How many things have we been taught were true but aren't?

Ben, auto travel is much safer now for a number of reasons from safer road designs to safer cars, including seat belts. Your sources are not convincing irrespective of the fact you like the hypothesis. The data shows that the safety improvements including seat belts save many more lives than any excess lives lost to reckless driving.

Frankly, I don't even find the hypothesis all that convincing on its own merits. You would need to show that all people are reckless and/or as daring as possible. That simply isn't true. In fact, I find that idea counter to most driver's dispositions. If you were only looking at males, 15 to 25, maybe a fair percentage of them would increase risky driving with seat belts on. But as for the rest of the demographic, I see no evidence whatsoever. And if the 15-25 yr old males were already maxed out on speed and risk taking, I doubt the thought you would live through the wreck would increase risk taking any further. These are drivers who do not believe they are going to have a wreck. I can't see them further contemplating that if they crash their car they won't likely die so why should they care.

I ain't buying it. And the data simply does not support it.
 
Last edited:
Ben, auto travel is much safer now for a number of reasons from safer road designs to safer cars, including seat belts. Your sources are not convincing irrespective of the fact you like the hypothesis. The data shows that the safety improvements including seat belts save many more lives than any excess lives lost to reckless driving.

I am fully aware of how many factors have gone into improving the safety of our cars. For instance we no longer have steering wheels that break off and then impale you on the pole. I'd be the last to deny that these advances have saved lives. Since Unsafe at any Speed was written by Ralph Nader, fatality rates have come significantly down, and I applaud that.

I'm also well aware of the benefits of seatbelts, and you can be assured that I always wear mine.

However the question is whether legislation requiring seatbelt use is a good thing. That I'm not convinced of, and the data on it is far less clear than you'd think.

Frankly, I don't even find the hypothesis all that convincing on its own merits. You would need to show that all people are reckless and/or as daring as possible. That simply isn't true. In fact, I find that idea counter to most driver's dispositions. If you were only looking at males, 15 to 25, maybe a fair percentage of them would increase risky driving with seat belts on. But as for the rest of the demographic, I see no evidence whatsoever. And if the 15-25 yr old males were already maxed out on speed and risk taking, I doubt the thought you would live through the wreck would increase risk taking any further. These are drivers who do not believe they are going to have a wreck. I can't see them further contemplating that if they crash their car they won't likely die so why should they care.

If you think that you need to show that all people are reckless and/or as daring as possible, then you have not understood the hypothesis at all. Little surprise, then, that you'd criticize it.

The hypothesis is that we maintain a comfort level with risk. We cut corners a certain amount in life. Virtually all of us do it, for instance most of us sometimes come to a rolling stop at 4-way stop signs, and most of us routinely break speed limits, if only by a bit. And most accidents aren't due to people being really crazy, it is just due to people taking normal levels of risk and getting unlucky.

So we don't strap on our seatbelts and become speed demons. Instead we put them on and cut a few more corners. That's all. And that's enough to make a difference.

Have you driven in Southern California? Are you familiar with the stereotype we have here of the soccer mom using her cellphone while driving her SUV? There is a lot of truth to that stereotype, and the reason for it is that SUVs are designed to make their drivers feel safe. (Unfortunately they aren't really designed to make their drivers be safe, just feel that way.) And safe feeling drivers are a little more inclined to be aggressive and/or careless.

I ain't buying it. And the data simply does not support it.

Just curious, when have you personally looked at the data?
 
electricity is not the motion at the speed of light of electrons but of the electrical potential. The electrons move a lot slower, depending on the conductor, if at all. In AC they just kinda vibrate a bit. Not really a flow of them.

Actually, even that doesn't move at the speed of light. It depends on the kind of conductor and the frequency, but it's usually a reasonable fraction of the speed of light.
 
So we don't strap on our seatbelts and become speed demons. Instead we put them on and cut a few more corners. That's all. And that's enough to make a difference.

It's just anecdotal, but two of the three cars that ran into mine were Volvos.

In any event, I doubt the suggested connection with seat belts, simply because seat belt use has become so common that people don't even think it makes them safer any more. They just do it as a matter of course.
 
Plato -

Strange times are these in which we live, when old and young are taught in falsehoods schools. And the one man that dares to tell the truth is called at once a lunatic and fool.
 
It's just anecdotal, but two of the three cars that ran into mine were Volvos.

In any event, I doubt the suggested connection with seat belts, simply because seat belt use has become so common that people don't even think it makes them safer any more. They just do it as a matter of course.

Well Volvo is a special case. :)

They had a series of very safe cars. Then in the early 90s they introduced the 850 series, which was a very overpowered safe car. As a result they wound up with two distinct user bases. Those who liked the safety, and those who liked the speed. You could usually tell which was which by how fast they were driving.;)
 
In regards to the OP: My high school biology teacher insisted that if a person has Herpes 1 (cold sores) that they also have Herpes 2 (genital warts).

A few years ago, I was in a public restroom when I overheard a mother telling her little girl to wash her hand with "real hot" water because it's the heat of the water that kills the germs.

The most memorable "wrong thing" I was taught was Columbus discovered North America while trying to prove that the Earth was round.
 
The most memorable "wrong thing" I was taught was Columbus discovered North America while trying to prove that the Earth was round.

"She is a-round, like-a a apple"
"She is flat, like-a a pancake"
"She is round, like-a my head"
BAM!
"She is flat, like-a you head"

"Oh Columbus is the discoverer of America
As he sailed the seas in 1492
And the good queen Isabella
Gave her jewels to her fella
So Columbus could sail 'cross the ocean blue"

So much you could learn from Bugs Bunny.
 

The idea of that article is to dispell the idea that a rigid 8 glasses a day is a golden rule for everybody.

Why wouldn't drinking water be a good idea? If you are drinking a little too much water it will go straight to your "waste disposal system".

On a personal note, I enjoy drinking water throughout the day and rarely drink anything else.
 
Putting hot tap water in ice cube trays makes them freeze faster than cold water from the faucet (no, they don't).

(Please, let's not discuss this again.... they DO NOT FREEZE FASTER... period. The key is hot tap water, which is around 120-140F... as opposed to near boiling which does freeze faster but produces very very small ice cubes.)

The first time I saw my wife do it, I told her she was insane.... then we bought a fridge with an ice maker.
I've been told that using hot water for ice cubes is done so that there will be no bubbles in the ice. Just clear ice.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom