Skeptic Ginger
Nasty Woman
- Joined
- Feb 14, 2005
- Messages
- 96,955
Ben, auto travel is much safer now for a number of reasons from safer road designs to safer cars, including seat belts. Your sources are not convincing irrespective of the fact you like the hypothesis. The data shows that the safety improvements including seat belts save many more lives than any excess lives lost to reckless driving.
Frankly, I don't even find the hypothesis all that convincing on its own merits. You would need to show that all people are reckless and/or as daring as possible. That simply isn't true. In fact, I find that idea counter to most driver's dispositions. If you were only looking at males, 15 to 25, maybe a fair percentage of them would increase risky driving with seat belts on. But as for the rest of the demographic, I see no evidence whatsoever. And if the 15-25 yr old males were already maxed out on speed and risk taking, I doubt the thought you would live through the wreck would increase risk taking any further. These are drivers who do not believe they are going to have a wreck. I can't see them further contemplating that if they crash their car they won't likely die so why should they care.
I ain't buying it. And the data simply does not support it.
Frankly, I don't even find the hypothesis all that convincing on its own merits. You would need to show that all people are reckless and/or as daring as possible. That simply isn't true. In fact, I find that idea counter to most driver's dispositions. If you were only looking at males, 15 to 25, maybe a fair percentage of them would increase risky driving with seat belts on. But as for the rest of the demographic, I see no evidence whatsoever. And if the 15-25 yr old males were already maxed out on speed and risk taking, I doubt the thought you would live through the wreck would increase risk taking any further. These are drivers who do not believe they are going to have a wreck. I can't see them further contemplating that if they crash their car they won't likely die so why should they care.
I ain't buying it. And the data simply does not support it.
Last edited: