How many things have we been taught were true but aren't?

My 5'th grade physical science teacher and I got in a debate (a rather short one) in class. He argued that because of gravity, the Earth weighs exactly what it did millions of years ago. I pointed out meteorites and the thousands of tons of space dust that fall to Earth each year. He didn't respond.

Actually substitute mass for weight and you are both close to being right. The % increase of mass of the Earth due to meteorites and the thousands of tons of space dust is very small. Also some mass is lost due to the atmosphere going into space.

My favourite is that the atmosphere weighs 16 pounds per square inch. That is the pressure of the atmosphere.
 
I think the title of a book about it was "Lies my teacher told me"...


There are several good books I've seen which list commonly-believed-things-which-aren't-so (and quite a few more which I haven't read yet but would like to some day). They can generally be found right around the 001 section (Dewey Decimal) in a library. I forget what the LC number is (but Library Lady would probably know...)

One commonly mis-taught item concerns Christopher Columbus. His disagreement with the learned people of the time was over the size of the world, not its shape. It was already known that the world was round; but Columbus believed the world was small enough that he'd be able to sail all the way around, while the royal advisers believed it was too large for that to be practical. Columbus was wrong, and they were right.
 
Had a middle-school math teacher tell me (in front of the class) that there was no method of calculating square roots and that it had to be done with trial and error...


In elementary school, during lunch hour, another student and I got into an argument about what 1/2 multiplied by 1/2 was. I knew it was 1/4, but could not convince the other person of that. (I think he thought it was 1.) So I suggested we ask the teacher.

We each told the teacher what we thought the answer was. The teacher said she didn't know what the answer was, but she did know it couldn't be 1/4 because 1/4 is smaller than 1/2 and when you multiply things they get bigger...
 
nope. you know the tubes your blood shoots into when you get your blood drawn? they have a vaccum in them, so that darker red color is the color of venous blood w/o being exposed to air(people think its them shooting the blood out like that, but veins just sort of leak when you poke a hole in them so a vaccuum is needed to make the proccess quick). the blue color of veins through skin is an optical illusion.

This effect is called Rayleigh scatteringWP.

:)
 
In elementary school, during lunch hour, another student and I got into an argument about what 1/2 multiplied by 1/2 was. I knew it was 1/4, but could not convince the other person of that. (I think he thought it was 1.) So I suggested we ask the teacher.

We each told the teacher what we thought the answer was. The teacher said she didn't know what the answer was, but she did know it couldn't be 1/4 because 1/4 is smaller than 1/2 and when you multiply things they get bigger...
:jaw-dropp

I hated working with fractions when I was in grade school, but in spite of that I still remember that multiplying fractions was easy - just multiply each numerator and each denominator. Adding or subtracting fractions, on the other hand, with all that messing about to get a common demoninator... *shudder*
 
My favourite is that the atmosphere weighs 16 pounds per square inch. That is the pressure of the atmosphere.


Are you saying it doesn't weigh that much? I think it does. (Approximately, anyway. Atmospheric pressure is 14.7 psi, actually, not 16 psi.) Where does the pressure come from, if not weight? The atmosphere isn't sealed up in a closed container.
 
You could say the air weighs so much per cubic kilometre or a tube of air from sea level to outer space which is one square inch in cross section weighs 14.7 pounds (or whatever it is) but pounds per square inch is not a weight measurement.

Edit. Maybe on second thoughts the above is density. The atmosphere in total has a weight of so many tonnes.
 
Last edited:
Just remembered one. The Mackinaw bridge was a popular field trip when I was in school and the teachers used to tell us that dogs were not allowed to walk across the bridge because the rythmic clicking of their nails resonated in the suspension wires and would cause the bridge to collapse. We were also told that the bodies of workers were in the pillars.

As I kid I didn't understand why there was a toll to cross the bridge while traveling but there was a turn-around just before the booths (which are only on the north side) so you can cross it for fun for free. Passing over once costs money, but twice was free. It seemed to defeat the purpose.
 
Putting hot tap water in ice cube trays makes them freeze faster than cold water from the faucet (no, they don't).

(Please, let's not discuss this again.... they DO NOT FREEZE FASTER... period. The key is hot tap water, which is around 120-140F... as opposed to near boiling which does freeze faster but produces very very small ice cubes.)

The first time I saw my wife do it, I told her she was insane.... then we bought a fridge with an ice maker.
But the Mpemba Effect is that hotter water freezes more rapidly than cooler water.
Mpemba & Osborne (1969) "Cool".Physics and Education, 4, 172-175
 
Last edited:
A coworker showed me a 19-century textbook that explaind that Zachary Taylor died from eating cherries and ice cream on a hot day. It claimed that that particular combination of foods was often deadly.
 
My 5'th grade physical science teacher and I got in a debate (a rather short one) in class. He argued that because of gravity, the Earth weighs exactly what it did millions of years ago. I pointed out meteorites and the thousands of tons of space dust that fall to Earth each year. He didn't respond.

We're also losing hydrogen and helium from the upper atmosphere (and probably other heavier molecules, but much more slowly), as well as gaining some from sun blowoff. I have no idea how these stack against each other or vs. meteorite and dust.

When I was little (early '70's) I had a science book at home that had a hypothetical painting of people in a little colony on Mars. The ship, standard 50's rocket style, was perched on its pylons, which made little dents in the pink surface that looked to me for all the world like it was sitting on pink angelfood cake.

So in 3rd grade, when we talked about Mars, I mentioned how the surface was soft and spongey. My teacher said, "I don't think so..."
 

If you define senses as "similar" sensations that are otherwise of a different quality, this listing seems to claim too much. Sweet and salty are the "same stuff", but not the same as sound, or red, or green.

The usual 6th sense, your sense of balance, almost has more of a feel sense to it. So too your "kinetic" sense, and this sense of your own body position.

This site also seems to separate out touch, pain, and temperature, which also have a same feel quality, if you ask me.

One they don't list (of the 9, they don't present the 22) is flavor, which seems to be a pseudo sense that is greater than the sum of its parts: taste and smell.

I think the site is getting confused between the raw sensation itself, and the emotional impact and drive the brain associates with it.

One wonders if you could attach a color to the "horror recoil" response and panic of severe pain, and, in the reverse, associate the raw sense of horrible pain with the emotional response of smelling a delicious meal. Just how intrinsic is the reaction to the actual sensation itself?

As evolution occured, did it grab onto emotionless sensations that the universe's physics are, for whatever reason, capable of generating, and arbitrarily assign them to emotional impacts? Or is it intrinsic to that odd and not understood sensation itself. Was an emotionless touchlike feeling latched onto and attached to a horror recoil panic response, and called pain? Or is the horror recoil an intrinsic part of this "spirit" sensation portion (for lack of a better word I use a religious term.)
 
Last edited:
I have a 1959 edition of The world Book Encyclopedia and it speaks of the Ku Klux Klan in very glowing terms. It says they were a critical part of the South overcoming the obstacles of the reconstruction. It glosses over the murders of blacks and stresses the intimidation of carpetbaggers and "scalawags".
 
If you define senses as "similar" sensations that are otherwise of a different quality, this listing seems to claim too much. Sweet and salty are the "same stuff", but not the same as sound, or red, or green.

The usual 6th sense, your sense of balance, almost has more of a feel sense to it. So too your "kinetic" sense, and this sense of your own body position.

This site also seems to separate out touch, pain, and temperature, which also have a same feel quality, if you ask me.

One they don't list (of the 9, they don't present the 22) is flavor, which seems to be a pseudo sense that is greater than the sum of its parts: taste and smell.

I think the site is getting confused between the raw sensation itself, and the emotional impact and drive the brain associates with it.

One wonders if you could attach a color to the "horror recoil" response and panic of severe pain, and, in the reverse, associate the raw sense of horrible pain with the emotional response of smelling a delicious meal. Just how intrinsic is the reaction to the actual sensation itself?
The standard list of the human senses in every introductory psych text includes vision, hearing, taste, smell, pressure, temperature, pain, the kinesthetic system and the vestibular system. The site is correct, but uses more technical terms than are necessary for the introductory level.
The different senses have different specialized receptors (except for pain, which is detected by free nerve endings), detect different physical stimuli and are represented in different areas of the brain.
 
Last edited:
You were both wrong. The Earth (or any planet, for that matter) is weightless. It is in Orbit around the sun, and therefore in free-fall.:D
(Thanks, Dr. Asimov)

Hmm. Not sure about that. As a planet is in orbit around the Sun, clearly gravitational force exists between the two bodies and since the weight of an object is the force exerted on it by gravity, a planet does have weight?

The force exerted on an object in circular motion is (mv^2)/r where m is the mass of the object, v is the radial velocity & r is the radius of rotation.

So for Earth:

m= 6 * 10^24 kg
v = 30,000 m/s
r = 1.5 * 10^11 m


So the weight of Earth is 3.6 * 10^19 newtons
 
Last edited:
We're also losing hydrogen and helium from the upper atmosphere (and probably other heavier molecules, but much more slowly), as well as gaining some from sun blowoff. I have no idea how these stack against each other or vs. meteorite and dust.

I should have said "mass"... I beg forgiveness. As for the helium thing, I always did wonder where all those balloons went.
 
... One they don't list (of the 9, they don't present the 22) is flavor, which seems to be a pseudo sense that is greater than the sum of its parts: taste and smell.

The site I listed was only to present the argument that others claim more than the usual 5 that are taught -- it is certainly not intended as the be-all-and-end-all of senses.

Plus, another "sense" that I felt was missing was one's sense of time. I'm sure that healthy, conscious individuals can differentiate 1 second from say, 5 seconds fairly closely without any external timing device (clock).
 
Although not taught formally in school, this seems to get passed on quite a bit and gets accepted as being true ...

Moist air is heavier than dry air.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom