How do you know when a War On Terror is won?

Many of us here live in countries who have domestic terrorism issues (and have had so since long before 9/11); the UK, the Spaniards, and so on. If you believe that terrorism is a remote beast, that it is restricted to 9/11, then you are either niaive or a fool. There will always be those who reach for the gun, or the bomb, before they will go to the ballot box.

Here you are stating that the War on Terrorism will never end.

Can you now not see the scam?


What you are purportedly concerned about - and given your previous inability to adequately research the topics you seek to talk on, I have no great faith in your proposition - is that your government is worngly or vexatiously classifying action groups as bein terrorist. Well, when we see proper evidence, links, and a balanced analysis then we might think about it. Now go away and do your homework, son.

Welcome to the Brave New World, dad.

:gnome:
 
I should have added the caveat "that I've encountered" which would explain that it is a small, likely not representative, sample that I'm talking about.

Count me as someone left of center that believes 9/11 was an unforgivably horrific act committed by terrorists (not freedom fighters) who should be brought to justice. I think the invasion of Afghanistan was necessary and proper. I would have cried no tears if ObL had been killed before being captured. On the other hand, I also think the invasion of Iraq was unnecessary and was planned and executed so poorly that people at the top should have lost their jobs.

I also believe that while the vast majority of terrorists are born out of the hateful speech of Islamic fundamentalists, some are also born out of the coalition forces' arresting, abusing, and torturing innocent people.

. . . . . . .
I'd like to get rid of all lobbyists.

While they may prove somewhat irksome, their existence is protected by the First Amendment's right to petition the government for a redress of grievances.
 
Here you are stating that the War on Terrorism will never end.Can you now not see the scam?

No, I'm going to have to ask you to clarify that answer. Are you suggesting that terrorism, i.e. in the sense commonly understood, is being deliberately maintained by our various governments? And if so then how, for example, do you explain the effective dismantling of the IRA over the last 10 years in the face of the various peace agreements?

Ireland is the big bit just to the west of Great Britain where they shot at each other for 30 years, btw. You might want to look it.
 
While they may prove somewhat irksome, their existence is protected by the First Amendment's right to petition the government for a redress of grievances.

No problem, just do what other countries do and put limits on the extent of paid lobbying and any special access so arising.

Really, the rest of us in other democracies seem to manage just fine.
 
Nobody has advocated genocide, making this a strawman. In fact, Mark6 already made clear that this is not what he meant, but you seem to have chosen to ignore him.
To the contrary, I paid attention to what he said. What he said was that he did not intend "ultimate solution" as a euphemism for genocide. Specifically,
I was not being sarcastic, but neither was it intended as a euphemism for genocide. Parallel with "final solution" did not occur to me.

That does not mean that genocide is not the logical end to his line of rhetoric. Let's review:
There cannot be peaceful coexistence with a people whose ultimate goal is to compel everyone to live under a single religion, one that is not just a religion but a way of life.
"As long as they exist, we can never be safe."

And if that's the case, the only ultimate solution is to defeat them militarily, however long it takes, which sadly cannot be done without killing large numbers of them, because it may well prove impossible to change their minds.
"They cannot be changed. They must be killed again and again until they are no longer a threat."

When are they no longer a threat? From the previous sentence, there cannot be peaceful coexistence with them. That only leaves two options: non-peaceful coexistence and or peaceful mono-existence. Since the goal is for them to not be a threat (i.e. peace), that can only mean the latter.

And that, Ziggurat, means genocide of either us or them.


and not saying anything to guy taking the "I don't like what you say and we should keep killing you until you stop saying it" position.
Except nobody took that position. So why do you expect me to attack your strawman alongside you?
First, because it isn't a strawman. Let's review again:
As for how do we know War on Terror (or whatever we call it) has been won? I would say when there is not a single madrassa left in the world openly calling for global jihad and killing of unbelievers (i.e. either destroyed or driven into hiding), I would say it has been won. How will we know it happened? Well, the word "openly" is key here. If they are open about it, we know it has not been won yet.
Maybe I'm going out on a limb here, but I'm assuming that Mark6 does not like "madrassas" (:rolleyes:) "calling for global jihad and killing of unbelievers". This would be the "I don't like what you say" portion of the position. According to Mark6, the war "has not been won" as long as they keep saying it, correct? War, in this context, entails killing the enemy and it stops, in Mark6's opinion, when they stop saying the stuff he doesn't like, namely the global jihad and killing of unbelievers.

Therefore, Mark6 has taken the position that he doesn't like what they are saying and we should keep killing them until they stop saying it.

Second, it is an absurd and much more radical position than the one I am taking about people being able to say whatever they like so long as it doesn't intentionally lead to violence. If you are being honest, I would expect you to at least recognize and acknowledge that.
 
No, I'm going to have to ask you to clarify that answer.

By your statement that "There will always be those who reach for the gun, or the bomb, before they will go to the ballot box.", and such action being defined by the context of your statement as terrorism, then a War against Terrorism can never end.

:gnome:
 
Actually, genocide is not required unless, by genocide you really mean the removal of all Muslims who believe that people of all other faiths must be killed or converted. Unless all Muslims believe that (which I trust is not correct), genocide is unnecessary. Also, Muslims are not the only terrorists-criminal gangs (and other types of gangs), religious xtian fundies, many political seperatist groups, certain political advocacy groups (especially environmental and animal rights) are as bad as Muslim fundies. I'm fine with all terrorists dead. And, if their non-terrorist supporters also go, won't bother me a lot either.
 
You have been given many answers to that question but appear to have rejected them so,
I'd have to go back and check the older part of the thread, but I don't recall any that were both reasonable and measurable (i.e. unambiguous). As such, yes, I would have rejected them as not being sufficient answers.

Did you see something you thought fit the bill?

it is only fair that you answer a couple of question yourself. Do you feel that we should even be fighting a "WOT"? If so, how do you think it should be fought?
You will likely see this as a cop out, but as I mentioned earlier in post #127, what do you mean by "Terror"? The current "War on Terror" is ill named because the overall scope has little to do with terrorism. Or, at least, much less than the name would imply.

Do I think we should find, capture, or kill those responsible for planning and executing the 9/11 attacks? You betcha! Do I believe that has been the primary goal of the current "War on Terror" since 2003? Nope.
 
Actually, genocide is not required unless, by genocide you really mean the removal of all Muslims who believe that people of all other faiths must be killed or converted. Unless all Muslims believe that (which I trust is not correct), genocide is unnecessary.
Mark6 appears to lump all Muslim fundamentalists, terrorist, war-like, or otherwise, into a single group. If you intend to kill them as a group, which he certainly appears to be advocating based on his rhetoric, I think that does fit the definition of genocide.


And, if their non-terrorist supporters also go, won't bother me a lot either.
I don't understand. What do you mean by "non-terrorist supporters"? Those who have the same goals but use other methods or those who finance terrorists but do not actually participate in the terrorist acts?
 
Mark6 appears to lump all Muslim fundamentalists, terrorist, war-like, or otherwise, into a single group. If you intend to kill them as a group, which he certainly appears to be advocating based on his rhetoric, I think that does fit the definition of genocide.



I don't understand. What do you mean by "non-terrorist supporters"? Those who have the same goals but use other methods or those who finance terrorists but do not actually participate in the terrorist acts?
Those who hide them, provide for them, send them recruits, suggest targets to them, launder money for them, applaud (except clearly out of fear) them.
 
When are they no longer a threat? From the previous sentence, there cannot be peaceful coexistence with them.

Who is "them"? Muslims in general? You will search in vain for any statements from Mark6 to that effect. Them, in the context of who we're fighting and killing, are the jihadis. And killing all the jihadis doesn't mean genocide, any more than killing all the Nazi soldiers would have meant genocide of Germany. And victory may not require that we do so (we didn't have to in WW2), but I have absolutely no problem with being prepared and willing to do so.

Maybe I'm going out on a limb here, but I'm assuming that Mark6 does not like "madrassas" (:rolleyes:) "calling for global jihad and killing of unbelievers". This would be the "I don't like what you say" portion of the position.

No, this would be the "don't threaten to kill me" part of Mark's position. Why do you continue to try to frame that as a free speech issue when it is nothing of the sort?

Second, it is an absurd and much more radical position than the one I am taking about people being able to say whatever they like so long as it doesn't intentionally lead to violence.

Sorry, but if you preach that muslims should kill infidels, it's pretty damned unambiguous that the intention is to lead to violence. Why you continue to pretend otherwise is beyond me. It's really hard to take you seriously when you keep tripping over this most basic issue.
 
That's how you would have fought the War On Terror? Your first action after 9/11 would have been the impeachment of American Politicians?

I'd love to hear your rationale for this.


Not after 9/11 - but immediately after the Iraq invasion since there was no terror threat to us. Plus the Administration pretty much gave a [fill in the blank] about the Saudi-Arabia side of the terror-story. Pakistan got some cash, the Saudis weapons, not enough troops in Afghanistan, no initial action concerning the Israel-Palestinian conflict, denunciating a non-terror Iran yadda, yadda, yadda.

There are enough rationals to assume that the War on Terror is a hoax. But let me guess, you're still falling for it, right?
 
Last edited:
Those who hide them, provide for them, send them recruits, suggest targets to them, launder money for them, applaud (except clearly out of fear) them.
I'm with you on all but the last one. With the first five, those people are accomplices. The last group are just jerks, to put it mildly and to stay within forum language rules.

Who is "them"? Muslims in general? You will search in vain for any statements from Mark6 to that effect.
No, "Islamic Fundamentalism" as Mark6 specified way back in post #130. (It wasn't that hard of a search.)

Them, in the context of who we're fighting and killing, are the jihadis. And killing all the jihadis doesn't mean genocide, any more than killing all the Nazi soldiers would have meant genocide of Germany.
Mark6 also defined "Them" as those who subscribe to a specific kind of ideology and "who want to make the world conform to their THOUGHT" (#134). He also calls for continued warfare not until just the soldiers give up, but the society does, as well (#130 again).

And victory may not require that we do so (we didn't have to in WW2), but I have absolutely no problem with being prepared and willing to do so.
If that is your opinion, that is fine. I happen to agree with that. However, that is clearly not the position Mark6 is taking. Just because I am attacking his position does not mean I am attacking yours, Zig.

Don't think there are only two sides to a specific issue. Just because we disagree on some aspects does not mean that we disagree on all aspects.


No, this would be the "don't threaten to kill me" part of Mark's position. Why do you continue to try to frame that as a free speech issue when it is nothing of the sort?
I've explained why several times now. A threat is only really a threat if there is a reasonable expectation that it would be acted upon. Until then, and Mark6 even agreed with this, "their mutterings are unimportant" (#143). And yet, it is on the basis of their mutterings, not the expectation that it would be acted upon that Mark6 defines his criteria for the war to be over.

There is a difference between calling for death of infidels and calling for the death of these particular infidels at this place, at this time, done in this manner, and here is all the information you need to do it. It's the difference between threatening and being a threat.


Sorry, but if you preach that muslims should kill infidels, it's pretty damned unambiguous that the intention is to lead to violence. Why you continue to pretend otherwise is beyond me. It's really hard to take you seriously when you keep tripping over this most basic issue.
Okay, I think you're hung up on this because of the subject matter de jour. Let's switch it out for a more classic example:

Consider here in the US, some members of the KKK want to have a public rally where they will advocate driving black people out of the state. They represent less than one tenth of one percent of the population of the state. Should they be allowed to speak? If violence does occur, does that mean the KKK should never be allowed to have a public rally again anywhere, ever?

I'm not saying that they should not be condemned, but what what is the phrase? "The cure for bad speech is more speech, not less."
 
Last edited:
If that is your opinion, that is fine. I happen to agree with that. However, that is clearly not the position Mark6 is taking.

I don't think your evaluation of his position is correct. Perhaps he can further explain what he meant, until then I doubt we'll make much headway on that front.

I've explained why several times now. A threat is only really a threat if there is a reasonable expectation that it would be acted upon.

Well, no. It's a threat if there's a reasonable expectation it could be acted upon, not necessarily that it would be acted upon. And given the history of Islamic terrorism, I conclude that preaching death to infidels qualifies.

There is a difference between calling for death of infidels and calling for the death of these particular infidels at this place, at this time, done in this manner, and here is all the information you need to do it. It's the difference between threatening and being a threat.

And yet, threatening someone is frequently illegal in and of itself. So the distinction between threatening and being a threat doesn't turn this into protected speech.

Consider here in the US, some members of the KKK want to have a public rally where they will advocate driving black people out of the state. They represent less than one tenth of one percent of the population of the state. Should they be allowed to speak?

Actually, it depends. I've been talking about incitement to violence, but the real dividing line is incitement to illegal activity (which is why saying you should shoot a home intruder may be legal, but saying you should vandalize a school may not be). In this hypothetical, the question would be HOW do they advocate driving black people out of the state. If it's by violence or other illegal acts, then they've crossed the line. If it's by being mean and nasty so that all the blacks move away, that's not illegal, so it's protected. Your scenario is insufficiently specified to determine whether or not it's protected speech. But "killing infidels" is sufficiently specified: I don't need to know the details to know it's illegal, and therefore not protected.

If violence does occur, does that mean the KKK should never be allowed to have a public rally again anywhere, ever?

They should be banned from having public rallies for as long as they incite illegal activity by their speech. This is a different standard than whether or not violence occurs, because it's possible violence could be instigated by opponents. I'm not sure what you think this has to do with the argument at hand.
 
From the context, I'm not even really sure you understand what "jihad" means to a Muslim.

Please, enlighten us. What does jihad mean to a Muslim?
And is it even relevant what this Muslim thinks it means?
I had a similar discussion with 'Firegarden' before. I'm curious.

As for the topic, we'll be making progress once we don't have articles like this one anymore.
 
Mark6 also defined "Them" as those who subscribe to a specific kind of ideology and "who want to make the world conform to their THOUGHT" (#134). He also calls for continued warfare not until just the soldiers give up, but the society does, as well (#130 again).


1110747334d8e071db.gif


:rolleyes:
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom