medical texts claimed masturbation was unhealthy and dangerous.

An awful lot of kids had tonsillectomies for no good reason.

Hysteria means "wandering uterus" in greek, and was deemed sexist about 30 years ago (as it implies only woman can be hysterical) and so was changed to hypochondriacal neurosis.


I still would like to hear more about the tongue thing. I thought indeed different areas of the tongue had lowerthresholds for different tastes.

I even used to teach it back in another life when I taught perception.
 
An awful lot of kids had tonsillectomies for no good reason.

I was in that cohort. You have tonsillitis (even mild), and the tonsils & adenoids come out. I was five. They used ether to put me under. I thought they were trying to kill me.
 
I believe average venous pressure depending on a healthy heart not in congestive failure is about 4-6 mm Hg. But it varies considerably, for example, in the chest as you inhale you create negative pressure and positive pressure when you exhale. Breathing is also moving venous blood back to the heart. And you can bear down without exhaling and increase venous pressure considerably.

im not too keen on the science aspect of blood pressure, im just going by what ive seen, so I am not sure what you are implying with your numbers.

even with a tourniquet most peoples arms just sort of leak blood when you puncture a vein. id say about one in four hundred peoples veins squirt when you puncture them. it just doesnt happen very often, and once the tourniquet is off it just leaks. thats been my experience anyway, the majority of my draws were on geriatric patients though too.
 
Then way are people weightless in space? The Earth has mass. If the Earth were sitting on the Sun it would have weight. In free fall it is as weightless as an astronaut orbiting the Earth.

Weight is the force on an object due to gravity, calculated by m*g, the mass times the acceleration due to gravity. In a rotating reference frame, like being in orbit, this is balanced by an inertial force ('pseudo force'/'centrifugal force' if you like), so objects feel weightless. Proper weightless would require being very far away from any significant amount of gravity. It's not obvious if you are just moving around in the space shuttle, or on earth, but it makes a big difference if you want to change orbits.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom