How many things have we been taught were true but aren't?

im not too keen on the science aspect of blood pressure, im just going by what ive seen, so I am not sure what you are implying with your numbers.

even with a tourniquet most peoples arms just sort of leak blood when you puncture a vein. id say about one in four hundred peoples veins squirt when you puncture them. it just doesn't happen very often, and once the tourniquet is off it just leaks. thats been my experience anyway, the majority of my draws were on geriatric patients though too.
I wasn't trying to imply venous blood 'spurts', it cannot. Once the pulse wave reaches the capillary bed the vessels get larger. Any pulse pressure is dissipated and there is no more influence of heart pumping action.

I wasn't trying to say anything. I was just spouting knowledge for knowledge's sake.

If you have a vein "spurting" then it isn't from pulse pressure. Drawing blood from a vein in the interior antecubital space you can on rare occasion actually hit an artery instead. The two run close together there. I've done it twice in 30 years.
 
Last edited:
Perhaps one should ask the question "Does an object still have weight as it falls freely?" Or as I drop an apple onto the floor, does it still have all of its weight as it falls? The correct answer is, yes. For as it falls its weight is the constant force causing it to accelerate all the way down to impact.

Now, if instead of letting the apple just drop straight down we throw it horizontally outward it will still have all of its weight causing it to arc in a parabolic path. Throw it hard enough (and from high enough so that air resistance is negligible) and we have an object in orbit. It still has most of its weight (as long as we're still close to the planet) as it orbits -- but this condition is commonly known as being weightless. Free-fall would be the more accurate description.

So, whether in orbit aboard a spaceship or in an elevator falling freely, the sensation in either case within the confines described are the same -- weightlessness. But also, in both cases you still have your weight.
 
Its mass is the reason for the force, JT. Weight requires a measurement (real or theoretical) of pressure on a scale. Otherwise weightlessness is a myth and I don't think it is.

But then, I'm a nurse practitioner, not a physics expert.
 
Its mass is the reason for the force, JT. Weight requires a measurement (real or theoretical) of pressure on a scale. Otherwise weightlessness is a myth and I don't think it is.

But then, I'm a nurse practitioner, not a physics expert.

Mass is required for weight (in this case) -- but weight needs no measurement of pressure on some surface in order for it to be present. As an object falls (like the apple example) its weight is the amount of force which keeps it accelerating. Now, since this force (weight) is proportional to its mass, we see that in a gravitational field all masses will accelerate at the same rate.

As for true weightlessness, you would need to either have no gravitational fields present, or a net field of zero. The closest one might get to that condition in our solar system is at the Sun's core.
 
zero gravity
n.

The condition of apparent weightlessness occurring when the centrifugal force on a body exactly counterbalances the gravitational attraction on it.

Weightlessness

A condition induced by the effective lack of resistance to gravitational force on an object or organism, sometimes known as free fall.

Newton proposed the law of universal gravitation, which states that two bodies of matter in the universe attract each other with a force that is directly proportional to the product of their masses and inversely proportional to the square of the distance between their centers. According to this law, even a small increase in the distance between bodies will produce a large decrease in the gravitational force, since the force decreases with the square of the distance. As a body moves from the Earth's surface to a location an infinite distance from the Earth, the gravitational force approaches zero and the body approaches weightlessness. In the true sense, a body can be weightless only when it is an infinite distance from all other objects.

Weightlessness is also defined as a condition in which no acceleration, whether of gravity or any other force, can be detected by an object or organism within the system in question. According to Albert Einstein's principle of equivalence, there is no way to distinguish between the forces of gravitational fields and the forces due to inertial motion. When a gravitational force on a body is opposed by an equal and opposite inertial force, a weightless state is produced. This is based on the fact that the mass that determines the gravitational force of a body is the same as the mass related to the acceleration produced by an inertial force of any kind. These inertial forces have no external physical origin, but are the consequences of an accelerated state of motion. Because of inertia, a moving object always tends to follow a straight line. When a person swings a bucket by the handle in a large circle, he or she feels a pull on his or her hand, because inertial force (also called centrifugal force in this case) tends to keep the bucket moving in a straight line, while the bucket holder exerts a counterforce constraining the bucket to move along the circle. A similar situation exists in a spaceship orbiting the Earth 200 mi (320 km) above the Earth's surface, where the gravitational field is only slightly weaker than at sea level. The ship, in free fall with negligible atmospheric drag, is pulled toward the Earth by the Earth's gravitational attraction force, while the inertial or centrifugal force of the moving ship is directed radially outward from the Earth; consequently, the force of gravity on the orbiting ship is opposed and nullified by the centrifugal force, and apparent weightlessness results. See also Gravitation; Gravity; Inertia; Newton's laws of motion; Space flight; Space processing.
...
There's more, go to the link.

It appears we are both correct depending on whether we are talking about apparent weight or true weight.
 
Then way are people weightless in space? The Earth has mass. If the Earth were sitting on the Sun it would have weight. In free fall it is as weightless as an astronaut orbiting the Earth.

People aren't weigtless in space! They are however in freefall, because the spaceship is falling as fast as they are, their weight is not causing them to press against the floor so it feels as if they have no weight. The correct term for this situation is "reactionless". They still actually have weight in all these situations because gravity is acting on them and the weight of an object by definition is the force exerted by gravity on that object. You get a similar but short lived sensation when a high speed lift begins a descent or an aircraft such as the "vomit comet" goes into a dive.

Edit: Just Thinking beat me to making this point.

BTW, my calculation was out by three orders of magnitude :blush: the correct value is 3.6 * 10^22 newtons
 
Last edited:
One thing we did at school that almost scares me now. We routinely boiled Mercury in test tubes with no precautions against inhaling the fumes.

How times change. A few years ago a worker dropped a thermometer in the ceiling at work. It stayed there for an unknown amount of time. Then it broke and dropped Mercury onto the ground. The floor was evacuated, fire fighters in full HAZMAT suits uniforms took out all the furnishings. We then had to have Mercury poisoning tests done. All were negative.
 
The one that always bugged me, because it's still taught today, is the death of William Harrison. For you non American readers he was the 9th president of the United States. He also had the shortest term, of only 30 days in office before he died.

The textbooks tend to tell the same story. During his inauguration it was a wet and cold day. He decided to not wear an overcoat and delivered the longest inauguration speech ever. Because he spent so much time out in the cold that day, he got sick and died.

Folks, ever since the 60's we've known that being exposed to cold does NOT make you more susceptible to viruses. Yet even today we look for a woo answer to the question "why?". George Washington, we are told, died because he was exposed to bad weather, got sick and died. Perhaps it's human nature that we have to add a cautionary moral to our history. Still, it's bad science.
 
One thing we did at school that almost scares me now. We routinely boiled Mercury in test tubes with no precautions against inhaling the fumes.

And let's not forget the wondrous cleaning benefits of Benzene (in the lab) that was used outside of a hood, by hand.
 
Ahh, and those home chemistry sets, where you could make stuff that exploded, and scarred your lungs for life...
 
BTW, my calculation was out by three orders of magnitude :blush: the correct value is 3.6 * 10^22 newtons

Had my text all typed to point that out... :)

With the weight thingy:

An amiable turtle of mass M stands in an elevator accelerating at a rate a. Find N, the force exerted on him by the floor of the elevator.

The forces acting on the turtle are N and the weight, the true gravitational force W = Mg. Taking up to be the positive direction, we have:

N - W = Ma
N = Mg + Ma
N = M(g + a)

This result illustrates the two senses in which weight is used. In the sense that weight is the gravitational force, the weight of the turtle, Mg, is independant of the motion of the elevator. In contrast, the weight of the turtle has magnitude N = M(g + a), if the magnitude of the weight is taken to be the magnitude of the force exerted by the elevator on the turtle.
An Introduction to Mechanics, Kleppner & Kolenkow


What we have is simply two definitions of what weight is...
 
People aren't weigtless in space! They are however in freefall, ....
You ignored this: It appears we are both correct depending on whether we are talking about apparent weight or true weight. See post #65, and Gertrude's post #71 about defining weight.
 
The one that always bugged me, because it's still taught today, is the death of William Harrison. For you non American readers he was the 9th president of the United States. He also had the shortest term, of only 30 days in office before he died.

The textbooks tend to tell the same story. During his inauguration it was a wet and cold day. He decided to not wear an overcoat and delivered the longest inauguration speech ever. Because he spent so much time out in the cold that day, he got sick and died.

Folks, ever since the 60's we've known that being exposed to cold does NOT make you more susceptible to viruses. Yet even today we look for a woo answer to the question "why?". George Washington, we are told, died because he was exposed to bad weather, got sick and died. Perhaps it's human nature that we have to add a cautionary moral to our history. Still, it's bad science.
Oh my, do the text's really say that?
 
Glass is a very slow-lowing liquid, which is why old windows are thicker at the bottom than at the top.

....
I had to look into this one. I had still thought that was true.

Is glass liquid or solid?
It is sometimes said that glass in very old churches is thicker at the bottom than at the top because glass is a liquid, and so over several centuries it has flowed towards the bottom. This is not true. In Mediaeval times panes of glass were often made by the Crown glass process. A lump of molten glass was rolled, blown, expanded, flattened and finally spun into a disc before being cut into panes. The sheets were thicker towards the edge of the disc and were usually installed with the heavier side at the bottom. Other techniques of forming glass panes have been used but it is only the relatively recent float glass processes which have produced good quality flat sheets of glass....

[snip]

There is no clear answer to the question "Is glass solid or liquid?". In terms of molecular dynamics and thermodynamics it is possible to justify various different views that it is a highly viscous liquid, an amorphous solid, or simply that glass is another state of matter which is neither liquid nor solid. The difference is semantic. In terms of its material properties we can do little better. There is no clear definition of the distinction between solids and highly viscous liquids. All such phases or states of matter are idealisations of real material properties. Nevertheless, from a more common sense point of view, glass should be considered a solid since it is rigid according to everyday experience. The use of the term "supercooled liquid" to describe glass still persists, but is considered by many to be an unfortunate misnomer that should be avoided. In any case, claims that glass panes in old windows have deformed due to glass flow have never been substantiated. Examples of Roman glassware and calculations based on measurements of glass visco-properties indicate that these claims cannot be true. The observed features are more easily explained as a result of the imperfect methods used to make glass window panes before the float glass process was invented.
 
What about this?
Really bad science?

However, I will investigate further. My question, not having access to the full article, is were the people with their feet in cold water in the same room all at once? After they were randomized, were each group processed differently. All it would take is one person on the research staff or in the test group having a cold to infect a few extra people in that group. It was peak upper respiratory infection season. In order to test the researchers hypothesis, that unapparent infections become apparent with cold feet, one would have to have positive viral throat cultures on asymptomatic test subjects. Also, were there any controls on these people being exposed to cold outside of the test procedure? It can affect a study even if the test subjects were randomized.

abstract

letters in response to the article

The letters intrigue me as well as the study. I have however, read a few other studies that came to different conclusions about cold and the onset of upper respiratory infections. I'll let you all know what I find.

BTW, an overwhelming number of studies have refuted Linus Pauling's vitamin C study from the 50s. Vitamin C has no impact on upper respiratory infections either in preventing or modifying them.
 
Last edited:
Were you not paying attention?

Now go put cold tap water and hot tap water in some ice trays... (psst, the cold one freezes first).

Straight Dope
Well, the Straight Dopes weren't paying attention to the Mpemba Effect. You and they are wrong. Under certain conditions hot water does freeze faster than colder water. You might look up a reference or two before implying someone wasn't paying attention.
 
So far the results of my lit review are maddening.

I have found cold matters, cold doesn't matter; vit C works, vit C doesn't work; Echinacea works, Echinacea doesn't work; zinc lozenges have an effect, zinc lozenges have no effect; .....

About the only thing that was consistent, was these studies' value should be questioned with so many inconsistent results. What's an NP to do?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom