Those who hide them, provide for them, send them recruits, suggest targets to them, launder money for them, applaud (except clearly out of fear) them.
I'm with you on all but the last one. With the first five, those people are accomplices. The last group are just jerks, to put it mildly and to stay within forum language rules.
Who is "them"? Muslims in general? You will search in vain for any statements from Mark6 to that effect.
No, "Islamic Fundamentalism" as Mark6 specified way back in
post #130. (It wasn't
that hard of a search.)
Them, in the context of who we're fighting and killing, are the jihadis. And killing all the jihadis doesn't mean genocide, any more than killing all the Nazi soldiers would have meant genocide of Germany.
Mark6 also defined "Them" as those who subscribe to a specific kind of ideology and "who want to make the world conform to their THOUGHT" (
#134). He also calls for continued warfare not until just the soldiers give up, but the society does, as well (#130 again).
And victory may not require that we do so (we didn't have to in WW2), but I have absolutely no problem with being prepared and willing to do so.
If that is your opinion, that is fine. I happen to agree with that. However, that is clearly not the position Mark6 is taking. Just because I am attacking his position does not mean I am attacking yours, Zig.
Don't think there are only two sides to a specific issue. Just because we disagree on some aspects does not mean that we disagree on all aspects.
No, this would be the "don't threaten to kill me" part of Mark's position. Why do you continue to try to frame that as a free speech issue when it is nothing of the sort?
I've explained why several times now. A threat is only really a threat if there is a reasonable expectation that it would be acted upon. Until then, and Mark6 even agreed with this, "their mutterings are unimportant" (
#143). And yet, it is on the basis of their
mutterings, not the expectation that it would be
acted upon that Mark6 defines his criteria for the war to be over.
There is a difference between calling for death of infidels and calling for the death of these particular infidels at this place, at this time, done in this manner, and here is all the information you need to do it. It's the difference between threatening and being a threat.
Sorry, but if you preach that muslims should kill infidels, it's pretty damned unambiguous that the intention is to lead to violence. Why you continue to pretend otherwise is beyond me. It's really hard to take you seriously when you keep tripping over this most basic issue.
Okay, I think you're hung up on this because of the subject matter de jour. Let's switch it out for a more classic example:
Consider here in the US, some members of the KKK want to have a public rally where they will advocate driving black people out of the state. They represent less than one tenth of one percent of the population of the state. Should they be allowed to speak? If violence does occur, does that mean the KKK should never be allowed to have a public rally again anywhere, ever?
I'm not saying that they should not be condemned, but what what is the phrase? "The cure for bad speech is more speech, not less."