How many things have we been taught were true but aren't?

im not too keen on the science aspect of blood pressure, im just going by what ive seen, so I am not sure what you are implying with your numbers.

even with a tourniquet most peoples arms just sort of leak blood when you puncture a vein. id say about one in four hundred peoples veins squirt when you puncture them. it just doesnt happen very often, and once the tourniquet is off it just leaks. thats been my experience anyway, the majority of my draws were on geriatric patients though too.

I have to tell you that about one in 400 times, you hit an artery.

Hey, this sounds like a method of collecting blood which is seriously deadly as far as exposing people to blood-borne infections is concerned. Like HIV.

How long ago did you say this was?

Rolfe.
 
Not entirely accurate, though. The term was used during a time when 'protestant' referred to anything that was not strictly Roman Catholic. In practice the church is via median - a middle ground between Catholic and Protestant ways, though the majority of its rituals and practices are staunchly Catholic.

Well I agree that it's hard to tell the difference between C of E and RC, as far as a C of S (Presbyterian) member is concerned. However, the Episcopalian (Anglican) church is most certainly "protestant", as in "reformed", as in a product of the Reformation.

I once heard someone remark, "well, there aren't many protestants in England, after all."

To which someone rather quicker than me replied, "oh really? Henry VIII would be a bit disconcerted if he knew that!"

Rolfe.
 
Not entirely accurate, though. The term was used during a time when 'protestant' referred to anything that was not strictly Roman Catholic. In practice the church is via median - a middle ground between Catholic and Protestant ways, though the majority of its rituals and practices are staunchly Catholic.

Not in the cult I was forced to join at a tender age. No incense, no mandatory confession before communion, no calling the married reverend "father". But they did have the symbolic cannibalism and blood drinking thing.
 
Weight is the force on an object due to gravity, calculated by m*g, the mass times the acceleration due to gravity. In a rotating reference frame, like being in orbit, this is balanced by an inertial force ('pseudo force'/'centrifugal force' if you like), so objects feel weightless. Proper weightless would require being very far away from any significant amount of gravity. It's not obvious if you are just moving around in the space shuttle, or on earth, but it makes a big difference if you want to change orbits.
Nominated for "The Stundies" on the Conspiracy forum.
To change orbit, you apply acceleration to mass--not weight.
Weight is artifical-a result of mass being accelerated. g is different for all locations--that's why we use mass in calculations, not weight.
 
I wasn't trying to imply venous blood 'spurts', it cannot. Once the pulse wave reaches the capillary bed the vessels get larger. Any pulse pressure is dissipated and there is no more influence of heart pumping action.

I wasn't trying to say anything. I was just spouting knowledge for knowledge's sake.

If you have a vein "spurting" then it isn't from pulse pressure. Drawing blood from a vein in the interior antecubital space you can on rare occasion actually hit an artery instead. The two run close together there. I've done it twice in 30 years.

oh ok. when i said the vein squirts i mean just like once upon inserting the needle, but im sure you know anyway since you have a bunch of experience.

yeah i do my best not to get near the artery in the arm. I still stick to the vein choice guidelines, though most people i know do not.
 
Nominated for "The Stundies" on the Conspiracy forum.
To change orbit, you apply acceleration to mass--not weight.
Weight is artifical-a result of mass being accelerated. g is different for all locations--that's why we use mass in calculations, not weight.

Er, what? Weight isn't artificial, it's a force. Seeing as how I never said anything like "apply acceleration to weight", I'm going to need more of a hint as to why you think anything I said is wrong.

Edit - Huh. From the Stundie thread
Notice--Weight is force--then he goes somewhere...
Changing orbits requires an acceleration, moving mass.
Weight is simply mass*acceleration--regardless of source--gravity or whatever

That's just wrong. There are two common definitions of weight: mass times local acceleration due to gravity, best seen in free body diagrams; and the normal force, or more generally any force that only acts on the surface of an object. It's never the mass multiplied by any old acceleration.
 
Last edited:
You were both wrong. The Earth (or any planet, for that matter) is weightless. It is in Orbit around the sun, and therefore in free-fall.:D
(Thanks, Dr. Asimov)

If you want to get really anal about it, then we could note that weight, like all forces, is frame-dependent. In Earth's reference frame it has no weight. In the Sun's reference frame it does.

Any object in free-fall is weightless in a frame that has the same acceleration as that object. Our own local frame of reference is the same as Earth's (so long as we're standing on it) so in our frame Earth is indeed weightless.

But it seems they were talking about mass, not weight.
 
Not only are they fish, they're tasty fish.
Bender: "Who wants dolphin?"
Leela: "Dolphin? But dolphins are intelligent!"
Bender: "Not this one. He blew all his money on instant lottery tickets."
Leela: "Oh. Pass the blowhole."
Amy: "Can I have the fluke?"
Hermes: "Hey! Quit hogging the bottlenose!"
Professor: "Toss me the speech center of the brain."
 
One thing we did at school that almost scares me now. We routinely boiled Mercury in test tubes with no precautions against inhaling the fumes.

How times change. A few years ago a worker dropped a thermometer in the ceiling at work. It stayed there for an unknown amount of time. Then it broke and dropped Mercury onto the ground. The floor was evacuated, fire fighters in full HAZMAT suits uniforms took out all the furnishings. We then had to have Mercury poisoning tests done. All were negative.

OH! Oh! Now you're gonna DIE!

It's true!

The dentist used to give me a little mercury from the amalgam mixer to play with. Maybe it was a curse?
 
I have to tell you that about one in 400 times, you hit an artery.
....
One in 400? There must be some really bad phlebotomists out there lowering the average.

But now that we are discussing it and I'm thinking about it, once in a great while I have had a venous puncture actually squirt a bit. It doesn't pulsate, it happens when the vein has built up a little pressure from the tourniquet.

I draw blood a lot and I've only hit an artery twice in 30 years. (Not counting drawing blood gases that is.)

I have heard people claiming you didn't have to draw back on the plunger giving IM injections also and that's a bad idea. I've gotten blood back 3 or 4 times. I do literally give thousands of shots though.
 
Last edited:
Er, I meant that if she said she got a spurt one time in 400, then she was hitting an artery that often.

I agree, shouldn't be nearly that much. Depends on what you mean by a spurt though.

I took squillions of blood samples from horses during my PhD work, and hit an arterly (carotid) maybe a handful of times. I noticed that when that happened the horse or pony objected strongly to the procedure, while they usually put up with the venepunture quite philosophically. Also, the blood was bright red. Also, there was a high chance of a haematoma developing over the site.

I agree with you about drawing back before injecting i/m. You never know.

Rolfe.
 
Well, the Straight Dopes weren't paying attention to the Mpemba Effect. You and they are wrong. Under certain conditions hot water does freeze faster than colder water. You might look up a reference or two before implying someone wasn't paying attention.

You remind me of http://math.ucr.edu/home/baez/physics/. Lots of fun stuff.

Many years ago it was more deliberately provocative. It started with a list of ridiculous claims, like "hot water freezes faster than cold", "energy is not conserved", "if a fat man and a skinny man coast down a hill on bicycles, the fat man arrives at the bottom first", "absolute zero is not the coldest possible temperature" and so on. Then proceeded to defend each one. But people got tired of all of the resulting arguments in sci.physics, plus there were some very involved discussions about the conservation of energy point, and the faq became less provocative.
 
Bender: "Who wants dolphin?"
Leela: "Dolphin? But dolphins are intelligent!"
Bender: "Not this one. He blew all his money on instant lottery tickets."
Leela: "Oh. Pass the blowhole."
Amy: "Can I have the fluke?"
Hermes: "Hey! Quit hogging the bottlenose!"
Professor: "Toss me the speech center of the brain."

Whenever I see it on the menu (and these days, it's always called mahi-mahi or dorado) I always order it. For one, it's delicious, and secondly, to shock the ignorant diners around me. I refer to it as 'dolphin' loudly and often. I say "This DOLPHIN'S sooooo tasty!" and wait for someone to ask if I'm really eating dolphin. I point out that Mahi-mahi is actually dolphin and that they call it that because they don't want people to know what it REALLY is. People say "That's Dolphin? You mean like Flipper?!" I point to the tasty peice of fish on my plate and say "well, I'm pretty sure that this one isn't Flipper. I think Flipper's been dead for a number of years".
 
You remind me of http://math.ucr.edu/home/baez/physics/. Lots of fun stuff.

Many years ago it was more deliberately provocative. It started with a list of ridiculous claims, like "hot water freezes faster than cold", "energy is not conserved", "if a fat man and a skinny man coast down a hill on bicycles, the fat man arrives at the bottom first", "absolute zero is not the coldest possible temperature" and so on. Then proceeded to defend each one. But people got tired of all of the resulting arguments in sci.physics, plus there were some very involved discussions about the conservation of energy point, and the faq became less provocative.

I don't quite understand your point. Do you mean to say the Mpemba Effect is a "ridiculous claim"?
 
I don't quite understand your point. Do you mean to say the Mpemba Effect is a "ridiculous claim"?

To someone with an elementary understanding of physics and a lack of understanding of how reality can complicate affairs, it seems like a ridiculous claim.

Just because it may seem ridiculous, doesn't mean that it is not true. :-)
 
OH! Oh! Now you're gonna DIE!

It's true!

The dentist used to give me a little mercury from the amalgam mixer to play with. Maybe it was a curse?
Yep, I remember fun times on the kitchen floor after mom dropped and broke a thermometer. Pushing around that little blob of mercury on the tiles was so cool!
 
OH! Oh! Now you're gonna DIE!

It's true!

The dentist used to give me a little mercury from the amalgam mixer to play with. Maybe it was a curse?

Yep, I remember fun times on the kitchen floor after mom dropped and broke a thermometer. Pushing around that little blob of mercury on the tiles was so cool!

You're both mad as hatters!!

:p
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom